News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by iammisc on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @12:48PM (#27835159)
We used to call this going to church. When literally everyone of all political stripes attended the same churches, going to a church potluck was basically being paired randomly.

However large political factions have made church membership out to be undesirable.

We are reaping the rewards.

I realized yesterday reading about cornel west, that even though I disagree with his politics, I see from his Christianity we have the same concerns, and values. I can't honestly say that about other people

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by edmundsauto on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @12:55PM (#27835263)
This is a rosy view of religion, although I accept that is your experience and perspective, and thank you for sharing it.

To me, church attendance is about making the in/out group very clear. You may feel close to different political views based on your single church or flavor of Christianity, but that's still a pretty limited group.

I think church membership has become undesirable because 1) fewer people believe in the supernatural and 2) the stated positions of many major religions on issues of abortion and inclusion.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by nine_k on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:16PM (#27835550)
It's not about religion per se, but about a common religion which has rituals that make people meet each other more, piercing their bubble of like-mindedness (smaller than the religion).

It's like going to a supermarket makes you see people more varied than your family circle and your chosen TV show characters. (It does not nudge you to talk to these people, though.)

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by edmundsauto on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @04:17PM (#27837887)
I am not a religious person or church goer, but are the perspectives really that different? To me, it looks like a church is a self selected group of geographically proximate people who tend to look alike and dress alike. You don't usually see much ethnic diversity in a church photo.

It's more diverse than sitting at home, but I think exposure to a few TV shows has more diversity of thought, ethnicity, sexuality, etc., compared to going to church.

I'm not saying its bad for people to get together and talk. I see that church was an important mechanism for this in the past. However, I can't get past the negatives (supernatural belief, child abuse, kowtowing to authority, shame, ostracism) to believe it will continue to be a net positive.

What we need is more of what I think the Unitarians are after - non denominational community.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by ceilingcorner on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @04:29PM (#27838033)
The Catholic Church is probably the single most ethnically diverse organization on the face of the earth.

https://www.pewforum.org/2013/02/13/the-global-catholic-popu...

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by edmundsauto on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:27PM (#27838653)
Right, but the context here is in people attending their local church. Your point is like saying that America is so diverse - it is, but how much do the different ethnicities actually interact?
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by iammisc on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @06:00PM (#27838958)
Catholic churches are the most integrated denomination. And Catholics are the group most likely to intermarry between ethnicities. Speaking of my own family, my brother and I are both married to women of different ethnicities (and differing ethnicities at that).

Sources:

[1] https://www.jbhe.com/2018/07/americas-churches-are-becoming-...

[2] http://blogs.thearda.com/trend/featured/the-ties-that-may-no...

> The only exceptions were Catholics. Catholics were almost twice as likely to be in an intermarriage and Catholics who attended services more frequently were slightly more likely to be in an intermarriage, the researchers found.

It's more than just your local parish though. When I visited Hungary, it was amazing to go to a church where I didn't speak the language, but still be able to feel totally 'at home', because it was a church, and they were saying mass. Even though it was in Hungarian, I understood exactly what was going on. Then when I visited India, which couldn't be further from Hungary, I had the same experience.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by edmundsauto on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @06:27PM (#27839240)
The takeaway from those articles seems to be that even the most integrated churches are still trailing average neighborhood integration numbers (which are broadly considered problematic). There has been progress, but there is still a ways to go:

> Despite progress in church integration, congregations remain far more segregated than the society in general. Dr. Dougherty, an associate professor of sociology at Baylor University, states that “congregations are looking more like their neighborhoods racially and ethnically, but they still lag behind. The average congregation was eight times less diverse racially than its neighborhood in 1998 and four times less diverse in 2012.”

The context here is whether churches are a good way for people of diverse backgrounds to engage and interact. I contend that they have unnecessary elements that make them worse than a non-religious community event (supernatural beliefs, explicit conformity of dress and thought, protecting predators, etc.)

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by selimthegrim on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @07:49PM (#27839898)
I grew up in an Ahmedi congregation in suburban Cleveland. It was about 50% African-American and 50% post-60s Pakistani or Indian immigrants with the odd old-time immigrant family (mine) who intermarried or white converts. (My great grandfather famously had Elijah Muhammad to dinner on one of his visits to Cleveland.)

Later as I grew up I realized just how unusual that sort of integration was among any congregation, not just Christian or Islamic. When I read Vivek Bald’s book Bengali Harlem: The Lost Histories of South Asian America, I realized that actually this was the norm in the 20s-60s for South Asian immigrants of all backgrounds.

This has led to some befuddlement amongst others. A black City Councilperson in New Orleans egged a crowd on to call my cousin from Islamabad names based on his origin for trying to set up a tiny house village for homeless people in a residential neighborhood in Eastern New Orleans. I roared back at him that it pained me to see someone that looked like my grandmother beating up on my cousin, mentioned that my congregation met in a formerly AME church and kept the pews for years and shame on him for assuming we are all carpetbaggers. He turned to me and said “You are presumed to be what you look like.” I’ve never been happier to see someone lose an election.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by iammisc on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @07:52PM (#27839917)
Yeah I grew up in a Catholic church that was probably 30% vietnamese, 30% hispanic, and 40% white / everyone else. I guess my views are heavily influenced by that.
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by travismark on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @07:42PM (#27839846)
in the southwest US there is plenty of interaction between Hispanics and non-Hispanics in Catholic churches
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by munificent on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:53PM (#27838893)
> To me, it looks like a church is a self selected group of geographically proximate people who tend to look alike and dress alike. You don't usually see much ethnic diversity in a church photo.

I agree any given local church in the US is unlikely to have a ton of ethnic diversity. And, for obvious reasons, it will have almost no religious diversity.

They do tend to have a decent amount of professional and socioeconomic diversity, though, which is also valuable.

[dead]
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by airstrike on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:05PM (#27838424)
I keep mentioning this video because it's just so good, but Roger Scruton argued that the world has turned selfish and with it we've lost beauty, which in turns means life has lost its meaning. It's a powerful, profound view and one that I can't shake off my head ever since watching it.

> Our language, our music and our manners are increasingly raucous, self-centered, and offensive, as though beauty and good taste have no real place in our lives. > One word is written large on all these ugly things, and that word is “me.” > My profits, my desires, my pleasures. > And art has nothing to say in response to this except, “Yeah, go for it!” > I think we are losing beauty and with it there is the danger that we will lose the meaning of life.

https://vimeo.com/128428182

https://orthosphere.wordpress.com/2017/09/16/roger-scruton-w...

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by watwut on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:20PM (#27838584)
The church I went in as kid was pretty tight socially and people in it were wery like minded. And by all I heard or read about, it is pretty much standard.
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by iammisc on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @02:06PM (#27836209)
> To me, church attendance is about making the in/out group very clear. You may feel close to different political views based on your single church or flavor of Christianity, but that's still a pretty limited group.

It's not really though. I mean, being Catholic (and honestly, I know so little about Protestantism that I don't really feel qualified to speak to it), there are a lot of politics in the church.

