That's categorically false, and the article alludes to this somewhat. The biggest problem with renewables (primarily solar) right now is the "duck curve" [1]. That is, there is plenty of energy available mid-day, but then right when available solar starts to subside is also when you get a sizable demand increase in the early evening (e.g. people getting home from work, cooking, watching TV, doing dishes and laundry, etc.) The slope of that rise means that you not only need as much dispatchable energy sources as before, but you need to ramp them up and down much more frequently, which takes a higher toll on equipment.
Thus, there is a real immediate need for the type of "time shifting" storage the article talks about right now.
As long as you come out ahead overall its still a good idea.
It's like saying gas flaring is a problem and we have a desperate need to solve that before getting rid of coal. Well, it would be nice, but overall swapping coal for natural gas is a good thing regardless.
Can you explain this? How does “wasting some solar” solve the problem when your max solar output is 0 at peak demand?
https://www.vox.com/energy-and-environment/2018/3/20/1712847...
This features some slides from the original use of the term. Note the repeated reference to "Ramp" since that's what the problem was.
> We have to be really careful when we talk about something breaking. The only thing that’s going to break is the economics of solar. The lights are gonna stay on. All it comes down to is more curtailment.
One of the other solutions was asking the gas plants to ramp faster. The specs said the equipment could do it, it was just institutional inertia as they hadn't needed to do it before and so weren't prepared for it.
Yes, that is the exact point. Unless storage capacity is introduced to the system:
1. It becomes uneconomical to add any more solar plants, because the time when the solar plants can produce already has demand fully met by other, existing solar/wind plants.
2. Since you reach peak daily demand when solar and wind approaches 0 output, it means you need just as much fossil fuel plant generation capacity as before - you can't decommission any of those plants (or, at present, perhaps you just convert them to natural gas).
I'm not sure how this thread went off the rails. All I was originally responding to was the sentiment that "you don't need to worry about storage capacity until you already have the vast majority of your energy met by renewables", and that statement is easily provably false because there are many areas of the world that still have relatively low levels of total power generation from renewables, but until the "time shifting" storage problem is solved it will be uneconomical to add more solar to the system.
> you don't need to worry about storage capacity until you already have the vast majority of your energy met by renewables
This, on the other hand is true.
There are places where incentives (planned or accidental) make batteries a useful, profitable thing to do right now, but only in very small numbers.
For example, some gas peaker plants installed batteries because it let them respond faster to market changes and so earn more money. Does this mean batteries are required for gas peakers? No obviously not.
We need some kind of storage, at a fairly large scale to meet the final 20% or so of going 100% renewable. My bet is green hydrogen is going to be the winner here. We'll also have a bunch of lithium batteries connected to the grid (EVs etc.) because they're useful for other things and will help out in getting to 100% if they have some grid intelligence.
But, nowhere in the world are we at a place where installing solar and/or wind is anywhere near maxed out. And when we are, the fix will not be batteries but things like grid interconnects, demand response, targeted efficiency improvements and a hundred other boring technologies that we already understand.
It's generally cheaper to build more renewables and just find a use for the excess than it is to build batteries.
This is why people who don't like renewables have consistently, for years now, pretended to think that you need to install exactly enough renewables to get 100% of your needs and then use as much lithium batteries as you need to shift that power from the time it was produced to the time it is needed.
This is stupid, and at least some of them know it is stupid and are just saying it for effect.
It is not true, and the numbers they come up with using this model are meaningless.
Even then it was one of those "good problems to have" as it meant you had an unimaginably high (at that time) level of solar. Some places arent as lucky as California when it comes to solar provision.
The fix for the totally seperate "nighttime" problem is some mix of oversupply of wind, hydro, demand management, transmission lines, batteries etc. but we only need to continue with the next low hanging fruit at the moment as we've not even maxed out solar pv (fallacy #1 in the article is expecting instant perfection and having solutions to all the problems we haven't actually hit yet)
(And annual peak demand is the correct timeframe to use, since our system targets reliability on the scale of years not days.)
Today's peak: http://www.caiso.com/TodaysOutlook/Pages/index.html?fbclid=I...
Annual peaks: https://www.caiso.com/documents/californiaisopeakloadhistory...
I wrote a detailed version of this comment later in another thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28436432
Fits with a "solar and wind will be too cheap to meter [the amount of cost and materials going into manufacture]" paradigm.
