News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by Tepix on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:58AM (#28075544)
I guess we need a proper CO2 tax to encourage better technology than proof of work
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by Taek on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:18PM (#28076678)
A proper CO2 tax wouldn't be disruptive to bitcoin, bitcoin only cares that everyone pays the same price for electricity. If the absolute cost of electricity goes up, nothing changes.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by godelski on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:19PM (#28077493)
The cost of electricity (coupled with the rewards and cost of hardware) changes how profitable mining is. The more profitable the more players. The more players the more transaction throughput. This is exactly why miners have bought powerplants and why they operate in locations with cheap electricity, because it makes it more profitable for them. Bitcoin mining is directly related to the cost of electricity.

That said, not every cryptocurrency is reliant upon brute forcing hashing algorithms to verify.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by snikeris on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:26PM (#28077582)
It's the same transaction throughput regardless of the number of miners.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by idiotsecant on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:06PM (#28078095)
Same transaction throughput, but not same security.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by arcticbull on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:32PM (#28078420)
Right people say that, but here in the real world we usually define some sense of sufficiency. Just adding more "security" by burning up all the worlds coal at some point has no meaningful benefit. This is just a nice narrative. Security is good -> more security is better no matter the externalities is a terrible way of looking at the current situation.

We don't make seatbelts out of titanium 8 inches thick with their own airbags when they're mounted in a go-kart.

When the hash rate dropped what, 75%, off the back of the China exodus literally nothing happened.

tl;dr: Same transaction throughput, same security, just less efficient.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by arcticbull on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:23PM (#28076754)
Unless the tax applies globally then they’ll just flee to Kazakhstan. Oh wait; they won’t have to flee far.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by akira2501 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:38PM (#28076973)
> If the absolute cost of electricity goes up, nothing changes.

The cost of electricity does impact the cost per transaction on the network, does it not?

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by RamshackleJ on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:41PM (#28077008)
nope, transactions clear at a rate unrelated to mining(so long as at least 1 person is mining).

The only thing that impacts transaction costs is how many other people are trying to clear their own transactions and bidding up the sat/vbyte rate.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by IfOnlyYouKnew on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:10PM (#28077387)
Either transaction costs go up, or electricity usage per transaction goes down. Anything else just doesn’t add up.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by arcticbull on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:38PM (#28078498)
Most coiners conveniently ignore block reward when calculating the cost of a transaction - that's your missing factor. Consider that the only reason you need to secure the blockchain is because it is mutable, if it were immutable it would be sufficient to simply publish it with a known hash. Ergo, 100% of the energy consumption of the Bitcoin network is attributable to transaction processing and therefore can be quantized into and proportionally assigned to transactions.

  TotalCost = DirectCost + ProportionalAllocationOfBlockReward
The value of the block reward is proportional to the price of bitcoin, and this block reward determines the ceiling of the consumption of resources in mining. The floor is determined by prisoners dilemma and so likely approaches the ceiling at the limit.

So yes, the transaction cost does scale with consumption of resources, albeit in a tail-wagging-the-dog kind of way, because the price of the block reward changes with price allowing more resources to be consumed.

Currently the actual cost of a Bitcoin transaction is $2.44 in direct costs + (6.25 * 41000)/2750 = $93 in indirect costs, so right around $95.44 - and that's using I believe the maximum possible transactions per block, the reality is it's more expensive still.

Move over Bank of America, there's a new king in town.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by mikeblackson on Friday August 06, 2021 @06:48PM (#28093647)
You can do 1+ million lightning network transactions that will settle as 1 transaction on the BTC blockchain, so ~$93/1,000,000? Sounds amazingly cheap for uncensorable transactions.

ESG people are trying to solve something that is already solved. POW is here to stay and will scale tremendously well as we all move to layer 2.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by arcticbull on Monday August 09, 2021 @04:49PM (#28122174)
As I mentioned upthread I can't possibly disagree more. PoW is designed specifically not to scale. The higher the price the more it wastes. It's an embarrassingly poor technology.

You completely synthesized $93/1000000 obviously, and as we discussed it would take 75 years to open a channel for everyone alive today and $300,000,000,000.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by andruby on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:39PM (#28078504)
Sorry, that's not how it works. The network adapts the difficulty to target 1 new block every 10 minutes.

