News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by gkoberger on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @09:17PM (#28309389)
I don't know... I have a really hard time getting too upset about this. I'm a big proponent of privacy and have always been a Snowden supporter. And while "protecting children" is a trope in politics, I think everyone with an iPhone knows they're giving up some privacy to own one. It's constantly tracking their location and sending other data to Apple.

This isn't a government agency. Apple has been incredibly thoughtful about privacy in the past, and I feel like they've earned the benefit of the doubt here.

I hope I'm not wrong, but I don't see how this is insane. They're just making sure the files you upload to them aren't illegal.

Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by tjmc on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @10:56PM (#28310093)
Maybe I'm completely paranoid here, but given that actual sex offenders commonly seek out ways to be near children, what happens if one or more of them end up in Apple's image vetting team?

They'd be completely anonymous and fully covered, with an endless pipeline of naked kids images being delivered to them.

The idea that if you take a picture of your kid in the bath, it just happens to match a CSAM fingerprint and then gets silently transmitted to anonymous reviewers for "review" is terrifying.

Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by simondotau on Thursday August 26, 2021 @01:57AM (#28311190)
This is a disgusting thought, but hear me out. Perhaps this might actually be a good job to give to a paedophile. Their classifications would probably have a superior false positive rate than someone who is disgusted by the images, and it would all but eliminate any concern about an employee suffering psychological trauma.
Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by ericwooley on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:54PM (#28318989)
> and it would all but eliminate any concern about an employee suffering psychological trauma.

I doubt this. If they were all images that this person happened to be into, maybe... But even then, I think it would likely make their addiction to child porn worse, which is it's own psychological problem that is probably worse for society than the trauma suffered by current employees. What happens when they leave that job, and are used to seeing hundreds of cp images a day?

Not to mention, that some of the stuff the scanner would be looking at would probably be horrific, and violent. Looking at that kind of thing all day would probably have similar psychiatric affects on pedophiles and non pedophiles. In the worst case, it might cause some pedophiles to start to like the worse images out of boredom from seeing so much cp.

Overall, I'd say this is would just be a bad avenue to go down.

Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by simondotau on Thursday August 26, 2021 @08:23PM (#28322800)
I thought we agreed that playing violent video games doesn't make people more violent. Isn't this the same thing?
Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by ericwooley on Friday August 27, 2021 @12:36PM (#28329871)
It's not the same thing. The argument would have to be: violent video games lead to more violent video games, which, anecdotally, I would probably say they do.
Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by simondotau on Saturday August 28, 2021 @02:26AM (#28336054)
The concern is that child pornography leads to more children in danger. This is akin to violent video games lead to violence.

We don't ban child pornography because it leads to more viewing of child pornography. We ban it because we recognise that demand for CSAM breeds supply of new CSAM. Also because it is—by definition—the product of child abuse.

Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by shuckles on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @11:12PM (#28310180)
Your terrifying idea mischaracterizes the nature of false positives. Any photo in your library is equally liable to be a false positive as any other; the perceptual hash is not looking for similar images by the metric of what you find similar (content). That’s also the underlying idea behind why people have been able to turn arbitrary images into adversarial false positives.
Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by tjmc on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @11:30PM (#28310311)
So that picture of my driver's license I took for an ID check or that sensitive work document I scanned with my phone are just as likely to be sent? Great.
Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by simondotau on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:06AM (#28311231)
The image would need to be vaguely similar in terms of gross shapes and arrangement. It's exceedingly unlikely that any CSAM would ever be remotely similar to an ID card or a sheet of paper.

If there are ever going to be any "natural" matches to any CSAM hashes, it's probably going to be a photograph of people who are coincidentally in a similar pose at a nearly identical angle and strikingly shading.

Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by waz0wski on Thursday August 26, 2021 @11:48AM (#28316455)
In the myriad of articles about this systems many issues there have been comments from people who have worked with the NCMEC upstream database and note that it's filled with mundane photos, empty rooms, etc - I think it was in one of the hackerfactor article discussions

This entire system is ripe for false positives AND adversarial attacks.

Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by simondotau on Thursday August 26, 2021 @08:21PM (#28322786)
I've no doubt the totality of the database contains a lot of photos, but only photos tagged as A1, A2, B1, or B2 would be considered illegal to possess. And then only the absolute worst of the worst (images categorised as "A1") are being included in the hash set on iOS. The category definitions are:

  A = prepubescent minor
  B = pubescent minor
  1 = sex act
  2 = "lascivious exhibition"
The categories are described in further detail (ugh) in this PDF, page 22: https://www.prosecutingattorneys.org/wp-content/uploads/Pres...
Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by shuckles on Thursday August 26, 2021 @11:51AM (#28316514)
The NCMEC database is large and graded to distinguish types of photos. There’s evidence in the false positive calculations that Apple is only using a subset, presumably the one where photos are graded as depicting active abuse.

It’s not reasonable to dispute the 1 in 1e12 false positive claim on mere speculation.

Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by brokenmachine on Friday August 27, 2021 @02:04AM (#28324761)
>It’s not reasonable to dispute the 1 in 1e12 false positive claim on mere speculation.

It's entirely reasonable. Have you seen https://thishashcollisionisnotporn.com/ ?

Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.

Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by simondotau on Friday August 27, 2021 @04:03AM (#28325396)
Collision attacks make for a fun tech demo, but I've yet to hear anyone suggest any plausible scenario where they could be used against Apple's implementation. It would require absurdly elaborate, Oceans Eleven style espionage to achieve any outcome whatsoever. And it would be immediately apparent to anyone involved that a collision attack was involved.

