News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by jandrewrogers on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @01:40PM (#28224608)
It is illegal for the US government to create a mandatory national identity system or coerce the States into creating one. The limits of this have been pretty thoroughly tested in the US Supreme Court.

Every time things like this come up, everyone asks why don't we just thing that looks like a national identity system to fix the issue, as if that never occurred to anyone in Congress. This is why: it violates the Constitution. Short of amending the Constitution, which seems highly unlikely, the US will never have a national identity system like European countries.

Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by dragonwriter on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @02:04PM (#28224907)
> It is illegal for the US government to create a mandatory national identity system or coerce the States into creating one. The limits of this have been pretty thoroughly tested in the US Supreme Court.

No, they haven't. There are people who have speculated that it is illegal since the idea started being discussed (serious discussions are actually fairly new, mostly a burst in the late-1990s and another one shortly after 9/11, though speculative strawman negative arguments go back a bit further, at least to discussions around HIPAA in the mid-1990s.) Those speculations have extrapolated from cases that are quite distant from a national ID (e.g., weirdly, critics of the idea have suggested a national ID would violate the protection of the eight to anonymous political speech found in the first amendment under McIntyre v. Ohio Elections Commission (1995), which aside from the WTF of what a national ID even has to do with that right, is clearly false because the First Amendment applies to the states under the 14th Amendment, so if somehow the creation of a federal ID would violate a First Amendment right, the creation of a state ID would equally violate the application of that right under the 14th. In fact, we have federal (directly issued or state-issued under federal regulations) ID cards required for certain federally regulated purposes, notably:

(1) Passports (or, for certain cases, state-issued under federal rules Enhanced Driver's Licenses) for border crossing;

(2) Passports, state-issued ID’s meeting federal Real ID standards, or certain other federal or federally-regulated IDs for air travel and access to federal facilities.

There are usage or production requirements that government might adopt for ID that violate Constitutional protections that have been firmly articulated by the courts, but those generally apply to state and federal ID equally.

Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by lostcolony on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @02:01PM (#28224860)
Citation needed. "It's against the constitution" - where? Cite an article, quote a paragraph, something. You say the Supreme Court has decided this; fine, quote a court case. I'm not saying you're wrong, but I have no idea what you're talking about.

We have plenty of de facto ID systems. But I'd argue they aren't mandatory because -there is no political will to make them mandatory-. What is achieved by doing so?

Hell, the same political party that would object most vociferously to making them mandatory (because of religious reasons and cost to the taxpayer) is also the one pushing for laws to require issued IDs to vote, a right that -is- guaranteed in the constitution.

Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by smsm42 on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @02:50PM (#28225545)
No law so far ever required single form of ID to vote. All voter ID laws require some form of ID, which could be of many forms - driver license, citizenship id, passport, military ID, handgun license, special voter ID, and so on. There are many forms of ID that are accepted (and if you don't have any, as much as a copy of a recent utility bill and a signed affidavit may exempt you from the requirement). This is nowhere even near establishing a single nation-wide ID system, or even a state-wide one.
Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by lostcolony on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @03:47PM (#28226205)
I said "require issued IDs to vote". Countering with "there are many forms of ID that are accepted" doesn't really feel like you're arguing against what I said.
Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by smsm42 on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @04:16PM (#28226510)
What I am trying to emphasize here is that there's a difference between "a myriad of disjoined systems which can be used to identify somebody" and "a single system that includes data about everybody". The difference is a bit like being able to hire a PI to follow somebody and having everybody's whereabouts in a single centralized database 24/7. Not the same thing, wouldn't you agree?
Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by lostcolony on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @08:51PM (#28229102)
But also...not at all relevant to the point I'm making, which is that a mandatory ID is not against the Constitution (that I know of), and that we -could- create a mandatory national ID, but there's no political will for it. That's it.

I provided an example of that, by pointing out where even the party whose stated goal is to validate a person's identity for voting (i.e., where a mandatory national ID would help with one of their stated goals; certainly, it would remove the objections the other party has) still isn't pushing for a mandatory national ID.

You commenting how multiple types of non-mandatory IDs are included in the bills that that party supports...isn't gainsaying anything I said, nor the point I was making. I'm not sure why you bothered.

Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by markhahn on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @03:16PM (#28225859)
the topic here is a national mechanism, and states could (asininely) allow lesser forms, even exclude the national one.
Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by jandrewrogers on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @02:17PM (#28225090)
There are cases spanning a century across several creative legislative attempts by the US Congress to create a de facto mandatory national identity system. This information is not difficult to find. All of them tried to workaround the fact that States can create mandatory identity systems but the Federal government cannot. (It is one of the reasons SSN cards go out of their way to assert they are not to be used as an ID.)

Past attempts included things like withholding tax disbursements to non-compliant States, but the US Supreme Court deemed that coercive and therefore illegal. The Real ID Act is the latest attempt but it has been delayed for many years by State non-compliance and general unwillingness to share their identity databases with the Federal government.

The ID required to vote is a State ID, which is perfectly Constitutional. No one is requiring a Federal ID to vote. In fact, many States will not recognize any Federal ID, including passports.

Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by lostcolony on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @03:39PM (#28226123)
"This information is not difficult to find"

Then please find and supply it. -I- have had difficulty finding it. It certainly isn't so easy to find as "here is a linked citation supporting my claim", since you've yet to provide one.

"The Real ID Act is the latest attempt but it has been delayed for many years by State non-compliance and general unwillingness to share their identity databases with the Federal government." - not at all. Everything you said just in this post is incorrect, but more egregiously (and why I'm not even bothering to point out why it's incorrect), it's also -irrelevant-. Real ID...isn't mandatory. Not at the state level, not at the federal level.

"The ID required to vote is a State ID, which is perfectly Constitutional" - there isn't an ID required to vote according to the Constitution. In practice, most states also don't require any form of ID. Hence all the bills by the GOP to try and require one, while also doing nothing to ensure it is affordable and convenient (i.e., creating a form of poll tax); the GOP doesn't even care about it as an ID system, just as a form of voter suppression.

Which is my point; no legislature, not even the people trying to require ID for things, is pushing for mandatory IDs. It's not against the Constitution as far as I can tell, and you've done nothing to convince me; it just isn't politically worth pushing for given the resistance it would face so has never happened.

Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by dragonwriter on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @03:55PM (#28226298)
> There are cases spanning a century across several creative legislative attempts by the US Congress to create a de facto mandatory national identity system.

Then it should be easy to present one, preferably the most applicable one to modern proposals.

> This information is not difficult to find.

Its not easy to find the arguments of the people opposed to national ID, and its not easy to verify that the cases they cite are not about national IDs.

> All of them tried to workaround the fact that States can create mandatory identity systems but the Federal government cannot

None of the national ID debates have been about a mandatory ID (a mandatory-for-specific-purposes ID, yes, but the feds already issue a number of those.)

> (It is one of the reasons SSN cards go out of their way to assert they are not to be used as an ID.)

No, social security cards say that because they aren’t designed to validate identity, since all they contain is a name and a number and no way other than possession (which is extremely problematic) to associate that with a particular person.

> Past attempts included things like withholding tax disbursements to non-compliant States

[citation needed]

> but the US Supreme Court deemed that coercive and therefore illegal.

[citation needed]

> The Real ID Act is the latest attempt

Real ID is not a mandatory ID, but a required-for-enumerated purposes ID. The enumerated purposes are ones for which the federal government already establishes acceptable ID standards without any Constitutional challenge, under various Article I, Sec. 8 powers, Real ID is just a change to the standards. And all phases of it but for Phase 4 involving (notably) the mandated to use Real ID for commercial air travel have already gone into effect. Starting in 2014.

but it has been delayed for many years by State non-compliance and general unwillingness to share their identity databases with the Federal government.

Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by ciabattabread on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @02:24PM (#28225200)
Name a case.
Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by gnopgnip on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @05:08PM (#28227183)
The anti commandeering doctrine, from the 10th amendment is what prohibits the federal government forcing states to implement a mandatory federal ID requirement for things like applying for credit or opening a bank account
Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by casefields on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @02:07PM (#28224941)
Voting is not a constitutional right.

Voting Rights Act is statutory like most of our laws.

Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by dragonwriter on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @02:14PM (#28225048)
> Voting is not a constitutional right.

Yes it is.

> Voting Rights Act is statutory like most of our laws.

Constitutional rights are often enforced by legislation; Amendments articulating rights often explicitly authorize this. See, with regard to voting rights, the 15th, 19th, and 26th Amendments. (EDIT: also, the 14th Amendment [see Sec. 2 and 5], and, as noted in a sibling comment, the 24th Amendment. Also the 17th Amendment, though that doesn’t have a Congressional enforcement clause. Voting rights are the single most common subject of Constitutional amendments.)

Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by azernik on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @02:56PM (#28225637)
15th Amendment:

Section 1. The right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of race, color, or previous condition of servitude.

Section 2. The Congress shall have power to enforce this article by appropriate legislation.

The 19th Amendment has identical language for "on account of sex", the 24th Amendment has "by reason of failure to pay a poll tax or any other tax", the 26th Amendment has "on account of age" for 18 years and older.

Like many other things in the Constitution, the constitutional text defines the general principle and the power of the federal government to enforce it, and normal legislation establishes the actual enforcement mechanisms.

Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by Buttons840 on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @01:59PM (#28224837)
Things might magically change if we ever manage to shift the legal and financial burden of "identity theft" to the banks who made the actual mistake, and credit agencies who illegally spread false information about people.
Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by volta83 on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @01:58PM (#28224828)
> It is illegal for the US government to create a mandatory national identity system

The system can be voluntary.

If you don't need an SSN today, you wouldn't need to use that system.

If some bank or health care provider only accepts such a system, just pick another one, or create your own bank / health care provider.

Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by smsm42 on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @02:52PM (#28225575)
You can not create a bank that does not verify identity according to a myriad of KYC regulations. You'd be heavily fined and most likely jailed if you do. Not sure about healthcare providers, probably if you're something like a massage therapist, there are no such requirements, but for a larger one there are probably regulations too.
Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by InitialLastName on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @03:16PM (#28225856)
I suspect that for healthcare providers, the ID requirement is driven more by insurance fraud prevention (including Medicare/Medicaid); i.e. the insurers require the providers to perform due diligence to ensure that the patient being treated is the patient who is covered.

I don't know of any examples, but perhaps a provider who did not take insurance would be able to avoid the requirement.

Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by volta83 on Thursday August 19, 2021 @04:42PM (#28239127)
So how do banks verify identity in the US ?
Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by smsm42 on Friday August 20, 2021 @02:59PM (#28250012)
Usually they rely on government documents (driver licenses, passports, such kind of thing). Online banking has been a bit more lax but started having more KYC requirements recently. For an American though it's usually boils down to asking for SSN and driver license.
Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by lhorie on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @02:30PM (#28225288)
> everyone asks why don't we just thing that looks like a national identity system

Aren't passports national/federal identity systems?

Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by snowwrestler on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @03:53PM (#28226281)
But not mandatory. You don’t need to get a passport unless you want to travel internationally.

The question is whether the U.S. federal government can require all U.S. residents to get, carry, and provide a national form of identification. To my knowledge it cannot, but I’m not handy with a case citation to prove it. Watching the rest of this thread to see what people turn up.

Note that Social Security numbers are explicitly not intended to be such IDs, although many services do use SSN as a key to distinguish people from one another.

Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by dragonwriter on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @04:20PM (#28226570)
> But not mandatory.

Even state IDs aren’t generally mandatory in theory, they are mandatory for specific purposes. Like most proposed national IDs. Like Passports. Like Real ID. Like EDL. Like Military ID. Like…

> The question is whether the U.S. federal government can require all U.S. residents to get, carry, and provide a national form of identification.

No, its not. Literally no one is advocating that. Its actually pretty well established that even states, while they can require you to use ID for a whole lot of purposes, but can’t mandate that you carry and produce one generally.

Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by snowwrestler on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @09:32PM (#28229342)
Thanks
Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by iknowstuff on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @02:04PM (#28224905)
Thanks for bringing that up. Denmark, an EU member state, does not have ID cards, so it's not exactly mandatory over there.

Seems weird that a SSN is not considered a national identity system? What if the federal government sunset SSNs after a bunch of big states implemented an equivalent of EIDAS on their own volition?

Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by pionar on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @02:17PM (#28225083)
It's basically because SSNs were not supposed to be used for that purpose, they were only supposed to be for the SSA to track people, like an account number.

In fact, the paper cards used to say "NOT FOR IDENTIFICATION" on them. I forget when that was removed.

The military started using them for ID in the 60s, then the IRS started using them in the 70s, and it's just kind of morphed into an ID number because "everyone has one".

Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by adzm on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @01:48PM (#28224698)
Things like the Real ID Act seem to be as close as we can get without constitutional changes. Something like the above could potentially be implemented like that, but still would not be as widespread as an SSN.
Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by jandrewrogers on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @02:02PM (#28224878)
The Real ID Act has not been tested in court yet because it has not gone into effect, having been delayed a decade now. As soon as it goes into effect, lawsuits will immediately drop on several grounds. Furthermore, many States have declined to implement the part of the Act that requires them to share their identity databases with the Federal government, only complying with the "identity standards" part.

Prior Supreme Court cases have ruled that the Federal government cannot coerce the States, e.g. via taxation or regulatory authority, to do something for the Federal government that the Federal government is prohibited from doing itself. Without the voluntary compliance of the States, which is like herding cats, with respect to creating a national identity database, the net effect of Real ID will basically be more standardized State IDs.

Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by dragonwriter on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @02:23PM (#28225188)
> The Real ID Act has not been tested in court yet because it has not gone into effect

It went into effect in 2014. You are probably confusing Phase 4 requirements (the requirement for Real ID for commercial air travel being the main one) with the act as a whole. Real ID are issued, and are required for a variety of purposes.

> Prior Supreme Court cases have ruled that the Federal government cannot coerce the States, e.g. via taxation or regulatory authority, to do something for the Federal government that the Federal government is prohibited from doing itself.

Which would be relevant if cases had also established that the federal government cannot issue photo ID cards that the Federal government required for functions subject to federal regulation under the Constitution.

But no such ruling has been made, and the federal government issues a variety of IDs (passports, permanent resident ID, military ID), and mandates their use (allowing, in some cases—like commercial air travel—the use of an acceptable alternative) for a variety of purposes.

Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by brewdad on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @02:13PM (#28225035)
Once again, citation please.

You seem very sure of these Supreme Court decisions that appear to have slipped past the rest of us. Not saying you are wrong, with the firehose of info these days it's easy to miss things, even really important things.

Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by jandrewrogers on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @03:42PM (#28226148)
To be clear, it isn't that a national identity database doesn't exist, they just can't force you to have a national identity token (that is a power divested to the States). Several legislative attempts have been made to link that database to some other token that is de facto mandatory even if they don't control it, like (currently) State ID. The challenge is, then, that they can't deprive citizens of rights for not having a token over which the Federal government has no control. The States have not been cooperative in this regard across the political spectrum, albeit for different reasons. So at the national level we either have optional ID tokens, like passports, or mandatory IDs that are not tokens, like SSN.

There isn't one court case that informs the boundaries of the Federal government and ID, and how the government may facilitate the linking of an existing identity token to their database, it is diffused across many. The policy and regulatory practice in the Federal government threads a convoluted path through this precedent, with myriad loopholes and workarounds, and exploiting gray areas that have not been adjudicated. I've worked in this environment, which is the only reason I know about it. Every time they create a database on US citizens, they must articulate the title authority that both allows that database to exist and to be used (use and existence are, somewhat dubiously, deemed separate authorities which notionally allows them to collect data if they don't look at it -- this reasoning is not well-tested).

In practice, the US government outsources identity stuff to companies like Lexis-Nexis, which rely on duck-typing to determine identity since this doesn't require the person being identified to carry a token. Just about everyone carries an ensemble of tokens that are sufficient for identity purposes if you have fewer database building prohibitions than the US government.

Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by ciabattabread on Thursday August 19, 2021 @12:30AM (#28230334)
What in the US Constitution is preventing Congress from passing a law establishing national identity tokens? I’d figure that would be done under Congress’s power “To establish a uniform Rule of Naturalization.”
Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by rhizome on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @02:48PM (#28225513)
Your explanations here are pretty vague and feel like they're trying to say "do your own research (on my claims)." I'm not saying you have to cite chapter and verse, but know that when you're gettin pushback here that actual factual details might help, because it seems clear that force of personality doesn't.
Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by sneak on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @02:22PM (#28225181)
Real ID is a backdoor national ID, just administrated piecemeal by the states.

The feds have all of the secure flight data and all of the Real ID license/state ID card data, linked to SSN.

Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by jandrewrogers on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @03:47PM (#28226217)
Yes, this was the intent. However, many States have refused to implement the requirement to give the Feds access to their databases, even if though the ID conforms to standards, and the Feds don't have a lot of leverage to force compliance.
Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by renewiltord on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @02:03PM (#28224889)
Well, we could just make it just as mandatory as the social security system. And since the SSN is constitutional, so can this private/public pair system.