News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by Animats on Sunday June 27, 2021 @08:45PM (#27656912)
This is bad. The bill does not define "hate speech"; that's left for later administrative determination. All we have so far is “expresses detestation or vilification of a person or group on the basis of a prohibited ground of discrimination.”

Combining "detestation" ("I don't like you") with vilification ("You're evil") is a concern. The first is legitimate opinion. The second is defamation. For which truth is a defense under US law.

The committee report that fed into this bill [1] is scary. "Finding that certain expression falls within political speech does not close off the enquiry into whether the expression constitutes hate speech."[2] This is at least in part about suppressing political speech on certain issues.

YMCA of Canada proposed a definition: "integrate an intersectional gender equity lens and consider the gendered impacts of anti-Black racism, anti-Indigenous racism, anti-Semitism, Islamophobia and Xenophobia in any definition of “hate” and “online hate”". Think of trying to defend against a claim of that in court.

The Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs proposed the IHRA definition of antisemitism, the one that includes some kinds of criticism of the Israeli government.[3]

This isn't classic hate speech, intended to incite people to violence. Such as "Hang Mike Pence". This is far, far broader.

[1] https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/42-1/JUST/report...

[2] https://scc-csc.lexum.com/scc-csc/scc-csc/en/item/12876/inde...

[3] https://www.jta.org/2021/01/15/global/the-ihra-definition-of...

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by neartheplain on Sunday June 27, 2021 @09:44PM (#27657267)
I suspect anti-white speech would not be considered hate speech according to the YMCA of Canada. An "intersectional equity lens" often implies the redefinition as racism as racism-plus-power, viewing all whites as empowered and all non-whites as oppressed.

We know anti-white speech can and does incite violence, as it did last week in Daytona Beach:

https://twitter.com/gwupoe/status/1409137548899893251

It can also incite white identity politics, which to me is the much bigger problem caused by this sort of law.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by prvc on Sunday June 27, 2021 @09:57PM (#27657330)
>§ 15.1 Every individual is equal before and under the law and has the right to the equal protection and equal benefit of the law without discrimination and, in particular, without discrimination based on race, national or ethnic origin, colour, religion, sex, age or mental or physical disability.

>§ 15.2 Subsection (1) does not preclude any law, program or activity that has as its object the amelioration of conditions of disadvantaged individuals or groups including those that are disadvantaged because of race, national or ethnic origin, colour, religion, sex, age or mental or physical disability.

Indeed, this is covered by the Charter. Confer with "All animals are equal/ But some etc."

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by etripe on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @03:40AM (#27673001)
What seems to be missing from the list of classes is sexual orientation. Is this just how it appears from the outside?
Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by novok on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @07:36PM (#27694779)
It was written before gay rights was much of a thing, I think in the 70s. I'm fairly certain it's there as a normal law although.
Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by TMWNN on Sunday June 27, 2021 @10:03PM (#27657361)
>It can also incite white identity politics, which to me is the much bigger problem caused by this sort of law.

"Part of left's problem is it expects/demands blacks/hispanics to vote on ethnic basis but is appalled when whites do" (<https://twitter.com/JYDenham/status/796345533124186113>)

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by neartheplain on Sunday June 27, 2021 @10:52PM (#27657604)
The quote from the Labour MP is absolutely correct. Doubly so when whites are told that they're always "acting to preserve their own power and privilege", even when they're not, and they've been raised to despise the behavior they feel criticized for doing. This leads to the mindset of "well, if I'm a racist either way, I'd rather be one who actually DOES look out for my own self-interest."

It's a classic Prisoner's Dilemma [0]. I feel this dilemma quite deeply myself. I vastly prefer a society that treats people as individuals, while still condemning racism and teaching its role in our history, but if every other group acts selfishly and I still get called a racist either way, then at the very least I won't be a sucker too.

Lately this manifests in access to education. Consider this excerpt from a Washington Post report on admissions changes at Thomas Jefferson, the nation's #1 high school:

>Eleven percent of this year’s offers will go to Hispanic students, and 7 percent will go to Black students — both representing significant increases. 22 percent of this year’s offers are going to White students — a number that is largely consistent with the past four years, when White students accounted for between 17 and 22 percent of offers extended. Fifty-four percent of offers are going to Asian students, a marked decrease. In previous years, Asian students have accounted for between 65 and 75 percent of all offers.

>The county at large was 60 percent White, 10 percent Black, 20 percent Asian and 17 percent Hispanic in 2020, according to Fairfax government data.

>Still, the sharp decline in Asian representation is sure to stoke controversy in the Fairfax school system, a Northern Virginia district of 180,000 located just outside D.C.

Tensions stoked by "a decline in Asian representation"? What about the white parents, whose children make up 60% of the county but just 22% of TJ students? White students are now the most underrepresented race in TJ admissions, by a lot. The possibility that they might object to this status isn't even considered. In this case, every other big racial group is now openly fighting for their own self-interest, in the courts and the bureacracy, except for whites. How long do we expect this to last?

The solution is to preserve and rebuild trust between people of different racial and ethnic groups, including white people. I don't know how best to do this, exactly, but laws like the one proposed in Canada are probably on the wrong track.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prisoner%27s_dilemma

[1] https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/after-admissions-changes-t...