It would be far easier (and far more effective) to just acquire child porn, break into your victim's house, stash physical prints under their mattress, and then contact the police.

Furthermore, the website includes numerous misleading statements about Apple's system, or makes critical omissions on the description of Apple's system. Whatever side you're on, misleading arguments should be dismissed for what they are.

Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by shuckles on Friday August 27, 2021 @11:56AM (#28329411)
This is apples to oranges. The whole thread was about random false positives and not adversarial ones.
Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by brokenmachine on Friday August 27, 2021 @10:50PM (#28335203)
If it's that easy to generate a false positive then I believe it will be more common to accidentally have one.

Onge again, extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.

Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by simondotau on Saturday August 28, 2021 @02:49AM (#28336131)
The ease of adversarial collisions has no relationship to the probability of natural collisions.

It's entirely possible to make a cryptographic hash algorithm that has an exceptionally low probability of natural collisions but where adversarial collisions are trivial.

It's also possible to create a cryptographic hash algorithm where occasional natural collisions are expected, but adversarial collisions require brute force.

Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by shuckles on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @11:34PM (#28310335)
The chance that any pictures from your library are revealed at all is at most one in one trillion (mod you not storing CSAM or being attacked by someone trying to plant evidence on you). Contrast this to a server side scanning system where every photo in your library will be accessed with unknown false positive characteristics.
Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by diebeforei485 on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @09:22PM (#28309433)
They can do that on their servers, not on my phone.
Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by mangoman on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @09:39PM (#28309549)
"just making sure the files you upload to them aren't illegal"

the problem lies in this sentence. 1) this happens on device before they're uploaded, which is a monumental shift for a company that claims to be pro-privacy 2) they're now saying they're willing to surveil photos for governments, the reason is sorta irrelevant. they're opening pandora's box - are they going to start scanning files on behalf of the RIAA or other copyright stuff now?

Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by istingray on Thursday August 26, 2021 @04:24AM (#28312062)
I'm curious could you unpack what this means for me? "big proponent of privacy and have always been a Snowden supporter"

Given that, my assumption is this would click for you, but as you said it doesn't. What does being a big proponent mean to you? How do you support Snowden? What's important to you about privacy? Curious to hear your logic, I bet there are tons of people who have the same concerns (or lack of).

Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by geophile on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @09:22PM (#28309430)
"just"

And who gets to decide what is illegal?

Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by Pxtl on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @09:24PM (#28309442)
Laws?
Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by bigiain on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @10:39PM (#28309981)
Which laws?

I'm uncomfortable enough with US laws or Australian laws deciding what images are "illegal" to have on my phone.

But China also have laws. And Iraq. And Saudi Arabia.

And Afghanistan had one set of laws last month, but new different laws since then.

Multinational Corps may like to think they've lifted themselves above petty regional political and legal pressure from elected governments and regional law enforcement. But Apple is 100% capable of being destroyed by either of China or the USA. Anyone who thinks otherwise is fooling themselves. If you shut down Apples manufacturing in China, or head office and server farms in the US, they'd be finished.

Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by czzr on Thursday August 26, 2021 @04:07AM (#28311954)
The laws of the country you live in. If you don’t like those laws then work to change them, don’t depend on a foreign tech company to decide for you.

If I wanted to live under US laws and cultural expectations I’d move there.

Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by bigiain on Friday August 27, 2021 @01:19AM (#28324530)
> If I wanted to live under US laws and cultural expectations I’d move there.

If I didn't want to be poor, I'd just be rich instead!

Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by geophile on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:05AM (#28315114)
Yes, and that's the problem. If you think that the laws protect you, an average iPhone user, you are sadly mistaken. Laws are dictated by the highest bidder, and by those in power. If they want to go after gays, or Jews, or Blacks, or Moslems, or immigrants, or political activists, or whoever, do you think the laws are going to protect or remain neutral to those groups?
Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by SixDouble5321 on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @09:53PM (#28309662)
I've not met any laws. Where do they live?
Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by lostgame on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @09:23PM (#28309439)
Thank you for expressing this opinion. I know it’s not a popular one; but I’m 100% with you.
Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by randomhodler84 on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @09:20PM (#28309413)
Time has proven otherwise. All censorship systems start with protecting the kids, and grow to eventually encompass all undesirable content…
Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by robertoandred on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @10:45PM (#28310023)
How have Google’s, Facebook’s, or Microsoft’s CSAM scanning grown?
Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by vayeate on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:17AM (#28315281)
Facebook filters and censors content on a massive scale. They even block private messages with certain keywords or domains
Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by shuckles on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @11:13PM (#28310190)
To be fair, Google and Facebook both do plenty of content scanning, but you’re right that it likely doesn’t use the CSAM pipelines. Apple’s pipeline is probably even harder to repurpose since it’s designed very closely for this use case.
Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by randomhodler84 on Thursday August 26, 2021 @12:07PM (#28316748)
Unknown re private scanning, however Australia and UK have rigorous internet censorship regimes that block copyright infringement and gambling that use exactly the same censorship infrastructure that was build to block CSAM in the early 00s.
Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by torified on Friday August 27, 2021 @02:09AM (#28324782)
Lol, Australia's internet filter is just a DNS block. It couldn't really be any less rigorous. Not that I'm complaining...
[dead]
Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by dang on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @10:25PM (#28309868)
The site guidelines ask you not to post like this. Could you please review and follow them? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Also, it would be good if you'd stop posting unsubstantive comments generally.

Re:The All-Seeing “i”: Apple Just Declared War on Your Privacy by gkoberger on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @09:57PM (#28309685)
I read it. I just disagree with it.