News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Does Oil Come from Dinosaurs? by airiers on Sunday August 08, 2021 @05:17AM (#28105291)
Another similar myth is that the air we breathe comes from trees.

2/3 of the air we breath also comes from plankton.

Trees are mostly net zero in regards to oxygen. What they release during their lifetime they take back when they die and decay.

Re:Does Oil Come from Dinosaurs? by tomtomtom777 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @11:21AM (#28107360)
I think it's a bit odd to call this "net zero".

If there are more trees, there's more oxygen.

Sure, if a tree dies this is eventually reverted but it also makes room for a new tree (unless humanity claims the land).

Re:Does Oil Come from Dinosaurs? by bnegreve on Sunday August 08, 2021 @06:50AM (#28105770)
If by air you mean (di)oxygen, it kinda does come from the plants, but prehistoric ones rather than modern ones.

E.g. see [1] "The growth of these forests removed huge amounts of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, leading to a surplus of oxygen."

[1] https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/carbonife...

Re:Does Oil Come from Dinosaurs? by pfdietz on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:56AM (#28106353)
The timescale for O2 to be stripped from the atmosphere (by reaction with reduced chemicals exposed by erosion, weathering, and emitted from volcanoes) is only about 10 million years, so the current composition of the atmosphere is due to recent conditions, not ancient conditions.

There is an open question of why atmospheric O2 has been relatively stable (varied by a factor of several) in the Phanerozoic. This may just be anthropic selection: if it ever fell too far, higher life would have been wiped out, and we wouldn't be here. This has implications for the existence of extraterrestrial intelligence: it might be that most life-bearing worlds suffocate themselves before ETs can evolve.

Re:Does Oil Come from Dinosaurs? by bnegreve on Sunday August 08, 2021 @12:14PM (#28107760)
Hum, I'd like to read more about this. I find hard to believe that the current atmospheric conditions are completely unrelated to the rise of oxygen attributed to photosynthesis, and that they can only be explained by anthropic selection (which is always a possible explanation anyway).
Re:Does Oil Come from Dinosaurs? by pfdietz on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:33PM (#28108940)
Oxygen has cycled many times through the crust and back out again since the GOE (or even since the Neoproterozoic Oxygenation Event) so I don't see why you think any sort of "memory" of those ancient events would remain in the system.
Re:Does Oil Come from Dinosaurs? by bnegreve on Sunday August 08, 2021 @04:12PM (#28109710)
Ok, I'm not saying that the exact same molecules of O2 from the GOE were preserved until today, rather that the presence of O2 in the atmosphere is related to the emergence of plants and photosynthesis. This is what I meant by "O2 comes from prehistoric plants".

For the record, the "memory" if you want to call it like this, would be the (unoxidized) carbon buried underground and/or segregated in the plants body.

Re:Does Oil Come from Dinosaurs? by pfdietz on Sunday August 08, 2021 @04:46PM (#28109944)
There is unoxidized carbon buried underground, but the bulk of the Earth has vastly more reducing capacity than relatively piddling amounts of buried organic carbon. Fully oxidized, the Earth could consume orders of magnitude more oxygen than exists in the atmosphere. Simply oxidizing all the minerals in the crust down to a couple of hundred meters would use all the atmosphere's O2, and then there's thousands of kilometers of mantle loaded with ferrous iron and sulfides, and then the iron core.
Re:Does Oil Come from Dinosaurs? by bnegreve on Sunday August 08, 2021 @05:23PM (#28110232)
I see, it's actually a bit scary. But if oxidation doesn't happen fast enough (no matter why) the O2 surplus can still be explained somewhat indirectly by the emergence of photosynthesis billions years ago. Or maybe by something else. Anyway, I finally got your point, interesting.
Re:Does Oil Come from Dinosaurs? by pfdietz on Sunday August 08, 2021 @06:43PM (#28110879)
The atmosphere is like a leaky boat. Oxygen leaks out when rocks are eroded and weathered and when volcanoes release reduced gases, and burial of photosynthesized material pumps it back in. The troubling part is that there's no obvious reason why these two processes have to be balanced over periods much longer than the time constant of the system.
Re:Does Oil Come from Dinosaurs? by emmelaich on Monday August 09, 2021 @01:22AM (#28112986)
Yep, I've read somewhere that an enormous amount of oxygen came from rocks, and the Himalayas in particular.
Re:Does Oil Come from Dinosaurs? by pfdietz on Monday August 09, 2021 @06:58AM (#28115115)
What? That's not what I said at all. Erosion of mountains should itself be an O2 sink, not a source (although subsequent burial of organic matter as the eroded material reaches the ocean, and fertilization of plankton in the ocean by the material, could be an O2 source).
Re:Does Oil Come from Dinosaurs? by emmelaich on Tuesday August 10, 2021 @05:41AM (#28126824)
Sorry if I misunderstood, but you wrote

> Oxygen leaks out when rocks are eroded and weathered..

which is what I reinforced.