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by sellyme on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:00AM (#27658277)
> The possibility that they might object to this status isn't even considered.

Presumably because, as you quoted:

> 22 percent of this year’s offers are going to White students — a number that is largely consistent with the past four years

The author for this article has concluded that something changing is more likely to stoke controversy than something remaining more or less the same as it has been for a while.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by UncleMeat on Monday June 28, 2021 @07:30AM (#27660460)
Are you a TJ grad? It has been wild to see so many people form incredibly strong opinions about the school but have no actual connection to it.

The new policy is race blind. It has further improved access for economically disadvantaged students and students with other special needs. That is precisely the sort of result that class absolutist leftists would hope for.

Further, the merit lottery proposal that activists wanted (which was rejected by the school board and decried by critics as racist) would have produced a more representative student body for all races, including white people because it was a lottery system. The thing you are concerned about isn’t a concern.

The conservative white racists already lost at TJ because their normal arguments of “meritocracy” failed them, so they aren’t an especially important political player on the topic.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by neartheplain on Monday June 28, 2021 @08:11AM (#27660829)
I live in DC and read local news. The TJ article was featured in last week's WaPo Metro section. I have a personal interest in the school's academic quality and admissions policy.

>The new policy is race blind.

The old admissions policy was race-blind.

>It has further improved access for economically disadvantaged students and students with other special needs

It has removed standardized literacy and numeracy testing. The test has been replaced with a 7th grade GPA requirement, and opaque "holistic review" which lets county officials paint whatever demographics picture they want. The holistic review is a fig leaf over what many parents suspect to be de facto racial quotas, which are expressly illegal. One group of parents is suing over this: https://pacificlegal.org/case/coalition_for_tj/

EDIT: Yes, and I'd have taken merit lottery over holistic review, per previous comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27569189

What the new process does NOT do is address the root causes which led to low black and Hispanic admissions with the old system, i.e. underperformance on standardized numeracy and literacy tests. A true "class absolutist leftist", which I am not, would address those problems at the root instead of fudging TJ admissions numbers to obscure the issue. Now it looks like the county is preparing more diverse students for success at TJ, which it isn't, because the old race-blind system showed that it wasn't. We've put a thin coat of paint over a bunch of subpar middle schools and support systems.

Under the new policy, TJ will admit more students who are not equipped to succeed in such a rigorous academic environment. In response, either the students or academic standards will suffer. Underequipped students admitted under the new system replace others who in all likelihood would've been better prepared to succeed. This is the problem of affirmative action "mismatch," about which much has already been said: https://harvardpolitics.com/matters-mismatch-debate-affirmat...

>The conservative white racists already lost at TJ because their normal arguments of “meritocracy” failed them, so they aren’t an especially important political player on the topic.

That's quite the laundry list of assumptions.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by UncleMeat on Monday June 28, 2021 @08:38AM (#27661087)
The new process is not perfect and will not address all problems with biased racial outcomes in FCPS education. Many of the activists who support changing the admissions system actually support eliminating TJ entirely and rethinking how access to accelerated education works. Why is there a limit to the number of students who can get these experiences?

However, as somebody who has personal experience working with this for the accelerated programs starting in 3rd grade, it is precisely the same people who complain about policies trying to address inequities earlier in education. This makes the argument that the changing TJ admission policies won't address root issues seem very disingenuous.

If you want to help change inequities in early accelerated education, then there are places where you can help. Since you are local, I'm sure people would love to have you!

I went to TJ. The testing culture there was amazingly toxic and a huge portion of my alumni friends consider our experiences there to be actually traumatic. Not the actual learning, but the testing culture. It has also gotten worse over time, and despite continued high rankings it has become more difficult for graduates to be accepted into top universities. This is true even for institutions like CalTech that famously focus on "traditional" application processes. That's not exactly a ringing endorsement of the TJ test.

I was one of the students whose parents paid many thousands of dollars for test prep, which was structured in the "testing strategies" manner rather than actually teaching any sort of academic material. I do not believe that the TJ test was actually a proxy for merit and I do not believe that the incoming class will be ill equipped to succeed at an accelerated program.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by everdrive on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @01:05PM (#27678693)
It's completely maddening how backwards this thinking is:

> Racism is bad.

> People from the same race have the same traits, guilt (or victimhood) and needs.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by qbat10 on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:02AM (#27662102)
In Europe there have been many attacks by suspected Islamists, the latest one just this week:

https://www.timesofisrael.com/german-police-say-several-kill...

The skin color of the victims is not mentioned in these cases, so I presume they were white. If anyone were to say that white lives matter, he would be branded a racist.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by justbored123 on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:20AM (#27658373)
You are speculating. There's no reason to believe that. So far it only says "hate speech" and nothing about "power" or "white".
Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by jaspax on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:46AM (#27658510)
You're right, there's no reason to believe that. At least, not unless you've been paying any attention at all to the rhetoric and explicit ideological content of "anti-racism" over the past decade and you're able to locate this bill in that context.
Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by prohobo on Monday June 28, 2021 @03:54AM (#27659145)
There are still people who think the woke thing is just a fad and doesn't actually affect anyone.
Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by iagovar on Monday June 28, 2021 @05:46AM (#27659771)
Well, but it does. People loses their job. Maybe you didn't but you know someone who did, or a public figure you like.

