News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by dcgudeman on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:33PM (#28762669)
You really think Facebook is the equivalent of Big Tobacco? This moral panic is really reaching a feverish crescendo.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by RosanaAnaDana on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:53PM (#28762979)
That's actually a great analogy.

Years of social media and misinformation resulted in an attempted coup and insurrection earlier this year, the major contributing factors of which are still ongoing. I don't think phillip-morris ever got that far.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by ARandomerDude on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @02:05PM (#28763160)
While FB no doubt contributed to the Jan 6 riot, it's too simple and tidy to blame it on social media. There is a complex web of factors, including interpretation of the Constitution, view of history, fear of tomorrow if the other side takes over, frustration with a sense of powerlessness, etc.

Frankly, the Jan 6 episode is not all that different from the BLM riots last year, in that their causes are analogous and the sense of powerlessness led to rioting.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by stephencanon on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @02:48PM (#28763836)
> sense of powerlessness led to rioting

Middle-class and rich white people from politically-advantaged parts of the country, that famously powerless group.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by evnc on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @03:09PM (#28764142)
I don't mean to defend those who stormed the capitol, who to be clear I don't agree with, but the important thing to note here is sense of powerlessness. These people felt powerless, regardless of whether or not they were in any kind of objective sense, and that feeling motivated their actions.

This is relevant to the current discussion inasmuch as FB (and social media generally) may have contributed to, stoked and fomented said feelings of powerlessness for the sake of engagement / eyeballs / ad clicks.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by stephencanon on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @06:02PM (#28766250)
I don’t think I believe that they actually feel powerless, though. The right-wing and centrist press spin that narrative, because it’s the only way to justify their actions, but it doesn’t square with reality: people who feel powerless do not violently threaten the workings of government, believing that they will succeed and avoid any negative consequences if they fail. Those are the actions of people who are used to getting their way all day every day, who cannot believe that they won’t get their way again.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by angelzen on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @09:33PM (#28768109)
I will never forget the exhausted desperation in the voice of a young woman talking to her parents in an undisclosed middle America location: 'there are no jobs'. The words are cliche, I know. Nonetheless I'd recommend taking a few days and visit such a place as opposed to yet another scuba trip in French Polynesia. Won't get as many likes on Instagram, but may give a bit of a perspective. There are vast swaths of this country that are not thriving.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by stephencanon on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @06:46AM (#28771470)
(a) I live in rural America. (b) That has almost nothing to do with Trump support, despite what the media says. (c) Those are not the people who broke into the capitol. They can’t afford a trip to DC.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by beambot on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @02:12PM (#28763275)
Except that one of them occurred at the time & place of the major transition of power and actively stormed a congressional session resulting in deaths in a core federal government building. But sure... other than that "not all that different".
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by angelzen on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @09:17PM (#28767962)
I remember a church being set on fire across the street from the White House. I guess arson, especially if directed at Christian churches, is just the way we exercise our 1st Amendment rights in this country.

https://www.nbcwashington.com/news/local/historic-church-nea...

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by ARandomerDude on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @02:18PM (#28763370)
No disagreement there, and for the record I am glad the Jan 6 rioters are being prosecuted.

The point I was raising is that "Facebook = riot" is too simplistic an explanation. Moreover the contributing factors are not isolated to one event or political persuasion.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by atonse on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:57PM (#28763040)
Facebook has a much wider reach than Bic Tobacco could dream of.

As far as actual impact on thousands of lives, it's probably a tossup since Facebook has many means of ruining lives (psychological manipulation, distrust in government, pandemic misinformation, political misinformation). But I'd wager that Facebook has probably already caused way more harm than tobacco. It's hard to measure though.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by raxxorrax on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @03:41AM (#28770288)
Distrust in government is a democratic necessity. There were more insidious source for misinformation on vaccines than Facebook, although some of the worst cases were favored by government (lab leak suppression).

Tendency is that the parent comment is correct and the proposed solutions are practically bretty bad.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by irrational on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @02:12PM (#28763267)
It's worse, right? Other than second-hand smoke, tobacco for the most part hurts just that person. The same can't be said for social media.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by mFixman on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @03:04PM (#28764055)
Tobacco kills 8 million people per year, and that's with over half a century of regulation and cessation problems taxation. It's also a disgusting habit that destroys any area smokers step in.

