News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by chrisseaton on Sunday August 15, 2021 @06:36PM (#28193197)
Why are these local power lines up in the air on such low poles? Shouldn't they be buried when in an urban environment? I've only ever seen power lines up in the air when crossing open country, and then 50m or so up in the air.
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by jdavis703 on Sunday August 15, 2021 @06:41PM (#28193244)
This is fairly common across the US (based on your use of the metric system I’m guessing you’re not familiar with US cities.) About the only areas with buried lines are high-density urban neighborhoods and wealthy suburbs.
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by barsonme on Sunday August 15, 2021 @07:35PM (#28193565)
Some places on the coasts bury them as well. My wife grew up on the coast and it wasn’t uncommon to go a few days or more without power each year because wind storms would knock over trees onto the power lines. They’ve since buried a lot of their lines.
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by adventured on Sunday August 15, 2021 @08:11PM (#28193740)
It's not unusual for rural and suburban neighborhoods built since the 1970s to bury their powerlines. Even in nowhere Appalachia where I grew up that was very normal.
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by mcast on Sunday August 15, 2021 @10:21PM (#28194376)
Many of them in Florida on the east coast are also buried to lessen hurricane damage to infrastructure, but of course the main arteries coming from the power plants are always above ground.
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by koheripbal on Monday August 16, 2021 @11:28AM (#28199201)
Even most wealthy suburbs have them above ground. It is just way cheaper to install, insulate, and maintain.
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by JimTheMan on Sunday August 15, 2021 @07:05PM (#28193387)
To add to the other commenters, above ground local powerlines are the default around the world. They cool easily and are easy to build/fix/maintain.

I am curious as to where you live where underground is the norm? I wonder if they build them differently than elsewhere..?

Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by rini17 on Sunday August 15, 2021 @07:33PM (#28193551)
In Slovakia all new construction must have underground power lines. Not only that, hanging anything in the air (like fiber) across the street in all residential areas is banned. But only few decades ago it was common and there are still active 240/400 volt power poles everywhere. The major reason is probably winter icing.
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by Reason077 on Sunday August 15, 2021 @11:05PM (#28194587)
> "I am curious as to where you live where underground is the norm?"

It's very rare to see above-ground power lines in UK towns and cities. You do see them in more rural locations.

(Some UK towns do have broadband cables running on poles, installed in the 1990s/early 2000s and typically splayed out in star configurations to several houses from a single pole. They're very ugly!)

Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by nwallin on Monday August 16, 2021 @02:04AM (#28195357)
To further add on to other commentators, wooden utility poles are cheap in North America and expensive in lots of places in Europe. Wooden utility poles are made of a solid trunk, not smaller pieces of wood that have been attached together. North America has lots of long straight pine trees to build utility poles out of. European forests have lots of thin or bendy trees which don't make good utility poles. Much of Europe has been denuded of its natural forests.
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by DasIch on Sunday August 15, 2021 @07:17PM (#28193467)
In Germany the powerlines are always below ground except for high voltage. I’m pretty sure this is also the case for most of Western Europe.
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by Sharlin on Monday August 16, 2021 @08:13AM (#28197160)
I remember back in the 90s in Finland there still used to be overhead medium-voltage powerlines in lower-density urban areas; those are practically all gone now, replaced with underground lines. In higher-density areas underground was the norm even back then.

Many HV trunk lines (ie. tens to hundreds of kV) are buried as well, and those that aren’t, of course have wide buffer zones to avoid being hit by errant cars or falling trees.

In the countryside (of which there is a lot in Finland), overhead lines are much more common due to the cost of burying them all. Still, it’s increasingly being done because a few storms in recent years left thousands of rural residents without electricity for days or even weeks – and such storms are only becoming more frequent while our lifestyles are getting even more dependent on electricity.

Burying all those lines is of course expensive, and the expenses will ultimately be paid by the consumers. There has been some pushback due to this – transmission fees have gone up a lot in the 2000s and utility companies are accused of using the costs as an excuse to inflate their profits.

Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by jcrawfordor on Sunday August 15, 2021 @08:59PM (#28193945)
Above-ground pole infrastructure is considered an eyesore by a lot of municipalities, so it's common to require that new subdivisions bury everything for some decades now.
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by girvo on Sunday August 15, 2021 @09:36PM (#28194153)
They're incredibly common here in Brisbane.

https://utilitymagazine.com.au/underground-power-upgrade-com...

Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by JimTheMan on Monday August 16, 2021 @01:29AM (#28195196)
I can see the appeal for urban zones to have new underground high voltage lines (even though it's not ideal from a technical/operation standpoint) to appease land owners, who don't want big new easements for overhead transmission eyesores in their backyard.

That being said, in a typical neighbourhood it's still wires everwhere to the house. I even went as far to drop the little man in google maps and have a peek. Wires everywhere the eye can see!

Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by htns on Sunday August 15, 2021 @07:31PM (#28193543)
I'd guess anywhere snow can build up on roofs will have the lines buried.
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by post-it on Sunday August 15, 2021 @08:48PM (#28193883)
Nova Scotia has overhead lines. Power does go out a bunch, mostly due to tree branches though.
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by jpindar on Monday August 16, 2021 @12:47AM (#28195014)
Same in parts of New England. It's not too unusual to lose power during storms (especially ice storms), but it's typically restored within a few hours.
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by Reason077 on Sunday August 15, 2021 @10:49PM (#28194517)
> "Why are these local power lines up in the air on such low poles?"

Power lines suspended on poles are common throughout North American and Asian countries in my experience, even in urban areas.

Burying power lines by default in towns and cities seems to be a more UK/European thing.

Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by thirtyseven on Sunday August 15, 2021 @06:42PM (#28193249)
My understanding is that it's only economical to bury utility lines when there is frequent enough inclement weather to bring them down, which definitely isn't the case in San Jose.
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by beerandt on Sunday August 15, 2021 @07:03PM (#28193371)
Even then it's not worth it, unless there's some unique risk or liability they're worried about, like near airports.

Retrofits in urban areas are especially expensive, because any good contractor knows there's gonna be unknown problems once you start digging.

Most places that have underground electric in the US have it either because it's mandated by local code or because the original developer was willing to pay for it.

Hypothetically, enough bad weather would make burying it economical, but I've never heard of any particular instance where that was the case.

Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by chrisseaton on Sunday August 15, 2021 @07:05PM (#28193382)
I wonder why it's routinely buried in the UK - we're a lot poorer, don't have extreme weather, and retrofits must have been far more complex here.
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by beerandt on Sunday August 15, 2021 @07:28PM (#28193519)
There are a lot of interesting differences in the basic grid designs and layouts that are a result of the 120 vs 240 voltage differences. Everything from number of transformers, to distances between substations, to the required line separation and clearance from ground.

It all results in fundamental cost differences, that were originally calculated based on density and distances, with US being low density/ large distance and the opposite for the UK.

I'm sure there's related consequences with line burial, but I don't know if that's the reason it's so common in the UK.

Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by nwallin on Monday August 16, 2021 @02:11AM (#28195389)
Because ya'll don't have any trees.

Wooden utility poles are made from a single piece of wood, usually the trunk of a pine tree. It's cheap to toss a bunch of them on the back of a truck and drive them to wherever, but they're typically longer than a cargo container, so putting them on a ship is annoying.

The forests in North America has lots of tall, straight pine trees but there are fewer forests in Europe and what forests there are tend to have more deciduous forests, where the trees are shorter, narrower, and ... squigglier.

You could have shorter poles and fit them into cargo containers more easily, but now you're stuck with short utility poles. Concrete or metal utility poles are a thing, but they're more expensive.

Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by Symbiote on Monday August 16, 2021 @02:48AM (#28195569)
Concrete poles are almost as cheap as wood, once the longer lifetime and lower maintenance are appointed for.

And anyway, Europe has plenty of farms pine/spruce forests. That Ikea furniture doesn't just appear.

Europe buries power lines because they're considered ugly.

Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by smcl on Monday August 16, 2021 @04:36AM (#28196083)
IKEA furniture isn't generally made from large, straight individual pine trees though. They're pretty notorious for using particleboard
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by pvaldes on Monday August 16, 2021 @03:25AM (#28195753)
All, wooden, concrete and metallic poles over a concrete block are common in Europe. Sometimes is buried, other not. Maybe is not the best solution where the phreatic water level is too high (i.e. most mediterranean cities in the coast).
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by x0x0 on Sunday August 15, 2021 @07:22PM (#28193494)
I suspect this is a big component: uk population density: 281/km2; us population density:36/km2. Obviously not a perfect comparison because density is highly variable, but the US is just so so much more spread out than european countries.
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by chrisseaton on Sunday August 15, 2021 @07:26PM (#28193510)
Isn't this San Jose? Eastern end of Silicon Valley, population density in the thousands, and home of the super-rich?
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by ojbyrne on Monday August 16, 2021 @01:05AM (#28195097)
1. Yes

2. I don’t think so. But the way way people describe the geography here is weird. Usually people say it’s the southern end.

3. It’s pretty sprawly, car is king, generally the threat of earthquakes and nimbyism has resulted in low density. I doubt ‘thousands’ though I’m not clear on your units.

4. Highly doubtful. The super-rich mostly live in the suburbs or exurbs of SJ, where it’s cooler (temperature wise) and less urban. Los Gatos, Mountain View, Palo Alto, Woodside, Menlo Park, Atherton, etc.

Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by beerandt on Sunday August 15, 2021 @07:36PM (#28193572)
The electrical grids in general were fundamentally designed differently from country to country, including the voltage difference.

That took into account what was cost effective from the perspective of large scale deployment, and then individual elements are designed from (and are intertwined with) everything downstream from that. So even if two cities (one US and one UK) were/are nearly identical, the resulting grid is going to end up being laid out very differently.

Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by bb611 on Sunday August 15, 2021 @11:24PM (#28194668)
The neighborhood in question was built in the late 1960s, underground has been the default for a few decades now but this neighborhood (along with many others through SJ) is just all old construction. There's no real justification for moving the power underground, even in rich neighborhoods most streets still have power via poles unless they're relatively new.
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by dboreham on Sunday August 15, 2021 @07:35PM (#28193564)
Electrical distribution plant generally follows the same code everywhere in the country. Also when SJ was first electrified it was a rural area.
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by Nasrudith on Sunday August 15, 2021 @07:12PM (#28193434)
That explains things - in my experience I have seen money as the most conspicuous main barrier in the Northeast. Get above a certain threshold of wealth and even in sparse areas they go underground and poorer areas can get a bit more density than usual before being forced underground. A suburb with power lines is on the lower side of middle class. An urban area with power lines is practically a red flag for poverty for the two go together.

Reminds me of the joke about cancer risk and lowered IQs and power lines - the mechanism of the damage is insidious - it doesn't act through radiation but through lowered property values.

Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by cafard on Sunday August 15, 2021 @07:15PM (#28193461)
It's economical for new developments. I lived some years about a mile outside the Washington Beltway, in a rowhouse development built in the mid-80s. Everything had been done on the cheap, but the utility lines were underground.
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by c_o_n_v_e_x on Monday August 16, 2021 @07:03AM (#28196778)
Local geology is a factor. Trenching through mud, clay, or sand is going to be a lot cheaper than rock.
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by wumpus on Sunday August 15, 2021 @07:10PM (#28193420)
The Bay Area has a long-running plan to bury all of them anyway.
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by m0llusk on Sunday August 15, 2021 @08:59PM (#28193944)
Which has gotten very bogged down. Undergrounding in San Francisco has all but stopped because of the expense. More ominous is the Palo Alto experience. Quite some time ago, like late 60s or early 70s or there about, Palo Alto undergrounded its utility lines. Since then the combination of clay soils and earthquakes has done enormous damage to the point that the City may have to rebuild their entire utility infrastructure. Seeing Palo Alto confront this enormous unexpected expense is giving pause to local governments all over the bay.
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by wumpus on Sunday August 15, 2021 @09:15PM (#28194034)
It would be fun to talk to you about it -- I moved to the part of Palo Alto with underground lines in 2013 -- but people are downvoting me, so, sorry.
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by jazzyjackson on Monday August 16, 2021 @12:34AM (#28194958)
getting downvoted is no reason to keep to yourself :/ its people moderating the overall discussion, not trying to punish you or silence you or something (getting flagged is another matter ofc...)
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by bagels on Sunday August 15, 2021 @11:48PM (#28194761)
Where can I read about this?
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by c54 on Sunday August 15, 2021 @06:52PM (#28193305)
The California Bay Area is earthquake prone, so leaving power lines exposed and above ground is pretty common. You'll see similar in Japan as well.
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by 8ytecoder on Sunday August 15, 2021 @06:56PM (#28193327)
That goes against my intuition. Everything standing about the ground is bound to have things fall over it in an earthquake. Power lines could be much safer under the ground.

From a friend of mine who was trying hard to get the “unsightly” utility poles buried underground - it was just a lack of interest and funds. Just not a priority here.

Almost all new neighborhoods have utility lines buried.

Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by fwip on Sunday August 15, 2021 @07:15PM (#28193457)
Perhaps it's safer underground, but repair is also more expensive.
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by rini17 on Sunday August 15, 2021 @07:41PM (#28193597)
Earthquake or flood so severe that it damages underground power line, damages water and sewer pipes even sooner. So in that case digging must be done anyway.
Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by dredmorbius on Monday August 16, 2021 @05:49AM (#28196428)
I don't know what the power-grid considerations are, but much of the SF Bay Area is on fill or other unstable ground which is subject to liquifaction and severe movement in seismic events.

Undergrouding local transmission might increase overall risks of outages / cost of repair.

Re:San Jose Fire had an impossibly complex incident scene (2... by dghughes on Sunday August 15, 2021 @09:23PM (#28194078)
Here in my area of Canada it's very rare to have underground electrical power lines. So rare that there was a study using a small town (in New Brunswick?) to research the cost, maintenance, durability of doing so. That was back in the 70s or 80s. It was a unique situation that didn't seem to catch on probably due to the cost.