Also, it affects personal relationships. It's amazing how my conservative friends unload their thoughts on me, because thy are afraid to speak frankly with other people.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by prohobo on Monday June 28, 2021 @07:54AM (#27660675)
Right, it has psychological effects on anyone who it targets (directly or indirectly). There's a debilitating mental burden that gets put on you when you are constantly trying to defend yourself or others against assailants who don't adhere to any basis in reality or principles. Most likely it's a social problem; the pain of challenging your own community and being alienated. It's also commonly seen in people who have to deal with narcissistic abuse.

Just as a historical anecdote, it was common for the resistance in the Soviet union to have mental health issues because of having to wrestle with all of the propaganda, insane behaviours, accusations and attacks. The Soviets took advantage of that by accusing anyone who had negative views of the government or culture of being schizophrenics and locking them in institutions.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by iagovar on Monday June 28, 2021 @08:42AM (#27661139)
I didn't notice on any of them, but I notice the struggle of being constantly under attack, that's right. I mean, I do notice myself, being a kind of materialist and utilitarian social-democrat in country with a leftist social majority.

Well, maybe a bit of depression for those who have a softer personality.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by jhfyjvxx on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:48AM (#27662695)
If it doesn't affect anyone they shouldn't feel the need to defend it

It's another motte and bailey

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by ergot_vacation on Sunday June 27, 2021 @10:17PM (#27657428)
Agreed. There is a 1000% chance this legislation will be used to muzzle valid criticism of the rich and powerful, both in and out of government. The uncritical crowd here tends to assume anyone critical of hate speech laws just wants to toss slurs at people online, but the reality is that this represents a very real threat to free society on a basic level. Governments are ALWAYS trying to get more power than they need, so that they can abuse that power, and it's the ongoing sisyphean task of the population to push back if they don't want to end up in a dystopia.

Power to muzzle people for saying something mean is power the government SHOULD NOT HAVE. And if they get it, it WILL be abused.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by busymom0 on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:03AM (#27658039)
Every single leader of almost each of the Canadian political parties was caught breaking their own covid guidelines and going on vacations, without masks, hugging and kissing etc. Yet not a single one of them got held accountable. Similarly in UK, the health secretary was caught having an affair the entire time he was telling people to socially distance. Not a single political will ever get held accountable.

But business owners, everyday people were getting arrested and fined. Kitchen chefs were getting fined $300 for not having their mask on "properly" while they operated 500 degree ovens: https://mtracey.substack.com/p/kitchen-worker-not-wearing-a-...

This legislation will get abused so easily against everyday people, I can't believe that anyone thinks this is a wise idea.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by zdragnar on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:19AM (#27658108)
We saw the same in the US with both elected and appointed officials in many of the states with the strictest of mandates, including California, Michigan and New York.

At least CA has a recall election planned for the governor, but if I were a betting man I doubt I would bet on it succeeding.

People of all political leanings seem quick to forgive politicians (from their side) for being human, while average citizens do not receive the same leniency from the government itself.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by neartheplain on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:10AM (#27658078)
>Similarly in UK, the health secretary was caught having an affair the entire time he was telling people to socially distance. Not a single political will ever get held accountable.

In response to this affair, the Health Secretary has resigned:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/newsround/57622888

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by JetAlone on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:52AM (#27658244)
All things considered, holding himself accountable is an honourable thing to do. I don't know if I could trust him to lead a health department again, but I'd surmise he's on the road of redemption in his family and community's eyes.
Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by busymom0 on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:43AM (#27658502)
He refused to resign first. Only after there was significant pressure did he finally do it.

https://www.express.co.uk/news/politics/1454520/matt-hancock...

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by JetAlone on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:47AM (#27658520)
Ah, thank you for further elucidating!
Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by nate_meurer on Monday June 28, 2021 @04:08AM (#27659213)
And to pile on a bit, he also appears to have dumped his wife (and unavoidably his kids to an extent) to run off with the mistress.
Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by busymom0 on Monday June 28, 2021 @06:55AM (#27660214)
Reminds me of 'Professor Lockdown' Neil Ferguson, 53, who resigned from SAGE last year after also getting caught having an affair and breaking his own social distancing policies.

Best part is that back then, this same Health Secretary Matt Hancock was criticizing Neil Ferguson for doing so. Now he's caught doing the exact same thing too. Full circle.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by BoxOfRain on Monday June 28, 2021 @09:16AM (#27661523)
“Rules for thee but not for me” is an enduring part of British social stratification, while I’m glad Hancock’s resigned the time for an honourable exit was months ago. There’s a real notion among members of British high society that they’re exempt from the rules they impose upon little people, and while Hancock’s actions are undoubtedly contemptible I think this is just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to political immorality during the pandemic.

How can we expect people to follow social distancing rules and shoulder the burden of their resulting social and economic harm when the rule’s architects don’t follow them, seeing them as something just for the plebs to obey? It makes a mockery of the law to prosecute private citizens under the Coronavirus Act when the very people responsible for that law show such flagrant disregard for it. It’s like finding out the chief advocate of Prohibition is a habitual pisshead.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by busymom0 on Monday June 28, 2021 @07:38PM (#27669755)
Unfortunately this isn't a "British" thing. This is a human flaw thing and is occurring everywhere including my country in Canada and in US. This is why we cannot and should not be trusting governments with such powers.
Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by Aeolun on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:49AM (#27658222)
I’m curious if you live in the US, and if this is why you feel this way?