In 'the Big Sort', the author Bill Bishop talks about how Americans are dividing themselves up by geography, religion (or lack thereof), jobs, education, etc. It's like we're splitting in to two different worlds.

I've noticed it at church too. Frankly, the left-leaning Catholics have all left. We chock it up to things like abortion and sexual ethics but I don't buy it. Many right-leaning Catholics have severe disagreements with church preaching, especially on the topics of aid to foreigners, the responsibility of society with regards to health care, views on death penalty's usefulness, etc. The only difference to me, is that conservatives tend to value authority and order more, and thus remain catholic even when the church preaches things they don't like.

> 2) the stated positions of many major religions on issues of abortion and inclusion.

I guess, but man you should see my conservative friends after the priest gives a homily on immigration. If they left the church because of this, I'd accuse them of idolatry -- placing their views on immigration as more important than God. I accuse my leftist friends who leave because of abortion of the same. Independent of the religious and spiritual aspects, it seems to me to be abandoning your community, that has supported you for many years, simply because of one issue we disagree on. That's like leaving your wife because you can't agree on which style of house to buy -- at some point you need to compromise.

It's weird because my left-leaning friend's parents are often still Catholic and have the same view as my family does on remaining part of the church even if what they preach is hard. Whereas my younger friends all left.

The sad thing though is that I feel there is a lot of missed out opportunities for shared understanding. Despite classifying these parents as 'left-leaning' and myself being more 'right-leaning', I'd consider these people to be intelligent, thoughtful, and friends. Whereas with my own generation, if you label yourself a leftist, all of a sudden right-wingers are supposed to hate you, and vice versa. It just seems dehumanizing.

I'd rather chat about politics in a friendly manner with a shared set of concerns over a doughnut on Sunday morning, than in an angry social media screed. But it seems like my generation prefers the latter. And frankly, from my perspective, it feels like my left-leaning friends simply left while we stayed behind to talk.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by bittercynic on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @02:47PM (#27836804)
For the people who left the church because they found some of the teachings abhorrent, I would assume they were rejecting the church's authority, not rejecting God. From their perspective it may be the church who split with God, and they are trying to stay on the path by getting away from the church.

This is coming from an areligious atheist, so I must acknowledge my lack of experience with this even though I've read about it and given it some thought.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by iammisc on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @02:53PM (#27836868)
> For the people who left the church because they found some of the teachings abhorrent, I would assume they were rejecting the church's authority, not rejecting God.

If every conservative that rejected the church's authority decided to stay at home from church, the church would be empty.

I get you don't like the church... like I really understand this viewpoint. But why reject the church goers? The pope, the bishops, the priests, sure I can see not liking them. But if you show up and talk to the church members, the ones who you grew up with, etc, what exactly is wrong with that?

Man I can't tell you how annoyed we've been with our priest, our bishops, and yes the pope. I've gone through periods of extreme doubt. I still show up for the community. Always have, and likely always will. Just stick around.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by abeyer on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @03:40PM (#27837473)
> I still show up for the community. Always have, and likely always will. Just stick around.

Why would I choose to do this somewhere that the leadership rejects me and tells me I will burn in hell? I know that many individuals within the church may not agree, but plenty will, and culture is set from the top. It's not like there aren't more social/community options than I could possibly find the time to participate in that _don't_ have religious ties.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by hluska on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:23PM (#27838622)
Sorry to have to say this but anyone who tells you you’re going to hell isn’t a Christian. I left the church over similar feelings so I identify. But for the record and the benefit of anyone else who might need to hear this, you’re not going to hell.

The biblical Jesus (he’s the Christ in Christian) hung out with sailors, prostitutes and a tax collector. The fact that xtians tell people they’re going to hell in that person’s name is a disgrace. It’s not the biblical antichrist but it’s sure anti everything Jesus said and did.

If anyone reads these words and feels pain, feel free to reach out. You’re incredibly loved, at least by me and I’ll have your back no matter what.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by useragent86 on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @10:31PM (#27840849)
> Sorry to have to say this but anyone who tells you you’re going to hell isn’t a Christian. I left the church over similar feelings so I identify. But for the record and the benefit of anyone else who might need to hear this, you’re not going to hell.

What did Christ say about sin and repentance?

Matthew 11:20-24: Then He began to denounce the cities in which most of His miracles were done, because they did not repent. “Woe to you, Chorazin! Woe to you, Bethsaida! For if the miracles had occurred in Tyre and Sidon which occurred in you, they would have repented long ago in sackcloth and ashes. Nevertheless I say to you, it will be more tolerable for Tyre and Sidon in the day of judgment than for you. And you, Capernaum, will not be exalted to heaven, will you? You will descend to Hades; for if the miracles had occurred in Sodom which occurred in you, it would have remained to this day. Nevertheless I say to you that it will be more tolerable for the land of Sodom in the day of judgment, than for you.”

> The biblical Jesus (he’s the Christ in Christian) hung out with sailors, prostitutes and a tax collector. The fact that xtians tell people they’re going to hell in that person’s name is a disgrace. It’s not the biblical antichrist but it’s sure anti everything Jesus said and did.

What did Christ say about about his role in judgement?

John 12:47-49: If anyone hears My sayings and does not keep them, I do not judge him; for I did not come to judge the world, but to save the world. He who rejects Me and does not receive My sayings, has one who judges him; the word I spoke is what will judge him at the last day. For I did not speak on My own initiative, but the Father Himself who sent Me has given Me a commandment as to what to say and what to speak.

> If anyone reads these words and feels pain, feel free to reach out. You’re incredibly loved, at least by me and I’ll have your back no matter what.

What did Paul say about pain?

2 Corinthians 7:10: For the sorrow that is according to the will of God produces a repentance without regret, leading to salvation, but the sorrow of the world produces death.

Make sure the gospel you're preaching is of the Word and not of man. Many churches misrepresent the truth, but many others aren't willing to speak it.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by echlebek on Thursday July 15, 2021 @02:26PM (#27848226)
I realize you're probably a true believer, but for a lot of people there is no truth. The bible is written by people, translated by people, and interpreted by people. I don't believe in your religion or any other, but even assuming it's true, the fidelity of the text is poor at best.
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by useragent86 on Friday July 16, 2021 @03:10AM (#27853726)
These are distinct issues:

> for a lot of people there is no truth

> I don't believe in your religion or any other

> The bible is written by people, translated by people, and interpreted by people...the fidelity of the text is poor at best.

Briefly:

> for a lot of people there is no truth

A lot of people don't think clearly and have been misled. Do you and I exist in some form? Are we having a conversation? There: two truths. Dismissing truth as unknowable is a kind of, shall we say, cognitive off-ramp one may use when uninterested in working harder to find it. It's also a rhetorical trick used by some to shut down conversations they don't want others to have.

> I don't believe in your religion or any other

Framing philosophy as a matter of religion is a common way to dismiss a line of inquiry before it begins. It's also a rhetorical trick, a form of tribalism, a way to "other" those whom one disagrees with.

