News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:T-Mobile: Breach Exposed SSN/DOB of 40M+ People by dragonwriter on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @02:04PM (#28224907)
> It is illegal for the US government to create a mandatory national identity system or coerce the States into creating one. The limits of this have been pretty thoroughly tested in the US Supreme Court.

No, they haven't. There are people who have speculated that it is illegal since the idea started being discussed (serious discussions are actually fairly new, mostly a burst in the late-1990s and another one shortly after 9/11, though speculative strawman negative arguments go back a bit further, at least to discussions around HIPAA in the mid-1990s.) Those speculations have extrapolated from cases that are quite distant from a national ID (e.g., weirdly, critics of the idea have suggested a national ID would violate the protection of the eight to anonymous political speech found in the first amendment under McIntyre v. Ohio Elections Commission (1995), which aside from the WTF of what a national ID even has to do with that right, is clearly false because the First Amendment applies to the states under the 14th Amendment, so if somehow the creation of a federal ID would violate a First Amendment right, the creation of a state ID would equally violate the application of that right under the 14th. In fact, we have federal (directly issued or state-issued under federal regulations) ID cards required for certain federally regulated purposes, notably:

(1) Passports (or, for certain cases, state-issued under federal rules Enhanced Driver's Licenses) for border crossing;

(2) Passports, state-issued ID’s meeting federal Real ID standards, or certain other federal or federally-regulated IDs for air travel and access to federal facilities.

There are usage or production requirements that government might adopt for ID that violate Constitutional protections that have been firmly articulated by the courts, but those generally apply to state and federal ID equally.

There are no comments on this comment yet.