I think it’s fairly normal that countries place a restriction on what is acceptable free speech and what goes beyond your right of expression because it infringes on others.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by lodi on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:14AM (#27658349)
That's right; we already have free speech restrictions. Why do we need these extremely vague, extra restrictions, and why now? Nothing in this bill would have prevented the vehicle attack that supposedly prompted this bill.
Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by _fat_santa on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:52AM (#27662755)
American here. The problem I see with laws against hate speech is that "hate speech" is not defined concretely. While the intentions are certainly good, and I agree with the intentions, I disagree with the law because it leaves the definition of "hate speech" as a subjective term that is left up to the courts/prosecutors to define.
Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by AwaAwa on Sunday June 27, 2021 @09:38PM (#27657233)
I moved to this country in the hope of escaping speech controls. To this day, I am not comfortable participating in (easily identifiable) social media, simply because I am worried about when someone will black bag me for (hopefully only) a few days.

I'm sure that won't happen here, but I'll be darned if this doesn't make my PTSD seem like the master plan.

Incidentally even talking about the nations/religions that I moved here to escape from, could be construed as a "phobic" response now.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by busymom0 on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:07AM (#27658061)
I am in the same boat. I immigrated from a third world country where journalists get arrested, women have an ongoing rape pandemic and kids get exploited for labour and thrown to the streets for begging with their limbs chopped off. But a person having lesser melanin than me criticized my country in a similar way, that would be considered hate speech in Canada.
Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by vinay427 on Monday June 28, 2021 @03:51AM (#27659117)
> But a person having lesser melanin than me criticized my country in a similar way, that would be considered hate speech in Canada.

Did you read the pertinent definition of hate speech in this situation? It doesn't include banning the criticism of a political entity in general, and beyond that I would imagine political arguments are not protected grounds of discrimination regardless of the entity. Most hate speech laws try to limit the criticism of people and groups based on specific characteristics, and this one seems no different.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by busymom0 on Monday June 28, 2021 @06:20AM (#27659971)
Just yesterday there were 2 posts on HN:

Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Olympic place: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27598383

The blackout Palestinians are facing on social media: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27645282

In the first case, my women friends are too afraid to speak up because they are afraid of being labelled a transphobic. 3 of my female friends have lost sports scholarships to biological men.

A group of female athletes who are taking their case to the U.S. Court of Appeals are getting labelled "transphobic" simply because they want their Title IX rights (USAToday went and edited her letter without informing them): https://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2021/05/22/transgende...

In the second case, the reasoning provided is "Criticism of Israel is Anti-Semitism. Really.":

https://blogs.timesofisrael.com/criticism-of-israel-is-anti-...

You don't think both of these will also fall under this and get censored? Stating "man cannot be a woman" or "men shouldn't compete in women's sports" is considered transphobic in current climate. Regardless of which side of the Palestine-Israel conflict you fall one, either or both sides can be censored by labelling it as "anti-semitic" or "islamaphobic".

You say: "I would imagine political arguments are not protected grounds of discrimination regardless of the entity." Just wait until the opposite political party gets in power. Also things like abortion and other societal issues are all political in nature. Being pro-life will be considered "sexist". Or being pro-choice will be consider "racist". These laws can be twisted for whichever political side you fall on.

Also once such laws get implemented, give it a few years until those limitations get chipped away on too. Trudeau already did that with gun control. Back in 2011 he ran on "I am not trying to take away your rifles". Then in 2020 he took away those rifles and promised to take away the hand guns. Remember how Alex Jones got censored 5 years ago? Then Tulsi Gabbard got censored 2 years after. Everybody who was okay with AJ's censored 5 years ago is responsible for what happened to Tulsi Gabbard.

Also, I hate to use my skin color and "immigrant" status to make this crucial point which a lot of my other immigrant friends agree on - some government run by a bunch of elite politicians who are immune to everything trying to save me against any criticism/jokes/offense from someone else makes it very patronizing and condescending. This is what we call "soft bigotry of low expectations" which the ones pushing for this lack self awareness to realize. I am perfectly capable of defending myself against criticism/comments/jokes. I don't need some elite politician to treat me like a snowflake. What's really going to happen is that this sort of law will make everyday people self-censor to avoid offending anyone and thus the bad apples of lets say my skin color will exploit to do bad things. It will end up hurting us in the end.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by Chris2048 on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:44PM (#27664972)
FYI, Here is an alternative to USA-today with original letter: https://adflegal.org/blog/louisiana-governor-blocks-bipartis...
Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by vinay427 on Monday June 28, 2021 @08:05AM (#27660770)
> Also, I hate to use my skin color and "immigrant" status to make this crucial point which a lot of my other immigrant friends agree on - some government run by a bunch of elite politicians who are immune to everything trying to save me against any criticism/jokes/offense from someone else makes it very patronizing and condescending. This is what we call "soft bigotry of low expectations" which the ones pushing for this lack self awareness to realize.