More mining → higher difficulty → higher electricity usage per block.

The transaction costs paid are independent of difficulty or number of miners. Transaction cost depends on the demand. A block has a limited size in bytes. If more people want to send transactions than there is room in the current block, the miner that mines that block will include the transactions that include the highest fee.

When sending a transaction, you can choose that fee. Higher fee → higher chance of being included. Bitcoin clients will usually calculate a reasonable fee for you, based on the demand.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by vel0city on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:41PM (#28078542)
Miners don't set the transaction cost, they can only maximize fee revenue by picking the highest fee transactions at that time in the mempool. So, if it becomes unprofitable or not profitable enough for the taste of the miner, hashrate will go down, which will lead to a difficulty adjustment, which means overall electricity usage per transaction goes down.

So its scenario #2 in your comment.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by vel0city on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:38PM (#28078497)
The network self-adjusts difficulty so a block is mined roughly every ten minutes. A block has a maximum size of data in it, pretty much the maximum amount of transactions per block. As long as there aren't massive fluctuations to the mining rate, the rate of transactions will remain relatively constant.

As long as there is free space in the blocks, average transaction fees will remain low. If there are a lot of transactions in the mempool waiting to be included in a block, users will need to submit transactions with higher related fees to ensure they get picked to be included in a block soon.

Remember, miners don't necessarily set transaction fees. Users choose what they're willing to pay for their transactions, essentially placing a bid. Miners choose the transactions that maximize the fees per block. Miners always want as full of blocks as possible because there will only be a block roughly every 10 minutes.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by sputknick on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:04PM (#28075648)
ETH PoS mainnet transition is underway and will be completed early 2022. With this holders of ETH will be able to earn fees from transactions, just by running an application on their standard normal computer. The only encouragement you need to move off of POW is profit motive.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by whichquestion on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:27PM (#28075944)
Hasn’t PoS been something “in the works” for ETH for something like 6 years now[1]? I don’t think anything guarantees its delivery in early 2022, it all seems like hopeful speculation until they deliver something.

[1] This stackexchange question dates back to 2016, the earliest evidence I could find of ETH proposing PoS. https://ethereum.stackexchange.com/questions/9/why-does-ethe...

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by tornato7 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:39PM (#28076119)
This time it's very different. There are billions of dollars of ETH locked up in the staking contract, and proof of stake has been live and operating on the beacon chain for many months.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by casi18 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:49PM (#28076253)
it took a long time to work it out, but it is running on the beacon chain and the consensus upgrade spec has now been merged: https://github.com/ethereum/EIPs/pull/3675
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by overtonwhy on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:33PM (#28076004)
Haven't they been saying POS will be "ready soon" for years? Seems like maybe vaporware used for hype?

"The Ethereum proof of stake date has been set for December 1, 2020. While the proof of stake Ethereum date was originally set for January 2020, this deadline was missed."

https://www.exodus.com/blog/ethereum-proof-of-stake-date/

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by robcohen on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:47PM (#28076235)
PoS is already working in Cardano, Tezos, and Algorand (among others).
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by vmception on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:04PM (#28078915)
Is that what a cursory Google search brings up? It actually did launch in December 2020, so that's awkward.

Some HN users are staking Eth and earning on Eth 2.0 contract, which functions on the Beacon Chain.

Both chains have not been merged yet, far from vaporware so I guess last decade called and wants its arguments back.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by tedunangst on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:17PM (#28078223)
There's a button you can click to stake ethereum on Coinbase, which seems a bit past the vapor stage.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by Yizahi on Monday August 09, 2021 @10:45AM (#28117559)
So do you think Eth miners will just write off their expensive GPUs and throw them into trash bin? It is rather obvious that they will switch to either fork (less probable) or to next best token (more probable).
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by godelski on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:08PM (#28076531)
There's plenty of PPOS systems that aren't as resource intensive. ETH2 doesn't require POW. Algorand is PPOS and built a contract into the leger to offset carbon emissions for the electric costs, making it carbon neutral or negative.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by sunshinerag on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:59PM (#28076415)
There is nothing in POW that requires CO2 emissions.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by p_l on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:07PM (#28076521)
But the core principle of Proof of Work is wasting energy. If it takes from green sources, that just means those green sources won't be available to push out polluting ones. Combine this with buildup of polluting sources as backups for intermittent ones...
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by sunshinerag on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:39PM (#28076996)
No, there is no waste. It is a very efficient conversion of energy to security of the ledger.