?

Re:Does Oil Come from Dinosaurs? by pfdietz on Tuesday August 10, 2021 @02:00PM (#28132062)
It leaks out of the atmosphere. It is pumped back into the atmosphere by photosynthesis + burial of organic material.

Perhaps not the best metaphor.

Re:Does Oil Come from Dinosaurs? by emmelaich on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @09:48PM (#28150668)
I was mistaken. It's a sink for CO2. See the work of Ruddiman and Raymo.
Re:Does Oil Come from Dinosaurs? by TheFreim on Sunday August 08, 2021 @10:48AM (#28107111)
All of these myths I learned in school make me think it was an even bigger waste of time than I originally though.
Re:Does Oil Come from Dinosaurs? by dredmorbius on Sunday August 08, 2021 @08:56PM (#28111657)
The roles played by education are ... an interesting topic. It's not a complete waste, but motives must be understood. True education belongs when you become self-motivated to learn (and hopefully don't fall prey to the numerous other pitfalls which exist).

First, the universities were given the task of providing an unceasing supply of ideologically correct candidates for vital positions in government, church, and business. The state was able to make the faculties of the "venerable institutions" of higher education, or rather indoctrination, assume this duty because it controlled appointments and held the purse from which "emoluments" flowed into the coffers of academics. Hence the members of the university "hierarchy" made it their "business, the business for which they ... [were] paid," to "uphold certain political as well as religious opinions," namely those of the "ruling powers of the state" (J.S. Mill, Autobiography and Literary Essays, p. 429 (1981), J.S. Mill, Journals and Debating Speeches, p. 350. (1988) ). Thus the universities pursued with vigor their assignment to inculcate in their students those political and ideological views that were cherished by the power elite. The graduates of the ancient universities were, therefore, well prepared for employment in, and by, those institutions that were instrumental in perpetuating the existing maldistribution of income. All of this might come to naught, however, if the masses of the underclass should achieve anything approaching success in potential attempts at throwing off their fetters.

The state devised a second educational strategy in order to prevent such a calamity from occurring. According to Mill, the "elementary schools for children of the working classes" were given the task of ensuring that the poor would continue to accept docilely their dismal station in life. It was very easy for the state to force the public schools to assume this role. It did so simply by failing malignantly to allocate sufficient funds for the operations of what Mill identified contemptuously as "places called schools" (J.S. Mill, Essays on England, Ireland, and the Empire, p.200; emphasis in original).

See: http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00346760110081599

I've discussed this earlier and in more depth here: https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/6x7u6a/on_the_...

Re:Does Oil Come from Dinosaurs? by ptr2voidStar on Sunday August 08, 2021 @12:38PM (#28108000)
This is precisely my thoughts, as I scroll through the comments - jaw on the floor.
Re:Does Oil Come from Dinosaurs? by rabuse on Sunday August 08, 2021 @10:58AM (#28107194)
Our public education in the U.S. is a travesty. There's really no incentive to remain up-to-date on information, and it seems to be getting worse.
Re:Does Oil Come from Dinosaurs? by mncharity on Sunday August 08, 2021 @04:48PM (#28109958)
An educator suggests[1], in the context of preK science education, that students have a human right to make sense of their world "now". That's very not the focus of current science education content. PreK-13. But what if were? What might that look like?

Status quo is students being told the Sun is yellow, from preK on through to the most common intro astronomy college textbooks, with only a few of them getting an "oops, nope, our bad" decades later, in astronomy graduate school discussion of common misconceptions in astronomy education. We've known Sun color for a century, had detailed limb darkening and tint numbers for decades, and now years of intensive effort on stellar atmospheres in support of occultation and exoplanet work. Also years of hemispherical-camera daytime-sky surveys. And science education content manages to remain decoupled from all of that.

A startup pivoted from supporting learning of English in Japan, because the market there turned out to be for performance on English proficiency exams, not for English fluency. And a teacher remarked that it seemed the societal objective was English accessibility for work, while avoiding the fluency which could contaminate culture. Similarly, an truly excellent briefing on biology would necessarily be pervasively steeped in evolution... and thus be less than entirely welcome in the US. Not that Europe or Russia, or China, India, or Brasil, have incentivized its creation either. It seems neither the science research nor science education communities are set up to pursue it.

[1] https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=Larimore+Vision+2020