News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Alexandra Elbakyan in real trouble this time? by kergonath on Sunday July 04, 2021 @04:59PM (#27732575)
That is a huge problem if you acknowledge using an illegal platform in your professional work, including for your co-authors. Almost the opposite of genius, actually.
Re:Is Alexandra Elbakyan in real trouble this time? by wizzwizz4 on Sunday July 04, 2021 @05:03PM (#27732599)
Ah, but Sci-Hub isn't illegal. There's nothing wrong with visiting the Sci-Hub home page, nor with using it as a convenient way to access open-access papers.
Re:Is Alexandra Elbakyan in real trouble this time? by kergonath on Sunday July 04, 2021 @05:29PM (#27732767)
Right* (depending on jurisdiction, ymmv). Getting from it articles that you cannot have otherwise is (except for the vanishingly few articles in the public domain, which are not really likely to be found on Sci-Hub anyway. I tried).

Saying that the work could not have been done without it is basically admitting that you got papers outside the subscriptions of your institution. It is also against the policy of all the institutions I know, so could be grounds for termination. And again, this could apply to your co-authors as well.

I am really not endorsing the subscription model, but putting something like that in your articles' acknowledgments really is not smart.

Re:Is Alexandra Elbakyan in real trouble this time? by Aeolun on Sunday July 04, 2021 @06:26PM (#27733130)
> Saying that the work could not have been done without it is basically admitting that you got papers outside the subscriptions of your institution.

Isn’t that exactly the point? How is it not hindering scientific progress if you do not have access to research that you don’t pay for.

It’s not like the journals themselves fund the research, they’re just getting a free ride.

Re:Is Alexandra Elbakyan in real trouble this time? by amelius on Monday July 05, 2021 @09:56AM (#27738038)
> if you do not have access to research that you don’t pay for.

The situation is worse as most of the research is already paid for by tax money.

Re:Is Alexandra Elbakyan in real trouble this time? by amelius on Sunday July 04, 2021 @06:08PM (#27733015)
> Saying that the work could not have been done without it is basically admitting that you got papers outside the subscriptions of your institution.

Not really. It could also mean: Scihub offers an efficient way to explore scientific articles, and without it, I (the scientist) wouldn't have bothered with all the different paywalls to even check if papers were worth reading. And as such, I would not have reached the same results.

Re:Is Alexandra Elbakyan in real trouble this time? by kergonath on Sunday July 04, 2021 @06:10PM (#27733029)
It does not make the work possible, though. Just more convenient.
Re:Is Alexandra Elbakyan in real trouble this time? by amelius on Sunday July 04, 2021 @06:15PM (#27733075)
No because a scientist can only deal with so much bureaucracy.

After a certain limit, they will go into "I will invent it myself" mode.

And here is a different argument. Scientists often have brilliant moments while e.g. showering. So they could have written: "this work would not have been possible without showers". The statement itself does not imply anything about whether they paid for the water or not. Or even if they took a shower. Perhaps the thought of a shower triggered the eureka moment.

Re:Is Alexandra Elbakyan in real trouble this time? by userbinator on Sunday July 04, 2021 @05:31PM (#27732786)
That reminds me of a phrase I've heard in relation to file sharing and such: "if everyone runs the red light together, there is nothing to be afraid of".
Re:Is Alexandra Elbakyan in real trouble this time? by samatman on Sunday July 04, 2021 @05:56PM (#27732948)
Can't tell if it's intentional (some variation on Poe's law applies here), but this is a near-perfect illustration of the difference between a rivalrous (space in an intersection) and non-rivalrous (copies of a digital file) good.

I will allow that there may be some harms which can result from unlimited copying of anything you want— but they bear no resemblance to the collision of automobiles in the midst of a busy intersection.

Re:Is Alexandra Elbakyan in real trouble this time? by drewmol on Sunday July 04, 2021 @07:34PM (#27733476)
I assume an open intersection or clear path is implied in which case the intersection space becomes non-rivalrous. Automated enforcement w red light cameras change the outcomes however
Re:Is Alexandra Elbakyan in real trouble this time? by samatman on Sunday July 04, 2021 @08:29PM (#27733727)
Probably! If I had to offer a definitive opinion on the author's intention I would agree with this interpretation.

