News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by hn_throwaway_99 on Monday September 06, 2021 @04:48PM (#28437942)
> The only thing that’s going to break is the economics of solar.

Yes, that is the exact point. Unless storage capacity is introduced to the system:

1. It becomes uneconomical to add any more solar plants, because the time when the solar plants can produce already has demand fully met by other, existing solar/wind plants.

2. Since you reach peak daily demand when solar and wind approaches 0 output, it means you need just as much fossil fuel plant generation capacity as before - you can't decommission any of those plants (or, at present, perhaps you just convert them to natural gas).

I'm not sure how this thread went off the rails. All I was originally responding to was the sentiment that "you don't need to worry about storage capacity until you already have the vast majority of your energy met by renewables", and that statement is easily provably false because there are many areas of the world that still have relatively low levels of total power generation from renewables, but until the "time shifting" storage problem is solved it will be uneconomical to add more solar to the system.

Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by ZeroGravitas on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @08:09AM (#28443699)
You're wrong, and I'll try to explain why you are wrong.

> you don't need to worry about storage capacity until you already have the vast majority of your energy met by renewables

This, on the other hand is true.

There are places where incentives (planned or accidental) make batteries a useful, profitable thing to do right now, but only in very small numbers.

For example, some gas peaker plants installed batteries because it let them respond faster to market changes and so earn more money. Does this mean batteries are required for gas peakers? No obviously not.

We need some kind of storage, at a fairly large scale to meet the final 20% or so of going 100% renewable. My bet is green hydrogen is going to be the winner here. We'll also have a bunch of lithium batteries connected to the grid (EVs etc.) because they're useful for other things and will help out in getting to 100% if they have some grid intelligence.

But, nowhere in the world are we at a place where installing solar and/or wind is anywhere near maxed out. And when we are, the fix will not be batteries but things like grid interconnects, demand response, targeted efficiency improvements and a hundred other boring technologies that we already understand.

It's generally cheaper to build more renewables and just find a use for the excess than it is to build batteries.

This is why people who don't like renewables have consistently, for years now, pretended to think that you need to install exactly enough renewables to get 100% of your needs and then use as much lithium batteries as you need to shift that power from the time it was produced to the time it is needed.

This is stupid, and at least some of them know it is stupid and are just saying it for effect.

It is not true, and the numbers they come up with using this model are meaningless.