The modern distinction between religious and irreligious matters is ultimately a contrivance. The question of the nature of reality knows no such distinction.

What matters is not what label we apply to a philosophy; what matters is whether it is true. In this sense, everyone has a religion, whether or not they label it so. In modern terms, one may call it a worldview.

> The bible is written by people, translated by people, and interpreted by people...the fidelity of the text is poor at best.

That is your subjective evaluation: "poor at best." How do you know this? What research have you done into the texts available? Have you studied the original languages and ancient texts? How do these texts compare with other ancient documents, ones whose authenticity is not commonly questioned in the field? Is it legitimate to boil down an entire field of research, practiced over thousands of years, to three dismissive words?

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by throwawayboise on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @06:52PM (#27839470)
No man can tell anyone how God will judge him. You seek forgiveness of sin through Christ and try to live accordingly. If your church is telling you you will go to hell (or guaranteeing you will not) you should find another church. That's not the same as condemning sin and trying to guide people away from it though.
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by useragent86 on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @10:21PM (#27840809)
What did Christ say about eternal judgement?

John 12:47-49: "If anyone hears My sayings and does not keep them, I do not judge him; for I did not come to judge the world, but to save the world. He who rejects Me and does not receive My sayings, has one who judges him; the word I spoke is what will judge him at the last day. For I did not speak on My own initiative, but the Father Himself who sent Me has given Me a commandment as to what to say and what to speak."

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by iammisc on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @03:49PM (#27837572)
> Why would I choose to do this somewhere that the leadership rejects me and tells me I will burn in hell?

Because of the people in the church? Because of the fact that 'the leadership' is just the guy preaching, whereas the actual community is run by everyday people (well in my experience it is).

> It's not like there aren't more social/community options than I could possibly find the time to participate in that _don't_ have religious ties.

Well that's exactly it. People say there are myriad options and then don't participate, because they don't have time. Whereas in a church, you have to go. It's an obligation. Which makes it easier for people of all backgrounds to show up.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by abeyer on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @04:41PM (#27838152)
You seem to be simultaneously arguing that it's ok to ignore the religious trappings and just treat the church as a social club, but also that the church is better than just any social club because of the religious trappings.
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by iammisc on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:32PM (#27838710)
You've summed up my position pretty well.

If you're not religiously inclined, then you can treat the church as a social club and ignore the religious trappings. It would behoove you to keep your atheism to yourself though, because the church is better than just any social club because of the religious nature. While some number of public doubters can be tolerated without negatively impacting the group, if it gets to be too large a number then the main benefit of community and fellowship would go away.

I am making a position without reference to the truth value of the religious claims because I'm not going to get into a debate on HN over whether Christanity / theism is right or wrong. I personally think that even if you are a committed atheist, church probably is a good idea anyway. If you're a western committed atheist, some denomination of Christianity is probably best

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by themacguffinman on Thursday July 15, 2021 @01:44AM (#27841788)
In my experience, good & satisfying relationships are rooted in trust, loyalty, and respect. I don't really see how hiding your atheism in a community exclusively for believers is anything but a massive betrayal of trust. And how is this worth spending 2 - 3 hours, likely a majority of church time, in a sermon or religious discussion you are utterly unengaged in?

Either you build a friendship on lies, or you spend most of your bonding time unengaged.

I think it's certainly possible to build a substantial relationship with a religious person when you aren't religious yourself, but I'd imagine that in such a scenario, each of you would at least respect each other enough to be honest about your core beliefs.

I can appreciate that if you still believe in their god, there's still a lot of faith and "religious trappings" you can earnestly share. For atheists and the nonreligious, IMHO this seems like terrible advice.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by iammisc on Thursday July 15, 2021 @02:02AM (#27841846)
I believe if you're honest with yourself and follow the secular lines of reasoning you will arrive at deism pretty easily

I think atheists are just people who refuse to accept the natural conclusions.

So I don't see any need to hide your atheism really. We're all prone to folly, pride and irrationality and inconclusive thinking.

Honestly, if an atheist came to my Church and was open about it, that's fine with me. I confess doubt all the time too... It's not like I'm perfect. If the number of times my atheist friends have sincerely prayed before a big exam are any indication, I'd think most atheists have periods of extreme fervor.

But, when I've been more of an atheist, I've still found amazing value in religion, so I guess I'm probably just weird.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by bittercynic on Thursday July 15, 2021 @11:13AM (#27845692)
As I've grown up and become secure in my atheism, I realized that I have not come to my beliefs through any kind of logic or based on evidence. It's just what I believe - or don't, and the beliefs we have on matters we can't directly observe are formed in ways I don't fully understand. I cannot account for my atheism, and I don't think I have to. Similarly, I don't think you can account for your belief in God, but you also don't have to. It's a BELIEF, not a theorem to prove.

It's not like I go around thinking "there is no God", it's just not part of how I find meaning and make sense of the world.

This is not a moment of folly, just like your belief in God is not a moment of folly. It's just part of how I, and you, make sense of this confusing situation of coming into being on Earth for a little while, knowing that we won't be here for very long.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by gilbetron on Thursday July 15, 2021 @09:14AM (#27844269)
Deism requires rejecting all rationality - it's literally the point of almost all religions. Secular lines of reasoning results in science and all of the progress that has come with it. Being honest with ourselves leads to an understanding that there is no evidence of any sort of a deity - it is when we are fearful that we reach out into the void looking for someone to help us.
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by iammisc on Thursday July 15, 2021 @04:59PM (#27850066)
> Secular lines of reasoning results in science and all of the progress that has come with it

Unless you have some unknown faith by which 'progress' is good, I fail to see how you can come to that conclusion. Especially when various secular lines of reasonings reject 'progress' as a useful metric, or even a desirable thing at all.

> it is when we are fearful that we reach out into the void looking for someone to help us.

That is not true. A benevolent God is a requirement of Christianity being true. It is not a requirement of deism, which is simply the belief that there is a divine. You're conflating two things. IMO, that there is a divine is incredibly obvious. Christianity requires more of a stretch.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by gilbetron on Friday July 16, 2021 @09:19AM (#27855925)
> IMO, that there is a divine is incredibly obvious.

There is absolutely no evidence of such a thing, in fact, all major religions require that lack of evidence, it's a fundamental feature of them.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by bittercynic on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @04:09PM (#27837808)
I don't think you have to reject the churchgoers to reject the church. Some of the people I feel closest to are devoutly religious. When we eat together I pray with them as a matter of respecting their tradition and participating in the culture, and it is an enjoyable thing to do.

The church has gone out of its way to be unwelcoming to many people, and I just don't want to be part of it. I've been to one church service where the preacher spent a large fraction of the sermon vitriolically condemning atheists. I'm not going to argue with him, but I'm also not going back for more.

I'm not trying to mess up anyone else's tradition, but if churches are shrinking and losing power I don't think that is necessarily a bad thing.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by hluska on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:04PM (#27838421)
I'm an ex-Catholic and am likely one of the left leaning people you're talking about. I left the church because frankly, the actions of the church and its policies are so far from Jesus' teachings that I could no longer reconcile a belief in Christ with mother church.