First of all, please don't paint everyone who supports a certain policy with a broad brush. I apparently have a relevant skin color and immigrant status (probably to a different country) in common with you, and yet I seem to disagree with you on the general approach. Obviously, I don't support politicians being immune to their own misdeeds, but that shouldn't have a bearing on this legislation.

> You don't think both of these will also fall under this and get censored?

Sure, I understand that this danger exists, but the social ostracizing in the second case seems out of the context of this law, as I understand it, and also (more importantly) out of the context of what I would consider hate speech. I think this can be handled on a case-by-case basis, especially as I see clear potential benefits of this policy. It's straightforward to find hypothetical issues with every policy including ones we support, but that doesn't in and of itself make a strong case against them.

> Everybody who was okay with AJ's censored 5 years ago is responsible for what happened to Tulsi Gabbard.

Are you referring to the Google/Tulsi Gabbard censorship incident? What does this have to do with a hate speech law?

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by busymom0 on Monday June 28, 2021 @07:23PM (#27669635)
I did not "paint everyone who supports a certain policy with a broad brush". I specifically stated:

> a lot of my other immigrant friends agree on

A lot is not the same as all. And based on my anecdotal experience, majority of them disagree with this.

> out of the context of what I would consider hate speech. I think this can be handled on a case-by-case basis

"consider" and "think" being the important words in your comment. So you are agreeing that this is subjective. That's the problem with "subjective" laws. They get twisted to suit whatever political party or affiliations of the judges making decisions want.

Christians not wanting to see Jesus represented as gay in a comedy show will use this power to censor it:

https://www.yahoo.com/entertainment/netflix-ordered-to-take-...

Muslims not wanting to see Allah in drawings will use this power to censor it.

If you are pro-life, you can make the case that abortion is racist based on the origins of Planned Parenthood and number of black babies which are aborted. If you are pro-choice, you can make the case that abortion is part of women's rights and therefore any criticism is sexist.

Similar to the other examples I already stated about women being hurt and called transphobia for speaking out against biological men in women sports or Palestine / Israel censorship. Criticism of China's slave labour Uyghur camps, or lab leak theory or wet markets will (and has been already) get labelled xenophobic.

When asked about whether CCP could be trusted and whether he would commit to ending research collaboration with China, Trudeau responded with "diversity" and about "xenophobia, racism" and attacks on Chinese people:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dqo16fveYD0

So can such government be trusted with "subjective" laws?

As someone else perfectly stated:

> "The true test of any bill of this nature is to hand it over to your enemies to run. If you wouldn't be comfortable with the X administration defining "hate speech", you shouldn't be comfortable with Y defining it either."

And I haven't even addressed the sheer impossibility of enforcement of such legislation on the internet without operating a full spying of citizens. How exactly will one track down online comments on anonymous message boards or alias accounts on social media? It's impossible to achieve without giving the government more spying power resources.

The "porn ban" in India already was a complete failure. Doing the same with speech will end up with the same fate eventually.

Censoring "offensive" things is simply hiding it under the rug. Sunshine is the best disinfectant. More speech to counter the "incorrect" speech is the solution. Let people say offensive things so everyone knows who they are and can counter it with "correct" speech or at least know whom to avoid. Trying to "fine" it will just let them move over to anonymous message boards and even deeper echo chambers. This legislation will create more anonymous echo chambers.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by ayngg on Sunday June 27, 2021 @11:09PM (#27657691)
I certainly hope everyone involved understands how precarious this path they are taking is. It should be well known by now from history that this sort of thing can be very dangerous, but it seems like there is a large part of the population that is more than willing to relinquish liberties for a perceived sense of safety without understanding the potential consequences involved.

Given the current political climate, I don't have much faith in things turning out well.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by lurquer on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:33AM (#27658156)
> It should be well known by now from history that this sort of thing can be very dangerous,

Dangerous to whom?

Not to those in power.

It’s precisely because it’s dangerous that it is so popular; the masses love the idea of their ‘enemies’ being muzzled.

The pernicious aspect is not that people fail to recognize the danger; it’s that they fail to see those in power aren’t actually on their side.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by hndamien on Monday June 28, 2021 @03:07AM (#27658887)
I would say they fail to see the danger, because you have to expect that at some point your enemy will wield the reigns of power.
Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by jollybean on Sunday June 27, 2021 @09:39PM (#27657238)
" left for later administrative determination."

True, and it will unfortunately be weaponized.

Really it's left to the courts and they will do as they please - subject to the kinds of cases that are brought to the, usually by people with agendas.

Since the new Constitution, we're living in a kind of Judicial Supremacy (in other places as well) where the best legislators and lawyers in the world basically don't even know if something is legal when they make it.

It's a giant gaping hole in how our Liberal institutions were founded that's only obvious now in hindsight I suppose. There really needs to be some kind of way for the Legislative and Judiciary to work something out - maybe by presenting test cases for new proposals, advisory etc.. Because as it stands, all of the 'most important things' are decided by an un-elected and 'Council of Elders' behind closed doors, with not nearly the same level of oversight, public or media scrutiny as in Parliament.

In Canada there is a 'notwithstanding' loophole, literally meaning Provinces can just 'opt out' of something being Constitutional, which is another, weird, separate problem.

We should really err on the side of freedom of expression in the law.