HN is at its worse when fuming over Facebook, and comparing the tragedy caused by smoking companies with social media is a good example of how uninformed the site can get.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by satellite2 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @03:29PM (#28764421)
With only 10 years of existence and already to its palmares a genocide in Myanmar and making the worst pandemic since the plague much worse, I think the comparison is not so far fetched.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by mFixman on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @03:42PM (#28764584)
So the Burmese government and military junta had nothing to do with the genocide. The local media, endemic discrimination, local warlords, international support, nor the people actually guiding and doing the genocide had any responsability.

Was social media the cause for the 1994 genocide in Rwanda too?

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by shadilay on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @03:53PM (#28764721)
"Cut the tall trees" Mass media sure helped.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by satellite2 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @03:52PM (#28764714)
As with cigarette seller, it was never in their best interest that their product cause cancer. But it does. In top of that they had evidence of it earlier than the public and chose to hide it.

Facebook had many internal whisteblowers that the platform was used to shape the public opinion and facilitate the genocide and choose to do nothing.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by munk-a on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:36PM (#28762709)
I think Big Tobacco is still worse but honestly? The extreme radicalism we're seeing in our modern society is pretty terrible - I just don't think it's fair to blame all of that radicalism on Facebook, even if it has played a role in nurturing it.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by marvin on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @03:16PM (#28764240)
I'm fairly confident that widespread internet-based multicast communication is almost solely responsible for many of the profoundly weird things that have happened in global politics for the last six years. It's a very powerful new tool for communication that has hit very fast and without enough time for society to adapt to the change. A textbook example of accelerating technological change throwing a monkey wrench into what seemed to be a well-oiled machine.

It's fair enough to say that Facebook is only responsible for a significant part of this, as there's also Twitter, YouTube, Instagram (pre-acquisition), Snapchat, TikTok and so on, and there would be others if these did not exist. The root cause is smartphones, the Internet and cheap bandwidth & servers.

But in the context of regulation, finding out how to deal with this new weapon of communication, starting with a case study of the biggest seems like an excellent beginning.

I honestly think unregulated social media has the potential to do more damage than unregulated tobacco sales, if by regulation we mean "government-enforced rules". But I don't mean to frame it as a context; it seems obvious that both are a good idea.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by dntrkv on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @02:17PM (#28763351)
> The extreme radicalism

What do you think FB's role is in that? Do you think the "algorithms" are to blame?

Seems to me that unmoderated online discussion will always be toxic. Take a look at the chan forums for an extreme, anonymous version of social media where there are no algorithms to blame.

When you bring the general public online and give them a platform to voice their insane ideas they never discussed before, you get the internet in 2021.

Combine that with the fact that until recently, people on the opposite sides of the political spectrum rarely interacted. The division was there, but it was masked by the inability to directly attack each other. Now, I can go on Twitter and argue all day with the other side in a thread below a Senator's tweet.

Unless you are suggesting Facebook begin heavily moderating what people say, there will be no other outcome until we as a society collectively learn to 1. Have empathy for others when conversing online, 2. Stop participating in discussions that make you feel terrible, and the classic, 3. Don't believe everything you read online.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:42PM (#28762827)
It wasn't fair to blame all of cancer on Big Tobacco, either.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by heavyset_go on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @05:36PM (#28765939)
Read "A Genocide Incited on Facebook, With Posts From Myanmar’s Military"[1] and "Facebook Admits It Was Used to Incite Violence in Myanmar"[2].

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/15/technology/myanmar-facebo...

[2] https://www.nytimes.com/2018/11/06/technology/myanmar-facebo...

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by aaroninsf on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:56PM (#28763036)
Facebook is much, much, much worse.

Assuming general equivalency in manipulation of public opinion to hide their malfeasance,

the impact of that malfeasance is orders of magnitude worse for our society, democracy, and world culture.

If you have any doubt about this, you haven't looked at any of the reporting, not just from this latest data dump, but from any of the other whistle-blowing, leaks, third party investigations, etc.

It's not just that they bury and spin any internal findings which may compromise their ability to pursue "engagement," it's so so much worse.

Look at the documents. This whistleblower brought the receipts.

Their continued operations as a monolith represents an acute and active threat. They should be broken up and subjected to transparency requirements.

That's what you get when you pursue profit and power at the expense of social cohesion, functioning government, and in the case of many in harsh realities outside the US, assistance in brutal political suppression and worse.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by aaroninsf on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @05:09PM (#28765668)
LOL downvotes are the surest possible sign of unsettling and upsetting those who are complicit.

Work for them? Quit. Do business with them? Don't. Think access to clients and relationships with them depend on participating in this ecosystem? It doesn't.

Break the monopoly.