> We chock it up to things like abortion and sexual ethics but I don't buy it.

Homophobia != sexual ethics.

After my goodbye confession with a good priest I'm still friends with, I never thought I'd have to say these words again. But here we go. Outright homophobia is not about sexual ethics, it's about hatred and closed mindedness. Can you point out a section a single section in the gospels that indicates that this is okay? Can you point out a single statement that Jesus made that implies there is anything wrong with being gay?? I can't, yet mother church won't cut the homophobia.

Or take the church's silly little pro life movement. Do you notice that it's directed against women? Pro lifers never take out billboards that say 'Men, don't have sex with women when they're drunk. That is called rape.' But they sure like to harass scared, pregnant women and/or people who have had abortions with their shitty propaganda. Can you show me one thing in the gospels that suggest that is okay??

You can't because it's not. None of this is okay. Jesus would not have approved of much of anything. Crap, you don't even have to read too far into Matthew to realize that Jesus would not have been accepting of any of this.

Catholics are supposed to worship a dude who stopped a woman from being stoned with the words 'let he without sin cast the first stone.' And here we are, stoning the gay, stoning the activists and stoning reproductive rights without so much as a thought about it. Has the church sinned?? Hundreds of thousands of abused children point to the fact that yeah, the church has sinned.

Who is the Catholic church to cast stones, particularly when the dude we're supposed to follow was really against casting stones? And why should I stick around something so actively disrespectful? Frankly, I'd rather find a community of people who think love is the solution rather than find a community who preaches love unless you fall into one of about 15,000 boxes.....

Edit - Here's another example that really gets my goat. My own archdiocese excommunicated a woman who was ordained as a priest. I know her, in fact, my Mom used to work with her. I even went out on a couple of dates with one of her daughters and she is an absolutely wonderful person. But mother church excommunicated her because she was ordained as a priest? Why can't she be part of the community that she helped build? She worked within Catholic churches for decades, hence her work with my Mom. She was removed from the community and the priest in her own parish read the most disgusting letter about her. Do you know why???

Her calling is not legitimate. Only a man's calling can be legitimate.

Let's assume that God in God's wisdom subscribes to the Harvard Business Review. If God had an organization with a really serious sexual abuse crisis and if God read the HBR, God might decide it makes sense to bring some women into leadership positions. But oh no, the Catholics know God. They had a direct line to God when they were abusing all those kids or ethnically cleansing Canada of its indigenous population.

I'm sorry but I can't even write this shit with a straight face. How is a woman's calling totally irrelevant to a point of excommunication when men can fuck children and just get moved to a new parish (for the 17th time)?

Serious question.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by iammisc on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:48PM (#27838850)
I appreciate your candor. You seem to have pretty set views, but I think they're caricatures. In particular, while pro-life work that is most visible is someone praying at a planned parenthood (and of course, the ones that harass are typically not even Catholic, since it's not just catholics in this 'movement'), the bulk of pro-life work is exceptionally boring things like collecting bottles, diapers, baby clothes, putting together mum and baby classes, etc. No one talks about this because it's not polarizing. Or take the issue of 'homophobia'. No doubt many Catholics will say insensitive things, but almost anything about the potential of homosexual acts being wrong is today conflated with homophobia. And you ask for Christ's statement on sexual orientation, but they are abundant in the gospels. You seem familiar with them, so let's start:

Matthew 19:5: "For this reason a man will leave his father and mother and be united to his wife, and the two will become one flesh?".

As you yourself said, Christ was certainly not afraid of breaking social norms of his day. Heterosexuality was a major norm at the time. Don't you think Christ would have said 'For this reason a man will leave his father and mother and be united to his wife, and the two will become one flesh? Oh yeah, and sometimes a man will leave his father and dad and be united to his husband, because that's the same thing'. The lack of teaching on that speaks volumes, as does Christ's strictifying of existing Jewish sexual ethics, rather than loosening (in his ban on divorce).

The second thing that I see is a lack of understanding of repentance. Christ preventing the prostitute's punishment was because she had repented of her sin, not because sin is irrelevant. The same is true of the female priest. Should she repent, I'm sure she'd be welcomed back (otherwise your Gospel passage would be quite relevant). The priests who corrupted children... well this is a very long story and I know of no lay Catholics who really support the church's handling on this. But the existence of sinners doesn't take away from the utility of church. However I'll point out that the reason that happened was that the church bought too much into the mercy rhetoric that you seem to want it to buy into further. A lot of justification for moving priests was based on the assumption that (1) they had repented, (2) the church should be merciful, and (3) based on psychological understandings of sex in the 60s and 70s which were more radical than today, pedophilia was a condition that could be cured.

Anyway, I'm guessing this will fall on deaf ears and that there is an impenetrable barrier that will keep either of us from convincing the other. So to end, I'll just wish you the best. I mean that. Thanks for the response.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by edmundsauto on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @07:14PM (#27839644)
> Heterosexuality was a major norm at the time.

Inaccurate - the Greeks, for example, had institutionalized pederasty disguised as building bonds between generations. The Romans had... problematic beliefs about heterosexual sex as well.

> The lack of teaching on that speaks volumes

It speaks volumes about how incomplete the historical record is, but very little else. Did the person who wrote this passage ever even meet Christ? I'm under the impression that Chris-as-singular-historical-figure is accepted based on lighter evidence than we require for other historical figures. And that the Bible was mostly written hundreds of years after Jesus supposedly existed. That's not much of a basis for strict interpretation based on what isn't present, nearly 2000 years later.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by alentist on Thursday July 15, 2021 @02:03AM (#27841849)
> I'm under the impression that Chris-as-singular-historical-figure is accepted based on lighter evidence than we require for other historical figures.

You're under a false impression, and are spreading a myth [0][1]. In fact, your claim is exactly backwards: Certain laypeople (you seem to be among them) demand more evidence for the historicity of Jesus than for other famous people of antiquity.

> And that the Bible was mostly written hundreds of years after Jesus supposedly existed.

First, this is complete nonsense, given that ~77% of the Bible is the Old Testament, whose books have been dated to centuries BCE [1].

Second, if we charitably reinterpret your comment as referring to the New Testament, it is also false. The Book of Revelation is generally accepted by traditional scholarship to have been written during the reign of Domitian (81–96 CE) [1]. A handful (3-4) of other books are dated to 110 CE at most.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christ_myth_theory

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Historicity_of_Jesus

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dating_the_Bible

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by edmundsauto on Thursday July 15, 2021 @04:38PM (#27849830)
My understanding is based on the wikipedia article called "Historical Jesus", which confusingly is different than the "Historicity of Jesus". Also, a book I read a long time ago, called "Who Wrote the Bible".

I'm not purporting to be a biblical scholar, but it's clear to me that the evidence for Jesus is not as strong as, say, the evidence for Julius Caesar.

