News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by jimmaswell on Thursday September 09, 2021 @09:19PM (#28476711)
And as an American, Germans/Australians/etc. will still insist they're more free than me because of something arbitrary like free healthcare. I don't think there's anywhere I'd feel particularly more "free" all things considered aside from maybe Mars.
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by simonh on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:29PM (#28477113)
I suppose it depends how you look at it. There are different kinds of freedom. My main concern in the US is the absurd levels of incarceration over there, often for relatively trivial nonviolent offences that aren’t even crimes in many countries, and the politicisation of the judicial system. I’m a lot more confident I’d get fair treatment from the justice system in most European countries than I would in the US. The relationship between the police and the public in the states also seems dangerously adversarial and does not inspire me with confidence.
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by zepto on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:55PM (#28477256)
> The relationship between the police and the public in the states also seems dangerously adversarial and does not inspire me with confidence.

This is greatly exaggerated. Not that the bad things you see in the news don’t happen. Just that most interactions with the police aren’t in fact any more adversarial than in other countries.

I am not white, and I have been stopped by police multiple times in the US, Europe, and Asia, as well as selected for additional screening in airports in the US, London, and the Netherlands.

Whether the police were adversarial or not was not a function of whether they were in the US. Indeed the one time the police actually behaved in a threatening way was in the UK.

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by marcod on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:04PM (#28477320)
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by zepto on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:50PM (#28477615)
> Not saying your anecdote isn't true,

Given that your links are not cross cultural comparisons, your response doesn’t seem to be in good faith.

It looks like you just used my comment as a chance to post some anti-US policing links that aren’t actually relevant to what I said.

Bear in mind that racism and racist policing are present in Europe, and Asia too.

I assume you have no experience of police in different countries yourself.

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by vxNsr on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:10PM (#28477374)
> My main concern in the US is the absurd levels of incarceration over there, often for relatively trivial nonviolent offences that aren’t even crimes in many countries, and the politicisation of the judicial system.

That’s such an odd thing to say on a article about someone getting their home raided bec they called someone a dick in Europe…

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by simonh on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:32AM (#28477838)
It’s a matter of proportionality. This case us getting massive coverage, it’s clearly an extreme outlier. I don’t think it’s reasonable to equate that with many hundreds of thousands of people literally in gaol.

I suppose Stalin was right, to paraphrase. One person is a tragedy, hundreds of thousands is a statistic.

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by l33t2328 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:54PM (#28477255)
> offences that aren’t even crimes in many countries

Like what? Drugs are becoming decriminalized the world over, but this is an extremely recent phenomenon.

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by milesvp on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:11PM (#28477381)
Like driving while poor. It’s very very common for someone to get a fine that they can not pay, then lose their drivers license for failure to pay. Then get stopped and have to deal with driving without a license, which can include jail time.

Source: good friend was a public defender.

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by l33t2328 on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:22AM (#28478072)
Other countries don’t arrest people who drive without a license?

I’ll need to see worldwide numbers, American numbers, and an exemplar list of laws before I accept such a broad conclusion.

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by milesvp on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:08PM (#28483530)
You may also be missing the fact that many other countries weren’t designed around needing a car. Chances are, if you can’t afford a fine in the first place, losing access to driving will guarantee that you cannot work, making it less likely you can afford to pay the fine. It’s the escalation that’s the problem, but also indicative of the punitive nature of laws weighted against underclasses. Any law with a fixed rate fine is essentially a law that “only exists” for the poor.

You may be right that this is a world wide problem, and I’m only imagining places that don’t punish the poor so harshly. That said, I saw an article recently that gives me hope. It was a jurisdiction in the US where police handed out gift cards to some auto parts store instead of citations when pulling over vehicles for faulty equipment. While the cynic in me thinks this is just a play by the auto parts store to grow it’s market, I like to think it’ll provide good data to drive policy.

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by simonh on Friday September 10, 2021 @03:36AM (#28478741)
I can't speak for other countries, but here in the UK courts can be resistant to charges snowballing like this against a defendant as it's a recognised problem. Fines can be delayed, split into instalments, reduced or put pending against credit history for up to 5 years - although if they find you are able to pay but unwilling they get tough fast. DWL can result in longer suspension of a license, fines, or community service.

It does help that traveling by public transport here is a lot less likely to be a problem, to be fair.

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by nautilius on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:46PM (#28477594)
How about using public places in a way you see fit (while not endangering others), e.g. skateboarding or biking in town?

How about letting your kids go to school or to a playground without perpetual parental surveillance, without you being persecuted?

How about the right to sit at a beach in whatever (non)clothing you want? How about just changing into your swimming shorts just there on the beach?

