News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by p_l on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:07PM (#28076521)
But the core principle of Proof of Work is wasting energy. If it takes from green sources, that just means those green sources won't be available to push out polluting ones. Combine this with buildup of polluting sources as backups for intermittent ones...
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by sunshinerag on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:39PM (#28076996)
No, there is no waste. It is a very efficient conversion of energy to security of the ledger.

And with that ledger instead of all the wars and waste generated by manipulatable central bank ledgers it’s a win.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by vkou on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:44PM (#28077054)
1. There is nothing efficient about wasting that much electricity on securing a ledger that can handle single-digit transactions per second.

2. The needs of central banks don't start wars, the needs of politicians, warhawk nationalists, and the needs of modern industrial economies do. [1] Unless BTC somehow magically gets rid of politicians, nationalism, or of our addiction to oil, that's not going to change.

[1] The US didn't invade Grenada because of the Fed. The USSR didn't invade Afghanistan on behalf of Gosbank. China didn't invade Tibet to fix the balance sheet of the PBC. Vietnam didn't fight a war with its occupiers, and then a civil war, and then a war with Cambodia, and then a war with China, because it was unhappy with the Dong to USD exchange rate. The US participated in that civil war because of domino theory, not because of its departure from the gold standard. The list goes on and on. [2]

[2] Wars aren't fought over currencies, wars are fought over territory, pan-ethnic nationalism, to increase the internal popularity of a warhawk, to maintain a hegemony, to impose one's religion on another, to expel unwanted people from a territory, etc, etc, etc. Bitcoin solves none of these problems.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by sunshinerag on Thursday August 05, 2021 @05:34PM (#28080219)
Layer 1 transactions are not necessarily 1 to 1 transactions. They can be settling millions of transactions in Layer 2 (lightning). It helps to think of layer 1 transactions as a settlement layer.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by sunshinerag on Thursday August 05, 2021 @05:32PM (#28080194)
Wars are used to force citizens to give up their labour for free to the state. In a country with financial mismanagement wars can be used to erase debts.

The US does and will go to war if it feels its dollar/oil hedgemony is threatened. if the dollar demand/circulation outside US falls for any reason, it will cause hyperinflation within the US economy. So they have to constantly threaten/intimidate other countries.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by vkou on Thursday August 05, 2021 @06:01PM (#28080563)
> Wars are used to force citizens to give up their labour for free to the state.

Wet streets don't cause rain, and wars aren't started in order to collect taxes. Wars are started to pursue particular goals, many of which I have listed in my prior post.

> The US does and will go to war if it feels its dollar/oil hedgemony is threatened.

This is an interesting, and oft-repeated theory, that, unfortunately does not survive contact with history. It's not a strong explanation for the majority of the conflicts that the US has been involved in. It is not remotely an explanation for the majority of the conflicts that other countries are involved in.

Which dollar/oil hegemony is Russia trying to maintain in Crimea? China in Tibet? USSR in Afghanistan? Argentina in the Falklands? Sudan in Darfur? Israel in Lebanon? Saudi Arabia in Yemen? ISIS in Syria?

Never mind that BTC doesn't do a thing about the dependency of industrialized sociaties on oil, minerals, fresh water, and other limited material resources.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by arcticbull on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:47PM (#28078632)
Bitcoin is the single least efficient system ever conceived of or reduced to practice by mankind.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by sunshinerag on Thursday August 05, 2021 @05:29PM (#28080153)
Is there a more efficient system to arrive at consensus of a state in a distributed, trust-less, permission less manner?
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by arcticbull on Thursday August 05, 2021 @06:46PM (#28081048)
Well there's proof of stake. However, whether alternatives exist or not has no bearing on the efficiency of a system.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by sunshinerag on Friday August 06, 2021 @09:09AM (#28086641)
well it does matter. you can't use the words "less efficient" or "more efficient" if there are no alternatives with similar properties.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by arcticbull on Friday August 06, 2021 @12:58PM (#28089888)
Thermal efficiency is an absolute - units of energy expended vs work achieved. There is an alternative: proof of stake. Or removing certain constraints on the problem space. A different approach to solving the problem is absolutely an alternative. Visa is an alternative. The extant banking system is an alternative.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by mikeblackson on Friday August 06, 2021 @06:59PM (#28093750)
You can't say how efficient it is without calculating how layer 2 scaling affects per transaction energy usage. You can do millions of layer 2 transactions that eventually settle as 1 transaction on the main chain.
Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by arcticbull on Sunday August 08, 2021 @06:06PM (#28110562)
You can do “layer 2” transactions that settle on ACH or wire transfers, like Venmo or square cash, what’s your point? This is just more shameful greenwashing to pump up bag.

You would have to do literally millions per on chain transaction using bitcoin to match ACH, visa or a proof of stake chain.

This is of course after you consider opening a single LN channel for every human on earth would take 75 years and 300 billion dollars if the chain did nothing else. Like putting in a request for a Soviet phone line. LN has quadratic routing efficiency and is boat anchored to garbage.

Re:Senators move to exempt Bitcoin, crypto miners from propo... by politician on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:11PM (#28076574)
The Sun is wasting energy. Did you know that only like 0.0001% of the energy radiated by the Sun makes it to the Earth?

Proof of Work doesn't waste energy. It uses energy to secure a distributed ledger.