News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by azinman2 on Monday July 12, 2021 @02:17PM (#27813320)
Chemotherapy is basically cave man medicine. That a therapeutic drug is explosive only adds to that sentiment. The idea that we'll basically poison you just up to a point that's nearly fatal in order to kill the cancer is such a terrible way to treat someone. Now I'm not saying don't ever do it -- unfortunately that's where we're at in 2021. It's just kind of unbelievable that cancer remains so elusive that we're still using medical treatments that started from mustard gas usage during world wars, when we're so advanced technologically in so many other ways.

Interestingly, cancers for children are largely successfully treated. I was at a fancy conference a few years ago where some cancer researchers were socializing over wine, and I asked them why that was versus adults. They said the difference was that parents are willing to do almost anything (aka enroll their kids in experimental treatments) to cure their kids, but adults aren't quite so willing for themselves. Thus the rate of experimentation was just so much higher for children to the point where it's often curable. Perhaps one day we'll be able to simulate the body well enough to the point where we can brute force treatments computationally to fix this gap.

Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by robbiep on Monday July 12, 2021 @02:40PM (#27813556)
The cancers that are treated successfully in children are the blood borne ones (mostly leukemias) and generally because they’re easier to wipe out and replace the marrow with. Some Childhood brain tumours are also very successfully treated, and most other adult cancers children don’t get. Sarcomas still kill people left right and centre though.

The truth is that we’re already peeking out of the dark ages of chemotherapy. Immunothérapies have revolutionised the field and new stuff coming online is incredible. When I started medical school 11 years ago the 5 year survival of metastatic melanoma was close to 0%. It’s now close to the population average (well, not really, but it’s greater than 50%). Records are being smashed

Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by et2o on Monday July 12, 2021 @04:17PM (#27814569)
Metastatic melanoma? I haven’t seen any data showing close to 50% survival rate, where are you looking? Just managed a young patient with metastatic melanoma and very poor prognosis.
Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by Herodotus38 on Monday July 12, 2021 @04:53PM (#27814980)
I think they were referring to pd-1 inhibitors. I’m not an oncologist but that generally fits with what I’ve seen as a hospitalist. FWIW I personally know someone who has survived > 5 years who received it right when it cane out.

Here’s a paper supporting:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7019511/

Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by jcims on Monday July 12, 2021 @05:41PM (#27815458)
PD-1 inhibitors seem like magic when they work.

Unfortunately they don’t work in every case, but it’s abundantly clear when they do that the immune system is good at killing unwanted cells roaming around the body. *smacks forehead*

Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by robbiep on Monday July 12, 2021 @05:56PM (#27815575)
Yes sorry I should have specified, PD-1s. Was 4am in australia on mobile and wasn’t in the mood to reference. Sorry
Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by dredmorbius on Monday July 12, 2021 @03:30PM (#27814034)
A rather surprising number of chemo compounds trace directly to chemical warfare and compounds used during WWI, including several mustard-gas-related compounds.

Some years ago, a close friend died of a relatively rare and aggressive form of cancer. Among my roles was running interference against those who were pitching various miracle cures, with that tired old scam laetril playing a significant role.

In the decades since, I've watched developments in the science and development, as well as traced the history. It turns out that the treatment received a few decades ago was little changed from that of the 1960s, and has progressed little since. Genetic sequencing identified the affected chromosome of the triggering mutation in the 1980s, and we now know the specific codons involved. There remains no cure.

Five year survival remains about 20%. Laetril is still a fraud. And several of the other patients we came to know during the course of my friend's treatment have died since of conditions related to the treatment itself, though yes, they did buy another 10--20 years.

Cancer is brutal.

I will note: "cancer" is a symptom cluster manifested by malignant growth, and virtually always due to genetic mutation within the affected cells (I'd say "always" though I'm not completely sure of that). The specific triggers, and the possibilities for cure, vary tremendously. Some bladder cancers are virtually entirely treatable by, of all things, tuberculosis baccili. Skin cancers if caught early pose little risk. Others are tremendously aggressive, and an online friend's posts progressed from announcing their partner's diagnosis with liver cancer to the partner's death over the course of less than two months.

Broad-brush statements are virtually always false.

Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by agumonkey on Monday July 12, 2021 @04:28PM (#27814688)
There's a weird wedding here, toxic/warfare compounds dropped into your blood stream and nowadays it's used with administrative processes (for repeatability and liability purposes). Back in the days the people who came with the chemotherapies were also aggressive in the way the approach treatment (and according to De Vita it gave better results [but maybe cost more])
Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by dredmorbius on Monday July 12, 2021 @05:52PM (#27815540)
There's also a direct connection to vivisection and human-subjects research during wartime which would fail to meet most ethical review board standards today.

