What rationale could anyone possibly have to teach this mindless nonsense to children, unless it was to prepare them for other standardized tests later in life, which are unanimously the product of mathematically impotent failed bureaucrats?
For example, consider this problem for geometric series: 1 + 2 + 4 + 8 + 16 + 32 + ... + 4096 = ?. This problem may look completely intractible and tedious without a calculator. But once you start adding: 1+2=3, 1+2+4=7, 1+2+4+8=15, 1+2+4+8=31, ..., even a child can spot the pattern. Now that they are amazed, they will be motivated to learn more about the cause of this pattern, etc, etc.
Would the problem work if the student started summing backwards from the last item? How many items would the student have to swap in that case?. For how many random combinations of items would the problem "work" (i.e. require exactly one change?)
On the other hand, in your example you're not just trying random things until something works. Noticing that 1 + 2 = 3, etc is more analytical than adding members at random and hoping that the person who created the problem thought of the same random pattern you thought about.
The dollars-and-cents addition problem mapped onto the "fun" toy store narrative is not mathematically interesting until assigned the type of analytical firepower outlined in OP's blog post. It is a deliberately obtuse trick question posed as a learning tool; children labelled "gifted" will figure it out and feel the dull satisfaction of killing another "problem", and those without that benefit will simply experience more fear and boredom.
"Smart" children are identified early. After that they are smart because everyone knows they are smart. It is very hard for a person who knows they are not smart to convince a society who knows they are not smart.
Dumb people are sometimes lucky and get something right. That doesn't make them smart. Smart people sometimes make mistakes. That doesn't re-label them as dumb. The important thing is the label you start with. Smart people will recognize the grammatical "mistake" in the previous sentence and understand that this post came from a dumb person.
That said, this problem isn't about mindlessly adding. It's about figuring out a way to systematically discover the answer. Most math challenge problems are designed with a method in mind; it's your job to figure that method out, and that's where the fun lies.
In fact, this question is more than „just sum things up“, as described pretty well by the person above your comment.
I am a scientist. When I see a problem I have never seen before, I start to analyze it using the tools I know. This helps me to learn more about the given problem and supports me finding a „clever“ Solution in the next iteration.
I am not opposing the idea that to do math, you must occasionally "get your hands dirty" as another commenter says; I am opposing the idea that it is useful to set this question in front of third graders in the form "find the solution and move onto another problem". As OP's article proved, there are many, many interesting implications that arise from this problem, and an investigation of those implications requires much more care, passion, and analysis than is implied by the form in which the problem is presented (as a solvable worksheet). For what it's worth: if you want to teach the lesson "sometimes you have to just start adding things up", just write that down in plain English and teach that. Put this question in a giant book of trick problems with an explanation of why each question is a trick, don't put this on a worksheet for of children who are required to attend class and then expect them to pick up on the subtleties of instruction after they write down the answer and get their grade back.
I am not a very smart mathematician; I am a middling intellect and have been my entire life. It was not until I was two years out of my engineering degree that I started investigating the world on my own and began to find out the true size and power of mathematics, and now it always angers me when I see the shallow imitations of real pedagogy and instruction passed off on the world's children as "useful math worksheets". My self-esteem and lifetime mathematical achievement were butchered by worksheets just like these.
[1] https://www.maa.org/external_archive/devlin/LockhartsLament....
This is a thinking problem that could be approached in a lot of different ways. It's really the opposite of a standardized test problem.
>unless it was to prepare them for other standardized tests later in life
yes, it teaches you how to understand standardized tests and to exploit them.
There's a somewhat popular TED talk on how kindergarteners frequently outcompete adults in the marshmallow challenge (tl;dr; build the tallest structure possible using assorted materials but a marshmallow must be on top) because, among other reasons, they're willing to just try out different approaches and fail fast rather than take a long time to think up of an approach that ultimately fails.
https://www.tanveernaseer.com/5-lessons-on-fostering-team-su...
I don’t think recognizing a trick problem is necessarily about being good or smart. Is the author of the cited blog post dumber than a fifth grader?
Not to detract from the nice explanation in that post, but I do think "smart" can be a bit of annoying term. It sort of implies an innate property. I'm pretty confident anyone can become really good at anything, given enough motivation and time. I'd prefer the term "experienced" or something to that effect.
And I'm pretty confident that some people can become really good at said thing faster, due to some form of innate talent. And as we all have finite time, that's a pretty important trait.
It goes a bit beyond that; this problem solving algorithm is pretty clearly unworkable. Even here where it can come to an answer in reasonable time it is questionable.