The fact that there is no direct evidence points to at least some haziness about the character. The same could be said for a number of other historical figures. It's pretty clear there are limitations to the evidence, from Wikipedia:

"The historical Jesus scholarship is bound by the following limitations:

- There is no physical or archaeological evidence for Jesus; all existing sources are documentary.

- The sources for the historical Jesus are mainly Christian writings, such as the gospels and the purported letters of the apostles.

- All extant sources that mention Jesus were written after his death.

- The New Testament represents sources that have become canonical for Christianity, and there are many apocryphal texts that are examples of the wide variety of writings in the first centuries AD that are related to Jesus.[33] The authenticity and reliability of these sources have been questioned by many scholars, and few events mentioned in the gospels are universally accepted.[34]"

So it seems that no writings about him survive from his life, by or about him. There is no physical evidence of his existence. Most of the evidence was written by early Christians, and few of the events they write about are universally accepted. And given the propensity of religious followers to exaggerate, I don't personally put a lot of stock in much of the motivated reasoning exhibited.

His is a resume with some holes in it. Smarter and better informed people disagree with me, but I'm just processing the evidence as I see it.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by alentist on Friday July 16, 2021 @03:11PM (#27860048)
What do you mean by "physical evidence"? As Bart D. Ehrman (a non-Christian New Testament scholar) explains:

The reality is that we don’t have archaeological records for virtually anyone who lived in Jesus’s time and place.

Who was the most important Jewish figure in Palestine for the entire first century (who wasn’t, say, the actual king)? There’s no doubt. Flavius Josephus. Highly placed aristocrat, military leader, political figure, eventually made a court historian by the Roman emperor himself, and our principal source of information for the Jewish people and history at the time. And how much archaeological evidence do we have of his existence? None.

So too, who is (by far) the best known Jewish cultural figure outside of Palestine in the first century? Again, not much competition: Philo of Alexandria, brilliant philosopher, massively prolific author, political activist, known even at the highest levels of government in Rome itself. How much archaeological evidence do we have of his existence? Again, none. The lack of evidence does not mean a person at the time didn’t exist. It means that she or he, like 99.99% of the rest of the world at the time, made no impact on the archaeological record.

The most detailed record of the life and death of Jesus comes from the four Gospels and other New Testament writings. "These are all Christian and are obviously and understandably biased in what they report, and have to be evaluated very critically indeed to establish any historically reliable information," Ehrman says. "But their central claims about Jesus as a historical figure—a Jew, with followers, executed on orders of the Roman governor of Judea, Pontius Pilate, during the reign of the Emperor Tiberius—are borne out by later sources with a completely different set of biases."

Within a few decades of his lifetime, Jesus was mentioned by Jewish and Roman historians in passages that corroborate portions of the New Testament that describe the life and death of Jesus.

Regarding the apocryphal texts, they're called apocryphal for a reason, and do not form part of the Biblical canon.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by hluska on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @08:56PM (#27840336)
Dude, you started this out by calling my views caricatures and end it with wishing me the best?? The cognitive dissonance is very very strong in you.

I’m not going to reply to anything this disrespectful. Fake people aren’t worth my time.

Edit - A great Jesuit priest and mentor once said to be very careful with people who start with an insult, move on to a bible quote and end with good wishes. I understand his position. Frankly, it’s a shame you couldn’t be more respectful - we could have learned from each other’s theology.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by iammisc on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @09:51PM (#27840669)
Just because I disagree with someone doesn't mean I wish him ill. Calling his view caricatures says nothing of his character.
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by alentist on Thursday July 15, 2021 @02:31AM (#27841966)
Your comment was indeed full of caricatures:

> Or take the church's silly little pro life movement. Do you notice that it's directed against women? Pro lifers never take out billboards that say 'Men, don't have sex with women when they're drunk. That is called rape.'

> And here we are, stoning the gay, stoning the activists and stoning reproductive rights without so much as a thought about it.

> Only a man's calling can be legitimate.

> If God had an organization with a really serious sexual abuse crisis and if God read the HBR, God might decide it makes sense to bring some women into leadership positions.

> They had a direct line to God when they were abusing all those kids or ethnically cleansing Canada of its indigenous population.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by nicoburns on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @04:47PM (#27838218)
It's religion not politics that makes church-attendance undesirable for most non-church-goers. Having said that, I agree that we are missing something that modern secular society is missing something that used to take place in churches.

I'm not so convinced as you that the religious aspect is required to make it work. Shared purpose maybe, but there are lots of ways of creating that. In another comment you mentioned "might as well be a community centre", which I think is interesting because community centres are one of the other places I've this sense of well... community.

One thing that churches have other than religion which I think often gets overlooked is money (in particular they generally own the building they use). I've seen more than one excellent community centre closed down because they ran out of funding and couldn't afford to keep paying the rent. I would love to see a concerted effort at government funded secular churches designed to serve a parish-sized community.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by iammisc on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:53PM (#27838884)
I doubt I'd participate in a secular community center, so I'd be interested in seeing this as an outside observer. But honestly, I doubt it'd work. Without any common values, it'll be hard to get a diverse set of people.

In my experience, when secular people start this, it ends up being a club for other secular people 'like them'. In America the starkest examples of this are when these community clubs founded by whites end up being essentially white only, or black-only if founded by a black. Not due to any racism on part of the founder but simply that, without an explicit shared value system, no one quite knows what to believe except those 'already in the know'.

I notice this with my own in-laws, who are white WASPy types. I am a Catholic obviously, and not white. Sometimes, they'll talk in ways that make me feel out of place and that I can't relate to. On the other hand, when white Catholics talk about Catholicism, I feel we're on the same wave length.

> I would love to see a concerted effort at government funded secular churches designed to serve a parish-sized community.

I think it's sad we have to replace grassroots decentralized community efforts with centralized government funded ones in this day and age. It's like we've regressed.

That's my observation. I'd be interested in seeing this thing come around, and i'll continue to watch from the sidelines with interest. Maybe I'll even show up after church.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by majormajor on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @06:47PM (#27839433)
You have gone to very different churches than I grew up in. The secular groups I was in at public school, college, and then as an adult were all MUCH more accepting and diverse than the churches I was in as a kid, and the private school I went to for the first 9 years of my education.

"If you stay Catholic you're going to hell" was a memorable thing one of my teachers told one of my classmates...

They really didn't like me much when I started asking questions they didn't have answers for other than "you just have to have faith," either.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by iammisc on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @07:15PM (#27839648)
No doubt. If it were not for one teacher who was clearly trained in Catholic apologetics in middle school, I don't think i would have remained Catholic. The church does a terrible job of catechesis, which is a shame, since it's spent a lot of time thinking about it.
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by munificent on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @06:29PM (#27839256)
> Without any common values, it'll be hard to get a diverse set of people.

The fundamental premise of the United States is that a body of people can have shared values without shared religion.

A supernatural deity is not required to believe that all people are created equal and deserve the right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by throwawayboise on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @06:45PM (#27839414)
The fundamental premise was not an absence of religion. Most of the founders and certainly all of the original colonists were religious. The premise was no state-endorsed or mandated religion.
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by iammisc on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @06:34PM (#27839311)
There's a big difference between living in the same country as people I don't share deep values with and actively seeking out their company.