That makes 0 sense. If you have 3x needed capacity at midday but 0x capacity at midnight, you could over-provision by 100x - zero times a hundred is still zero.
When evening dusk envelops Boston and New York, there's still plenty of sunlight near Chicago or Saint Louis. Conversely, when it's still morning dusk in Chicago and Saint Louis, sun is already shining over Boston and New York.
We of course already have transmission lines all over the country. They can help, given some coordination between energy companies, and maybe upgraded in the east-west direction to help deliver solar energy when its generation increases.
"This is the problem with renewables..." - this amusingly sounds a little like an instance of fallacy #1. It becomes "the" problem only when youve got way more renewables capacity than almost everyone has right now.
All grids have a lot of excess production thats only used to meet occaisional peaks. This is not a bad thing in itself and not something new to renewables.
It doesnt exactly render the solar panels pointless.
Other locations have more flexibility, either due to natural gas peakers or the prevalence of water (pumped hydro is the best battery)
Again, the source article talks about this, but this is also not just a simple problem that can be wished away, and the only "fallacy" is pretending this problem doesn't exist.
Firstly, you are correct that on most days, demand peaks around 7pm when solar output is tiny.
Source: http://www.caiso.com/TodaysOutlook/Pages/index.html
However, on most years, demand often peaks around 3pm-5pm, not 7pm (and note that in late summer in California days are longer and solar noon is roughly 1pm, so output is not bad at all). The reason for this is that the days with the most electricity consumption tend to be hot with large AC loads, and those loads tend to be higher during midday.
Source: https://www.caiso.com/documents/californiaisopeakloadhistory...
So when you say solar output is 0 at "peak demand", it's worth mentioning whether you mean the daily peak or the annual peak or a peak measured over another timeframe.
For utility capacity planning, we use the annual peak, not the daily peak, because we want to avoid blackouts most years, not most days. Therefore, adding solar - at today's margin - still does reduce our capex and need for gas peakers.
The math gets a bit more multidimensional when you do this for real and consider aspects beyond peak demand (like ramping, fuel, current generation fleet, tradeoffs in characteristics of new gas plants, geographic spread, congestion, etc.), but the main point remains true and important: the daily peak is not the annual peak, and it's a clear mistake to use the daily peak to conclude that solar doesn't help with peak demand.
In fact, at today's margins, solar both helps with peak power and with energy generation. It's fantastic. (And of course it gets less and less fantastic the more you add.)
Anyway, this is a common misconception I've seen a lot, so I've added a new section to the Duck Curve Wikipedia article you cited above to help explain it.
You're saying there's a need for storage right now because without it peak demand can't be met by solar.
They're saying you don't need it right now because if you're ok wasting some of the solar power you can still reduce non-renewable use further without adding storage.
It's just two different ways of looking at it.
No matter how many panels you add, you won't add any electricity at 7pm / 8pm (depending on time of year) because the sun has already set. There's still substantial demand for electricity.
This means to solve the 7pm / 8pm duck curve, you need to build natural gas peaker plants, or figure out a storage methodology.
That's it. Otherwise you get brownouts at 7pm every night and need to manage the lack of electricity. Maybe rolling brownouts is the solution people are proposing?
The other solutions are: figure out storage, or build a gas peaker plant to temporarily provide power in those few hours.
-----------
We focus at the "Duck Curve", because that's clearly where the next brownout will occur without intervention. Secondly: environmentalists are going to block the build of any natural gas plant (even if its necessary), so getting "ahead of the argument" only makes sense.
Also, the duck curve problem isn't the need for gas peakers after the sun goes down, it's the speed at which you need to ramp them up from being switched off.
If they can't ramp as fast as the solar drops, then you need to start them earlier and end up producing extra electricity (and carbon) that you don't want.
The problem you are talking about is called "nightime" and I'll refer you to the footnote in the article that covers this.
Wind is certainly a thing. Its not perfectly reliable, even over large areas (ex: a hurricane on the East Coast would shut down turbines due to too much wind... over a large area). But wind is at least part of the answer to the duck curve.
And Hydro is great, but has a peculiar weakness, especially in the context of California's drought conditions. California has the problem of water-shortages as well, which means that hydro-plants are in "water management mode" rather than energy-management.