And with that ledger instead of all the wars and waste generated by manipulatable central bank ledgers it’s a win.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by vkou on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:44PM (#28077054)
1. There is nothing efficient about wasting that much electricity on securing a ledger that can handle single-digit transactions per second.

2. The needs of central banks don't start wars, the needs of politicians, warhawk nationalists, and the needs of modern industrial economies do. [1] Unless BTC somehow magically gets rid of politicians, nationalism, or of our addiction to oil, that's not going to change.

[1] The US didn't invade Grenada because of the Fed. The USSR didn't invade Afghanistan on behalf of Gosbank. China didn't invade Tibet to fix the balance sheet of the PBC. Vietnam didn't fight a war with its occupiers, and then a civil war, and then a war with Cambodia, and then a war with China, because it was unhappy with the Dong to USD exchange rate. The US participated in that civil war because of domino theory, not because of its departure from the gold standard. The list goes on and on. [2]

[2] Wars aren't fought over currencies, wars are fought over territory, pan-ethnic nationalism, to increase the internal popularity of a warhawk, to maintain a hegemony, to impose one's religion on another, to expel unwanted people from a territory, etc, etc, etc. Bitcoin solves none of these problems.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by sunshinerag on Thursday August 05, 2021 @05:34PM (#28080219)
Layer 1 transactions are not necessarily 1 to 1 transactions. They can be settling millions of transactions in Layer 2 (lightning). It helps to think of layer 1 transactions as a settlement layer.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by sunshinerag on Thursday August 05, 2021 @05:32PM (#28080194)
Wars are used to force citizens to give up their labour for free to the state. In a country with financial mismanagement wars can be used to erase debts.

The US does and will go to war if it feels its dollar/oil hedgemony is threatened. if the dollar demand/circulation outside US falls for any reason, it will cause hyperinflation within the US economy. So they have to constantly threaten/intimidate other countries.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by vkou on Thursday August 05, 2021 @06:01PM (#28080563)
> Wars are used to force citizens to give up their labour for free to the state.

Wet streets don't cause rain, and wars aren't started in order to collect taxes. Wars are started to pursue particular goals, many of which I have listed in my prior post.

> The US does and will go to war if it feels its dollar/oil hedgemony is threatened.

This is an interesting, and oft-repeated theory, that, unfortunately does not survive contact with history. It's not a strong explanation for the majority of the conflicts that the US has been involved in. It is not remotely an explanation for the majority of the conflicts that other countries are involved in.

Which dollar/oil hegemony is Russia trying to maintain in Crimea? China in Tibet? USSR in Afghanistan? Argentina in the Falklands? Sudan in Darfur? Israel in Lebanon? Saudi Arabia in Yemen? ISIS in Syria?

Never mind that BTC doesn't do a thing about the dependency of industrialized sociaties on oil, minerals, fresh water, and other limited material resources.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by arcticbull on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:47PM (#28078632)
Bitcoin is the single least efficient system ever conceived of or reduced to practice by mankind.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by sunshinerag on Thursday August 05, 2021 @05:29PM (#28080153)
Is there a more efficient system to arrive at consensus of a state in a distributed, trust-less, permission less manner?
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by arcticbull on Thursday August 05, 2021 @06:46PM (#28081048)
Well there's proof of stake. However, whether alternatives exist or not has no bearing on the efficiency of a system.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by sunshinerag on Friday August 06, 2021 @09:09AM (#28086641)
well it does matter. you can't use the words "less efficient" or "more efficient" if there are no alternatives with similar properties.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by arcticbull on Friday August 06, 2021 @12:58PM (#28089888)
Thermal efficiency is an absolute - units of energy expended vs work achieved. There is an alternative: proof of stake. Or removing certain constraints on the problem space. A different approach to solving the problem is absolutely an alternative. Visa is an alternative. The extant banking system is an alternative.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by mikeblackson on Friday August 06, 2021 @06:59PM (#28093750)
You can't say how efficient it is without calculating how layer 2 scaling affects per transaction energy usage. You can do millions of layer 2 transactions that eventually settle as 1 transaction on the main chain.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by arcticbull on Sunday August 08, 2021 @06:06PM (#28110562)
You can do “layer 2” transactions that settle on ACH or wire transfers, like Venmo or square cash, what’s your point? This is just more shameful greenwashing to pump up bag.