How about only being prosecuted for DUI if you were actually under the influence, and not because a passenger had a bottle of beer in their hand?

How about sitting with your friends in any city square in summer, listening to street musicians and drink a beer, and then walk to the next bar while drinking your beer?

How about just playing music on the radio without censoring ‘bad words’, and even having censored CDs in the stores?

How about someone cursing on national television without this becoming a scandal, or someone showing a breast on television as a singer on stage without it ending your career?

How about driving as fast as you want?

And to your example: how about having actual choice of leaving a job because health insurance is not tied to a job? (Yeah I know, with COBRA you can simply pay a couple thousand a month and just keep your insurance)

How about being able to actually retire in old age and not having to work at Waffle House and Walmart with 80?

How about yelling at some asshole in the parking lot without being legally shot dead because of stand-your-ground?

How about the freedom to study at a college of your choosing, without admission scandals and bribery, and without ruining your future with 6 digit debt?

How about freedom from religion, and still being electable for high office as atheist?

How about never having to worry whether you are in a good enough area of town to just drive through?

How about freely choosing your health insurance rather than being forced to pick one of the two your employer has contracts with?

How about freely choosing internet / power / gas, with the dramatic drops in price that go along with competition in a free market?

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by djrogers on Thursday September 09, 2021 @09:29PM (#28476779)
It would be hard to argue that a country where it's illegal to call someone a dick is particularly free, if that indeed is the case.
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by tpush on Friday September 10, 2021 @06:38AM (#28479717)
It's actually very easy to do that, for example:

Murder: People lose the freedom to murder people, but gain the freedom to not be murdered. American society considers taking the first freedom away to result in better society overall. Germany does the same.

Insults: People lose the freedom to insult other people, but gain the freedom not to be insulted. German society considers taking away the first freedom to result in a better society overall. Americans take the opposite side here.

See, it's actually not at all a naive question of "who has more freedom", because each side can be argued to be more free than the other. Ultimately, it comes down to what choice results in a 'better', more livable society.

Germany and the US simply make different tradeoffs.

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by nautilius on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:41AM (#28481412)
If you think the first amendment ensures your right to call anyone a dick, I suggest you go to the nearest cop you can find and start insulting him, his mother, his family, his children. I am sure if you tell him you’re just exercising your first amendment right, he will endure this for hours without batting an eye.
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by WastingMyTime89 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:19PM (#28477045)
Then most of the world isn't free I fear.

Why should it be legal to publicly insult someone? You can't punch people in the USA. Does that make the country not particularly free?

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by throwawaylinux on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:38PM (#28477168)
> Then most of the world isn't free I fear.

I fear that too. Freedom has always been paid for with blood, so if it's just meekly handed back, we are robbing our grandchildren and passing that cost on to them.

That said, what parts of the world are you talking about? If you look at the insults being freely hurled on twitter at politicians around the the English speaking western world, I'm not sure how bad it is here yet. Maybe it's only a problem there if you insult the wrong type of politician?

> Why should it be legal to publicly insult someone?

How do you define an insult? Would it be insulting to call someone a nazi, white supremacist, racist, misogynist, Russian agent, heartless, senile? What if those things were true or you believed them to be true or at least a valid comparison to some degree? What if you call a religion or ideology bad or point out bad things about its teachings? Even if what you say is true, it can still be taken as insults by followers. Should blasphemy be outlawed?

> You can't punch people in the USA. Does that make the country not particularly free?

It does not.

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by tomschlick on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:26PM (#28477090)
Insulting someone with words and punching them in the face are two drastically different things.
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by ms4720 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:37PM (#28477164)
And be very very wary of people and groups that try to erase the difference.
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by WastingMyTime89 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:55PM (#28477260)
Because as an American you put the border at physical violence but think verbal violence doesn't matter. You see that as freedom. I see it as a lack of culture. Far more than an ocean separates these two continents.

Note that it is entirely play pretend anyway. I know for a fact that I can actually say and do far more here than the American society would tolerate in the USA.

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by tomschlick on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:59PM (#28477287)
Because the line of physical violence is pretty clear cut. The line at which someone gets offended is not and can vary drastically depending on the person, religion, current events, etc. Laws need clear definitions.
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by WastingMyTime89 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:05PM (#28477324)
Insulting someone has an actual definition. It is not about being offended.
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by yjftsjthsd-h on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:32PM (#28477512)
> Because as an American you put the border at physical violence but think verbal violence doesn't matter. You see that as freedom. I see it as a lack of culture. Far more than an ocean separates these two continents.