That is to say: Hydro serves two masters: energy management AND water management. If you're using the dam as water-management, you're not necessarily getting the electricity you want at the right times.
----------
I'm not convinced that anything aside from peaker plants really solve the duck curve frankly.
Storage will get there eventually. But not today: there needs to be more research and development into storage technologies before we have something large enough. (Either that, or we need to solve the West's water issues, so that hydro plants can be more into energy-management mode rather than the more pressing water-management issues)
The storage needs that OP mentioned...the kind that gets us from 80% up to 100% renewables is a lot of storage. We're talking multiple days, possibly weeks of storage.
The supply/demand graphs for the California grid are public for all to discuss. We can look at 9/05/2021, and see that 25GW was demanded at 12-noon, while 36GW was demanded at 7pm at night (hour 19 on the graph).
The energy required between 5pm and 10pm on 9/5/2021 (from 17 to 22) is ~37GW per hour.
That's 185GW-hrs of energy. Exactly what technology can both store-and-output 185GW-hrs each day, and every day? The "Tesla Megabattery pack" in Australia is 0.3 GW-hrs FYI, to give you what a "very very large" battery can do.
California already has 4500 GWh of storage. They don't have those peak power levels (currently, 4.5GW) but that's a matter of capital investment into pumps and generators.
Not that that is even needed. California has a very large coastline with extremely reliable wind power. For example, there isn't a single spot anywhere along the coast of California that is forecast to have <8kts of wind for more than a day this month. Overprovisioning of wind power is a much bigger part of the solution to the duck curve than storage is.
https://www.energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2020/12/f81/SETO%20P...
This scheme would also allow backstop generation by using a fuel to reheat the storage material, potentially useful for "black swan" prolonged outages.
The fluidized bed heat exchangers seem particularly interesting to me, if sufficiently low escape of particulate matter can be achieved.
I don't think the but storage is used to argue we shouldn't build renewable resources.
I see three parties to this argument in the states.
1. Climate change deniers - These people don't ever really ever argue about storage in good faith. Because they don't believe climate change is a problem.
2. Pro-Nuclear climate change believers - People who believe climate change is a problem that needs to be addressed and believe nuclear is probably our best bet. This is the group that brings up "but storage" all the time.
3. Anti-Nuclear climate change believers - These people believe that storage isn't really an issue or will be fixed shortly. They believe solar and wind is the solution to our climate change problem.
Group 2 is believes in replacing fossil fuels with renewables. But when it comes to finite amounts of attention, and funding they believe nuclear is a better option.
1. People who don't or won't believe that renewables work
2. People who believe they do.
So whether you like nuclear is irrelevant. If you like nuclear but hate renewables you're in group 1 with the climate change deniers, if you like nuclear but believe the general reality based consensus on renewables costs and viability you're in group 2 along with the people who don't like nuclear.
- air quality, radiation from burning stuff
- noise, pollution
- accidents(mines, oil rigs etc.)
- with every gallon/liter of oil you buy, you send at least 50% of those money to a foreign despot.
Being a climate change "denier" is mostly irrelevant for this discussion.
If you (correctly) think coal causes lots of pollution and fossil fuels have issues and need replaced then whether you end up in group 1 or 2 still depends on whether you agree with the general consensus that renewables are better/cheaper than nuclear or not.
Otherwise at best you can adjust the output of your dispatchable energy sources (mostly coal and nuclear) to make up for the unpredictiveness of the solar and wind. But you still need the same capacity.
This is why Germany and Spain, 2 countries who invested a lot in solar and wind, continued to grow their use of traditional power plant at the same pace as before they started on renewable. For Germany it's even worse because they decided to stop using nuclear, so they burn even more coal than before.
So, if you have medium amounts of solar and wind, it's fine keeping the gas plants in reserve and maybe having to use them on a particularly cold day once every other year. A gas plant is very cheap from investment perspective. From total emissions point of view it is also fine. (These exceptionally cold windless winter days are waved as examples of the unsuitability of wind and solar.)
Of course if your gas pipes leak like crazy, maybe it's best to turn to decommission the plants and network.
That said, storage is growing, a 1GW DC line to Norway was put into operations recently.
So an excess amount of renewables is not a big issue for the grid. Owners of renewable sources may be less happy to switch them off.
