News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by TaylorAlexander on Thursday July 01, 2021 @03:13PM (#27703247)
Very upsetting the mindset of a police officer (sergeant!) who will harass someone while listening to a pre trial hearing for an officer who murdered a man having a mental breakdown, and then upon being recorded will attempt to interfere with that recording. Police officers are given extraordinary powers by society and yet they can act like spoiled brats (or worse). Not cool!
Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by slowmovintarget on Thursday July 01, 2021 @03:50PM (#27703758)
Why aren't you upset about YouTube allowing automated removal of videos with zero reconciliation to fair use statutes?

It's YouTube and Instagram that are broken. The right to record is preserved. The ability (not right) to distribute is hampered by these organizations.

Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by darkwater on Thursday July 01, 2021 @03:57PM (#27703880)
Because YT automated removal of copyrighted content here is just the loophole used by the police officer to avoid being recorded and published (which it's a citizen right in the US, according to the article). So it's the sergeant attitude the problem here, he would use another loophole if this one wasn't available.

Why are you trying to diverge the attention spot here?

Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by ballenf on Thursday July 01, 2021 @04:14PM (#27704139)
I think both are fair readings here.

There's even a strong case for a third problem: copyright itself is a tool fundamentally one-sided and OP.

Three different things can all be true at the same time without detracting from each other.

The problem with focusing on just the police here is that there are any number of circumstances where copyrighted audio will be naturally occurring that the issue will require more than just getting the police to refrain from using the loophole.

Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by PragmaticPulp on Thursday July 01, 2021 @04:17PM (#27704191)
The video, including Taylor Swift music, is available on YouTube and has not been removed: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cmZmo81Cdcc

I suspect the idea that they can play music in the background to prevent YouTube views is a misconception about how the system actually works.

Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by slowmovintarget on Thursday July 01, 2021 @04:27PM (#27704336)
Right, the mistake was not playing Hotel California instead.
Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by TaylorAlexander on Thursday July 01, 2021 @04:11PM (#27704078)
I mean, I do take issue with that. But police officers behaving inappropriately is a MUCH larger problem, and so the focus on my concern.
Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by lancesells on Thursday July 01, 2021 @04:16PM (#27704163)
I think you're reaching a little here. There are many, many things wrong with YouTube but just because someone found a hack on attempting to stop things from going viral doesn't mean they are really to blame here.

Also, YouTube is not the internet or the world's preservation archive of video. It's a massive tv station from a massive ad company. I can't imagine there won't be a time where YouTube doesn't start deleting videos that are uploaded to their service just because they are taking up storage. So let's not give YouTube that power.

Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by squeaky-clean on Thursday July 01, 2021 @04:10PM (#27704076)
It's copyright law that's broken. Youtube and etc are just an ugly stack of mismatched patterned band-aids covering a large infected wound that really needs antibiotics and not just bandaids.
Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by deadbunny on Thursday July 01, 2021 @03:58PM (#27703905)
I could be wrong but doesn't YouTube just remove any monetisation from the uploader and assign it to the artist/label if it detects copyrighted music?
Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by sixothree on Thursday July 01, 2021 @06:24PM (#27705634)
Can't a person be upset about both? Why do you need to present a distraction here?
Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by acituan on Thursday July 01, 2021 @04:09PM (#27704056)
I have no doubt you will receive remarks about whataboutism, maybe rightly, but I find this peculiar too.

On one hand there is a personified "evil", which we are very good at handling mentally, dishing out imaginary punishments, righting their wrong etc. On the other hand there is a faceless corporate entity that not only scales massively in their "evil" but also in a way that is not quite intelligible to us right away. And our minds immediately flow to the more graspable object which is the cop, even though the cumulative harm of automated rent seeking is probably greater.

Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by a9entroy on Thursday July 01, 2021 @04:06PM (#27704015)
Because YouTube is doing it at the behest of the public. People voted in representatives that brought laws that force YouTube to do this. Your outrage is misplaced.

You think YouTube has any incentive in this? If it were up to YouTube they would just bring in rules that give creators ample flexibility while still making sure there's no infringement.

Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by nitrogen on Thursday July 01, 2021 @04:13PM (#27704115)
Laws don't force YouTube to preemptively detect and demonetize or remove anything. They chose to do that.
Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by jMyles on Thursday July 01, 2021 @03:36PM (#27703544)
> Police officers are given extraordinary powers by society and yet they can act like spoiled brats (or worse).