This, for instance, is clearly an insult; please report to the nearest detention center for your reeducation immediately. /s

But seriously, no; insults are subjective enough to be a terrible legal basis.

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by hervature on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:19PM (#28477444)
Is calling someone fat when they are indeed fat an insult? It obviously depends on context, intent, and delivery. Any definition is going to be nebulous.
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by thaumasiotes on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:08PM (#28477361)
Whatever definition you provide, there will be an infinite number of insults that don't match it, or an infinite number of compliments that do.
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by zepto on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:58PM (#28477275)
It’s not much of a ‘culture’ if politeness has to be enforced by the government.

For what it’s worth, having lived in both places Americans are less likely to insult you than the British, but more likely to take it seriously.

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by yann2 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:17PM (#28477430)
Jesus Christ..European cultural "superiority" was used to justify colonization of people around the world by literally every European country.
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by Levitz on Friday September 10, 2021 @11:23AM (#28482843)
>Why should it be legal to publicly insult someone?

I consider an insult to be an expression of an opinion and thus protected by the 19th article of the universal declaration of human rights.

As far as I am concerned, ideally such blatant misuse of power in such an authoritarian way should land people in jail.

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by ALittleLight on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:55PM (#28477634)
Some states in the US allow "mutual combat", meaning that if both parties agree to fight you actually can legally punch people in the US.
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by syntheticcorp on Friday September 10, 2021 @02:43AM (#28478461)
I assume other countries allowing boxing matches?
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by zepto on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:55PM (#28477264)
Can you not tell the difference between physical violence and words?
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by WastingMyTime89 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:07PM (#28477341)
Worlds can hurt just as much if not more. Insults are unneeded. They are unnecessary to a discussion and they are a form of violence. Why should they be legal?
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by zepto on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:44PM (#28477590)
> Worlds can hurt just as much if not more.

Only if you compare words with the most trivial of physical violence.

> Insults are unneeded. They are unnecessary to a discussion and they are a form of violence. Why should they be legal?

This is dismissive of my perspective and therefore insulting. I think you should be arrested. Maybe the cops and the judge will agree with me.

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by Levitz on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:55PM (#28485007)
>Worlds can hurt just as much if not more.

I'm sorry but that only applies if you are thoroughly infantile. I don't mean this as an offense but that behavior is proper of literal children.

If some random person says a word and that has serious consequences upon the mental health of an adult person that person needs therapy.

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by PixyMisa on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:44PM (#28477589)
> Then most of the world isn't free I fear.

Well, exactly.

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by jdavis703 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @09:44PM (#28476872)
It’s possible for a democratic political system to exist, and still prohibit insulting politicians. It’s quite possible to criticize any politician without resulting to ad hominem attacks. Even the former US Vice President Dick Cheney nearly faced consequences for violating senate rules by telling a senator to “go f___ himself.”
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by charia on Thursday September 09, 2021 @09:52PM (#28476918)
Do you genuinely believe that laws that try to separate criticize versus insult can work?

I can't see anything other than laws like that being abused by politicians and government officials to quell speech and create a chilling effect amongst the populace.

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by Retric on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:25PM (#28477084)
Dueling used to be acceptable in the US and that didn’t prevent free speech. As long as it’s limited to reasonable fines simply requiring civility is unlikely to significantly quell free speech even if it did get abused by government officials.
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by kook_throwaway on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:00PM (#28477289)
>As long as it’s limited to reasonable fines

This will only result in those not living paycheck to paycheck being willing to speak out.

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by jdavis703 on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:46AM (#28478202)
If this were true, then low-income people wouldn’t speed or run red lights. (In reality they still do it, they just wind up in debt trap.)
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by jdavis703 on Friday September 10, 2021 @11:13AM (#28482695)
It seems to be working fine for Germany. In general I believe the chilling effect is often moderated by the Streisand effect.
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by mc32 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:24PM (#28477070)
What goes around comes around. Mr Cheney got a nice cold serving of revenge by a constituent in Miss. who, apropos, was inspired by mr Cheney's own exchange with sen. Pat Leahy. Around the :24s mark https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lmhmYYjrVUY To his credit Cheney took it in stride.
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by technothrasher on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:00PM (#28476956)
Are you talking about Cheney swearing at Durban? I don't recall him facing any consequences. All I remember is some pearl clutching about it and then nothing else. I don't think he even broke any senate rules, as the senate was not in session at the time he swore. Since then, public swearing and insults by US politicians seems to have only increased.
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by jdavis703 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:05PM (#28477322)
There was some tut tutting about the VP technically being a senator since the VP casts tie-breaking senate votes. But I don’t think it went anywhere serious. Anyways, it later turned out the VP is allowed to shoot people without consequences too, so it seems VPs are given a certain amount of immunity. Point is, there are rules on political speech, but it doesn’t have to quell political debate.
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by throwdecro on Thursday September 09, 2021 @09:56PM (#28476936)
As another commenter pointed out, it looks like it's against German law to insult anyone, not just politicians.

