News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by tomohawk on Monday July 05, 2021 @03:13PM (#27741006)
Ships transiting the canal are required to have an Egyptian pilot on the bridge. Why isn't it more correct to say that that pilot blocked the canal using the ship?

It seems like Egypt is just taking advantage of the situation and their canal monopoly.

Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by krisoft on Monday July 05, 2021 @04:20PM (#27741483)
> Why isn't it more correct to say that that pilot blocked the canal using the ship?

It doesn't matter. The Suez Canal Authority - Rules of Navigation Article 4, section 7:

“(7) Owners, mobilizers, charterers and/or operators bind themselves responsible for any mistakes resulting from pilot’s advice or arrise by SCA personnel.”

https://www.suezcanal.gov.eg/English/Navigation/Pages/Ruleso....

> It seems like Egypt is just taking advantage of the situation and their canal monopoly.

Yes.

Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by RegnisGnaw on Monday July 05, 2021 @03:28PM (#27741129)
The captain is always in command and is responsible for the ship. The pilots assume command with the approval of the captain only. The captain can withdraw the approval at any time.

Holland America has an good FAQ on this topic: https://www.hollandamerica.com/blog/technical/what-does-the-...

Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by perl4ever on Monday July 05, 2021 @04:10PM (#27741419)
In the article the spokesperson for the insurer is quoted as saying:

"It is important to clarify that whilst the master is ultimately responsible for the vessel, navigation in the canal transit within a convoy is controlled by the Suez Canal pilots and SCA vessel traffic management services. Such controls include the speed of the transit and the availability of escort tugs."

In other words, they do not accept that the simple rule of the captain being responsible for the ship is all there is to it, case closed.

I'm not saying they are/were right or wrong, just that they are not a random pseudonymous person on the internet who's ignorant of the shipping industry and can be dismissed the same way.

Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by skeeter2020 on Monday July 05, 2021 @04:40PM (#27741623)
Isn't that exactly what they are saying? It was in response to the SCA statement about how the ship was going too fast and inadequately controllable; they responded that while the responsibility ultimately lies with the captain, he was under the guidance of SCA staff and tugs for speed and piloting, not a drunk teenager whom they had no influence over, which is how the SCA has tried to frame this from the beginning.
Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by perl4ever on Monday July 05, 2021 @11:20PM (#27743934)
Isn't what exactly what who is saying?

The insurer seemed to be acknowledging that the formal rule about the captain exists, while claiming that's not the end of the discussion about responsibility.

That suggests to me that quoting the rulebook isn't really an adequate response to the original question of why isn't it the pilot's fault. It's the position of the SCA, by definition.

I guess we will never know though, what was agreed on, because it was settled in private.

Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by Talanes on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @12:45AM (#27744304)
>The insurer seemed to be acknowledging that the formal rule about the captain exists, while claiming that's not the end of the discussion about responsibility.

I don't disagree with your broader point, but an insurance company acting like a claim is disputable doesn't really tell us anything. It's just the default sort of response for any insurance claim, just magnified to scale.

I'd expect them to be phrasing it as an open matter even if the captain had drunkenly taken control and stuck the ship himself.

Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by dkdk8283 on Monday July 05, 2021 @05:24PM (#27741957)
While technically correct I would (reasonably) expect the captain to only exercise this in extreme circumstances. Asserting control in an ambiguous situation can be a difficult decision.
Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by userbinator on Monday July 05, 2021 @07:40PM (#27742858)
Also, if I were a captain, I would reasonably trust the judgment of a pilot whose job is to navigate ships through the canal unless in the case of, as you noted, "extreme circumstances"; and even withdrawing approval may be too late, given how slow ships of this size are to respond to sudden control inputs.
Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by WillPostForFood on Monday July 05, 2021 @09:04PM (#27743322)
Read the article posted on HN about transiting the canal.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26588272

It may not be reasonable to trust the Suez pilots, but hopefully bigger ships get better pilots.

Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by Lammy on Monday July 05, 2021 @04:25PM (#27741514)
> their canal monopoly

An alternative is technically possible since Israel has contiguous territory between the Mediterranean and Red Sea: https://www.businessinsider.in/science/news/the-us-had-a-pla...

Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by ben_w on Monday July 05, 2021 @05:13PM (#27741865)
A plan which involves 520 nukes of 2 megatons each, putting it roughly in the same ball park as some of the Project Orion proposals.

