News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Signal is experiencing technical difficulties by emptysongglass on Monday September 27, 2021 @01:58AM (#28667517)
For casual messaging, Telegram is fantastic. Actual multi-session clients across devices. No Electron. Truck loads of features and thoughtful touches everywhere. It's easily the slickest and if you're looking to have friends and family who don't have a lot of patience for technical issues actually convert and stay converted, it's the only one I've found to do the trick.

Searching through your messages by type, really good video messaging, voice messaging, video chats, and the best stickers on any platform.

It doesn't do E2EE by default (you need to manually flip on Secret Chats) and group chats are not E2EE at all, both of which make it HN kryptonite because apparently E2EE everywhere, by default, is the only thing that matters even though there are technical trade-offs to an E2EE-everywhere model. I appreciate I can flip on Secret Chats when I need them but do wish it was an option in group chats.

I selfhost a Matrix homeserver: it's nowhere near ready for primetime and misses a lot of those thoughtful touches less technical people appreciate. If you do want to try to onboard people to Matrix with the Element client (and be very careful because you only get one, maybe two shots with your friends and family before they go back to whatever they were using before) use Mozilla's homeserver for its vastly better performance and option of SSO sign-on.

Re:Signal is experiencing technical difficulties by theshrike79 on Monday September 27, 2021 @02:51AM (#28667816)
> I selfhost a Matrix homeserver: it's nowhere near ready for primetime and misses a lot of those thoughtful touches less technical people appreciate.

This is true. I've been on IRC since the mid 90's with ircII and BitchX and even I find Matrix/Element to be tedious to navigate.

There's exactly zero chance I will suggest it to anyone non-technical until they get their clients up to snuff with the competition.

Telegram and Discord are the two best IRC-replacements, both offer easy native bot support and tools to manage bigger group chats (100+ members).

Re:Signal is experiencing technical difficulties by novok on Monday September 27, 2021 @02:28AM (#28667681)
WhatsApp has a better privacy story than Telegram, because every chat is a 'secret chat' by default. If your using signal, a priority for you is private chat with something the normies in your life can use, otherwise you'd just use whatever is the most popular where you live.
Re:Signal is experiencing technical difficulties by fsflover on Monday September 27, 2021 @05:48AM (#28668821)
> WhatsApp has a better privacy story than Telegram

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25685446

Re:Signal is experiencing technical difficulties by maqp on Monday September 27, 2021 @06:46AM (#28669158)
The backdoor only applies to WhatsApp for Business, where companies want a fail-safe to open employee messages e.g. after they've left the company. The fact they're transparent about it should be enough. Do not use WA for Business, for personal private communication. They are not the same product, and the business version isn't truly E2EE.
Re:Signal is experiencing technical difficulties by fsflover on Monday September 27, 2021 @02:57PM (#28674596)
There is no way to verify this. Do you trust Facebook?
Re:Signal is experiencing technical difficulties by theshrike79 on Monday September 27, 2021 @02:53AM (#28667823)
I'll take proper native bot support over privacy for my everyday chats any day. And by "chat" here I mean a channel with multiple people.

For 1-on-1 it's all the same to me. Telegram is still the easiest, since I can have the same chat history on multiple devices easily.

Re:Signal is experiencing technical difficulties by the_other on Monday September 27, 2021 @03:18AM (#28667971)
> WhatsApp has a better privacy story than Telegram

No it doesn’t. It’s owned by the 2nd largest surveillance capitalist; it shares a back-end with Facebook (so at a whim they can use the metadata around your chats to update their advertising models of you and your contacts); IIRC it leaks your engagement to FB (via web link previews).

Re:Signal is experiencing technical difficulties by maqp on Monday September 27, 2021 @06:41AM (#28669130)
Let's do an apples to apples comparison

-End-to-end encrypted by default (WA yes, Telegram No)

-End-to-end encrypted group chats (WA yes, Telegram No)

-End-to-end encrypted group video calls (WA yes, Telegram No)

-End-to-end encrypted desktop chats (WA yes, Telegram No)

-Client-side encrypted cloud backups (WA yes, Telegram No)

-Cross-platform end-to-end encrypted chats (WA yes, Telegram No)

It's a bit hard to make a case for Telegram's good intentions when they lack the ability to actually deploy usable, ubiquitous end-to-end encryption. They could even pay people like Moxie to implement it for them, which begs the question, why haven't they. Durov absolutely has the money.

Yes WA and FB has access to your communications metadata, but so does Telegram. And every entity that hacks Telegram.