YouTube is still free to have their own thresholds, which is also fair.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by prvc on Sunday June 27, 2021 @10:00PM (#27657347)
>Since the new Constitution, we're living in a kind of Judicial Supremacy (in other places as well) where the best legislators and lawyers in the world basically don't even know if something is legal when they make it.

Can you provide some further reading explaining this phenomenon in more detail?

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by jollybean on Sunday June 27, 2021 @11:05PM (#27657669)
I'm not a constitutional scholar, so take with a grain of salt, but in a nutshell, without a 'Constitution' which broadly codifies rights, then laws are interpreted more narrowly - government has more flexibility to 'enact laws'.

But when there is a 'Constitution' that sets a broad but vague boundaries (Canada got one in 1982), then the Courts have significantly more power to interpret laws through the lens of Constitutionality.

After Canada got a proper Constitution in 1982, a bunch of laws that were on the books were overturned by the Canadian Supreme Court.

So things like abortion, civil rights, gay marriage, euthanasia etc. ... we don't actually 'legislate' these things - even if we do - the 'actual rules' are basically going to be determined in the Supreme Court.

Euthinasia is allowed in Canada, not because we legislated it, but because there was a Supreme Court ruling [0] in 2015, which kind of 'flip flopped' on a previous ruling a decade before.

This is from the CBC [1] which articulates some of the changes. In this article they talk mostly about 'human rights' which is good obviously (but you have to think about framing bias). Most conspicuously, they note in the last section the rise of 'Judicial Activism' - kind of an American term, and kind of loaded so a lot of people don't take to it very well, but what they mean is 'more freedom of the courts to interpret the law'.

i.e.

"amounts to a significant transfer of policy making to the courts," especially in an area that could be described as "morality issues."

"The charter has meant that the courts have a major influence on those things in a way they wouldn't have previously," he says.

Some would argue that this is 'how it should be' and that previously there was Parliamentary Supremacy ... except that I do believe something is fairly wrong when we really have no clue if the laws we write are constitutional or not. That makes absolutely no sense.

The courts don't write the laws, but they're ultimately the deciding factor on all the huge issues.

I don't believe that Constitutionality should be the purview of the courts, since it kind of implies they set their own jurisdictional bounds.

In my view - the Courts should only be able to interpret the law as is. If there is a major Constitutional review - that it might get deferred to a different body or process. I don't know what that would be. But not the Supreme Court in the way that it works today.

This is a global phenomenon because a lot of 'new' constitutions are being written.

It's not talked abut a lot, but it's one of the major behind the scenes issues around Brexit.

The EU (as the EEC) established a court called the 'European Court of Justice' (ECJ).

It was never agreed to in treaty that it's laws would be 'supreme' to those of nation states.

But - in hugely impactful ECJ ruling in 1964, the ECJ basically made a constitutional assertion: "Since we have formed a union, and act like one, and since we are the court of he union, then our rulings have supremacy over national courts".

What that means is - the ECJ ruling on a fairly minor case (with huge implications) decided their own jurisdiction: they were the 'Supreme Court' of Europe, and their laws trumped national laws.

Consider how crazy that is: EU leaders never actually explicitly agreed to that. Don't you think, that if your nation was going to enter into a treaty with other nations, and that you're going to hand over a fundamental pillar of sovereignty' - that this would be explicit* and clear in the treaty? With a bunch of parameters? And a referendum?

So who has 'Supreme Power'? The ECJ? Because they said so?

Over time, it's an issue that makes it's way through the various national legal systems. In some countries (France) it's more established. In others, not so much. But there have been further EU treaties since then so it effectively becomes more 'codified' indirectly.

The Germans maintain a kind of 'backstop' to this, in that they believe they have the right to review EU laws in a certain way, and that their Constitution is 'inviolable' but it's still kind of 'up in the air'.

This comes back to the 'Constitutional' issue in an important way since the EU has established their 'Charter of Fundamental Human Rights' [3] - which codifies more strongly all the 'nice human rights things' - with the caveat that the wording is naturally very vague, and gives the courts enormous power over established law.

It wasn't talked about much, but the ambiguity of all of this, and particularly the ECJ's interpretation of this new Charter, mean that there was a kind of 'unspoken war' brewing between UK Courts and the ECJ that was going to happen basically over decades of proceedings. This is partly because the UK doesn't have a formal Constitution with all the 'nice rights' in 'clean, nice sounding paragraphs' etc..

Basically, it's a giant paradox. Everyone wants 'human rights and constitutional protections', but they're generally fairly vague and aspirational documents that some arguably put the entire legal system up for grabs by the institution that has (or 'takes') the power to do it. However much oversight, there's a kind of a back door mechanism to incredible power.

When we say 'Western Liberal Democracy' we usually mean Executive, Legislative and Judiciary with 'equal' powers - the balance of power to stop authoritarianism. (In reality you could throw in the Central Bank and 'free press' as being just as important).

So it's not a small, petty debate, it's kind of foundational material. It's a really big deal.

Finally: huge grains of salt here, I'm not an expert, just a casual observer. I reserve the right to be fully corrected by the many lawyers here on HN.

[0] https://www.justice.gc.ca/eng/cj-jp/ad-am/scc-csc.html

[1] https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/6-big-changes-the-charter-of-...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primacy_of_European_Union_law

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charter_of_Fundamental_Rights_...

