Until then it’s basically them spreading misinformation about what quality of life without fossils is like.
This is such a gray and difficult area this propaganda pretending to be journalism is ridiculous.
isn't there kind of a huge difference, regarding climate change, with using fossil fuels for plastics, etc, and burning them for energy?
Like - plastics (particularly in the ocean) do present a massive issue, but they're dwarfed by the problem that is C02 and climate change?
This doesn’t say anything about plastics vs using oil as fuel. When you’re making big accusations about misinformation you should probably be clear and accurate in your journalism
Textbook example of climate misinformation. People are talking about not using fossil fuels. Nobody's talking about banning tires or lotions. (Well, I mean, nobody who's being taken seriously. I'm sure you'll find a few village idiots wanting to go back to wooden chariots, if you look hard enough.)
From the article: “Some of the most significant tactics found included tying the use of oil and gas to maintaining a high quality of life”
This doesn’t say anything about plastics vs using oil as fuel.
When you’re making big accusations about misinformation you should probably be clear and accurate in your journalism
We MUST prioritize R&D for precisely the things you mention, but the onus is on industry to adapt, not stymie necessary conversations and necessary change.
Get on board
At that point unless you can factually prove your accusations you are basically slandering.
A recent example I found is Formula1 planning to be "carbon-free" by 2030 https://www.bbc.com/news/business-51226066, but carbon-offsetting is something very discussable, and they wouldn't account for their fans carbon cost which represent 8 times theirs (a solution could be no spectators, and at this point they could avoid travelling around the planet which would save from almost all their pollution)
To be fair, I'm not especially against those producers, I think the ones that need to act responsibly are consumers and their elected governments. Consumption decrease → demand decrease → production will adjust accordingly
It seems you mistake misinformation for false claims. They are not the same. Misinformation is a truth claim that has the intention to deceive in order to further an agenda. It's doesn't even have to be false!
For example, Shell used to push really hard that it 'planted 5 million trees' and invests in renewables in the Netherlands. The intention was clearly prop up a reputation as a green company. But actually, that investment is not even a blip on the radar compared to their continued investments in fossil fuels, including exploring new sources in the arctic, which is completely incompatible with the Paris agreement. This is pure greenwashing and rightly called misinformation, even which there isn't a single false truth claim.
Your post, on the other hand, has a couple of false claims, but it clearly isn't misinformation. Unless it's really good and you have me fooled.
By the way, the 404 isn't really the guardians fault, InfluenceMap seems to have (re)moved the report.
Not that there ever was a definition of misinformation but wtf is your definition? And how the hell do you objectively decide what is misinformation if facts can be that?
And how is Facebook supposed to measure what facts are actually misinformation by your standards? Should they build an AI that is able to recognise that because shell pumps a lot of oil they shouldnt be able to run ads about planting 5m trees?
Do you realise what you are advocating for?
I don't realize what I'm advocating for because I'm not advocating for anything. I'm just pointing out that misinformation is different from stating false facts, which isn't very controversial.
Also, greenwashing exists. It's a thing, I'm not making it up.
https://www.ethicalconsumer.org/transport-travel/what-greenw...
I'm not sure what we can do about it, exactly. Facebook's product is clearly one that facilitates the manipulation of targeted individuals with misinformation, as is also seen with anti-vaxxers and the "Trump won" crowd.
In my opinion, the missing ingredient is a trusted and wise editorial function. I agree with you: I doubt we want an AI to do that.
And that's probably true. Almost all news is propaganda.
One profiteers externality is all of humanities shared future.
There is no planet B, and if we can’t take reasonable care of our home planet, we can’t be trusted with others.
I blame capitalism for incentivizing bad behavior and calling collective damage an externality
I don't know why you think that they need to restate what you should already know, and also seemingly already know because you state that you agree with it.
By not playing that game, to try to justify it further when there is no need, they're showing that it is indeed misinformation.
To the degree that you impede solutions to climate change, you deserve some of that anger
I'm not carrying water for Exxon and would like us to move to sustainable energy, but by the same measure I'm sick of being told that something is "misinformation" with no justification given other than the fact that it was put forth by unpopular person or organisation.