Re:Does Oil Come from Dinosaurs?
by pfdietz on Sunday August 08, 2021 @04:46PM
(#28109944)
There is unoxidized carbon buried underground, but the bulk of the Earth has vastly more reducing capacity than relatively piddling amounts of buried organic carbon. Fully oxidized, the Earth could consume orders of magnitude more oxygen than exists in the atmosphere. Simply oxidizing all the minerals in the crust down to a couple of hundred meters would use all the atmosphere's O2, and then there's thousands of kilometers of mantle loaded with ferrous iron and sulfides, and then the iron core.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I see, it's actually a bit scary. But if oxidation doesn't happen fast enough (no matter why) the O2 surplus can still be explained somewhat indirectly by the emergence of photosynthesis billions years ago. Or maybe by something else. Anyway, I finally got your point, interesting.
The atmosphere is like a leaky boat. Oxygen leaks out when rocks are eroded and weathered and when volcanoes release reduced gases, and burial of photosynthesized material pumps it back in. The troubling part is that there's no obvious reason why these two processes have to be balanced over periods much longer than the time constant of the system.
Yep, I've read somewhere that an enormous amount of oxygen came from rocks, and the Himalayas in particular.
What? That's not what I said at all. Erosion of mountains should itself be an O2 sink, not a source (although subsequent burial of organic matter as the eroded material reaches the ocean, and fertilization of plankton in the ocean by the material, could be an O2 source).
Sorry if I misunderstood, but you wrote
> Oxygen leaks out when rocks are eroded and weathered..
which is what I reinforced.
?
It leaks out of the atmosphere. It is pumped back into the atmosphere by photosynthesis + burial of organic material.
Perhaps not the best metaphor.