I sincerely doubt most hn readers are seeking active companionship with someone from rural Alabama.

Of course I have shared values with almost every american. That small set of values is just not enough for deep friendship even if it's enough for civic patriotism.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:33PM (#27835741)
> When literally everyone of all political stripes attended the same churches

The mere act of belonging to any given religion pre-selected certain ideas about how the world works and should work. Hardly "all political stripes".

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by iammisc on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @02:08PM (#27836248)
Okay but if everyone attended church, as it used to be in this country, then by definition, essentially all political stripes of any import would be represented in them, and people would have to confront people who disagree with them physically.
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @03:22PM (#27837234)
It sounds a lot like what you're saying is "only christians matter", or worse "everyone should either be christian or pretend to be", because I can't see that working any other way. If jews go to temple and christians go to church, and muslims go to mosques, then they don't have to be exposed to each other's opinions. If jews and muslims pretend to be christian and go to church then they can't expose any opinions that go against christian worldview.
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by iammisc on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @03:30PM (#27837340)
I think this is a valid criticism, but seeing as that we've replaced church with ... nothing, I still find it difficult to imagine that my vision of society would be worse than the one we're living in.

The truth is that despite decades of trying, the secular regular get-together groups for people without any unifying interests or socioeconomic status have utterly failed.

For most people, church is the only place they're going to be exposed to others that may share absolutely no interests with them and be of widely different socioeconomic status and yet still be acquaintances.

Our neighborhoods are segregated by socioeconomic class and increasingly, by profession. Our 'clubs' are non-existent, and where they do exist, cater to special interests and hobbies.

We need something that works, not something that is perfect. I still maintain that church, temple, mosque, etc is the best thing.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @03:47PM (#27837563)
Church attendance isn't about "unifying interest" or socioeconomic status? The unified interest is obvious: salvation through christ, and churches tend to serve a relatively small community which is likely to be of very similar socioeconomic status. That's not even to mention the abject racism that led to black christians having to set up their own churches (which white people often subsequently burnt down).

The olden days where "everybody" went to church every week still had tons of social problems.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by iammisc on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @03:52PM (#27837611)
Salvation through christ is -- from a secular perspective -- such a nebulous interest, it might as well be a community club.
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by mcavoybn on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:30PM (#27838692)
>the secular regular get-together groups for people without any unifying interests or socioeconomic status

Unfortunately, I don't think what you are describing ever existed. Every "get-together-group" I can think of has some kind of common interest, even if its something as simple as drinking coffee or reading books. I think your attachment to the church has a lot more to do with your emotions than thinking rationally. The way I see it, the cat is out of the bag with regards to organized religion. It is well known that there have been many corrupt religious organizations and heinous acts committed in the name of religion. To make the argument "The economy was shut down last year and there is a massive issue in our society with depression and loneliness as a result, but it's what those liberals deserve for leaving the church!" is asinine.

>Church is the only place they're going to be exposed to others that may share absolutely no interests with them

Are the bible, history of the church, the nature of reality, and developing a community not shared interests? Also, was the point of the article to only talk to people without shared interests? Isn't one of the first things you do when you get to know someone is try to find a common interest?

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by iammisc on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @06:03PM (#27838991)
> Io make the argument "The economy was shut down last year and there is a massive issue in our society with depression and loneliness as a result, but it's what those liberals deserve for leaving the church!" is asinine.

What? I never made that argument. You're putting words in my mouth and calling me asinine. Please actually respond to what I wrote.

> Are the bible, history of the church, the nature of reality, and developing a community not shared interests?

Nature of reality is more than an interest in my view. If you can't agree on reality, then no amount of shared interests can cover that gap.

As for the bible, history of the church, and community development... I guess those could be shared interests. But if you've ever met many Catholics, few are interested in the bible, even fewer in church history. We do like drinking and eating together though, so we got that! But other than super uppity social clubs, I've never really seen a dinner group achieve the success of the church, so i'm forced to conclude the religious aspect has something to do with it.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by mcavoybn on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @07:41PM (#27839831)
>We do like drinking and eating together though, so we got that!

Regardless of the details of your argument, or whether my paraphrase of your original comment was accurate, it is an infeasible solution to suggest that everyone needs to go to church in order to address the loneliness, social anxiety, and tribalism. Your comments all have a condescending, passive aggressive tone and you are trying all kinds of dirty tactics to manipulate the debate to your favor. I doubt you have any real interest in more people going to church. Based on your comments, your goal is to argue and put blame on others. I'm not sure if anyone in this thread has really learned from this discussion (flamewar) and I regret engaging in it.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by alentist on Thursday July 15, 2021 @01:36AM (#27841732)
This is a more apt description of your own comments, not least because you misattributed a completely fictitious "argument" to the GP. Perhaps your anger is clouding your ability to understand the GP's comments, which have been very respectful.
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by shkkmo on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:20PM (#27838582)
You realize that political battles between catholics, protestants, puritans, etc have historically been far more partisan and violent than what we see happening today. Church attendance is absolutely not a panacea for social cohesion with a country.
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by evilduck on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @06:23PM (#27839204)
The United States was basically created because of religious splits in Europe and an unwillingness to agree. Constitutional freedom of religion, something baked into the founding tenants of the country, exists solely because religious people clearly can't get along.

To see a Catholic espouse church and faith as a social solution in the US is some next level irony.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by socialist_coder on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:48PM (#27838848)
Totally. As a devout Anti-theist I really wish I could join some kind of secular group that was identical to a church but without the religion. Go every Sunday with my family, socialize with the folks, have potlucks and events, help people out when they need it, etc. We need to bring back this sense of community.
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by machinehermiter on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @07:13PM (#27839641)
Isn't the problem though that this doesn't work without a fiction that we all believe to be non-fiction?

You need to create a fiction that is believed in more than any individual differences but it doesn't work if we know it is fiction. The group will not be able to put aside differences for very long without it.

There is very clever aspect to what the church has done that is very hard to replicate.

I really think team sports are the closest you can get. This guy putting the ball over the goal line is the most important thing in the world and you can gel 90,000 drunk people to watch it without it becoming complete chaos. It is the same process at work.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by alentist on Thursday July 15, 2021 @01:33AM (#27841711)
Why "fiction"?
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by munificent on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:51PM (#27838875)
You could take a look at Unitarian Universalism or fraternal organizations.
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by jdavis703 on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @07:26PM (#27839715)
> However large political factions have made church membership out to be undesirable.

