News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by throwaway_nkp on Sunday August 29, 2021 @10:12AM (#28346836)
Never read religious texts before, but I remember Oppenheimer's famous quote, "Now I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds." What stuff might be interesting in Bhagavad Gita for a scientist like him?
Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by launchiterate on Sunday August 29, 2021 @10:17AM (#28346880)
The Bhagavad Gita is really a philosophy of living life by calmly performing duty while being outcome independent. It’s one of the popular philosophies that discusses what is right action. Especially what is right action in extremely uncertain and difficult circumstances such as what Oppenheimer faced. The main protagonist of the Gita is a warrior facing his own kinsmen in the battlefield and his charioteer the symbolic representation of the divine guides him through his moral dilemma. Their dialogue is the Bhagavad Gita translated as “The song of the Lord”.
Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by caddybox on Sunday August 29, 2021 @11:05AM (#28347281)
The Bhagavid Gita attempts to define a person's response to a life event by decomposing it into "dharma" and "karma". Dharma is external and is specified by a person's birth, caste, etc. (essentially societal factors) whereas Karma is more personal and rises out of actions from a man's conscious volition. It attempts to propose the right action by checking what is good dharma and good karma but as I've read in a beautiful introduction to the Mahabharata translation by John D. Smith, Dharma and Karma can often point in opposite directions.

I thoroughly agree that the central idea of the Bhagavad Gita is to do your job without unnecessary worry or anxiety about the outcome. I've seen similar ideas in Epictetus's Enchiridion (put yourself to things in your control and forget about things beyond your power) and more recently in the notion of "separation of tasks" central to Alfred Adler's works. Irrespective of the source, the idea of focussing on my job without worrying about the outcome has been immensely helpful to me in moments of great anxiety and uncertainty.

Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by nuker on Sunday August 29, 2021 @12:05PM (#28347855)
Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by launchiterate on Sunday August 29, 2021 @11:44AM (#28347610)
One the lessons I personally took from it is following your path even though other paths may seem more attractive. Follow your calling essentially.
Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by eklavya on Sunday August 29, 2021 @12:34PM (#28348156)
I think that’s really really wrong interpretation of it. It tells you your karma (actions) should always be dictated by your dharma (the right thing to do, nothing to do with caste btw, not sure how that got into the translation if it did).

Krishna tells Arjun (the warrior being mentioned here) that it doesn’t matter that it’s your kinsmen including some which are the salt of the earth on the other side. You fight them because they are standing for adharma (injustice) and you should always stand for dharma (justice) no matter the personal cost.

Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by unmole on Sunday August 29, 2021 @01:22PM (#28348597)
> your dharma (the right thing to do, nothing to do with caste btw, not sure how that got into the translation if it did).

The right thing to do is not universal. Dharma doesn't place the same responsibilities on a king and a peasant. Your dharma is dependent on your role in the larger order and thus on your caste. The Mahabharata itself has more than a hundred references to Kshatriya dharma which is unsurprising given its martial context.

Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by naravara on Sunday August 29, 2021 @03:09PM (#28349552)
It also seems a little cynical in places about how that specific conception of “Kshatriya dharma” plays out. Most of the central conflicts of the tale revolve around people being trapped by certain obligations stemming from hardline adherence to certain Kshatriya codes of honor. Towards the end there is a whole soliloquy where someone widowed by the war is heaping the blame for the carnage of Krishna and everyone involved in upholding what she believes to be insane adherence to codes of loyalty and never backing down on a promise once given.

Krishna kind of receives it with a shrug, and eventually his own clan is annihilated by infighting and all the principal heroes of the tale save Yudistra perish with only the briefest and half-hearted eulogy that elucidates their main tragic flaw, like Arjuna’s vanity. In fact, Krishna’s whole purpose for incarnating is said to be a mission to “unburden the Earth” of these Kshatriyas and the ceaseless conflicts they brought to the world.

So in a way the story is as much about the importance of Dharma as it is about the passing (and possible follies) of that rigid conception of Dharma from the world. The end of the conflict ushers in the Kali Yuga, an aeon of strife in which it is stated explicitly that what is and is not dharmic conduct becomes difficult to parse.

Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by unmole on Sunday August 29, 2021 @09:05PM (#28351930)
> Krishna’s whole purpose for incarnating is said to be a mission to “unburden the Earth” of these Kshatriyas and the ceaseless conflicts they brought to the world.

Facinating. I've never heard of this interpretation before. Do you have any sources that discuss this? A quick Google search didn't show anything.

Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by naravara on Monday August 30, 2021 @12:14PM (#28357212)
It's in a variety of commentaries on the Puranas. This from the Srimad Bagavatam is just an example: https://vedabase.io/en/library/tqk/17/

The reasons why the Earth was "burdened" is up for interpretation. The commentary I linked comes from a pretty hardline "Krishnaist" point of view which is a bit on the messianic and manichean side. But wiping out all the "fallen" kshatriyas is one of the traditionally understood purposes for the Krishna incarnation.

It's hard to deny that at the end of the Mahabharata literally all the Kshatriyas are dead, including Krishna's own clan who wipe themselves out as a result of having some sort of senseless frenzy come over them. The only one who survives the age is one of Arjuna's grandsons, from whom all subsequent Kshatriya lineages are said to derive. (Although most modern ones are actually various sequences of steppe invaders who got integrated into Hindu society).

Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by alex_smart on Monday August 30, 2021 @03:09PM (#28359644)
>The reasons why the Earth was "burdened" is up for interpretation.

So, the source does not support your claim in any way, by your own admission?

The source is pretty much just reiterating the Gita's line: Whenever and wherever there is a decline in religious practice, O descendant of Bharata, and a predominant rise of irreligion – at that time I descend Myself.

>But wiping out all the "fallen" kshatriyas is one of the traditionally understood purposes for the Krishna incarnation.

Traditionally according to who? I have not heard this interpretation even once, and you have failed to procure a source.

Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by naravara on Thursday September 02, 2021 @10:23AM (#28392413)
> So, the source does not support your claim in any way, by your own admission?

You could just read it yourself and see that it does say he was there to wipe out the Kshatriyas. What's up for interpretation is what "burdened" means. You will find most religious texts leave many things like this up for interpretation because they're the outputs of evolving, oral traditions and not fixed technical manuals.

> I have not heard this interpretation even once

Then I have serious doubts as to how knowledgable you are on the subject. This is given as the central reason for the events of the Mausala Parva and why the hunter who ends up killing Krishna is held blameless for simply executing the last step in Krishna fulfilling his Dharma. The whole of the Mahabharata is about the concept of yagna/sacrifice, the eradication of the old to make way for the next Yuga.

Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by alex_smart on Thursday September 02, 2021 @08:17PM (#28399023)
> Then I have serious doubts as to how knowledgable you are on the subject

Let me remove all your doubts and assure you that I have absolute no knowledge of the subject whatsoever, apart from what comes from being born in a not-particularly-religious Hindu family. I never claimed any special knowledge nor do I need any to be able to verify your claim.

You are making a straightforward, factual claim that it is the accepted view that the whole purpose of Krishna was to wipe out the Kshatriyas. I am not even asking you to establish that this is the accepted view, which is your full claim. I am just asking for one source that reiterates the same view.

Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by alex_smart on Thursday September 02, 2021 @07:48PM (#28398805)
> You could just read it yourself and see that it does say he was there to wipe out the Kshatriyas.

I have skimmed through the article several times and I could not find anything suggesting that. Can you please quote the relevant sentence/paragraph from the article?

Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by naravara on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:20PM (#28406193)
It's not an 'article' it's a transcription of a book. There are multiple pages. https://vedabase.io/en/library/sb/11/1/
Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by alex_smart on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @10:08AM (#28457218)
>It's not an 'article' it's a transcription of a book. There are multiple pages.

Forget linking to the right chapter of the book, you had not even linked to the right book. How did you expect anyone to verify your claim!?

Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by alex_smart on Monday August 30, 2021 @01:04AM (#28352945)
Fascinating and... wrong. Krishna strongly portrays himself as the creator and preserver of the Varnashrama Dharma in the Bhagavad Gita.
Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by kumarvvr on Sunday August 29, 2021 @02:47PM (#28349373)
The Bhagavid Gita is not a religious book. It's a philosophical treatise. It is a book that is to be analyzed, contemplated and debated.

It clarifies on the way of the world, the duties of a human being, on how to decide what is right and wrong (or what is sin and not).

Ultimately, it posits that what we suffer as humans, are essentially results of our own actions (karma). However these effects are not limited to the lifetime of the human form (because Gita posits that the human body is perishable, but the soul is non-perishable and carries forward the karmic effects).

It puts the cause of human suffering on humans themselves and posits that to escape this never ending cycle of cause-reaction, detachment is the only way forward.

Gita then explains what is detachment. How to be detached from our actions, thereby breaking the cycle of re-birth and ending our suffering.

So, in the context of Oppenheimer, I speculate that his reading of Gita made him aware of his actions and the karmic effects of it on his soul.

Background Note : Hinduism puts forth that this universe and our existence is not the outcome of some being / God. As, logically, speaking, if the universe came to be from the actions of some superior being, then it is implied that some higher being made this superior being, and the hierarchy goes on without end. Hinduism posits that this is absurd and that the universe is nothing but god. Every molecule, every atom, every soul is an expression of god.

Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by omarfarooq on Sunday August 29, 2021 @03:35PM (#28349754)
> Background Note : Hinduism puts forth that this universe and our existence is not the outcome of some being / God. As, logically, speaking, if the universe came to be from the actions of some superior being, then it is implied that some higher being made this superior being, and the hierarchy goes on without end. Hinduism posits that this is absurd and that the universe is nothing but god. Every molecule, every atom, every soul is an expression of god.

Your statements are directly refuted by the Gita itself:

BG 10.39: I am the generating seed of all living beings, O Arjun. No creature moving or non-moving can exist without me.

BG 10.42: What need is there for all this detailed knowledge, O Arjun? Simply know that by one fraction of my being, I pervade and support this entire creation.

BG 10.8: I am the origin of all creation. Everything proceeds from me. The wise who know this perfectly worship me with great faith and devotion.

There is no problem of infinite regress when God is defined as the uncaused cause.

Neither is a scripture being both religious in nature and philosophical a mutual exclusivity.

Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by alex_smart on Sunday August 29, 2021 @04:12PM (#28350053)
>The Bhagavid Gita is not a religious book

Only somebody who has never read the Gita can say this.

Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by amriksohata on Sunday August 29, 2021 @04:23PM (#28350147)
What? No, it is a religious book teaching Dharma
Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by forgingahead on Sunday August 29, 2021 @10:49AM (#28347135)
What stuff might be interesting in Bhagavad Gita for a scientist like him?

There shouldn't be an implication that science and religion are at odds - perhaps the cartoon interpretation of religion by some segments of intellectual society, but scientists of old were often struggling to reconcile their desire of increased knowledge of the physical world with their faiths.

Isaac Newton for example, wrote more papers about religion than he did about science and math[0]:

How much of Newton’s writing has survived?

A huge amount. There’s roughly 10 million words that Newton left. Around half of the writing is religious, and there are about 1 million words on alchemical material, most of which is copies of other people’s stuff. There are about 1 million words related to his work as Master of the Mint. And then roughly 3 million related to science and math.

[0]https://www.wired.com/2014/05/newton-papers-q-and-a/

Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by sudosysgen on Sunday August 29, 2021 @11:19AM (#28347400)
It's a useful thought framework to rid yourself of the anxiety of doing things you think are morally questionable.
Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by FooBarBizBazz on Sunday August 29, 2021 @01:33PM (#28348721)
Side note, I understand that's a minor mistranslation: "Death" is more like "Time" (which eventually destroys all things). In that line, I imagine a Hindu analogue of Chronos -- Time the Reaper, which mows men down at the end of their season, like so much grass. Ozymandias as well.

This, then, would have less to do with the explosive power of the Trinity test, and more to do with the decaying remnants of missile silos, which are already ruins.

Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by naravara on Sunday August 29, 2021 @01:29PM (#28348684)
Oppenheimer’s quote is, while not quite a mistranslation, incomplete. The original quote would more properly translate as an incarnation of “time” rather than “death.”
Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by svat on Sunday August 29, 2021 @12:52PM (#28348320)
See "The Gita of Robert Oppenheimer" by James Hijiya, Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society 144 (2) (June 2000):

https://web.archive.org/web/20131126020921/http://www.amphil...

Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by alex_smart on Sunday August 29, 2021 @04:10PM (#28350034)
Anybody who is honest will tell you that Hindu religious texts are ultimately about justification for "varnashrama dharma".

(Varnas are obviously a little different from its contemporary form - caste, but also shares many essential features. Namely, pre-determination of social status and broad occupations based on birth and endogamy, although it's more like a woman from a higher varna can not marry a man from a lower varna.)

Why is Arjuna's dharma to fight? Because he is a Kshatriya. Why shouldn't Arjuna worry about what consequences the war might have on his family and society? Well, because Krishna himself is the upholder of Varnashrama Dharma. Arjuna should only worry about doing his duty, and not worry about such lofty matters.

Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by rramadass on Sunday August 29, 2021 @11:26PM (#28352549)
>Hindu religious texts are ultimately about justification for "varnashrama dharma"

No! That is a very shortsighted and narrow view of a complex and nuanced subject.

For details, I recommend that you look into the works on Dharma and Ashrama System by the noted Indologist Patrick Olivelle.

Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by rramadass on Sunday August 29, 2021 @11:11PM (#28352489)
>What stuff might be interesting in Bhagavad Gita for a scientist like him?

A specific Worldview and cultivating a Mindset to go with it which takes Death and Total Destruction as part of a Universal Lifecycle.

Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by iamshs on Sunday August 29, 2021 @11:01AM (#28347244)
Bhagvad Gita is a proponent of just war. Ambiguity in Bhagvad Gita can be used to endorse any position you find yourself in. Act but don’t act - perfect text which gives ample manoeuvring space if you are feeling spiritual.
Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by Xplune13 on Sunday August 29, 2021 @11:08AM (#28347309)
Not really. War is definitely the context there as it is said that it was spoken during the war itself, but it lays out what to do at what time. It isn't ambiguous enough so that anyone can interpret it in any way. It lays out the scenarios and just states what is right to do in that scenario.
Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by sudosysgen on Sunday August 29, 2021 @11:18AM (#28347394)
The ambiguity lies in which scenario you're choosing as an analog to your present. And yes the Bhagavad Gita is great for justifying atrocities to the individual, hence why Himmler carried it around.
Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by Xplune13 on Sunday August 29, 2021 @11:26AM (#28347463)
No. As with everything else in life, context is important. One can easily just read it and then proceed to justify their doings using it if they either don't know or choose to ignore the context of it.

Whole of Bhagvad Gita was spoken during the Mahabharata War. It contains some overall guidance i.e. it can be applicable to normal day life as well as situational guidance on the context of the going war.

Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by wolfretcrap on Sunday August 29, 2021 @12:41PM (#28348220)
In mahabharata war countless men died.

It was all justified by someone who goes by name Krishna in ancient text. Krishna origin is questionable as he's not one person throughout his history but fusion of multiple personalities which existed in past.

Krishna could as well be a master manipulator who convinced other's that God and him are actually just one. Many Kings of that time actually did try to become God the prime example was Pondrak who believed he's the real Vasudev. His version couldn't survive because he lost the battle against Krishna.

Mahabharata is not useful to for an average person, reading it will not enlighten you or anything. It's not a guide on how to live your life, it has many flaws, questionable ethics and morality defined in the text, bringing God into it to make beyond contest.

If it had anything of use, India where this religious text is most popular would be epicenter of good behavior, technological advancements, ethics and morality. Is it? No it's far away from it.

Before anyone questions my religion, I am Hindu from north India (Uttarakhand Purohit clan to be specific)

Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by cscurmudgeon on Sunday August 29, 2021 @12:58PM (#28348386)
1. In the first sentence you talk about the Mahabharata war as it was real.

