News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Court orders US Capitol rioter to unlock his laptop ‘with... by andrew_ on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @02:34PM (#27987728)
The rate at which law enforcement attempts to chip away at Constitutional Rights to pursue agendas is frightening. Perhaps it's always been this way, and I've only recently started to notice it.
Re:Court orders US Capitol rioter to unlock his laptop ‘with... by alistairSH on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @02:48PM (#27987949)
Which Constitutional right is being chipped away?

The test for whether something is protected by the 5th has generally been "is it testimony, or is it something that just is?"

Fingerprints, other biometrics, and physical keys are all things that just are. No testimony involved. Not protected. The government can compel you to provide them.

Passcodes and combinations are something you know. They're protected.

I'm certainly open to changing the law to protect biometrics, but I don't see anything in the reporting on this case that indicates it's any different than preceding cases in the last 10 years that dealt with fingerprints.

Re:Court orders US Capitol rioter to unlock his laptop ‘with... by dragonwriter on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @02:53PM (#27988033)
> Fingerprints, other biometrics, and physical keys are all things that just are

For nontrivial biometrics (and facial locking may not usually meet this) the act of unlocking is testimonial (as it demonstrates both the specific action and your knowledge thereof) as much as a password is. A command to “unlock this device with <biometric method>” is different than a command to simply provide, say, a fingerprint.

Re:Court orders US Capitol rioter to unlock his laptop ‘with... by function_seven on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @02:56PM (#27988088)
What about an order to "place your right thumb on this little circle", where the "little circle" just so happens to be the phone they seized from you?

You're not revealing any knowledge about the specific action—they're directing you to do it.

For the face scenario, an order to look directly at the camera is similar. You're not testifying that this laptop is indeed yours, or that you have access. The laptop is going to respond to your stare however it was already configured to do so.

Re:Court orders US Capitol rioter to unlock his laptop ‘with... by dragonwriter on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @03:19PM (#27988423)
> What about an order to "place your right thumb on this little circle", where the "little circle" just so happens to be the phone they seized from you?

Right, it doesn't, for instance, reveal that as a combination of quirks of the sensor and how I trained it, it only unlocks with my left index finger at a slight angle and a particular rolling motion, and moreover, doesn't reveal that I know that to be the case.

Re:Court orders US Capitol rioter to unlock his laptop ‘with... by function_seven on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @03:24PM (#27988505)
Yup. If you're concerned about being compelled to place a finger on the sensor, it seems a good countermeasure would be to train it on your non-dominant hand's pinky. And set a low failure count before the device demands a password instead.

I agree that if the demand was, "place whatever finger will unlock this device—in the orientation required—in this little circle," then that would be compelled witnessing against oneself.

Re:Court orders US Capitol rioter to unlock his laptop ‘with... by tzs on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @04:27PM (#27989300)
It's testimonial that you are the device owner but that usually is not incriminating so wouldn't run into 5th Amendment problems. If for some reason it was incriminating prosecutors could avoid 5th problems by granting you immunity.

Unless you are in the probably quite unusual situation where all they are trying to get you for is owning the device I don't think the act of unlocking is going to work well as something to hang your 5th hopes upon.

Re:Court orders US Capitol rioter to unlock his laptop ‘with... by alistairSH on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @02:59PM (#27988133)
I'm not grasping the difference between fingerprint scan and facial scan. Both have been ruled as acceptable and not covered by the 5th.

Are you arguing that fingerprint unlock and facial unlock should both be protected? I'm open to that argument, but I'm not seeing how they are any more testimonial than providing a fingerprint (or DNA sample) for matching other evidence?

Re:Court orders US Capitol rioter to unlock his laptop ‘with... by andrew_ on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @03:03PM (#27988190)
> Both have been ruled as acceptable and not covered by the 5th.

As the article states, and some quick research would reveal, this is largely dependent upon which state, and which federal jurisdiction, the court is in. A final word has not been given on the matter and each court is allowed to interpret it as it chooses. As such, it has been ruled both for and against.

Re:Court orders US Capitol rioter to unlock his laptop ‘with... by yuliyp on Thursday July 29, 2021 @04:42PM (#28001239)
In this case, the argument in the ruling is that there is no question that the defendant owns the laptop, so the act of proving that it's his account doesn't incriminate (since it's not establishing any fact not already known).
Re:Court orders US Capitol rioter to unlock his laptop ‘with... by artemonster on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @02:36PM (#27987759)
Right for privacy is not a right to obstruct justice.
Re:Court orders US Capitol rioter to unlock his laptop ‘with... by andrew_ on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @02:50PM (#27987974)
A distressing response. The 5th Amendment is pretty clear that the right to not self-incriminate paramount, and does not mention obstruction of justice in any clause. The issue seems to be subjective views on what self-incrimination is and that it's viewed as a grey area, and that makes me uneasy.
Re:Court orders US Capitol rioter to unlock his laptop ‘with... by LeifCarrotson on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @02:46PM (#27987920)
The fifth amendment reads:

> No person ... shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself

If you could compel someone to testify against themself, that would surely expedite justice. But we've decided that's not actually just.

Re:Court orders US Capitol rioter to unlock his laptop ‘with... by 8note on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @04:05PM (#27989045)
We're certainly compelled to have evidence collected from our stuff. You aren't compelled to say where to look, but you are compelled to let them look.

Unlock this computer vs tell me your password. The password could contain "I did the murder and I buried the body under the bus stop" which is clearly testimony, but unlocking and changing the password to something the government asks you to seems well within range

Re:Court orders US Capitol rioter to unlock his laptop ‘with... by jimbob45 on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @02:37PM (#27987782)
That’s some spicy doublespeak you’ve got there.
Re:Court orders US Capitol rioter to unlock his laptop ‘with... by artemonster on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @02:45PM (#27987911)
No, but really. For instance, in germany there are super strict policies regrding privacy on your workplace - i.e your employer cannot spy/monitor your activities under veil of security or productivity. That said, if you are a systematic slacker the employer may use some of that said spying to prove that you are slacker in exceptional (and well founded) cases and court will accept that evidence.

Seems like a working system for me. Employers still are not allowed to spy, slackers still can get punished, no apocalypse, no slippery slopes.

Re:Court orders US Capitol rioter to unlock his laptop ‘with... by andrew_ on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @02:51PM (#27987985)
We're not talking about Germany. The parent article is clearly speaking about a situation within the United States.