(In the EU) storage can take the place of fossil when fossil becomes expensive enough. No need to give more subsidies to storage than renewables would get.
Excess amounts of renewable can also be used for other purposes, such as producing green hydrogen.
Having a large capacity in the form of gas turbines that is only use occasionally costs money, but has to advantage that all extra renewable energy results in less use of gas and therefor less CO2.
So today, we can have a grid that consists of renewables plus gas turbines without any storage.
A combined cycle gas turbine power plant might cost 10% of a nuclear plant of equal output. So even if we have to back up the entire fricking grid with CC it's still much cheaper than doing it with nuclear.
So a windfarm backed up by hydrogen may need a significant fraction of the farm to produce hydrogen.
In the end, a nuclear power plant might be cheaper. Might be, because we just don't know. Nuclear power plants are insanely expensive at the moment.
You build more renewables than you need for electricity production and use it to generate hydrogen for agriculture and industry 99% of the time. When you really hit the yearly peak you can a) turn the electrolysers off and if that's not enough b) use some of the hydrogen to generate electricity.
Of course, if you're lucky, then you can get by with just the renewables and sell all your hydrogen for other uses but when that 1 in 10 year event happens you can get away without burning too much fossil gas and paying the carbon fee associated with it.
And no, nuclear isn't cheaper, even if during the rare times you're burning hydrogen the cost/kWh is high. That's because nuclear needs to be selling at high prices most of the time, including when solar/wind/batteries are able to directly deliver.
It's possible other technologies (transmission, demand dispatching, other storage technologies, even natural gas with atmospheric CO2 capture) will be cheaper than grid hydrogen storage. That doesn't help nuclear.
This is the reason why electricity was traditionally cheaper at night.
Germany also doesnt burn more coal than before. The amount of coal they burn has been falling steadily since about 2010.
(I am curious about more details since the figure lack context. It is not clear whether the 80% applies to nominal power.)
Edit: the English wikipedia article on load following is actually much clearer: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Load_following_power_plant#N...
> Modern nuclear plants with light water reactors are designed to have maneuvering capabilities in the 30-100% range with 5%/minute slope.
In any case, the problem with nuclear is that existing nuclear technology does not decarbonize the world. World primary energy demand is 18 TW. This would require 6000 nuclear power plants (3GW(th) each), if today's reactors are used they'd consume (the 235U in) 1.5 million tonnes of natural uranium per year. Total world uranium resource is a shade over 6 million tonnes, so it would run out in four years.
To power the world with nuclear one either needs seawater uranium extraction (scaled up by 12 orders of magnitude from what's been done so far; 170 km^2 of ocean area for each of those reactors; the power/area is much worse than PV) or breeder reactors (which France has given up on.)
Roughly half of the primary energy demand isn't actually used, it's just wasted as heat. Replacing fossil fuels with nuclear or renewables would mean that much less primary energy would be needed due to the efficiency gains of electrification.
The real issue with nuclear is that it needs all the same stuff as renewables (better grid connections, pink hydrogen production, demand management, EVs, hydrogen based flight and shipping) in order to keep costs reasonable but still just costs more because solar and wind are much cheaper.
Of course the renewables are cheaper, but in addition to that argument the pro-nuclear argument is deceptive when it tries to portray existing nuclear technology as sufficient.
Worried about terrorists? The reprocessing plant needs to leave a few isotopes in the fuel it produces. Things like Co-60. The spent rods have it--the reactors and the shipping systems are built to handle it. The terrorist can't handle it, though--while some are willing to engage in suicide missions they're not going to engage in futile suicide missions. Stealing the material will just get you dead before you can deliver it.
In any case, breeders mean the claim that existing nuclear technology, and in particular France's existing nuclear technology, can do it are wrong. France's breeder effort was a spectacular failure that they've now abandoned.
The numbers you use for uranium resources, are the amount that is economically extractable right now at current prices. Given that only 14% of the cost of a nuclear plant is raw fuel we have lots of room to increase to increase the cost of extraction.
And many places abandoned breeder reactors because the cost of uranium is cheap enough right now that fuel efficiency doesn't matter.
France's abandonment of their breeder program is the tell that they don't think there's any significant chance that nuclear will scale to power the world anytime soon.
