News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by tru3_power on Thursday August 19, 2021 @09:43PM (#28241479)
What was their reasoning for not using Lidar?
Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by doctoboggan on Thursday August 19, 2021 @09:46PM (#28241497)
I think originally it was because of the cost of the equipment. Elon and team saw how expensive lidar was and thought they needed to be able to solve the problem without it. However lidar has dropped drastically in price, so at this point I think they aren't using it just for ego reasons (i.e., we claimed it was possible to get self driving without lidar in the past, so we have to continue down that path)
Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by panick21 on Thursday August 19, 2021 @10:15PM (#28241670)
Lidar might have dropped in price, but please show me the Lidar that can produce that quality output, is incredibly cheap, easy to manufacture and integrate into the car and available millions of time by next year.

And it would be great if it something that almost never broke as things that move a lot tend to. As far as I know static lidar are nowhere near as good.

Then if the difference in quality is not actually that great, doing the development effort once will scale to millions of cars the next few years. So we are literally talking many, many years of millions of lidars produced and integrated (and not replacing other sensors) to maybe have a slightly better outcome.

However that depends on your sensor fusion and how the lidar handles weather conditions and other complexities.

But I am sure its all ego.

Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by c-cube on Thursday August 19, 2021 @10:53PM (#28241965)
Just because not needing lidar would be great for Tesla, doesn't make it real. That's wishful thinking. Tesla is not entitled to a well working lidar-free solution just because they need to sell cars right now.
Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by panick21 on Thursday August 19, 2021 @11:10PM (#28242088)
Can you point me to literally any evidence what so ever that the results fake? Is the FSD Beta regularly crashing into things it put at the wrong range?

Tesla has cars with Lidar on the road to check the models as well.

And who says anything about entitled, they have spent a huge amount of effort and therefore money into a solution that they think will be better.

Nobody with Lidar has delivered either so what is better is still an open question. Tesla has picked their strategy and working on it. Others do the same.

My point is simply, not that Tesla has the perfect solution, rather the idea that Tesla is operating based on 'ego' is idiotic. Elon Musk and his companies have repeatably shown that they are very willing, comically so, to throw away work and go back to the beginning if they have encountered a problem. E

lon is well known for not falling into the sunk cost fallacy. Consider the manufacturing of Model 3. Consider Starship being planned to be built from carbon fiber, and switching to stainless steel.

Do you really believe they know lidar would be better and they not changing because of what Musk said 4 years ago? That is literally the opposite of how his company have operated.

Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by sangnoir on Friday August 20, 2021 @01:35AM (#28242980)
> Is the FSD Beta regularly crashing into things it put at the wrong range?

As a matter of fact, yes: self-driving Teslas have been crashing into emergency vehicles so often, they are being investigated[1]

1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28197355

Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by tim333 on Friday August 20, 2021 @10:27AM (#28246412)
I don't think that's a range thing though. It's confusing the vehicles with things like road signs or puddles that you can drive over/past.
Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by simiones on Friday August 20, 2021 @12:44PM (#28248145)
That's exactly a range thing: LIDAR could tell you that there is an obstacle in front of you, it couldn't mistake a 3D object for a 2D picture on the road.
Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by Cogito on Friday August 20, 2021 @01:46AM (#28243049)
Just in case you missed it, the person you're replying to asked a focused question about the new FSD Beta software.

The investigation you reference stems from previous versions of the softawre.

The broader context can't be ignored when discussing the new software, but it's reasonable to point to progress as demonstration that the chosen technology path is a viable one.

Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by c-cube on Friday August 20, 2021 @07:29AM (#28244866)
Like you say, FSD beta is new, so, no. The autopilot software has killed people though.

The sunk cost fallacy is stronger when it's not just R&D but thousands of people who paid 10k$ on the promise that their car had all the hardware required... Cars that shipped without a lidar.

And I believe waymo uses lidar and has, as far as I know, killed nobody. They also take a more cautious approach where bystanders are not turned into beta testers, of course :-)

Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by cycrutchfield on Friday August 20, 2021 @01:01PM (#28248413)
> The autopilot software has killed people though.

Sorry, what’s your point? You need to prove that the autopilot software has killed more people than if the cars were driven by humans.

> And I believe waymo uses lidar and has, as far as I know, killed nobody.

With a footprint probably orders of magnitude smaller than Tesla. What do you want to bet is the difference in terms of miles driven by Waymo vs. miles driven by Tesla autopilot?

Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by joshuamorton on Thursday August 19, 2021 @10:20PM (#28241711)
> And it would be great if it something that almost never broke as things that move a lot tend to. As far as I know static lidar are nowhere near as good.

Keep in mind you're saying this about something that attaches to a car, which already has dozens or hundreds of parts that rotate at hundreds or thousands of RPM.

> Then if the difference in quality is not actually that great, doing the development effort once will scale to millions of cars the next few years

The adage "do things that don't scale" comes to mind. If your options are "have tens of thousands of autonomous vehicles" or "have none", I'm not sure how the second is better. And we know that hundreds of thousands or even millions of lidar units are being produced (cruise and waymo and co have multiple units per vehicle and collectively hundreds of thousands of vehicles).

Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by panick21 on Thursday August 19, 2021 @10:58PM (#28241996)
Adding more rotating parts is exactly what you are trying to avoid. For example, go look at how Tesla designed the heating and cooling system. The integrated all the different streams of hot and cold in one system duplicate these parts that can break easily.

In some cases it can simply not be avoided of course but you better make sure that you really need it if you are gone add it to millions of cars.

> cruise and waymo and co have multiple units per vehicle and collectively hundreds of thousands of vehicles

Waymo has vehicle count of a few 1000s as far as I know. I don't know about cruise but I don't think the have even 100k vehicles. Please show me a source.

And even if that were the case, the build those fleets of quite a long time and the cost per vehicle they currently have is nowhere near close to what would be possible for a car like the Model 3 or future cheaper models.

Margins in car industry are incredibly tight, car companies invest gigantic amount of capital to remove a few $ per car. These vehicles need to be able to be produced at a run rate of millions per year. If you are proposing to add something that cost 100-1000$ that is a absolute killer.

In addition its an additional part that can hold up your production. This current chip shortage is a perfect example where having a Lidar would just introduce a whole host of new chips that might be in a shortage.

Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by darkwater on Friday August 20, 2021 @09:59AM (#28246052)
> Margins in car industry are incredibly tight, car companies invest gigantic amount of capital to remove a few $ per car. These vehicles need to be able to be produced at a run rate of millions per year. If you are proposing to add something that cost 100-1000$ that is a absolute killer.

I don't get this. You have to pay ~8000$ as an extra to get the FDA in a Tesla. Can't they charge the cost of the lidar in there? Now you have to pay 9000 dollars to get it.

Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by joshuamorton on Thursday August 19, 2021 @11:41PM (#28242301)
You didn't really address the meat of the comment: The adage "do things that don't scale" comes to mind. If your options are "have tens of thousands of autonomous vehicles" or "have none", I'm not sure how the second is better.

Waymo and cruise especially, but even a number of others, have demonstrated better autonomy than Tesla. Musk has been claiming full self driving is 6 months away for 5 years now, and he hasn't gotten that much closer.

Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by panick21 on Friday August 20, 2021 @08:58AM (#28245446)
> Waymo and cruise especially, but even a number of others, have demonstrated better autonomy than Tesla.

Have they? They have a different approach where they focus huge effort on individual Geo-fenced locations and they both are losing 100M of $ every year. Neither has given any timeline for general availability in all locations.

The race, as far as I am concerned is still open. It is not at all clear to me that Waymo is ahead at what actually matters.

> Musk has been claiming full self driving is 6 months away for 5 years now, and he hasn't gotten that much closer.

The claim they made no progress is objectively false.

Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by joshuamorton on Friday August 20, 2021 @01:16PM (#28248615)
> They have a different approach where they focus huge effort on individual Geo-fenced locations

Where they actually have driverless vehicles. That's the key difference. Waymo and cruise have demonstrated driverless vehicles. People get driverless taxi rides today from waymo, and I think cruise as well. Tesla doesn't. It's still sitting in driver assist land and isn't particularly better than other luxury vehicle driver assist.

> The claim they made no progress is objectively false.

Thankfully that's not what I said.

Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by kitsunesoba on Thursday August 19, 2021 @10:09PM (#28241630)
Wasn't another factor the physical size of the lidar units? Part of Tesla's schtick is making normal or even attractive looking cars (as opposed to the "alien bug" aesthetic EVs were synonymous with at the time) and that's a lot harder to do with a big lidar unit on top.
Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by dharmab on Thursday August 19, 2021 @09:52PM (#28241533)
Also they marketed autonomous driving features as future software updates (including a discount/price hike for early/later adopters). Early adopters would be unhappy if future features required additional hardware.
Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by Robotbeat on Thursday August 19, 2021 @10:36PM (#28241845)
They upgraded hardware in the past to support FSD customers, so I’m not sure they’re completely against it. If it was, say, just a $500 decision to make it completely viable, I don’t think Tesla would hesitate. But the $500 lidars can’t do what needs to be done.
Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by mdoms on Thursday August 19, 2021 @09:58PM (#28241561)
Not just marketed, but sold, and for a very pretty penny.
Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by mandeepj on Thursday August 19, 2021 @10:13PM (#28241658)
> so at this point I think they aren't using it just for ego reasons

If their engineering is driven by ego (most of us think - it is) then - are they really engineers? We all know it’s coming from Top - Elon, in this case.

Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by sgustard on Friday August 20, 2021 @12:18AM (#28242532)
See, for example, Andrej's talk starting at the 6-minute mark. Lidar requires a pre-rendered detailed map of the lanes, traffic lights and obstacles. Vision can operate in any novel environment the car is not preprogrammed for and is thus more scalable.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a510m7s_SVI

Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by tw04 on Thursday August 19, 2021 @10:16PM (#28241678)
I for the life of me cannot find the quote, but at some point I believe he said that if humans can judge distance/drive with nothing but vision, cars/computers will be able to as well.