2. Then you discount Krishna being not real.

Do you see the obvious logical contradiction? Btw, unlike Christianity, Hinduism doesn't rely on Mahabharta being real. So this angle is a common attack from Christians.

Your previous comment:

> 666 is number of the beast. I wonder how many thiest scientists would have refused to work on it if they were to use 666

Why would a non-Christian believe that?

You are probably new to the site and don't know that people can see your past comments.

Your language perfectly mirrors the one used by missionaries in India (studied at one such school but didn't get baptized).

Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by Xplune13 on Sunday August 29, 2021 @01:06PM (#28348465)
India always had one of the biggest economies in the world before Industrial Revolution in the Europe.

Expecting anything to be "epicentre of good behavior" is wrong to begin with because every person is different no matter what any text/information/knowledge the person has access to and ancient India (as that is what we're talking about here) did have stable economies as well as kingdoms. Was it perfect? No, because nothing is.

India had pretty significant technological advancements and all you have to do is Google Search for it.

You have absurd definition of "anything of use". If you want everything to be perfect, then bad luck, there isn't such place to go for you.

Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by random314 on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @01:47AM (#28364365)
AFAIK, Krishna was a charioteer in the original mahabharata from 1000BC. Later additions to the story around 400-200BC turned him into a God. The Gita is also a later introduction. How does this gel with Krishna being an amalgamation of multiple personalities, as opposed to a later invention (by Brahmins?) to justify varna vyavastha or other objectives? I have read that Gita was created as a response to Buddhist texts as well.
Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by kbsspl on Sunday August 29, 2021 @01:29PM (#28348682)
> It's not a guide on how to live your life, it has many flaws, questionable ethics and morality defined in the text, bringing God into it to make beyond contest.

Can you please elaborate.

>Before anyone questions my religion, I am Hindu from north India (Uttarakhand Purohit clan to be specific)

What Vedanta school of interpretation are you talking about.

Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by la6471 on Sunday August 29, 2021 @02:19PM (#28349134)
That’s the greatness of Bhargava’s Gita and Hinduism. You are absolutely entitled to your own opinion and questions. As did Arjuna who pestered Krishna with continuous questions in Bhargava’s Gita. Hinduism , more specifically Santayana Dharma is not based on commandments , it is based on questions and answers.
Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by eklavya on Sunday August 29, 2021 @12:29PM (#28348101)
As a Hindu I would be very interested in parts of Gita which justify atrocities. I don’t understand how anybody would spread nonsense like that.
Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by rramadass on Sunday August 29, 2021 @11:37PM (#28352595)
There is a small book of 3 essays by B.R.Ambedkar under the name "Ambedkar's India" which you should read. It behooves us all Indians to understand how ancient texts, beliefs and rituals have been subverted to oppress people and legitimize it from a Man who lived and suffered through it all.

PS: Book link - https://www.amazon.in/Ambedkars-India-B-R-Ambedkar/dp/938702...

Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by iamshs on Sunday August 29, 2021 @11:32AM (#28347513)
Recently, Indian Embassy official in US borrowed Bhagvad Gita terminology and called Steve Bannon as great “Dharmic warrior”.

https://thediplomat.com/2017/02/steve-bannon-dharma-warrior-...

Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by iamshs on Sunday August 29, 2021 @11:24AM (#28347445)
War for Dharma, and you perfectly know everything can be called dharma in Hindu religious texts. Cleaning toilets, dharma for the subjugated caste Hindu; worshipping god - dharma for the dominant caste Hindu; fighting territorial war - dharma for the kshtriya. Dharma is central core of bhagvad gita and which renders it ambiguous and yet attractive to certain people. Define whatever as your dharma and you are on your way to do good.

Modern Example: Steve Bannon was defined as Dharmic warrior by Indian Consul General to US.

Re:Show HN: Bhagavad Gita Android App for searching verses b... by alex_smart on Sunday August 29, 2021 @04:17PM (#28350096)
Not really, Bhagvad Gita, like most Hindu religious texts, is a justification for Varnashrama Dharma.