References are pretty easy to find:

After promising animal research, physician researchers connected with Yale University and the University of Chicago tried injecting sulfur mustard and its somewhat milder relatives, the nitrogen mustards, into the veins of cancer patients in the early 1940s. This was the first time a systemic treatment was given for cancer. “It would upset the whole body,” says Smith. “That proved to be valuable when you deal with certain kinds of leukemia or lymphoma.”

https://www.the-scientist.com/foundations/from-chemical-weap...

Not long after the discovery of nitrogen mustard, Sidney Farber of Boston demonstrated that aminopterin, a compound related to the vitamin folic acid, produced remissions in children with acute leukemia.

https://www.cancer.org/cancer/cancer-basics/history-of-cance...

I'm not certain Japan's Unit 731 was engaged in research with chemotherapy precursors, though the range of testing was extensive, and the US provided a grant of immunity after the war.

Please note that pretty much anything horrific you can imagine, and then some, is discussed in the links which follow.

https://nationalinterest.org/blog/reboot/unit-731-japans-sec...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unit_731

Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by dragonwriter on Monday July 12, 2021 @07:05PM (#27816133)
> and virtually always due to genetic mutation within the affected cells

I haven't followed up on this, but I seem to remember hearing about research about 20 years ago that even with cancer-associated mutations, cancer usually required physical damage to the intercellular matrix before it would manifest.

If that's true, I’m not sure identifying the genetic mutations as the cause (at least the proximate cause) of cancer might not be entirely accurate, or at least might be somewhat misleading.

Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by soco on Tuesday July 13, 2021 @01:32AM (#27817870)
Indeed, because otherwise a crispr based therapy could be easily imagined...
Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by caymanjim on Monday July 12, 2021 @04:53PM (#27814988)
Chemotherapy, like cancer, is not one thing. Some of it is a matter of poisoning the body in ways that disrupt rapidly-dividing cells. This is why chemo patients frequently lose their hair (and other things you don't hear as much about, like gametes, fingernails, mucous membranes/digestive lining). You can call this "cave man medicine". Although that's more dismissive than is warranted, there's no denying that it's a blunt instrument.

Other chemotherapy treatments are "holy shit, we live in the future." They're targeted and have almost no side effects.

You specifically reference mustard gas. I had lymphoma, and one of my treatments was bendamustine, which is directly related to that class of chemicals, and the subsequent research. It's broadly toxic. The other treatment was rituximab, which is a monoclonal antibody that targets the CD20 protein that manifests on B cells, which are just one of many cells involved in the lymphatic system.

I have to say the whole thing was a walk in the park. Bendamustine isn't fun, but I never vomited once, never lost my hair, and outwardly didn't look any different at all. I felt pretty shitty for about three days once a month after treatment. Kinda like a mild flu, but honestly I'd take the bendamustine over the flu any day. I usually took three days off work for it, primarily because I had to be at the chemo infusion center for a few hours to get the drugs. I could have worked through it (not that I should ever have had to, but I could have). The rituximab was a walk in the park. I took that once a month for a year, then every two months for two more years. Aside from an allergic reaction the first time (solved with Benadryl subsequently), I barely noticed it at all. It was, at its worst, nowhere near as bad as a hangover.

I know I'm fortunate in that these treatments existed for my cancer, and that my cancer has a high survival rate (I've been clear for over a decade). Many people are far worse off, even if they survive. I like to take these opportunities to dispel some of the misconceptions that are out there.

Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by azinman2 on Monday July 12, 2021 @10:59PM (#27817252)
I'm glad that worked out well for you. I have friends who haven't been as lucky. Again, I'm not suggesting don't do chemo, I just wish we were much further ahead in targeted and less toxic treatment options such that chemo wasn't in the picture.
Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by gus_massa on Monday July 12, 2021 @04:00PM (#27814390)
> That a therapeutic drug is explosive only adds to that sentiment.

Explosivity and toxicity are unrelated. Cyanide can kill you, but it's not explosive IIRC. You can make explosives with aluminum, but it's safe to use as a food container, ...

> Chemotherapy is basically cave man medicine.

The main problem is that cancer cells and normal cells are very similar. Anything that kills cancer cells will probably kill normal cells. Anything that is safe for normal cells is probably safe for cancer cells. Killing one but not the other is like a poll trickshot.