I mean, you might accidentally solve the Middle East peace process if nobody wants to live there any more, but I don’t think it will be a popular solution to either that or the Suez monopoly…

Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by arcticbull on Monday July 05, 2021 @07:52PM (#27742929)
Man the 60s were really a time of laissez-faire nuclear projects huh. I mean I'll be the first to say the pendulum has swung too far the other way but boy were they ever enthusiastic.
Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by reaperducer on Monday July 05, 2021 @08:06PM (#27743020)
It seems that every time someone invents a new hammer, people use it to solve every problem, whether it's the right tool for the job or not. When viewed through the lens of hindsight, the advertisements are quite amusing.

In the 1890's it was "electricity." In the 1920's it was "radio." In the 1940's it was "radar." In the 1950's it was "atomic" everything. In the 1960's it as "space" this and "space" that. In the 1970's it was "jet." In the 1990's it was "cyber." Today, it's "blockchain" and "AI."

Some of it works. Most of it is snake oil. But people keep buying based on trendy keywords. People are just built that way.

Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by throwaways885 on Monday July 05, 2021 @09:58PM (#27743534)
Comparing blockchain to electricity and nuclear science is just depressing for me :/
Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by arcticbull on Monday July 05, 2021 @10:15PM (#27743618)
They both consumed the lives of many of the smartest folks of the time :)
Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by rpearl on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @12:20AM (#27744191)
Studying nuclear engineering should be worthwhile. Studying power system engineering was.

Blockchains aren't.

Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by arcticbull on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @12:53AM (#27744344)
Haha, yes, I'm known around here for sharing that view.
Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by allendoerfer on Monday July 05, 2021 @08:26PM (#27743122)
Has blockchain solved a single problem yet?
Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by travem on Monday July 05, 2021 @08:32PM (#27743156)
How to get paid for Ransomware attacks?
Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by hhjj on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @12:37AM (#27744264)
It could but gatekeepers aren't happy.
Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by fouc on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @03:47AM (#27745268)
Today it's "lidar"
Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by bradleyjg on Monday July 05, 2021 @08:30PM (#27743145)
None of them ever happened AFAIK, but there were some crazy ideas.
Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by sudosysgen on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @12:39AM (#27744272)
The Soviets did use a few nukes to stop oil well fires!
[dead]
Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by TedDoesntTalk on Monday July 05, 2021 @07:54PM (#27742938)
Sharing canal revenues with Gaza Strip residents might solve their poverty and unemployment problems.
Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by paxys on Monday July 05, 2021 @06:52PM (#27742572)
Because another complex geopolitical nightmare is exactly what that region needs..
Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by ant6n on Monday July 05, 2021 @10:06PM (#27743575)
Wow this website is fucked up. Half way through reading this adfest it jumps to some other article and messes around with the browser history, even reader display wont prevent it.

Now I’ll never know whether they executed that plan or not.

Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by Lammy on Monday July 05, 2021 @10:22PM (#27743659)
Sorry, my bad. I never browse without uBO and didn't notice.
Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by baybal2 on Monday July 05, 2021 @04:44PM (#27741665)
The straight of Tiran, and Aqaba are still largely under Egyptian control.
Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by gpt5 on Monday July 05, 2021 @04:57PM (#27741748)
The straight of Tiran are open to all ship traffic. Last time Egypt tried to impose a blockade on them, Israel considered it as an act of war which resulted in the six day war (where Egypt lost control of all the Sinai peninsula up to the Suez Canal.

Aqaba is a Jordanian port.

Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by marc__1 on Monday July 05, 2021 @05:29PM (#27741990)
For those curious, the list of books that cover the geopolitics of the Suez Canal (way before the current one) is extensive and include:

Blood and Sand: Suez, Hungary, and Eisenhower's Campaign for Peace

The Suez Crisis: The History of the Suez Canal’s Nationalization by Egypt and the War that Followed

1948: The First Arab-Israeli War

Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by austhrow743 on Monday July 05, 2021 @08:21PM (#27743094)
Read all three? Have a favourite?
Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by prawn on Monday July 05, 2021 @10:15PM (#27743617)
Not sure if this is at all useful/interesting information, but I was a photographer on a cruise ship 5-6 weeks ago and happened to be in/on/at (?) the bridge as we were approaching to dock after a 10-night trip.