Any student that is happy to employ this algorithm is either extremely smart to the point where they can process a lot of arithmetic very quickly, or not very smart and setting themselves up for failure later on in life when the first guess at an answer doesn't work.
Ordinary garden-variety smart (as in, likely to be good at maths but not Euler or Gauss) should fail to answer this question on the basis that there is no technique beyond brute force, and brute force is impractical without a computer.
How is that a bad thing? I think the world needs less confidence in it right now, not more.
I was fairly adept at math in fourth and fifth grade—well ahead of my peers. While I didn’t know terms like NP-Complete and NP-Hard, I would have immediately recognized that such a problem didn’t have a straightforward, timely solution for someone doing it by hand. I would have considered it a trap—in the sense that it’s a time sink—and moved onto the next problem.
If it later turned out that the solution to the problem required that I not actually understand it (from my perspective at the time), I would grow frustrated. I was the sort of asshole fifth grader who would not hesitate to chastise a teacher for giving us what I believed to be unrealistic, dumbed-down math problems. When in life am I going to encounter a knapsack problem that just happens to be quickly solvable that way? The chances of that are slim; the technique I’ve now learned has no application in the real world.
Take factoring, for example. I would regularly get frustrated with factoring assignments: how do you expect me to factor a collection of polynomials on a timed test if you cannot describe a deterministic algorithm for doing so? “If you’re having trouble, stay after school and I’ll help you.” After school, the teacher would helpfully demonstrate factoring several polynomials. I’d ask how the teacher knew how to guess the particular numbers they chose. What if the polynomial can’t be factored, and I waste time trying to find a solution? What if the numbers are large? The teacher would inevitably grow frustrated: “I won’t give you problems like that. Stop worrying about it.”
I’ll be the first to point out that I was never particularly nice to teachers who my judgmental 12-year-old brain considered incompetent, but I have little sympathy for this particular scenario. I wanted to understand the problems; I didn’t want canned solutions. My teachers knew I was perfectly capable of factoring the numbers with which we were presented, so they would get frustrated: why is an intelligent student stuck on a problem they’ve already solved?
Eventually, I found a book on prime numbers at a used book store and got the answers I needed.
You only need one counterexample, and in this case you can easily find it. E.g., you can note that the duckie in GP's solution can be swapped for the pinwheel+whistle without changing the solution's total cost, ergo the solution isn't unique.
I think a lot of people are looking at this like a coding interview, where it's assumed that your algorithm must work for all possible inputs, rather than just the inputs stated.
Everybody’s problem here, mine included, is that this is a toxic way to teach math. One which has no use in math, which does not teach how to properly approach a problem and which in fact teaches and artificially rewards a bad approach: “just try it! It’ll work because all problems, even ridiculously difficult ones, are artificially customised to be easy for you to solve!”.
It’s bad. It’s awful. It’s not good. It’s everything math education shouldn’t be: boring, artificial, useless, constrained and a lie.
I don’t want children to solve this problem. I want children who can like math, to like and learn math. This is one of many drops in the jar of bullshit that will eventually overflow and turn them off.
That's a very good goal. But for this problem, your success depends on whether you chose the same strategy that the teacher cherry-picked prices for - or just got lucky that another strategy happened to work.
"Intuition" implies that the student somehow understands the structure of the problem, but the prices in the problem could be adjusted ever so slightly in such a way that the strategy you outline would lead nowhere at all.
The only possible intuition to be found here is realizing that the only way to solve the problem is to throw shit on the wall until something sticks.
> I won't be surprised if many fifth-graders can solve the problem in five minutes.
A lot of fifth-graders could win on a scratch-off ticket in five minutes, too.
You wish to decrease your spending by $2.87, so you check if there are any items you have not chosen that cost exactly $2.87 less than an item you have chosen. A smart fifth-grader would quickly find that the car ($5.18) can be replaced by Jacks ($2.31). This concludes the problem-solving process.
This question was intended for fourth- and fifth-graders (https://www.insidemathematics.org/sites/default/files/materi...). Put yourself in the shoe of a smart fifth-grader who knows nothing about NP-completeness or knapsack problems. This problem is given to you, and you know it as solvable. This problem would look intimidating, but a good student would look for patterns, and the best way to start looking would be to sum the first few items (who knows, maybe the first items would sum up to exactly $43.94). After summing up to 46.81, a good student would "naturally" stop adding new items and ask himself "what can be done now?" All that he needs is now a mental "click".
Essentially, this problem tests students' intuition. It tests whether students can remain unintimidated in the face of difficult-looking questions. They need to start adding, and they need to have that one insight of replacing one of the items. Insights like these are extremely common and rewarding for young math learners.
I won't be surprised if many fifth-graders can solve the problem in five minutes.