Not arguing against renewables here but this 1+ day response time figure gets quoted a lot. (eg. my father-in-law uses it and I've always thought it was sketchy, your post just pushed me over the edge to go look it up. ;)
Source: Graph on page 10 of https://usea.org/sites/default/files/092014_Increasing%20the...
"What is expected to be the last new coal plant to come online in Germany entered commercial operation on May 30, more than a decade after it was first planned... The government last year said it would close all 84 of its coal-fired power plants by 2038 as the country moves toward cleaner sources of electricity."[2]
Spain is also in a similar phase: "Spain has recently made headlines with good climate news. In May, the government announced plans for full decarbonization. At the beginning of July, half of the country’s coal plants were retired. REN21 analyst Duncan Gibb explains why this is the moment for governments to understand that spending taxpayer money to keep fossil fuel infrastructure afloat is a sunk investment."[3]
[1] https://www.worldometers.info/coal/germany-coal/
[2] https://www.powermag.com/germany-brings-last-new-coal-plant-...
Anyways, things may or may not work if other countries go into renewables. They may have different spike times - but I kinda doubt it. Most Europe wakes up and plugs its kettles at about the same time. And it's small enough that being windy or cloudy will happen in most of it, at least some of the time.
In any case it seems like an unreliable source.
Example of German power imports:
https://energy-charts.info/charts/power_trading/chart.htm?l=...
https://www.renewable-ei.org/en/activities/column/20180302.h...
https://knoema.com/atlas/Germany/topics/Energy/Electricity/E...
but the OP does address that at all.
instead you get:"Fallacy 2 - 100% Lemon or 100% Lime or Bust"
I am not saying that the author does not make valid points,
I am saying that the valid points get lost when titled with evident nonsense
The issue with that article isn’t storage it’s the energy mix used and the lack of excess production. As #1 points out you get to 100% not by building that in a day you build more storage, more wind, more hydro, and or more solar and then figure out what else is cost effective to add. Currently there is seemingly excess solar in California with prices going negative except unlike what’s mentioned people are actually still building solar because it’s cheap enough that even without selling in the middle of sunny days it’s still profitable. It’s really not obvious that that’s going to happen just running some
Yeah, and at least solar is really easy to turn off so you don't actually have to pay the negative price, you can take zero.
Because they have French nuclear power to back them up. And fucking German coal.
Hydrogen is promising, but there are technical problems with transportation and storage. I'd like to see carbon taxes push us towards these types of solutions instead of burning 'renewable' carbon.
Hydrogen for load leveling can be stored underground as a pressurized gas, just as natural gas is stored. This is a demonstrated technology. Also, the US already has 1000 miles of hydrogen pipelines, so that too is a demonstrated technology.
The main issue is hydrogen embrittlement; where steel spontaneously weakens and fractures in the prescence of hydrogen. The problem is much worse with pure hydrogen than with methane (where even the low concentrations of hydrogen are enough to pose a serious problem). There is a lot of serious enghineering work being done on this front, but I don't think we have reached the ablility to scale by a factor 200k just yet.
The magical hypothetical world where nuclear is much cheaper is called "the 1970s." In this improbable scenario, first world countries like France completely divest from coal in favor of non-carbon-polluting energy techologies.
Hydrogen embrittlement is a known issue with known solutions. After all, the world consumes 700 cubic kilometers (at STP) of hydrogen each year. This gas is confined in tanks and pipes, which obviously have to be made of materials for which the problem is solved.
"Surges of cheap electricity tended to push down prices in the common German-Austrian bidding zone, leading to a rise in demand and exports, something the two countries' grid connections were unable to handle."
https://www.politico.eu/article/germany-austria-energy-europ...
This goes with my issue, emergencies. I expected to see that in the article.
When you absolutely MUST have power absolutely right now, renewables don’t cut it with current storage options. Think disaster or pop-up energy needs.
I’m just really skeptical that the hard pushes for renewables are taking into account we should have excess production options in coal and NG going forward.
A very pervasive argument against renewables is "but storage!!!".
That's one form of this type of argument. There isn't much storage needed for renewables unless you get to very large numbers. Germany is close to 50% renewables, and it barely built any storage at all in the past years. (There's some existing amount of storage, but that largely existed before renewables even started).
Every time you have a "but storage!!" argument, it's an argument primarily relevant for the step from 80% renewables to 100%. But it's very often brought up in situations where the question is rather how to get from 10% renewables to 30%.