I'm not sure the phrase "and yet" is precise; it seems like these are cause-and-effect. This is power corrupting, with the corruption approaching absoluteness as the power does.

Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by TaylorAlexander on Thursday July 01, 2021 @03:49PM (#27703748)
Well, it was a way to be charitable in my rhetoric. Giving the hypothetical police officer the benefit of the doubt that they might be worthy of the powers they are being given. Which, might not actually be powers humans can handle without abuse.
Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by kgwxd on Thursday July 01, 2021 @04:22PM (#27704248)
I don't think it's always cause and effect. People who want power, specifically so they can abuse it, seek it out. If society offers a position of power that lets acting like a spoiled brat go unchecked, spoiled brats will gravitate towards that position.

I often wonder what a police force with a zero-tolerance sobriety requirement, on and off duty, would be like. Is there some places in the world with a policy as strict as that and actually enforces it?

Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by moate on Thursday July 01, 2021 @03:14PM (#27703264)
It's almost like there is a systemic problem within the department...
Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by ipnon on Thursday July 01, 2021 @03:30PM (#27703463)
It seems like the police officer was remaining calm and collected while the protestors were mocking him, interrupting him, and calling him an "asshole."
Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by pempem on Thursday July 01, 2021 @04:03PM (#27703985)
It seems like signing up for a job like being a police officer, and receiving a gun, riot training, interrogation and arrest techniques means that they should be able to handle this without escalating.

Now if a cop was calling you those things and you had all of those weapons and verbally engaged in escalation, i think maybe, you might not survive the encounter.

Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by jdavis703 on Thursday July 01, 2021 @04:20PM (#27704221)
I’ve seen bus drivers treated worse. It’s just a part of working with the public, which is part of being cop. If an adult armed with a gun can’t deal with this, they should seek a desk job.
Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by jolux on Thursday July 01, 2021 @03:35PM (#27703531)
Ever heard of the first amendment?
Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by stale2002 on Thursday July 01, 2021 @03:38PM (#27703573)
They were arrested or anything. So I don't see the problem.
Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by vxNsr on Thursday July 01, 2021 @03:42PM (#27703645)
The OP said the cop was harassing them… the only harassment appeared to be coming from the crowd.
Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by jolux on Thursday July 01, 2021 @03:56PM (#27703852)
Point being, cops aren’t actually allowed to retaliate, or stop you from filming them, just because they don’t like what you’re saying. They are required to let you speak and film.
Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by gowld on Thursday July 01, 2021 @04:01PM (#27703945)
Not entirely true. Disturbing the Peace is an offense that police can respond to.
Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by vxNsr on Thursday July 01, 2021 @04:07PM (#27704035)
Let’s be clear, there was no retaliation. You’re making up laws to be able to claim the cops violated something and thus justify your anger. The truth is the cop is at best misguided about a civil matter (dmca take downs on YouTube) and is attempting to prevent the many people online from raging on him and his family while he attempts to do his job to the best of his abilities.
Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by pc86 on Thursday July 01, 2021 @04:19PM (#27704215)
Attempting to stop the distribution of Constitutionally protected speech isn't retaliation?
Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by vxNsr on Thursday July 01, 2021 @04:23PM (#27704282)
It’s unclear to me how recording something is a first amendment issue at all, let alone a speech issue. TheVerge makes this unsubstantiated claim and many people here accept it, but I struggle to understand how the first amendment protects recording something.

::Edit::

I’m being rate limited due to getting flagged and downvoted so I’ll reply here:

The EFF link keeps calling it a 1st amendment right, but doesn’t actually explain how it’s falls under the first amendment.

The ACLU does much the same thing, tho, they do say it pertains to “information gathering” which still feels like a stretch.

They both also appear to be very clear that it’s about recording police, vs private citizens. Which again, is confusing bec the first amendment doesn’t mention public vs private. I’m not saying it’s not protected, I’m just saying it’s not clear to me how it pertains in anyway to the first amendment.

Regardless of whether it’s protected though, it’s still not retaliation or even illegal to for someone to try to protect their family from an internet mob

Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by woodruffw on Thursday July 01, 2021 @04:34PM (#27704435)
> but I struggle to understand how the first amendment protects recording something.

