News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by thera2 on Friday June 25, 2021 @11:14AM (#27631815)
The reason their vacation is docked is because the actual punishment they're receiving is an unpaid suspension. But since going unpaid hurts, they take the suspension out of the vacation hours.
Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by djhaskin987 on Friday June 25, 2021 @11:18AM (#27631868)
It doesn't seem so outrageous. I mean, when you move the slider, 20 vacation days for not securing the firearm translates to an enormous fine. Moving the slider all the way to the right the web page reads "4 cases resulting only in a loss of 45 vacation days.". ONLY 45 vacation days. 9 weeks pay is a lot of money, folks.
Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by superkuh on Friday June 25, 2021 @11:25AM (#27631965)
Okay, losing vacation days does imply a significant lack of paid income. But at every other job when you do something that can or does get someone injured or killed you get fired.
Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by vorpalhex on Friday June 25, 2021 @12:55PM (#27633355)
Most jobs don't demand a steady stream of life and death decisions on 12+ hour shifts with terrible pay. The closest would be the medical industry, and typically screwups are disciplined but rarely result in firing.
Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by bluGill on Friday June 25, 2021 @01:15PM (#27633622)
Most police jobs don't demand that either. I know retied cops who never had to make a life or death decision in their job. (except first-aid situations which happen often but are different than this discussion)

It is useful for police to have a gun (but not required!), and they should know how to use it. However that doesn't mean they should use one off the practice range.

Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by jeffbee on Friday June 25, 2021 @01:12PM (#27633580)
The most stressful decision your median NYPD officer faces every day is whether to double-park in the bike lane or in front of a fire hydrant while getting their Starbucks. An MTA bus driver makes 1000x more life-or-death decisions per shift.
Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by thera2 on Friday June 25, 2021 @11:44AM (#27632213)
Not every infraction involves someone getting injured or killed.
Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by athenot on Friday June 25, 2021 @11:50AM (#27632291)
At other jobs, even committing an infraction that didn't injure nor kill anybody but was against company policy is enough to get terminated. It's often a liability issue for the company.
Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by thera2 on Friday June 25, 2021 @11:53AM (#27632325)
And that's still the case here? This is just one more possible punishment. I'm sure if at tech companies workers were receiving docked vacation they would be raging on HN.
Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by moate on Friday June 25, 2021 @12:07PM (#27632557)
Tech workers and police are extremely different types of workers with extremely different job responsibilities, working agreements/contracts, and level of impact on the groups that oversee them. We are not the same by a country mile.
Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by mosselman on Friday June 25, 2021 @11:49AM (#27632284)
One 45 day loss was for breaking a restroom door with a battering ram in a practical joke... pretty harsh punishment.
Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by ch4s3 on Friday June 25, 2021 @12:03PM (#27632480)
Could you imagine doing that at your job and not being fired immediately?
Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by siegecraft on Friday June 25, 2021 @12:37PM (#27633084)
current job? no. a job with a strong union? yes. a startup with a certain kind of work hard/play hard (really just lots of drinking) culture? definitely, there's plenty of stories like this (and worse) in the books.
Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by ch4s3 on Friday June 25, 2021 @01:17PM (#27633642)
Do you think the the people who hold the truncheon of the state's monopoly on violence should have a "work hard/play hard" culture, or union protections that absolve them of consequences when they impulsively act violently?
Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by mindslight on Friday June 25, 2021 @03:13PM (#27635041)
I think people who "hold the truncheon" should be intelligent enough to appreciate humor, yes.

FWIW framing things as if officers' job is to perform violence on behalf of the state is a big part of the problem. The state's monopoly on violence should be in the hands of the courts, and not individual officers doling out punishment. Police officers should be seen as citizens getting paid to do a good job at something that any other citizen could do if so inclined.

Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by ch4s3 on Friday June 25, 2021 @07:13PM (#27637390)
> The state's monopoly on violence should be in the hands of the courts, and not individual officers doling out punishment

I would generally agree, but at the end of the day any state prohibition must eventually be enforced by some level of violence or more mildly, coercive force.

One could write several books about the nonviolent crimes US police have killed people enforcing. And this is my point. The arm of the state must be reigned in somewhere.

Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by mindslight on Friday June 25, 2021 @08:53PM (#27638018)
We're definitely in agreement that the arm of the state must be reigned in somehow. I'm just saying that most violence done by police is not de jure state violence backed up by any legal order, but rather personal decisions on their part for which they should be held personally accountable.
Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by mosselman on Friday June 25, 2021 @02:57PM (#27634880)
Yes. I think a heartfelt appology and an assurance that it wouldn't happen again and paying for damages would come a long way.
Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by lostlogin on Friday June 25, 2021 @11:57AM (#27632400)
Is it? There is more to this story. Was someone in there at the time?

Edit: The list as a whole is horrific. Bullying, racism, sexism, corruption and incidents that resulted in death.

Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by klyrs on Friday June 25, 2021 @11:50AM (#27632295)
If a civilian broke down the door of a precinct bathroom with a battering ram, what do you think the consequences would be? I'm guessing more than 45 days in jail and they'd probably get fired wherever they're employed.
Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by jakelazaroff on Friday June 25, 2021 @12:07PM (#27632561)
This is key. People love to play the "what if the roles were reversed!" game when it comes to race and gender, even though those are just aspects of a person. People choose to be cops; we should hold them to an even higher standard than civilians.
Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by vorpalhex on Friday June 25, 2021 @12:57PM (#27633380)
Cops make $30k a year at entry, work insane hours and are closer to a blue collar labor force than a bunch of college grads arguing about microservices.

If you want to hold them to a higher standard, you have to pay them to a higher standard.

Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by Karunamon on Friday June 25, 2021 @01:11PM (#27633566)
If you want to hold them to a higher standard, you have to pay them to a higher standard.

That logic works when dealing with fast food workers, not agents of state-sanctioned violence. Those standards should be high regardless.

Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by diydsp on Friday June 25, 2021 @01:08PM (#27633528)
Where I live they enjoy outrageous amounts of overtime for guarding telephone pole workers and collect pension after 25 years.
Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by klyrs on Friday June 25, 2021 @01:21PM (#27633725)
Sounds like honest work to me, but this is definitely one of those situations that beg the question, "do we need trained paramilitary personnel to accomplish this task?"
Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by jakelazaroff on Friday June 25, 2021 @01:40PM (#27633966)
What would you say is the salary threshold at which we can expect police to not wantonly assault people?
Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by vorpalhex on Friday June 25, 2021 @02:47PM (#27634779)
In 2015 (latest year I have good data for), there were just shy of 54,000,000 police interactions in the US.

The same year, there were 1,104 recorded police uses of force.

That's 0.00002% of interactions if I did my math correctly. Even if you think the use of force data is a magnitude off, that's about the same risk factor as shark attacks and lightning strikes.

Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by jakelazaroff on Friday June 25, 2021 @03:00PM (#27634907)
Oh, I think your use of force data is more than one order of magnitude off. Police shot and killed 993 people in 2015 [1]. It's a safe assumption that fatal shootings are the tip of the iceberg in terms of use of force, not the overwhelming majority of cases.

And use of force is only one type of lawbreaking in which cops regularly engage. Buffalo News compiled over 700 instances of sexual misconduct by officers over 10 years [2]. Anecdotally, I see police commit traffic infractions all the time.

None of this is really relevant to my question, though, so I'll pose it again: how much must we pay for police officers to obey the laws they're supposed to enforce?

[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/investigations/polic... (filter by 2015)

[2] https://s3.amazonaws.com/bncore/projects/abusing-the-law/dat...

Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by objectivetruth on Friday June 25, 2021 @04:52PM (#27636121)
In the US, the 10th percentile cops earn about 40K a year. Median local cop salary in the US is 65K. And that's the SALARY.

And let me know if ANY cops in the US have ever complained about overtime -- guaranteed overtime and overtime pay rate are often specified in police union contracts and there are tons of articles every year about cops making $100K+ overtime on top of base.

Source:

https://www.bls.gov/ooh/protective-service/police-and-detect...

Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by klyrs on Saturday June 26, 2021 @01:38AM (#27639409)
I'm all for taking nonviolent responsibilities away from ("defund") the police, but I'd rather cops got paid $100k to not work so much overtime. Spend some time with their families, come to work rested, maybe they won't be so trigger happy.
Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by username90 on Friday June 25, 2021 @12:02PM (#27632468)
Alternatively if a civilian broke down a door in a company party likely the only thing would be that they got a bill for fixing the door, which is way less than 45 days of pay.
Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by klyrs on Friday June 25, 2021 @12:29PM (#27632940)
Agreeing with the sibling comment, I'd think that getting fired is the most likely outcome. But what about the occupants of the bathroom? Battering the door down is a violent and threatening act. Do you suppose they might have standing to press criminal charges? Or at least a lawsuit?

Did you know that damage over $1000 would be considered felony vandalism in many states? The door alone probably costs over $1000, not to mention damage to the frame. Looking at prison time and a permanent record here, and in some states, lifetime disenfranchisement.

So yeah. Only 45 days pay is pretty sweet. And if it was a civilian vandalizing and terrorizing a precinct, bet your ass they'd prosecute all of these charges and more to the fullest. Given that this is a violent felony, it could trigger a three strikes law if the perp already had a record.

Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by moate on Friday June 25, 2021 @12:09PM (#27632595)
Or fired. Fired is also a very reasonable thing if someone knowingly broke company property for a laugh. Obviously without knowing all the specifics of the case, IDK which is more reasonable but both are certainly plausible.
Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by long_time_gone on Friday June 25, 2021 @12:24PM (#27632841)
==likely==

What is this based on? Are you in HR? Do you know of examples of this happening?

Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by soperj on Friday June 25, 2021 @11:35AM (#27632088)
they aren't losing 9 weeks pay. They're taking time off with pay, they just don't get to choose the days.
Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by username90 on Friday June 25, 2021 @11:41AM (#27632168)
The article said they lost the days and nothing else happened. Are you saying the article is wrong or heavily misleading?

> In some 89% of the cases made public, reduced vacation time was one of the penalties levied, and in more than 60% of the cases it was the only punishment.

Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by soperj on Friday June 25, 2021 @12:42PM (#27633172)
They are taking administrative leave with pay, and in turn losing vacation days. Aka they're being forced to take vacation days when they haven't planned to use them. They still have time off with pay.
Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by lostlogin on Friday June 25, 2021 @12:04PM (#27632509)
I think I both can be correct. ‘Administrative leave’ is hardly a punishment.
Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by shkkmo on Friday June 25, 2021 @01:20PM (#27633704)
You are misunderstanding the use of "only" here. It is meant to describe which punishments were meted out, not to pass judgement on the severity. Cases where there were other punishments in addition to loss of vacation time are not included.
Re:New Records Show the NYPD’s Favored Punishment: Less Vaca... by IgorPartola on Friday June 25, 2021 @12:00PM (#27632447)
So instead of me choosing when to take a paid vacation the department would choose for me? Sounds like a great way to get Xmas or the 4th of July off if I can’t request it: commit a minor infraction a few days before my desired vacation timeframe knowing the punishment and the time it takes to administer it.