(Killing bacteria or fungus is easier, because some of the molecules they use are different, and sometimes they produce the molecules using a different method, so you can make a drug that attack the difference and hope the best.)

Also, not all the treatment for cancer use chemotherapy methods. Some cancers are affected by hormones, so you can modify the hormone levels. (This also cause problems in the part of you body that use the hormone, so it's a tradeoff.)

Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by EE84M3i on Monday July 12, 2021 @08:54PM (#27816718)
>Explosivity and toxicity are unrelated.

Really? Doesn't something being explosive mean it's highly unstable and reactive? Presumably ingesting highly reactive reagents is toxic.

Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by dogorman on Monday July 12, 2021 @09:03PM (#27816765)
> Really? Doesn't something being explosive mean it's highly unstable and reactive?

Not particularly, no. Some certainly are, but others require a great deal of activation energy to detonate. Nitroglycerine (another explosive medication) is notoriously touchy. But C4 is only mildly flammable; you can heat up your meal by lighting a piece of C4 on fire then put the fire out by smashing it with a hammer; it won't detonate like that.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/C-4_(explosive)#Detonation

Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by EE84M3i on Monday July 12, 2021 @09:18PM (#27816816)
Sure, but in this context, the drug we're talking about exploded with a drop hammer test, right? That seems more like nitroglycerin than C4.
Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by lazide on Tuesday July 13, 2021 @12:10AM (#27817555)
Nitroglycerin is also a therapeutic drug, and only toxic if you overdose - and isn’t used for chemotherapy. They’re tangential properties at best.
Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by TylerE on Monday July 12, 2021 @10:53PM (#27817234)
There are many different kinds of reactivity... chemical, thermal, shock (e.g. hit it with a hammer go boom).

One of the medicines with the longest history is nitroglycerin (for various heart conditions), which is literally dynamite.

Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by fabian2k on Monday July 12, 2021 @02:26PM (#27813420)
Many of the modern treatments are much more targeted, any antibody-based treatment is by nature extremely specific. But then you also have the problem that cancer isn't a single, unified disease, so a very targeted approach doesn't work for every cancer.
Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by joe_the_user on Monday July 12, 2021 @04:00PM (#27814387)
Chemotherapy combined with surgery and radiation is still a standard and still does cure a significant portion of people - my father's cancer was cured by this "ordinary method".

The problem is that more selective methods of killing cancers run up against the tendency of cancer cells to mutate and find a defense against them.

And this is definitely stuff that's killing you and the cancer and hoping the cancer dies first. To keep going, you need a strong reason to live.

Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by flying_kiwi on Monday July 12, 2021 @07:33PM (#27816311)
> It's just kind of unbelievable that cancer remains so elusive

One of the problems with cancer is that it's really an umbrella term that covers a huge variety of problems to solve. There are many, many ways for the normal cell lifecycle to get disrupted, and they will all respond differently to different treatments. I'm not sure if a single technology will ever appear to allow all cancers to be treated.

Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by vibrio on Monday July 12, 2021 @02:34PM (#27813504)
I agree with your wine-drinking physicians on clinical trial participation, and your question on how to improve broader participation. I also believe that there are fundamental difference in cancers that arrive in a young person versus cancers that have slowly evolved in the patients bodies, perhaps over a decade or more-the latter are likely much more stubborn.
Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by devy on Monday July 12, 2021 @03:31PM (#27814035)
I am not surprised the a Class 1 HAZMAT is used as the chemo agent for glioblastoma, the most malignant form of brain tumor. My father in law just recently passed with glioblastoma stage 3, from admitted to hospital to passing in a couple of month.
Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by refurb on Monday July 12, 2021 @09:10PM (#27816787)
I’d say this is a pretty unfair assessment. Sure chemotherapy such as nitrogen mustards are still used (because they are effective) but plenty of newer drugs are very targeted.

And it’s not like our approach is all that different for other life threatening diseases. Multi-drug resistant infection? Let me use antibiotics on you that will make you deaf and maybe damage your heart.

Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by azinman2 on Monday July 12, 2021 @11:02PM (#27817265)
I said started with, not continued to be exactly that. Of course new drugs and treatments have come out since.

Many other drugs/treatments can also be really bad! I'm on some pretty bad drugs myself right now (not cancer related), and wish other options existed here too. Cancer isn't the only area of medicine where I wish I was born hundreds of years in the future!

Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by al2o3cr on Monday July 12, 2021 @08:14PM (#27816514)

    The idea that we'll basically poison you just up to
    a point that's nearly fatal in order to kill the
    cancer is such a terrible way to treat someone.
TBH that's how a _lot_ of drugs work - for instance, sabotaging certain parts of cell division can be an effective treatment because the disease needs that mechanism more than the patient.

It's also a hazard in drug discovery - the linked blog has plenty of examples of compounds that did a GREAT job of disrupting biological activity of a pathogen in a Petri dish because they're GREAT at wrecking biology in general.

One other note, re: "started from mustard gas" - many antibiotics are really just chemical weapons we're borrowing from fungi.

Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by fossuser on Monday July 12, 2021 @07:13PM (#27816195)
There are some drugs that target the underlying mechanism, herceptin is a particularly famous one.

For those interested in this kind of thing I’d highly recommend the book The Emperor of All Maladies.

For Herceptin specifically, there was a book called her-2.

Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by cubicmeter on Monday July 12, 2021 @04:42PM (#27814846)
this could be true that as a different example along the lines of the same conclusion: Women-only medical conditions are less known by medical fields, and there are fewer treatments. Its because the society treats women's lives less seriously. For example pregnancy is still pretty mysterious in general medicine. Birth control pills are to prevent women fertility etc. It could be true that children lives are deemed more important by parents and more researched.
Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by open-source-ux on Monday July 12, 2021 @03:58PM (#27814362)
My understanding is that chemotherapy is indiscrimate when it attacks cells - it affects cancerous and healthy cells alike. However, doctors assume the healthy cells will recover from the weakening effects of chemotherapy. Meanwhile the cancer cells are stressed to a greater degree by the chemotherapy and thus suspectible to death. All this is presented as the "best outcome" scenario for chemotherapy treament.

However, for some patients (and depending on their type of cancer) chemotheraphy can leave lingering side-effects and can even cause cancerous cells to recur or turn even more aggressive. For some cancer patients, chemotherapy is not about curing the cancer but slowing the cancer spread ("treatable but not curable" is the phrase used by doctors for some cancer conditions).

Although chemotheraphy can be succesful for some (many?) patients, as you say it still feels like a crude, blunt approach to treating cancer. Doctors might baulk at that description. But consider: if someone has a non-metasized cancer (i.e. cancer in one part of the body that has not spread to other parts of the body), chemotherapy is applied with blunt force to the entire body including to the majority of healthy cells in the body. I can't see how anyone can say this isn't a coarse and crude treatment method even when the outcome is deemed successful.

Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by zaroth on Monday July 12, 2021 @04:13PM (#27814528)
Not entirely indiscriminate. For example as I understand it, a lot of chemo drugs attack cells that divide quickly. Which is why a lot of times hair loss is a side effect because they are some of the faster dividing cells in the body.
Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by da_chicken on Monday July 12, 2021 @05:37PM (#27815428)
My understanding was that chemotherapy drugs often affect cells literally as they divide. The exact mechanisms vary, but it's that timing of affecting a cell during division that makes a given substance possible to be used as chemotherapy drug.
Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by marzell on Monday July 12, 2021 @10:04PM (#27817022)
"That a therapeutic drug is explosive..." seems sensationalistic. Reminds me of when people say things like "x contains chemicals used in x!". What's the practical problem with this?
Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by lazide on Tuesday July 13, 2021 @12:12AM (#27817566)
For one, it’s probably pretty lucky the plant that makes it hasn’t exploded yet. The workers and neighbors probably benefit from knowing?
Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Monday July 12, 2021 @03:44PM (#27814185)
>Perhaps one day we'll be able to simulate the body well enough to the point where we can brute force treatments computationally to fix this gap.

This is why as a total outsider/non-expert I believe we will cure everything in the next 50 years if we do not regress or destroy ourselves.

Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by short_sells_poo on Monday July 12, 2021 @04:41PM (#27814829)
We still don't understand much of the inner workings of our own body. It's a bit like the divide between quantum physics and the macroscopic world. We have successfully observed and modeled individual processes as they happen at a cellular level, and we can draw some statistical conclusions at the whole body level, but much of the area in-between is basically unknown.

One just needs to look at nutrition or the farce that is "nutrition science". We only barely understand what we are supposed to eat to maximize our health, and that's such a basic and fundamental concept that I feel anything like "brute force treatments computationally to fix this gap." would require multiple generational leaps in our understanding. In other words, I feel like you are extrapolating to space flight when we have just recently invented the catapult.