The public's right to record the police is well established under the First Amendment[1][2]. The Verge doesn't substantiate it because, well, it's conventional wisdom.

[1]: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2020/06/you-have-first-amendme...

[2]: https://www.aclu.org/blog/free-speech/right-record-police-do...

Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by handrous on Thursday July 01, 2021 @04:56PM (#27704761)
> I’m just saying it’s not clear to me how it pertains in anyway to the first amendment.

The EFF link itself links to:

https://www.eff.org/document/eff-amicus-brief-martin-v-rolli...

Among many others, which contain a rabbit-trail of case law to explore.

The ACLU article links directly to:

https://www.aclum.org/sites/default/files/field_documents/20...

Which is a court ruling that appears to be directly relevant to the questions you're asking, and contains a similar rabbit trail of other case law (one "Glik v. Cunniffe, 655 F.3d 78 (1st Cir. 2011)", in particular, is repeatedly cited).

This is what one encounters pretty much any time one asks "why is/isn't [thing] constitutional under [amendment]"? Lots of reading.

The short answer is just, "courts have ruled it so".

Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by gknoy on Thursday July 01, 2021 @04:38PM (#27704486)
'woodruffw beat me to it, but I'll quote from the EFF's page that he links:

"""Federal courts and the Justice Department have recognized the right of individuals to record the police. Although the Supreme Court has not squarely ruled on the issue, there is a long line of First Amendment case law from the high court that supports the right to record the police. And federal appellate courts in the First, Third, Fifth, Seventh, Ninth, and Eleventh Circuits have directly upheld this right"""

They go into more detail in one of the amicus briefs that they link to in the text that I was quoting [0].

0: https://www.eff.org/document/eff-amicus-brief-martin-v-rolli...

Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by jolux on Thursday July 01, 2021 @05:08PM (#27704891)
The state is very broadly not allowed to suppress speech. “People might harass me online if you post a video” is not a very good argument for abridging peoples’ constitutional rights.
Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by TaylorAlexander on Thursday July 01, 2021 @03:48PM (#27703719)
I just watched the video in the article. Seems like everyone is calm. But the man with the gun on his hip seems to be demanding the crowd change their behavior due to some issue with a banner. Whether you call that harassment or not I suppose is a matter of perspective.
Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by sigzero on Thursday July 01, 2021 @03:59PM (#27703923)
Then you watched a different video. The crowd was not "calm".
Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by vxNsr on Thursday July 01, 2021 @03:56PM (#27703860)
That’s not really true tho right? they mock him, they hurl insults, at the end we can hear them telling him he has no life… I understand that we’re now entering a phase of cognitive dissonance, but it’s always surprising to see it so starkly represented.
Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by Judgmentality on Thursday July 01, 2021 @03:33PM (#27703504)
Good on the protestors for calling him out on being an asshole, filming it, and getting the publicity this deserves so we can have a public debate about the manchildren our government protects through qualified immunity.

If the officer really wanted to engage with the protestors, all he had to do was not play the song. The cops care more about protecting themselves than protecting the citizens they aren't even sworn to protect.

https://mises.org/power-market/police-have-no-duty-protect-y...

Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by nextlevelwizard on Thursday July 01, 2021 @04:26PM (#27704315)
>If the officer really wanted to engage with the protestors

It is painfully obvious that he did NOT want to do that. The protestors wanted to engage with him and nitpick on whatever order he had given them. They are acting hostile and trying to land the officer in question in trouble.

Yeah he kind a does it to himself by trying to play the music so the video won't end up on Youtube, but I can only see this as anti police folks having bad blood. When the protestors do anything that prevents their surveilance / recording by the police (like in Hong Kong when they were shining blinding lasers into officer's eyes and into recording equipment that was touted as genious use of technology and civil disobedience. Now that a cop tries something similar they are touted as trouble makers and assholes for simply not wanting to be recorded.

Yes it is a public place and you are allowed to record them but you don't have to bring your phone into their face.

Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by Muromec on Thursday July 01, 2021 @04:37PM (#27704464)
Cops are paid by public and public has a right to know how they are doing their job, so yes, it’s very different
Re:Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video of... by nextlevelwizard on Friday July 02, 2021 @02:12AM (#27708297)
Yes you have the right to know what they are doing, but again pushing right up to their face with a camera is just being a huge dick