It seems that this is the concept behind many startups that are successful. Airbnb, Uber/Lyft, DoorDash etc.
They try to take on risky efficiencies (by undercutting labor / capital, RnD costs, circumventing regulation), with the hope that they will become too big to be stopped. For many of them it worked.
Being accesses through someone else’s platform isn’t the same thing as trying to build a business on top of someone else’s IP.
The music industry owned the core of Genius’ content from the start.
Genius is never going to start hosting user created lyrics one day.
Sometimes that minimum is too high compared to the company value and so no sale happens and the company just dies.
You realize this makes absolutely no sense, right?
real_company_worth = sum(valueOf(technology), valueOf(people), valueOf(assets))
sale_price = max(total_money_raised_owed, real_company_worth)
if sale_price == total_money_raised_owed {
sale_price < real_company_worth // likely, since rarely total_money_raised_owed == real_company_worth
}
Better?"sale_price < real_company_worth"
This statement in that conditional seems like it could never be true.
If sale_price == total_money_raised_owed, then real_company_worth <= total_money_raised_owed because sale_price = max(total_money_raised_owed, real_company_worth).
Therefore, inside the conditional, sale_price = total_money_raised_owed >= real_company_worth, therefore sale_price >= real_company_worth which is the opposite of sale_price < real_company_worth.
What am I missing? Perhaps you meant min?
max is correct though (whichever value is highest, that sets the base price).
And of course, some sheareholders lost their stakes in this sale.
> Because the company’s obligations to its preferred shareholders exceeded the sale price, investors won’t be paid out in full, according to a document reviewed by Bloomberg.
Companies rarely sell for less than the total amount raised. This is true. It doesn't mean that buyers regularly pay double for something because the company wouldn't otherwise sell. It means the buyers just don't buy it!
If Genius was really only worth $1M - we probably wouldn't ever hear about it - because they probably wouldn't ever sell it for that price.
Very common that the baseline is the amount of money raised - it's why sometimes companies die and not get sold. Other times, companies will use amount of money raised as leverage to increase the final sale price (based on investor expected returns).
Money raised plays a huge factor in regards to sales price, or if a sale occurs at all.
The acquisition did not sell at the same price as money raised so this assertion is invalid. The article directly stated this - did you read the article you are commenting on?
"Its price tag of $80 million represents less than what it raised over the years in venture capital, according to PitchBook."
The biggest cost is that you have to figure out a substantial, original content way to differentiate from every other lyric source for SEO purposes.
So Google's search engine is crap because it allows people to 'only' search for a piece of information they're looking for? All the best startups are simple ideas.
Genius also has a great search engine, & allows you to play small samples of songs. It is also designed well and the UI is intuitive. It is more than a Hypothesis[0] clone.
You’re missing two key differences:
Google doesn’t have to pay people to index their content. Genius had to pay music labels large amounts of money to index their content.
Also, Google isn’t serving up the content itself. They’re directing people to competing content. Competition creates profit opportunities (ads). Genius users arrived on-site knowing more or less exactly what they wanted to see.
The fact that they took more than $80 million in investment to get to this point is what makes this a failure. Also raises a lot of questions about how a company needed so much investment money to build a website that never really did much more than allow people to annotate text.
I suppose licensing fees could have been extraordinarily high. But then again, they were likely high because the music industry knew they could extract all of that VC money right out of the company through licensing fees.
The entire product was built on top of lyrics they don’t own. In essence, they built their product on top of someone else’s platform.