Hell, we are only starting to suspect that the gut biome affects our consciousness. How crazy is that? And yet it is a very sobering indicator of how little we know. The human body is an incredibly complicated system with so many feedback loops that I'd put it in the same class as solving the halting problem or establishing a grand unified theory of physics.

We have modern robotics and tools like laser knives, but we still have to poke needles into a patient's brain to determine where to cut out tumors. I don't mean to disparage the doubtlessly talented surgeons of today, but to me this seems barely above medieval techniques. Our tools have improved 100 fold, our understanding just barely.

I think at best the prediction we can make is that "we believe eventually all diseases should be treatable". But to say that in the next 50 years we can become functionally immortal (treat all diseases), is a very long stretch IMO.

Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by shpongled on Monday July 12, 2021 @11:07PM (#27817296)
Simulating a single cell, let alone an entire human will be the final problem we ever solve. It's that difficult.
Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by pcarolan on Monday July 12, 2021 @05:45PM (#27815489)
You’re right that we haven’t made much progress but this drug is the only advancement in brain cancer in decades and has very few side effects for most people. Compared to traditional chemotherapy, it is a game changer for many patients’ quality of life.
Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by Gatsky on Monday July 12, 2021 @10:50PM (#27817220)
This is a very ignorant and low effort comment. Let me illustrate:

> Chemotherapy is basically cave man medicine

A meaningless statement. Actually, there is a sophisticated system of diagnosis and staging to work out who needs chemotherapy at all. This includes CT scans, ultrasound, MRI, positron emission tomorography. Chemotherapy agents are modern pharmaceuticals with a variety of supportive care measures to help patients who can benefit from them. How is nanoparticle bound paclitaxel a cave man medicine?

> The idea that we'll basically poison you just up to a point that's nearly fatal in order to kill the cancer is such a terrible way to treat someone.

Again, ignorant. Highly toxic multi-agent chemotherapy is used in acute leukaemias, because the patient will literally die next week or sometimes in a day unless you start treating. In that case you are trying to help someone who is already very sick, so of course there is a high mortality rate, but it is less than the 100% without treatment. How do you suggest we work out the best dose of chemotherapy, apart from giving it at increasing doses and monitoring what happens in a phase I trial? Anyway, many chemotherapy agents are given at a dose that controls disease and maintains quality of life in incurable disease, in direct opposition to your off-hand comment.

> Now I'm not saying don't ever do it -- unfortunately that's where we're at in 2021.

Do you realise that there are malignancies which are 100% fatal without chemotherapy, but curable with chemotherapy? Germ cell tumours in men for example. Acute leukaemias. Lymphomas. Gestational trophoblastic tumours. So what on earth are you talking about?

> It's just kind of unbelievable that cancer remains so elusive that we're still using medical treatments that started from mustard gas usage during world wars, when we're so advanced technologically in so many other ways.

Most chemotherapy agents in use today are not based on mustard gas, for a start. Many of them come from plants. One of the most useful and well tolerated chemotherapy agents comes from the bark the pacific yew tree. Anyway, the argument is stupid - your car engine is based on explosions, so car engines cannot be sophisticated or useful?

> Interestingly, cancers for children are largely successfully treated. I was at a fancy conference a few years ago where some cancer researchers were socializing over wine, and I asked them why that was versus adults. They said the difference was that parents are willing to do almost anything (aka enroll their kids in experimental treatments) to cure their kids, but adults aren't quite so willing for themselves.

This is bullshit. Walk into a clinical trials unit in an adult cancer centre and you'll see. The reason cancers in children are different are because the biology is different, to state the bleeding obvious. Also children are much more physiologically resilient and don't have other medical problems, so their response to treatment is fundamentally different.

Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by azinman2 on Monday July 12, 2021 @10:55PM (#27817242)
Not only did you misinterpret a lot of what I said (including the fact that I wasn't particularly making an argument, but rather an observation and opinion), your aggressive response certainly doesn't invite dialog and is in violation of multiple HN guidelines. I suggest you read them and consider being kinder in your word choice.
Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by Gatsky on Tuesday July 13, 2021 @04:36AM (#27818745)
My tone was inappropriate, you didn’t deserve that. It was unnecessary and rude. I’m sorry. Thank you for making a levelheaded reply.
Re:Temozolomide Is Explosive by azinman2 on Tuesday July 13, 2021 @12:31PM (#27823011)
All good! Thanks for your levelheaded reply.