You would have to do literally millions per on chain transaction using bitcoin to match ACH, visa or a proof of stake chain.

This is of course after you consider opening a single LN channel for every human on earth would take 75 years and 300 billion dollars if the chain did nothing else. Like putting in a request for a Soviet phone line. LN has quadratic routing efficiency and is boat anchored to garbage.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by politician on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:11PM (#28076574)
The Sun is wasting energy. Did you know that only like 0.0001% of the energy radiated by the Sun makes it to the Earth?

Proof of Work doesn't waste energy. It uses energy to secure a distributed ledger.

[dead]
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by purple_ferret on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:39PM (#28076121)
Carbon tax is about transitioning away from carbon. If you're afraid about the little guy, couple it with a tax cut on lower incomes.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by arcticbull on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:52PM (#28078717)
I believe the Canadian carbon tax is revenue neutral, and the amount collected is returned via income tax credits.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by dontreact on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:56PM (#28076360)
It depends on what you do with the revenue. If you distribute the revenue equally to everyone it stops being regressive and is actually progressive.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by gruez on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:40PM (#28076124)
>you'll quickly realize that the end result is the little guy paying the actual tax via inflation while the big guy actually enjoys larger profit totals

What's the alternative then?

Implement regulations, forcing companies to increase costs => "enjoys larger profit totals "?

Tax companies only, forcing them to pass them onto consumers => "enjoys larger profit totals"?

Do nothing?

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by jb775 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:06PM (#28076509)
> Do nothing?

Yes. If the currently available options intended to fix a particular problem don't actually fix the problem while at the same time make the offending business more powerful while making the little guy less powerful...then yes, doing nothing is clearly a better option in the short term.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by gruez on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:58PM (#28077249)
>If the currently available options intended to fix a particular problem don't actually fix the problem

Sounds like your expectation is too high. Either something stops climate change in its tracks, or it's not worth doing. Small incremental improvements? Nah, it won't solve the problem so let's not bother.

>doing nothing is clearly a better option in the short term.

But what about the long term?

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by 0134340 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:41PM (#28076155)
Why tax anything then? The big guys will always have the resources to hire the best accountants to get the biggest discounts.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by adolph on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:52PM (#28076307)
Agreed, the fairest form of funding is fee for service and not taxation.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by mjburgess on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:40PM (#28076135)
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by jonathanpeterwu on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:35PM (#28076047)
We should probably also find a way to tax US dollar usage with CO2 tax as the net energy usage here is quite high as well
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by ComodoHacker on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:06PM (#28075677)
This would just increase the cost of electricity and thus the cost of living for everybody, and won't affect crypto miners much.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by X6S1x6Okd1st on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:08PM (#28076528)
IMO the ethical thing to do is a re-distributive carbon tax. All the tax revenue should go directly back to the population as income/subsidy.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by kelnos on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:51PM (#28076287)
In this case, I think you could work around that, as they could implement a high capital gains tax rate for cryptocurrency sales. Then it would only impact people who mine.

Obviously it seems they are going in the exact opposite direction on this, though...

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by X6S1x6Okd1st on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:08PM (#28076533)
Miners typically get their funds as income, not necessarily cap gains.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by freeone3000 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:20PM (#28076716)
It's a gain based on your invested capital, isn't it? It's textbook capital gains. PoS, PoW, whatever.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by vmception on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:07PM (#28078968)
Mining is reportable as ordinary income in the US.

Cryptocurrency earners have to report ordinary income taxes as well as capital gain/loss taxes.

Its not that hard, less than ideal, its also easy to immediately convert to USDC or fiat automatically, or find other deductions to reduce or eliminate the tax burden.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by vel0city on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:55PM (#28078777)
A baker buys an oven which they use to bake bread. They sell the bread for dollars. Is that capital gains?
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by X6S1x6Okd1st on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:46PM (#28077069)
Odd that you call it textbook capital gains, what textbook are you working from?