I personally stopped going to church because of the politics coming from the pulpit. The last sermon I heard was the preacher saying Barack Obama was “demonic” because his weak foreign policy made it harder to spread Christianity throughout the world, therefore forestalling the end times. Of course it wasn’t just that one sermon: the homophobia, the sexism, the anti-science attitudes had all been bothering me for years before I finally quit.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by princeb on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @08:54PM (#27840329)
> When literally everyone of all political stripes attended the same churches

"It is appalling that the most segregated hour of Christian America is eleven o’clock on Sunday morning" -MLK

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by munificent on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @02:34PM (#27836636)
I think church is great for mixing up people who differ professionally and socioeconomically. But at least in the US it has also very much deepened the racial and (obviously) religious lines between people.
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by iammisc on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @03:07PM (#27837062)
> But at least in the US it has also very much deepened the racial and (obviously) religious lines between people.

Not clear at all. Catholics for example are the most likely group to marry interracially.

Religiously, I don't see the christian sects as very divided, despite their many differences. There seems to be a large set of common ground.

Even amongst religions, there is a lot of good will. I can't think of any widespread religious riot in the US (I could totally be wrong though).

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by munificent on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @06:11PM (#27839083)
> Not clear at all. Catholics for example are the most likely group to marry interracially.

Catholicism is an outlier here:

About half of people who attend church once a year or never said they had dated interracially; just 27 percent of respondents who attend weekly or more reported dating a person of another race, according to a study using data from the 2007 Baylor Religion Survey.

http://blogs.thearda.com/trend/featured/the-ties-that-may-no...

> Religiously, I don't see the christian sects as very divided, despite their many differences.

It matters less how you personally see this than it does how church-goers in aggregate feel and behave. Certainly, growing up in the South, it was abundantly clear that there were black churches and white churches and that the two very rarely mixed.

The KKK is an explicitly anti-Black, anti-Catholic, anti-Jew, pro-Protestant Christianity organization. Its self-stated reason for existence is to push down members of other religions and races. You can argue that these members aren't "real Christians", but they are sure as hell going to church and their fellow church-goers think they are.

*> I can't think of any widespread religious riot in the US (I could totally be wrong though).

It has a Wikipedia category:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Religiously_motivated...

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by iammisc on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @06:39PM (#27839365)
Honestly thanks for the info on the riots. The KKK is so obvious that I'm embarrassed it didn't cross my mind.

I will be the first to admit I have zero understanding of protestantism other than that most seem nice. They're like Muslims to me except they believe in Jesus which seems nice.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by wonderwonder on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @08:13PM (#27840077)
Plenty of people still go to church but attendance is declining as the popularity of the churches morals, biases and lessons fall out of favor. One could probably argue that as the larger Christian sects have become associated with politics that decline has accelerated. It does not make sense for people who don't believe in god or hold different views on what is moral or not to attend . With that said I am sure you are quite right that having something in common such as church attendance, etc. leads to community building but only as far as between those already in the same community, Catholicism, southern Baptist, etc. I do think that people would be well served to get involved in large organized groups but optimally ones that are not bent on separating people into us and them. I don't think that a decline in church attendance is in any way the driver of societies ills as church attendance was sky high in the 40's and 50's and did not go so great for everyone. My personal opinion is that social media, echo chambers and the ability to isolate oneself by having most of ones superficial needs met via technology is the cause.
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by amelius on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @06:59PM (#27839539)
> We used to call this going to church.

Elementary school was the same. Military service with enforced conscription is also similar.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by teachrdan on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @12:58PM (#27835296)
> However large political factions have made church membership out to be undesirable.

This comment appears to be a dog whistle, so please do correct me if I'm totally wrong here. But this reads like "Democrats / the left have demonized belonging to a church / Christianity," which is a common right wing talking point. Is that what you're saying here?

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by kian on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:45PM (#27835904)
There is no need to violate the principle of charity or HN norms. Whether or not the gp meant Democrats, do you really think that atheists, agnosts, members of all other religions, scientists, artists, spiritualists, conspiracy theorists, and rationalists of all stripes form a monolithic political faction?
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by iammisc on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @02:11PM (#27836293)
I don't mean just the democrats no. It seems to me to be a large faction of people, including certain elements of the 'alt-right'.

But yes, you're right in that I perceive the left as having demonized belonging to a church. This explains the growing disconnect between the democratic party and minorities, and why the GOP has started to make gains with them. The democratic party ignores religion at its own peril.

It's especially weird since the democratic party used to be really into religion.

This is hardly a 'right wing talking point'. My own parents left the democratic party because of this, well before they had ever tuned in to Fox, Limbaugh, or whatever. Labeling something as a 'right wing talking point' is just a democratic dog whistle to ignore real phenomena.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by ssully on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:18PM (#27835576)
Yeah, I too long for the days past when the US had less cultural problems/conflicts due to high church attendance numbers.
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by nate_meurer on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @02:58PM (#27836926)
I know right? What happened to the good old days when the big mainstream church organizations like the SBC were fighting the good fight against evils such as interracial marriage and civil rights?
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by munificent on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @06:13PM (#27839093)
Don't forget delightful religious advocacy fraternal organizations like the KKK.
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by iammisc on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @03:02PM (#27836989)
> I know right? What happened to the good old days when the big mainstream church organizations like the SBC were fighting the good fight against evils such as interracial marriage and civil rights?

You're just picking and choosing. In reality, religious organizations, like the Catholic church for example, were fighting the opposite fight. Perez v Sharp in California was orchestrated by the church: http://ccgaction.org/node/1011

Of course, if we encourage community involvement, there will be good organizations and bad ones. For example, we provide 501(c)3 status to both Planned Parenthood as well as a pro-life organization.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by nate_meurer on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @03:12PM (#27837118)
Good for them, seriously, but I don't think it takes a lot of "picking and choosing" to point out how influential "christian" churches were in the fight to preserve America's white supremist hierarchy.

The SBC was and remains the largest christian organization in the US, and it was founded for the express purpose of defending slavery.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by iammisc on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @03:15PM (#27837151)
> The SBC was and remains the largest christian organization in the US, and it was founded for the express purpose of defending slavery.

The Catholic church is by far the largest christian organization in the united states.

SBC is a distant second:

https://theosophical.wordpress.com/2011/02/16/top-10-largest...

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by nate_meurer on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @03:25PM (#27837280)
Ok, allow me to amend my statement:

The SBC was and remains the largest protestant organization in the US, and it was founded for the express purpose of defending slavery.

If you dismiss such things as mere "picking and choosing", you're unlikely to to be able to understand viewpoints to which you're inclined to disagree.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by iammisc on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @03:51PM (#27837594)
> If you dismiss such things as mere "picking and choosing", you're unlikely to to be able to understand viewpoints to which you're inclined to disagree.

You said the SBC was the largest Christian denomination. Then, when that was false, you changed it to 'largest Protestant organization'.

I mean, you can restrict things down to anything to prove a point. Did you know my McDonalds down the block has the highest sales revenue of any McDonalds in inner NE portland between the hours of 5 and 7PM? It's just crazy that we're blessed with such a prestigious example of fine business in my area.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by nate_meurer on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @04:21PM (#27837923)
Right, I acknowledge your correction, so I responded with an amended statement, with emphasis on the part that I'd gotten wrong. Let me know if you'd like something more, like a written apology or something.

If your argument mainly focuses on whether the SBC is the first or second largest American religious organization, then I guess you win. Congratulations!