Pavel Durov isn't a magical entity of good will and intentions, he's a Russian guy with sure, decent eye towards good user experience, but the cost for that is too great, considering he's never hired a competent cryptographer to even see if the features the app provides could be implemented in a privacy preserving way. I'd love to be able to defend Telegram's design choices, but the more they spend their time adding "sleek animations" and other bs features, the clearer it becomes it's just another social media platform with same privacy features as Facebook Messenger:

-Not end-to-end encrypted by default (Telegram Yes, FBM yes)

-No end-to-end encrypted group chats (Telegram Yes, FBM yes)

-Opt-in 1:1 end-to-end encrypted chats on mobile (Telegram Yes, FBM yes)

In that comparison, WA comes at the top. But then again, it's a false dichotomy as Signal puts incremental privacy features with no real down-sides.

-Open source clients (Signal yes, WA no)

-Reproducible builds (Signal yes, WA no)

-User-managed groups (Signal yes, WA no)

(And no, Telegram being open source with reproducible builds isn't really worth anything until the verification confirms that it's really using proper E2EE. Currently Telegram's source only confirms that it's not E2EE by default etc.)

As for the surveillance capitalistic aspect, Telegram is only as good as their word. FB wasn't surveillance capitalistic when it started back in 2005. Telegram isn't slaughtering the piglet before it's time to cash in, but they can get hacked at any point, and the hundreds of billions of messages that sit on their server, effectively unencrypted (storing the database key in server's memory is the same as "not encrypted"), Telegram isn't private even if Durov never wanted to use that data. The fact is experts agree such data is a liability, a toxic asset, that nobody can protect forever. Durov isn't as security researcher patching zero-days faster than NSA, GCHQ, Fancy Bear, Unit8200, CCA et. al. find them. Most probably Durov wouldn't even realize a rootkit has been sneaking data out of his server for the past 8 years.

Compared to these risks, WA has been ahead of Telegram ever since they implemented Signal protocol in 2016.

Re:Signal is experiencing technical difficulties by the_other on Monday September 27, 2021 @07:11AM (#28669288)
Invading your privacy is literally Zuck’s business model. The entire company operates based on selling an analysis of you and your friends to the highest bidder. Whether they planned that from the start or not, that is the basis of their funding, their IPO and their current valuation. All their products synergise to better invade your life. Duroc may not be squeaky clean, but he has a much better public record on standing up for ethical causes than Zuck. WA’s E2EE is entirely managed by WA - the user has no control over the keys and everything goes via their servers, so can it really be trusted?

I still think the WA privacy story is more suspect than Telegram’s at this point.

Re:Signal is experiencing technical difficulties by maqp on Monday September 27, 2021 @07:25AM (#28669384)
>but he has a much better public record on standing up for ethical causes than Zuck.

Paying lip service is not the same as practicing what you preach. I'm not saying Mark Zuckerberg is on your side. I'm saying WA team managed to implement Signal Protocol before Zuckerberg et. al. realized what was happening wrt. WA's data aggregation capabilities. Also, Durov isn't called the Mark Zuckerberg of Russia for nothing. Also, it's not like VKontakte users Durov made his fortune with, had too much privacy. Why is Telegram suddenly a magical fountain of privacy when on tech level it's worse than WhatsApp?

"the user has no control over the keys"

Extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof.

"everything goes via their servers"

Kind of the central point of centralized messengers?

Also, with Telegram there is a guarantee 100% of group chats, and 100% of Win/Linux desktop chats go through the server in the form that allows the server to spy on the content. All Telegram clients also leaks the metadata that you specifically enabled E2EE with some person, i.e. you disclose your desire to hide data from all third parties. That type of metadata is extremely valuable, and something WA -- due to ubiquitous E2EE -- is unable to collect.

"I still think the WA privacy story is more suspect than Telegram’s at this point."

Your opinion doesn't override that of Matthew Green, or Bruce Schneier who have explicitly advised to NOT use Telegram. I have never seen a security expert recommend Telegram, and don't expect you to provide evidence on the contrary, either.

Re:Signal is experiencing technical difficulties by the_other on Thursday September 30, 2021 @05:01AM (#28704390)
> Why is Telegram suddenly a magical fountain of privacy

I didn't say it was. I said the Telegram _story_ was _better_ than WA's at this point.

> when on tech level it's worse than WhatsApp?

I'm not arguing that Telegram has a better or worse technical model; I'm arguing that the WA business model and senior leadership and share structure, which controls its tech, creates a _story_ which is less trustworthy.

I take your points about WA appearing technically better.

Re:Signal is experiencing technical difficulties by emptysongglass on Monday September 27, 2021 @06:58AM (#28669210)
You're evaluating Telegram with many paragraphs given to your metric, which is E2EE. That's fair enough but it's not representative for what many users outside of the HN bubble are evaluating by. For me I value all of the features I wrote in my original comment in this thread more than I value E2EE by default. If someone were to come to me and offer me E2EE by default without those features I would say no thank you.