It seems pretty clearly like income to me.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by emteycz on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:35PM (#28076947)
No, mining is in no way capital gains. Capital gains is asset price increase.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by barbecue_sauce on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:59PM (#28077261)
Under that definition, almost all income would be considered capital gains.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by api on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:32PM (#28075993)
The parent is simply pointing out that all consumption taxes are regressive. A CO2 tax by itself is a tax on the poor, especially the rural poor who have longer commutes and are more dependent on automobile travel.

A CO2 tax is only fair if it's paired with progressive tax breaks in other areas and/or subsidies for transition to renewable energy. An example would be a progressive subsidy for electric vehicle purchases and for upgrades to CO2-heavy (coal) electricity generation infrastructure in poorer areas.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by admax88q on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:38PM (#28076094)
A CO2 tax and rebate is progressive. The poorest people would receive more back in a rebate than they pay. But the biggest CO2 users would pay way more than they receive back.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by Groxx on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:57PM (#28076394)
While I generally like CO2 tax/rebate/cap-and-trade systems: given how inefficient and polluting many low-cost techs are... not sure I can agree with that, particularly on the small scale down to individual people. Individuals have the least agency on decisions like this, since they have next to no purchasing power. Though we are talking about bitcoin, which does raise the technical/money base-level a fair bit.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by bee_rider on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:35PM (#28076942)
Wouldn't it be easiest to tax some of the raw materials that go into fuel production, rather than tracking every fuel use? In that case, the CO2 tax will naturally fall equally to everyone, including individual people. The rebate is just there to cancel out the effect of an inherently regressive but technically convenient way of doing things.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by Groxx on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:56PM (#28077209)
That's generally the idea of a flat tax, yeah. Tax everything at point-of-collection/creation (e.g. "you cut down a tree" or "you burned a log") or point-of-import (likely offset for similar taxes collected by the origin country), and there's no need to track anything beyond that point. E.g. re-use or re-selling is (CO2-)tax-free because it doesn't change the net input/output of the whole system.

Which rarely happens in practice, and we're so far from accurately taxing all these processes that it isn't even a dream of a dream. It's mostly tackling big targets, since that's where a ton of the impact-per-dollar-and-per-outrage can be found.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by adolph on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:49PM (#28076259)
> I guess we need a proper CO2 tax to encourage better technology than proof of work

The statement replied to does not mention "rebate."

> But the biggest CO2 users would pay way more than they receive back.

This statement does not seem believable given the recent stories about tax avoidance strategies of the wealthy.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by awrence on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:16PM (#28076640)
The math on the PoW energy FUD just doesn't check out.

- At current levels, bitcoin uses very roughly 0.1% of global electricity but electricity only represents 25% of fossil fuels emissions so current PoW contribution to global emissions = 0.025%, ie a rounding error. This issue is currently a total red herring. Now let's project into the future.

- bitcoin total addressable market cap if it took over the entire global monetary world (full global monetary premium): ~ 250tn or 300x from here implying a worst case outcome of 7.5% of global emissions, IF this happened TODAY and hashpower linearly tracked price. This is impossible off the bat because building out that infrastructure would take at least a decade. But more importantly it will take a decade or two for price to get there, by which time...

- The block subsidy will have gotten cut by ~ 10 (three halving cycles). Transaction fees might grow of course so let's say 5x lower which gets us back to 1.5% of global emissions.

- Add to that the following:

- 30% of CURRENT electricity production is stranded / wasted. All terminal bitcoin energy usage needs to do is tap into 5% of that to be emissions neutral. And it's heavily skewed towards tapping into that exclusively as that's the cheapest source and PoW is location neutral.

- the proof of work energy mix skews towards not only wasted / stranded but renewable which is trending towards being the cheapest form of energy.

- green power production is on an exponential adoption curve and enough sunlight hits the earth to power humanity for a year. Clean energy is there in amounts dwarfing societal needs, it's just a matter of harnessing it. This doesn't even include geothermal or nuclear.