But physical space is inherently rivalrous, and a policy of "everyone runs a red light if they think they can get away with it" is going to have people being disastrously wrong sometimes.

I've actually ridden a scooter in places in SE Asia which basically work this way and it's... different. Less insane than it sounds, or looks like, but the rates of traffic fatality are objectively much higher.

This is why I thought it was interesting enough to comment upon.

Re:Is Alexandra Elbakyan in real trouble this time? by kzrdude on Sunday July 04, 2021 @05:42PM (#27732861)
That metaphor backfirews pretty hard IMO, is that intentional?
Re:Is Alexandra Elbakyan in real trouble this time? by thaumasiotes on Sunday July 04, 2021 @06:11PM (#27733037)
How so? Everyone running a light together is the expected behavior if you change the color of the light. In other words, it describes nothing that isn't occurring constantly everywhere. Where does the metaphor backfire?
Re:Is Alexandra Elbakyan in real trouble this time? by mb7733 on Sunday July 04, 2021 @06:47PM (#27733229)
The metaphor backfires because if everyone runs red lights they will collide with one another, as well as with those going through green lights.
Re:Is Alexandra Elbakyan in real trouble this time? by thaumasiotes on Sunday July 04, 2021 @08:03PM (#27733610)
> if everyone runs red lights they will collide with one another

In the same way that if everyone runs green lights, they'll collide with one another? How do you go through intersections?

Re:Is Alexandra Elbakyan in real trouble this time? by anigbrowl on Sunday July 04, 2021 @10:06PM (#27734106)
Red lights rarely exist in the middle of a road just to slow down traffic, they mainly exist at intersections to allow people on different roads to take turns. It's really not a useful metaphor in this context.
Re:Is Alexandra Elbakyan in real trouble this time? by mb7733 on Monday July 05, 2021 @10:18AM (#27738253)
Green lights... are synchronized to avoid collisions.
Re:Is Alexandra Elbakyan in real trouble this time? by kzrdude on Monday July 05, 2021 @03:30AM (#27735454)
Imagine an intersection with 3 independent entrances. Normally 1 is green and 2 red. If everyone runs red lights, then we have cars entering from 3 ways instead of the normal 1. The result is collisions in the middle of the intersection.

"Running a red light" does not just mean "go when it's red" but it explicitly means "transgressing a stop signal". That there can be stop signals on multiple entrances also is complicating and sets up the crash.

Re:Is Alexandra Elbakyan in real trouble this time? by kergonath on Sunday July 04, 2021 @05:38PM (#27732838)
Doing it and claiming to have done it in a professional setting are quite different though. I am perfectly willing to believe that a lot of researchers use Sci-Hub (though from my experience they tend to use Researchgate more); I am certain that the number of people who would shout about doing it on the rooftops is nowhere near even a small minority.
Re:Is Alexandra Elbakyan in real trouble this time? by enriquto on Sunday July 04, 2021 @06:44PM (#27733214)
What you say does not correspond to my personal experience. As a single data point, in my research group all twelve phd students and five postdocs use SciHub regularly. Some of the faculty don't know it even exists, others do.
Re:Is Alexandra Elbakyan in real trouble this time? by breck on Sunday July 04, 2021 @05:34PM (#27732808)
Courageous, I would say. More important than genius.
Re:Is Alexandra Elbakyan in real trouble this time? by amelius on Sunday July 04, 2021 @07:25PM (#27733439)
If you don't have the courage, you can also do it indirectly: simply reference a paper that states that it would not be possible without Scihub. Then, your paper would not be possible without Scihub either :)
Re:Is Alexandra Elbakyan in real trouble this time? by kergonath on Sunday July 04, 2021 @05:39PM (#27732840)
Yes, that would fit better.
Re:Is Alexandra Elbakyan in real trouble this time? by mcguire on Sunday July 04, 2021 @05:28PM (#27732761)
How so? Might not want to mention it in the same footnote as the grant number.
Re:Is Alexandra Elbakyan in real trouble this time? by jfoutz on Sunday July 04, 2021 @05:41PM (#27732856)
I had a snarky remark about Galileo and Copernicus, but it’s probably not relevant.