If only politicians were protected from insult, I don't think that would be compatible with democracy at all.

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by esyir on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:59PM (#28477279)
I'm wondering if enforcement of this law is consistent. Somehow, I'm pretty doubtful, but I'd like some confirmation of how it works over there.
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by HotHotLava on Friday September 10, 2021 @05:31AM (#28479367)
It is never proactively enforced, it always requires a "Strafantrag" of the insulted party.
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by selcuka on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:00PM (#28477292)
> Even the former US Vice President Dick Cheney nearly faced consequences

But everyone else called him a "pimmel" with no consequences at all.

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by lmm on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:20PM (#28477052)
Are they wrong? Which is more likely to affect any given individual? Which country do you have the best chance of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness in?
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by chuckee on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:31PM (#28477132)
> Which is more likely to affect any given individual?

That metric is hilariously wrong. Consider a country with universal healthcare, but where only a single political party is allowed. You're much more likely to face medical issues in your life, than wanting to start your own party and being prevented.

Does that make the one-party-state more free than every country without universal healthcare?

In other words, by phrasing it as "freedom to live in comfort and safety", you are conflating comfort and safety with freedom.

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by soperj on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:59PM (#28477283)
Does it make a difference when there's only 2 parties and neither of them are really any different from each other?
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by lmm on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:37PM (#28477162)
If the one-party-ness doesn't actually affect anyone living there, then yes. Most of us would say that the problems with one-party states are not limited to the tiny minority of people who would want to start a new political party, but also has a large effect on people who disagree with government policies but have no representation.
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by kiawe_fire on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:50PM (#28477230)
Right. People presumably don’t start political movements because they’re happy.

They typically do so to affect change.

Change that may well be required, for example, to address problems in said one-party healthcare system.

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by esyir on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:00PM (#28477295)
I Find this definition of freedom mind boggling. By that logic, brave new world describes a free society.
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by lmm on Friday September 10, 2021 @02:20AM (#28478373)
Is that wrong? Huxley deliberately intended it as a critique of post-Christian morality; that people are mostly free of any responsibility is very much part of the point.
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by tomschlick on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:25PM (#28477077)
> Which country do you have the best chance of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness in?

Judging by immigration numbers, the US.

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by lmm on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:35PM (#28477152)
Germany has a higher proportion of immigrants than the US, so how do you figure that?
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by zepto on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:00PM (#28477291)
Only counting new immigrants over a very short recent period.
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by tomschlick on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:42PM (#28477191)
Proportions don't matter in this case. Individuals immigrating each year and the waitlist to do so does. Otherwise you're comparing admission policies instead of the will to live in that place.
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by lmm on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:44PM (#28477202)
Comparing absolute numbers is surely meaningless - if the US was arbitrarily split in half, there would be half as many immigrants to each half, but that wouldn't mean the US was suddenly half as attractive to immigrate to.
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by jimmaswell on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:14PM (#28477403)
> Which country do you have the best chance of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness in

In my case, the US where I am for sure.

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by lmm on Saturday September 11, 2021 @09:03AM (#28491654)
How do you deal with the healthcare thing? I'm not thrilled about the idea of getting arrested for calling someone a dick online, but realistically that seems like a much smaller risk to my prospects of a good life than the risk of medical bankruptcy if I lived in the US, particularly with the risk of losing health insurance through at-will firing.

(A dickhead manager lying and trying to fire me was the most stressful experience of my life even when I knew I was in the right and got a decent payout eventually; I can't imagine going through that with no legal protection)

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by codewithcheese on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:55PM (#28477257)
> more free than me

How are we meant to make sense of your comment, if you don't state which country your from/in?

I see this often, commenters presuming we know which country they are in.

Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by jimmaswell on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:10PM (#28477376)
"as an American" referred to me
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by codewithcheese on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:18PM (#28477433)
Ahhhhh, My parser failed on that terse grammar. Doh!
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by rad_gruchalski on Friday September 10, 2021 @03:12AM (#28478610)
Until you get stopped in Nevada and your possessions are ceased by the cops. Or until you get swatted. Or you piss Elon Musk off and he sends cops after you.
Re:A Twitter user insulted a German politician, then police ... by PixyMisa on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:44PM (#28477585)
Not many Australians insisting they're more free right now.