What I don't want is a corporation behind my chat app whose business is in monetizing my data. If Durov can keep Telegram out of that business I will be pleased.

Re:Signal is experiencing technical difficulties by maqp on Monday September 27, 2021 @07:16AM (#28669316)
Oh please. You're complaining about technical person evaluating technical product on technical level, on a technical forum.

E2EE is the bare minimum for security these days, as so carefully explained by the message you're replying to.

"If someone were to come to me and offer me E2EE by default without those features I would say no thank you."

This is such a loaded and unthoughtful comment. It assumes you have to make a choice. You don't, at least per technical reasoning. The only situation where you can't have E2EE is massive groups, and it's obvious those have no expectation of privacy. Anything else, I can explain to you on a technical level why it can be done in a privacy preserving way, and the only reason its not, is because Telegram's team lacks the know-how. Signal has already shown they can pull off pretty much any feature in a privacy preserving way.

So the question is not "what features do I need", but "should all my features be actual features". A feature that doesn't protect your privacy by definition can be used to spy on you, and I'm sure we both agree that is not a feature.

So ask yourself

Group chat with end-to-end encryption (Signal) or Group chat without end-to-end encryption (Telegram).

Which one do you choose? The answer is obvious.

>What I don't want is a corporation behind my chat app

Also, you should know Telegram is not a non-profit like Signal. Telegram is a limited liability _company_. It's a for-profit entity, and the LLC only means, the owners are "legally responsible for its debts only to the extent of the amount of capital they invested".

Re:Signal is experiencing technical difficulties by emptysongglass on Monday September 27, 2021 @08:01AM (#28669612)
> This is such a loaded and unthoughtful comment. It assumes you have to make a choice. You don't, at least per technical reasoning.

When Signal provides these features, please feel free to ping me back here but until then, the proof is in the pudding and the Signal pudding doesn't taste like the Telegram pudding.

As Signal's client is open source and its server is whenever they feel like it, I'm sure they'd also value your contribution to prove out your point.

Re:Signal is experiencing technical difficulties by maqp on Monday September 27, 2021 @08:17AM (#28669727)
So to return to your original post:

>"Actual multi-session clients across devices."

Not available with E2EE

>"No Electron."

Sure, because you need all 32GB of RAM but not your human right to privacy. Also, this is an argument against Signal's client, not excuse why you can't have E2EE on non-electron native client.

>"Truck loads of features and thoughtful touches everywhere."

So, eye candy. Not very strong argument.

>"Searching through your messages"

Only exact messages. Gets incredibly slow once you go past few weeks. Client-side searchers are as fast as your phone, i.e., fast.

>"video chats"

Not E2EE for groups

>"best stickers"

1:1 match between my Signal and Telegram sticker packs (50+ packs)

>"even though there are technical trade-offs to an E2EE-everywhere model"

The problem with this BS claim, is you can't point to a single trade-off. Everything you mentioned can be done with E2EE.

>"but do wish it was an option in group chats."

So the question is, why aren't you demanding it?

>"When Signal provides these features, please feel free to ping me back here but until then"

Again, which features? Please provide an actual, exact list so we know when to ping you.

>"the proof is in the pudding and the Signal pudding doesn't taste like the Telegram pudding."

The problem when you add a ton of sugar into a pot of porridge made from shit, is now you have a ton of sugar with an even coating of shit in it. No matter how much eye candy you glue on top of insecure design and spaghetti code that is Telegram, the fundamental truth is, it was never empowering you, only its owners who are collecting as much data about you as FB does, if not more.

EDIT: Fixed lack of E2EE on video calls to mean group video calls. Apologies if this looks like moving the goal post, not my intention.

Re:Signal is experiencing technical difficulties by lpcvoid on Monday September 27, 2021 @11:31AM (#28671898)
Actually, I value a non-electron client way higher than E2EE. In fact, the incredible desktop client is one of the main reasons I am a huge Telegram proponent.
Re:Signal is experiencing technical difficulties by emptysongglass on Monday September 27, 2021 @09:18AM (#28670290)
Hey bud, you're really writing aggressively. I'm not really here for that. But I do think it's important to debunk misinformation and this:

>>"video chats"

> Not E2EE

...isn't true. Please see https://core.telegram.org/api/end-to-end/video-calls

Re:Signal is experiencing technical difficulties by maqp on Monday September 27, 2021 @09:48AM (#28670587)
You're right in that the 1:1 video chats are E2EE, but not group video chats. This is my concern, but since you weren't making the claim, it's my mistake and now fixed.

It's not my intention to be aggressive towards you or anyone else. It's the argument (or lack of arguments) I'm attacking, not the person.