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by kashprime on Sunday June 27, 2021 @11:32PM (#27657823)
This is a very good point, policy making in Canada has shifted to an enormous degree to the courts. And the Supreme Court has also been very vocal about choosing its own members too [0]. The BBC had a lecture series [1] on something similar happening in the UK with the creation of their relatively new Supreme Court.

I'm not sure what the solution is, but perhaps provinces pushing back with the Notwithstanding clause will send a signal. It's tempting to be envious of the US and its more circumscribed constitution, but one good thing in Canada is that there's a mandatory retirement age at 75 for Supreme Court judges.

[0] https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/politics/marc-nadon-sup...

[1] https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m00057m9

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by xyzzyz on Sunday June 27, 2021 @11:34PM (#27657836)
Great comment.

> This is a global phenomenon because a lot of 'new' constitutions are being written.

Global, but now new. US was, I think, leading the pack here: its Supreme Court has reworked its entire system in early-to-mid 20th century into something completely different than the original Constitution has intended, with Wickard v. Filburn as the keystone. Then, this "new" constitution has gotten an amendment in form of Civil Rights acts in the 60s, which again have been interpreted well beyond their original intention, often, in fact, as something that's literally opposite of what it actually says.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by AlexTWithBeard on Sunday June 27, 2021 @09:31PM (#27657184)
> integrate an intersectional gender equity lens and consider the gendered impacts of anti-Black racism, anti-Indigenous racism, anti-Semitism, Islamophobia and Xenophobia in any definition of “hate”

... so that saying "all cops are bastards" stays perfectly legal. Unless you're talking about Israeli police, in which case you're stepping onto the shaky ground.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by Zak on Sunday June 27, 2021 @10:15PM (#27657418)
> Combining "detestation" ("I don't like you") with vilification ("You're evil") is a concern. The first is legitimate opinion. The second is defamation. For which truth is a defense under US law.

US law about defamation is even narrower than that. "Animats is evil" is almost certainly too vague to be taken as a provable, or disprovable statement of fact by a court. Even "Animats would steal if he thought he could get away with it" is probably too speculative.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by DanHulton on Sunday June 27, 2021 @10:22PM (#27657453)
What about the second half of that sentence? "...on the basis of a prohibited ground of discrimination", specifically.

"I don't like you because you're Black/gay/Jewish" is an entirely different thing from "I don't like you because you're rich". Specifically, one of these is a prohibited ground of discrimination.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by kevin_thibedeau on Sunday June 27, 2021 @11:23PM (#27657758)
"Men are scum" is now hate speech.
Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by DanHulton on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:12AM (#27658335)
I don't think this is the win you think it is.

That statement has always been problematic, and generally, even the people uttering it know it. Those that don't, who genuinely believe it, well, yeah, that's hate speech. That should be addressed.

Many feminists have been working to address this exact issue with their messaging. Discussions around "toxic masculinity" being the issue, not men themselves, and "Not All Men, but Yes All Women" draw attention to the fact that _enough_ men are dangerous, and enough men allow it, that there's a good chance that any woman you meet has a "harassed by a man" story.

Further, you and I are using the phrase "men are scum" without it being hate speech just fine, since we're using it to discuss an important social point. But using it to vilify an entire gender? Yeah, that's hate speech. You've hit the nail right on the head.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by iammisc on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:44AM (#27658505)
No sorry it's not.

I'm a traditional Catholic man. I'm as far as you can get from a feminist really.

But yeah they have every right to say men are scum and mean it. How stupid can a country get? It might be sinful, it might be pride, but it should be legal.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by wollef on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:17AM (#27658363)
Yes? "$GROUP are scum" is absolutely hate speech.
Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by sellyme on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:12AM (#27658338)
Well yeah, that's the exact kind of needlessly aggressive and divisive rhetoric this is meant to prevent.
Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by icegreentea2 on Sunday June 27, 2021 @11:02PM (#27657658)
A more fleshed out (but perhaps still sketchy) outline of the proposed definition of hate speech can be found here (https://www.justice.gc.ca/eng/csj-sjc/pl/chshc-lcdch/index.h...).

Quoting:

> The bill defines “hate speech” as the content of a communication that expresses detestation or vilification of an individual or group of individuals on the basis of a prohibited ground of discrimination.

> These grounds of discrimination are race, national or ethnic origin, colour, religion, age, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, marital status, family status, genetic characteristics, disability, or conviction for an offence for which a pardon has been granted or in respect of which a record suspension has been ordered.

> In addition, the hate speech would need to be communicated in a context where it is likely to foment detestation or vilification of an individual or group on any of these prohibited grounds.

> Speech that expresses dislike or disdain, or that discredits, humiliates, hurts or offends would not fall within the definition of hate speech. This distinction is intended to reflect the extreme nature of hate speech captured by the proposed amendments.

The prohibited ground of discrimination are inline with existing definitions (this isn't them caving into the YMCA of Canada or IHRA or something...)

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by Animats on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:45AM (#27658204)
That references some decisions of the Supreme Court of Canada. There's an analysis of those here.[1] The Court, in a 4-3 decision, did find that some pamphlets (this was 1990, when people still printed pamphlets) were "hate speech". The court didn't come up with a definition of hate speech. They merely outlined roughly how far the legislature could go in that direction.