It was around the time he made the comment that anyone using lidar is doomed, which is much easier to dig up as it was a headline everywhere:

https://arstechnica.com/cars/2019/08/elon-musk-says-driverle...

Hoping someone else has the link to the discussion of humans using nothing but vision, my google-fu is lacking this evening.

Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by Aliabid94 on Thursday August 19, 2021 @09:47PM (#28241510)
Too expensive. They also removed radar because of the global chip shortage so they're all in on vision.
Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by tablespoon on Friday August 20, 2021 @01:48AM (#28243066)
> Too expensive. They also removed radar because of the global chip shortage so they're all in on vision.

That doesn't make much sense to me. Tesla also needs chips for computer vision.

Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by tim333 on Friday August 20, 2021 @10:29AM (#28246432)
Yeah, from their talk it seemed more that it was difficult to integrate the information from the radar and visual sensors.
Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by Siecje on Thursday August 19, 2021 @09:45PM (#28241493)
Cost and reliability.

But Elon says it is because they don't need it.

Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by rnaud on Thursday August 19, 2021 @09:45PM (#28241495)
Too expensive + Your eyes already do the distance estimation and they are basically cameras so we can do this just as well or better.
Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by mdorazio on Thursday August 19, 2021 @10:03PM (#28241581)
> Your eyes already do the distance estimation and they are basically cameras so we can do this just as well or better.

This is not really accurate. Our brains do the distance estimation, and they use all kinds of tricks and contextual clues to do it, not just parallax (~2.5 inch parallax for objects more than ~100ft away isn't all that helpful). And this is the whole problem with vision-only autonomous driving - ML capabilities are nowhere near the capabilities of a human brain.

Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by awal2 on Thursday August 19, 2021 @10:30PM (#28241790)
Monocular depth estimation has gotten really good recently though[0]. Not saying this one paper/method is 100% sufficient, but we're closing the gap in this one capability (depth estimation from pure vision) quite rapidly.

[0] https://roxanneluo.github.io/Consistent-Video-Depth-Estimati...

Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by ctdonath on Thursday August 19, 2021 @11:05PM (#28242047)
That’s exactly what Tesla described tonight. 8 video cameras on a moving platform provide enough eyes, parallax, context, etc to build accurate 4D (!) models in real time.
Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by ajross on Thursday August 19, 2021 @10:38PM (#28241860)
> Our brains do the distance estimation, and they use all kinds of tricks and contextual clues to do it

So, first, this presentation we're talking about is literally about problems like that.

Second: your brain isn't nearly as good as you think it is, it's just constructing a coherent story to fool you into thinking it is. Try this on the highway sometime as a passenger: close your eyes and recite the distances to the vehicle in front of you and the one to either side. I bet you anything a Tesla is going to do that better.

Third: they pretty much cracked this already. They stopped shipping radar on US Model 3's and Y's in the spring, have shipped hundreds of thousands of them now, and there's not a hint of signal that something is off with distance measurements with the cars. My car doesn't get this perfectly (you can actually watch the animations on screen bounce around a bit as the estimates change) but I think it objectively does better than I do.

Distance/Lidar framing is old news, basically. Vision works fine. The worst bugs remaining with all the FSD Beta footage on Youtube are almost entirely pathing and planning issues. The car sees its environment just fine.

Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by gonzo41 on Thursday August 19, 2021 @10:54PM (#28241974)
Yeah but some people suck at throwing darts. So some part of their mechanical system is bad at making judgements. Sure they can learn. But I want a 2 ton cyber truck hurtling down the freeway to KNOW how far things are away.

Telsa should pivot and innovate to make lidar cheaper.

Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by cmrdporcupine on Thursday August 19, 2021 @11:02PM (#28242015)
My eyes don't get covered in salt and mud while driving down the highway.

But people in California probably don't get this.

Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by wombatpm on Thursday August 19, 2021 @11:13PM (#28242111)
So Elon just needs the neural acne to be working and hook up a brain in a jar to drive teslas
Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by reubenswartz on Thursday August 19, 2021 @11:21PM (#28242169)
It doesn't work well in rain, snow, fog, dust, etc. It's great in good conditions, but you either have a car that can drive only in good conditions, or you need a car that can drive safely without LIDAR. (Or someone needs to invent a better LIDAR.)
Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by babelfish on Thursday August 19, 2021 @09:51PM (#28241525)
Elon’s ego
Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by pcbro141 on Thursday August 19, 2021 @09:50PM (#28241519)
Maybe the government's Autopilot probe will force them to change their mind on Lidar.
Re:Tesla AI Day [video] by twiceaday on Thursday August 19, 2021 @09:50PM (#28241522)
I think Elon basically says that long term they will only need vision so they will spend all their time focusing on vision from the start. Maybe lidar will succeed first, but it will be a worse success than vision: redundant / expensive / intrusive.