It pains me to point out something so obvious, but the SBC was only one of the large mainstream Christian denominations to actively support slavery, and to later actively oppose civil rights for non-whites. But if you're able to dismiss the entire tortured and complicated historical relationship between American Christianity and racial oppression with a handy comparison to a neighborhood restaurant, then I guess you win again.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by iammisc on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @04:31PM (#27838063)
SBC is not only not the first largest, it's a different order of magnitude.

And my point was that it's a mixed bag. While a lot of support for slavery was nominally Christian, so was a lot of opposition.

For example, the Battle Hymn of the Republic is just that -- a hymn -- and its words on slavery are absolutely brutal. You can say 'christianity was a force for slavery' but you can't say that while not also acknowledging christianity was behind abolition as well.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by nate_meurer on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:05PM (#27838431)
"Yeah but you weren't just wrong. You were wrong by a lot!"

:)

> my point was that it's a mixed bag. While a lot of support for slavery was nominally Christian, so was a lot of opposition.

Ok, but that's not what you said. You objected, without qualification, to the notion that large mainstream christian denominations supported white supremacy. IIRC, you said such talk was "picking and choosing".

Now, if the new location of your goalposts is their true permanent home, I'm happy to report that we agree with each other!

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by iammisc on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @06:41PM (#27839386)
I think we were objecting to different things. I broadly agree that large mainstream denominations supported slavery. I just pointed out that many equally large denominations did not. If we're talking about Christianity as a whole, it's a mixed bag. There's no reason the SBC should be singled out.
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by watwut on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:29PM (#27838674)
And these two sets of people killed each other in the process of settling their diffences. It not unity by any meaningful sense.

And I mean, this even comletely ignores blacks who form their own groups definitely not united all that much with above.

[dead]
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by dang on Thursday July 15, 2021 @07:47PM (#27851469)
We ban accounts that take HN threads further into flamewar hell like this, so please don't do that.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

[dead]
Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by dang on Thursday July 15, 2021 @07:47PM (#27851470)
We ban accounts that take HN threads further into flamewar hell like this, so please don't do that.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by bsanr2 on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:33PM (#27835742)
"At 11:00 on Sunday morning when we stand and sing and Christ has no east or west, we stand at the most segregated hour in this nation." It's difficult for me to justify buying into the idea of Christian social life as the source of American unity when 10 years ago participating would have seen me bombarded with the reasons why my homosexuality would see me burn in hell for all eternity, or when 200 years ago it would have seen me bombarded with all the point of scripture that justified my being treated as property. This is as someone whose grandfather was a deacon; I can't imagine what people whose families don't have a church tradition at all must think of this suggestion.

I do think that the segregation of social life is at the heart of much of this country's ills. However, perhaps that has more to do with things like, say, Bill and Sally's frankly hysterical fear of sharing a street with the Freemans. How to reduce social division in America in the long-term: ban private schools, fund public schools at the national level, and do it quickly, utterly, and irrevocably. I don't know if you would end up with a single, continental American nation, but the part left still known as "The United States of America" would be profoundly united.

Even if you disagree, you must understand that the notion that everyone must attend church for America to achieve some measure of unity is about as radical. The focus must be on the bringing together of disparate communities, secularly.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by iammisc on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @02:24PM (#27836493)
> The focus must be on the bringing together of disparate communities, secularly.

Except the 'United' states of America has never been about that kind of community. That's more of the fraternite of the French revolution than the spirit of America.

American unity has been due to the result of multiple different organizations and factions all participating in a common undertaking, rather than one centralized organization doing the planning and execution (as would be the case if we 'nationalized' education and did away with private schooling).

My view of America as one in which everyone can belong to different organizations, but still work together is the historical norm.

In de Tocqueville's 'Democracy in America', written at the founding of the USA, de Tocqueville (an outside french observer) writes:

> Americans of all ages, all stations in life, and all types of dispositions are forever forming associations. There are not only commercial and industrial associations in which all take part, but others of a thousand different types—religious, moral, serious, futile, very general and very limited, immensely large and very minute. > > Americans combine to give fetes, found seminaries, build churches, distribute books, and send missionaries to the antipodes. Hospitals, prisons, and schools take shape in that way... In every case, at the head of any new undertaking, where in France you would find the government or in England some territorial magnate, in the United States you are sure to find an association.

By asking the government to 'fund public schools at the national level' you are making America like France or England rather than what it historically has been, which is highly decentralized and disjointed, but still unified.

This in my opinion is the great disconnect between 'progressives' and 'conservatives' (for lack of better terms). There's a certain type of person that, when they see a problem, immediately asks how government can be leveraged to solve it. Whereas, for me, personally, and others I know, my response would be ... how could I get my local church men's club to help out. Because I can't control the government, and by the time I lobby and campaign, the problem will still have affected a bunch of other people. Whereas it's pretty easy to gather a group of guys to fix it.

One obvious example of this is -- as you mentioned -- schools. Before public schools were a thing, catholic communities all across the country pooled together parish money to start affordable schools, with great academic results. In response, the government started the public school system so people wouldn't have to deal with the church. That's fine and dandy, but we need to accept the fact that private organizations worked better than the government to immediately provide the service of education.

The same is true of hospitals. Go to any US city of any import, and you'll be sure to find a Catholic hospital. Where is the government if it's so useful. Even in Europe, where the healthcare systems are nationalized, half the hospitals used to be ones run by the Church. It remains to be seen how these nationalized healthcare systems will play out over the long-term (thousands of years), but we know how it works when the Church runs them... they stay around for a long time.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by gilbetron on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @02:37PM (#27836663)
> That's fine and dandy, but we need to accept the fact that private organizations worked better than the government to immediately provide the service of education.

There's much wrong with what you have posted here and elsewhere, but I'll just focus on this one. There are numerous studies looking at private vs public schools, and public schools are just as good as private if you get rid of confounding factors (private school students tend to come from wealthier families, for instance).

There are many, many sources for this, here's a good start:

https://www.upworthy.com/public-versus-private-school-a-stud...

https://www.forbes.com/sites/christopherrim/2019/07/03/why-w...

https://www.hepg.org/hel-home/issues/31_1/helarticle/turning...

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by iammisc on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @02:40PM (#27836710)
You are arguing something completely different. I pointed out that before public schools, there were large networks of private schools. Public schooling started as a response to the success of catholic schools.

I am not arguing for superiority of one over the other.

I'm just pointing out that decentralized, distributed decision making led to people's educational needs being met before government got with the program.

Also, your articles are on public v generic private. Catholic schools are outliers in the private school space. They tend to be significantly cheaper, have a different set of outcomes, and tend to be more socioeconomically representative of society at large.

Re:The vital art of talking to strangers by war1025 on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:45PM (#27835907)
> How to reduce social division in America in the long-term: ban private schools, fund public schools at the national level, and do it quickly, utterly, and irrevocably.

We tried this to tame the savages [1], and I don't think people really look back kindly or positively on that choice.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_American_Indian_sch...