Re:NP Complete 3rd Grade Math Problems (2018)
by roenxi on Sunday August 29, 2021 @09:54AM
(#28346699)
> I don’t think recognizing a trick problem is necessarily about being good or smart.
It goes a bit beyond that; this problem solving algorithm is pretty clearly unworkable. Even here where it can come to an answer in reasonable time it is questionable.
Any student that is happy to employ this algorithm is either extremely smart to the point where they can process a lot of arithmetic very quickly, or not very smart and setting themselves up for failure later on in life when the first guess at an answer doesn't work.
Ordinary garden-variety smart (as in, likely to be good at maths but not Euler or Gauss) should fail to answer this question on the basis that there is no technique beyond brute force, and brute force is impractical without a computer.
It goes a bit beyond that; this problem solving algorithm is pretty clearly unworkable. Even here where it can come to an answer in reasonable time it is questionable.
Any student that is happy to employ this algorithm is either extremely smart to the point where they can process a lot of arithmetic very quickly, or not very smart and setting themselves up for failure later on in life when the first guess at an answer doesn't work.
Ordinary garden-variety smart (as in, likely to be good at maths but not Euler or Gauss) should fail to answer this question on the basis that there is no technique beyond brute force, and brute force is impractical without a computer.