- At an even higher level, if you got to this point, you would have replaced all the fiat systems in the world thereby: - eliminating the energy spent on maintaining the fiat system which is easily more than 1.5% of global emissions - flipping the world into a hard money world that is no longer incentivized to consume at all costs (read misallocate capital) ergo hugely reducing conspicuous consumption / GDP growth at all costs which is arguably the biggest driver of unnecessary emissions

- This final line of thought would have you conclude flipping to PoW would be emissions negative in the long run, but you don't really need to go there though, the energy numbers alone make this at best a chronically misunderstood narrative.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by endless1234 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:03PM (#28077301)
>At current levels, bitcoin uses very roughly 0.1% of global electricity but electricity only represents 25% of fossil fuels emissions so current PoW contribution to global emissions = 0.025%, ie a rounding error.

How does this argument make sense? Let's split up the world's energy consumption into 0.025% emission sized chunks in some arbitrary way we choose. Does nothing then make any difference, since everything is just a rounding error? The question is, does bitcoin provide value for the emissions it generates? For what it's worth, estimates seem to put the current usage at around 0.6% of total worldwide energy consumption.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by awrence on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:38PM (#28077746)
I see your point but my first bit just meant to highlight the unfair disproportionate energy attention PoW has been getting specifically vs just about any other use case.

I don't personally think you should be making moral judgements about energy use though. Let the market decide what's a good use of energy. If you have a carbon problem, tax / regulate that, PoW won't care. It will adjust through difficulty adjustments.

But if you are worried about PoW boiling the oceans if left unchecked, the numbers should comfort you it's at worst going to tap mostly into wasted energy / mostly renewable and probably not have a noticeable impact even extrapolated to a peak outcome (and probably even be a net positive).

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by spywaregorilla on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:13PM (#28077438)
I think bitcoin using 1 out of 1000 units of energy produced is pretty disgusting, hard stop.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by zaphar on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:30PM (#28076857)
You make a lot of claims here but I don't see anything in your post to back up the numbers. I'm too lazy to go do this research myself so I'm left as a result with defaulting to disbelieving you.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by awrence on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:50PM (#28077120)
I've been following this topic intensely for years and am very comfortable with these numbers but fair enough. I agree I should reference some official sources which I'll try and dig back up. Happy to discuss any assumption in closer detail though.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by cwkoss on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:35PM (#28076940)
> eliminating the energy spent on maintaining the fiat system which is easily more than 1.5% of global emissions

Absolutely. It's impossible to accurately account for, but a significant part of why the US Military Industrial Complex is so over-provisioned is to maintain dollar hegemony. 800 international US military bases, the Iraq war, invasion of Libya, force projection exercises by the navy, etc. Being the world police is expensive (in both dollars and CO2), and we wouldn't need to be if we weren't trying to tenuously maintain our status as world reserve currency.

"the DOD is the world's largest institutional user of petroleum and correspondingly, the single largest institutional producer of greenhouse gases (GHG) in the world. 5 From FY1975 to FY2018, total DOD greenhouse gas emissions were more than 3,685 Million Metric Tons of CO2 equivalent."

https://watson.brown.edu/costsofwar/files/cow/imce/papers/Pe...

Certainly the US military has other goals besides maintaining dollar hegemony, but if the dollar wasn't the world reserve currency there would be less need and funds for maintaining such a bloated amount of power.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by IlliOnato on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:53PM (#28077935)
[quote]if the dollar wasn't the world reserve currency there would be less need and funds for maintaining such a bloated amount of power[/quote]

Citation needed.

You really think that other countries, and businesses and individuals in these countries store their savings and denominate their contracts in US dollars at gunpoint?

Ridiculous.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by cwkoss on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:49PM (#28078671)
You are being superlative, but I absolutely believe that the reason we have a bigger military than the next ~10 countries combined is that we want to be the dominant superpower. And part of the desire for that dominance is maintaining the USD as the world reserve currency.

Whenever a country tries to move commodity trades away from the dollar (iraq oil, iran oil, libya gold, venezuela oil) coincidentally pretexts for military operations against them start being manufactured.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by paulgb on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:36PM (#28077717)
> And it's heavily skewed towards tapping into that exclusively as that's the cheapest source and PoW is location neutral.

Are there any big miners who are known to be using stranded/wasted energy that would be produced anyway, as opposed to operating stranded plants that would otherwise be shut down or have capacity reduced? I only really follow the publicly traded miners (and with a bearish thesis), and I've seen a lot of miners getting dedicated coal/natural gas capacity but very little in terms of recapturing wasted energy.

And these are (mostly) US-based public companies, so they have the most to gain by projecting an ESG image.