I.e what is done explicitly defines the color. Explicit Allow (blacklist opt out) -> whitelist Explicit Deny (whitelist opt out) -> blacklist
That's a blacklist.
The key here is that the developer can choose to opt-in/out when uploading to the mac store (defaulting to opt-in), however older apps will be opt-out by default (as the developer didn't have this choice when they uploaded).
And because it’s likely implemented like that, you can either generate a whitelist or blacklist if you want, but in reality it’s highly unlikely it’s implemented as either of these things.
But regardless it seems like this whole thread is just about semantics anyway.
But the moment you have a tighter integration with the system with a custom login or maybe ads and some inApp products you are in for a fun ride if you want users to get the latest and greatest version. The moment you have ingame products that are paid with real money you will have the added joy of dealing with customers and issues with said payments. The. One the yearly API deprecations with soft force updates to the latest build tools and so forth.
Also OpenSourcing a game is not just a push of a button on GitHub. For bigger projects and companies it means lawyers have to get involved.
So a user who has never used the app on iOS can go in the store, pay money for the app, and try to use it on their Mac.
So yes, that does create an implication of support by the developer for that app running on that platform.
That is a different scenario than removing access to download an app on your phone that you purchased in the past. You can remove the app from the store and still allow downloads for existing users.
So perhaps, many developers who exclude their app from running on M1 may be doing it for technical reasons.
I believe it also requires that system integrity protection not be disabled, so any other Apple spyware in macOS (eg serial-linked APNS phone-home) cannot be disabled.
You just download the iPad version from the App store and it runs automagically.
I even did a blog post about it: https://chrisbergeron.com/2021/06/16/Pushover-Desktop-Yes-on...