Re:Court orders US Capitol rioter to unlock his laptop ‘with...
by dragonwriter on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @03:19PM
(#27988423)
> What about an order to "place your right thumb on this little circle", where the "little circle" just so happens to be the phone they seized from you?
Right, it doesn't, for instance, reveal that as a combination of quirks of the sensor and how I trained it, it only unlocks with my left index finger at a slight angle and a particular rolling motion, and moreover, doesn't reveal that I know that to be the case.
Re:Court orders US Capitol rioter to unlock his laptop ‘with...
by function_seven on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @03:24PM
(#27988505)
Yup. If you're concerned about being compelled to place a finger on the sensor, it seems a good countermeasure would be to train it on your non-dominant hand's pinky. And set a low failure count before the device demands a password instead.
I agree that if the demand was, "place whatever finger will unlock this device—in the orientation required—in this little circle," then that would be compelled witnessing against oneself.
You're not revealing any knowledge about the specific action—they're directing you to do it.
For the face scenario, an order to look directly at the camera is similar. You're not testifying that this laptop is indeed yours, or that you have access. The laptop is going to respond to your stare however it was already configured to do so.