So passing the buck to the Court here is evading the issue.

This is a criminal statute. In common-law countries (UK, Canada, US, but not France) there's a general rule of construction that "Criminal law must be clear and unambiguous, so as to give ‘fair warning’." The legislature owes its citizens a clear definition of each crime. They're evading that duty.

[1] http://digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?a...

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by JetAlone on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:03AM (#27658287)
This point in particular makes me wonder about how it can get applied...

> In addition, the hate speech would need to be communicated in a context where it is likely to foment detestation or vilification of an individual or group on any of these prohibited grounds.

Any communication that is negative about a certain group, or even overly positive about one with the implication that it's considerably better than another's could end up contributing to this effect... Who gets to decide it's "likely"?

The right and the left really can't agree on the balance between equality/equity for who's actually vulnerable enough to need these laws to protect their human rights. This will be applied unevenly, maybe even arbitrarily.

When the government collects 16,000 dollars from every person it can fine for this, would social media even be worth the risk, for a poor person? Some rich kid with the right connections could pull some strings, and financially gut a person they disagree with who said something "likely to foment detestation" on their worst day, putting them 5 figures deeper in debt and driving them off social media. And then the ensuing storm foments hate between both groups. Maybe the poor kid gets a gofundme that won't get shut down so he doesn't have to pay it back over the course of many years, if he's lucky.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by AYBABTME on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:45AM (#27658205)
People seem to forget or not know that Canada is already in a grey middle ground where free-speech is limited, and hate speech is considered a crime. And so far, the fact that Canada doesn't take a free-speech-absolutist position on the matter doesn't seem to have led to the unavoidable-slippery-slope that free-speech-absolutists profess it should lead to.

I'm of the opinion that free speech is important but I think absolutism is a red flag, and here is a case where a pragmatic middle ground has proven to work out just fine.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by ping_pong on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:18AM (#27658366)
It's funny how quickly forget about Stephen Harper and how he tried desperately to turn Canada into its anti-thesis.

The same laws that protect speech that you may not agree when your party is in power, protect your speech when the opposite party is in power. And the way things are going with Trudeau, I really don't expect him to survive the next election.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by neom on Monday June 28, 2021 @04:28PM (#27667597)
Speech is not free in Canada. Personally I love it, I know many who hate it.

When is it hate speech?: 7 significant Canadian cases: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/when-is-it-hate-speech-7-sign...

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by bingbingbong on Monday June 28, 2021 @02:45PM (#27665946)
Looking at what goes on inside human rights tribunals (at least in ontario), I don't see how things are just fine. If anything, the tiny population size of Canada means nothing particularly exciting ever happens in Canada..
Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by peytn on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:52AM (#27658247)
How has an entirely new law proven to work out just fine?
Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by ramblerman on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:32AM (#27662496)
Agreed, for example where do the following statements fall.

> There are only 2 genders

> Religion is stupid

> Prophet xyz was a pedophile

> Some religions are more prone to violence than others.

> Men and women are not the same.

> Covid 19 was leaked from a Chinese lab.

-----

Twitter considers some of those hate speech already.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by AzzieElbab on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:52AM (#27662752)
"The Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs proposed the IHRA definition of antisemitism, the one that includes some kinds of criticism of the Israeli government.[3]" - the definition is against equating zionism with fascism and/or apartheid, and against questioning legal status of existence of Israel. The definition is obviously meant to outlaw BDS, and to push diaspora Jews towards taking sides. Other than that no one objects to criticism of Israel, its government, its defense forces, and zionism.
Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by FreeSpeech on Sunday June 27, 2021 @10:18PM (#27657434)
The true test of any bill of this nature is to hand it over to your enemies to run.

If you wouldn't be comfortable with the Trump administration defining "hate speech", you shouldn't be comfortable with Trudeau defining it either.

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by prvc on Sunday June 27, 2021 @10:26PM (#27657467)
There is already an asymmetry codified in the CCRF, as to which groups can be (putatively) protected by this legislation, so the gov't has little to worry about w.r.t. swapping places.
Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by sellyme on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:46AM (#27658511)
> If you wouldn't be comfortable with the Trump administration defining "hate speech", you shouldn't be comfortable with Trudeau defining it either.

I disagree with this. I wouldn't trust the Trump administration with coming up with a list of human rights, that doesn't mean that the only acceptable compromise is that we shouldn't have any.

Your first sentence is solid advice, but I think you've drawn the wrong conclusion from it. It's a totally reasonable stance to be more comfortable with someone who's at least vaguely competent being in charge when discussing a complex and delicate issue.

Perhaps the point you were intending to make was that we shouldn't be comfortable with it being ambiguous enough that it's up to any particular government's definition, rather than being inherently uncomfortable with the definition itself?

Re:Canada to make online hate speech a crime punishable by fine by unishark on Monday June 28, 2021 @07:21AM (#27660397)
> I wouldn't trust the Trump administration with coming up with a list of human rights, that doesn't mean that the only acceptable compromise is that we shouldn't have any.

The point remains the same. If you don't trust Trump (or the simple majority of voters in a given election) with the power to set rights, then you shouldn't give them such power. Rights are supposed to be restrictions on the govt. If the president can define hate speech then there is no right being protected from the govt.