There were two pilots that had boarded the ship some way out and were with the captain and another crew member at all times. The senior pilot gave constant instructions/advice but at no point did they ever touch controls. The captain in this case was very deferential but I'm not sure if that would be common in the situation or because he was introverted or that he was less familiar with that port.

Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by fouc on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @04:07AM (#27745410)
on
Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by ceejayoz on Monday July 05, 2021 @03:21PM (#27741076)
I'd thought the ship lost power - which wouldn't have been the pilot's fault - but it looks like that early claim got retracted.
Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by Freestyler_3 on Monday July 05, 2021 @04:00PM (#27741338)
Last I heard it was two pilots, one junior and a senior. The senior said to go faster because they were losing control, the junior disagreed because it would be way above max. speed (but a ship this big needs a lot more speed to deal with wind) so they argued and the captain didn't make a decision. Then it all went down slowly without being able to do anything about it.
Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by denton-scratch on Monday July 05, 2021 @04:41PM (#27741637)
"Enough speed"

Steerageway - enough speed for the rudder to work.

There's a reason you don't have two captains on a ship, even when there is an admiral on board. Having two pilots seems to be a bad pattern.

Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by CalChris on Monday July 05, 2021 @07:48PM (#27742904)
There are two pilots because the transit takes 11-12 hours.
Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by alexeldeib on Monday July 05, 2021 @05:26PM (#27741967)
Ironic, considering the opposite is true for planes. Although I do believe only one is typically in control/“pilot” at any given time. Not to mention autopilot and flying vs shipping conditions
Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by laurent92 on Monday July 05, 2021 @05:43PM (#27742093)
If you know anything about it:

- Do you think the shipping culture has lower standards about working together, as catastrophes are less traumatic and thus, there is much less public pressure into having clean responsibilities?

- Do you think the shipping industry would benefit from the pilots’ CRM, a mandatory training introduced in the 1970 to better manage moods and teamplay between pilots?

Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by nradov on Monday July 05, 2021 @06:30PM (#27742413)
Many shipping companies have adopted "bridge resource management" practices, adapted from the aviation industry. They do work when used but there are still many small companies with inadequate crew training and a lack of professionalism.
Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by skhr0680 on Monday July 05, 2021 @07:50PM (#27742916)
Airbus averaging the controls out between both pilots resulted in the Air France crash 10 or so years ago
Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by redis_mlc on Monday July 05, 2021 @06:01PM (#27742212)
> Ironic, considering the opposite is true for planes. Although I do believe only one is typically in control/“pilot” at any given time.

In US civilian flying, one is the pilot flying and the other is the pilot non-flying (usually operates radios, etc.) They usually alternate landings. Pilots study Cockpit Resource Management (CRM) to improve communications.

The Pilot in Command (PIC) is responsible for the flight (not ATC.)

Airplanes can be towed on the ground. Not sure how responsibility is assigned. It's pretty common for wingtips to collide during ground-handling, which grounds both planes.

Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by redis_mlc on Monday July 05, 2021 @07:25PM (#27742786)
I did a search and it looks like airline ground collisions are usually resolved via the courts.

The towing company in one case with Virgin Airlines tried to muddy the waters with "no specific airplane model training" and "not enough lighting", which the judge laughed at since if an airplane towing company can't tow an airplane, what's the point of using them?

FYI: a wingtip strike can cost a few million dollars to fix, plus the cost of grounding (AOG) for weeks or months, which is more millions, for an airliner.

With small airplanes, most flight schools don't charge for AOG, but in the cases I've heard of, the loss of use was more than the repair bill and probably ended the student's career. The numbers were in the range of $5,000 in repairs and $10,000 - $20,000 for loss of use.

Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by renewiltord on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @02:42AM (#27744930)
Because it’s like your tax return. Tax lawyers can do whatever they want so they will prepare your return and you’ll still take the fall for it all if they fucked it up.

It’s just a question of who is the whipper and who is the whippee.

Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by pyuser583 on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @02:28AM (#27744847)
Panama Canal is similar. The pilot is technically an advisor. Command rests with the Captain.
Re:Ever Given: Egypt agrees deal to release ship that blocke... by chrisseaton on Monday July 05, 2021 @03:49PM (#27741256)
Whatever the ship does, it's ultimately the captain's responsibility.