News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by WalterBright on Saturday June 19, 2021 @06:19AM (#27559315)
I've watched all the episodes of Aviation Disasters. The device missing from cockpits is the video recorder. Many investigations revolve around questions like what is the pilot looking at, what the instruments show, even who the heck is in the pilot's seat. Video can confirm switch settings and instrument readouts (the voice recorder is also used to confirm if the warning horns sounded properly).

Instead, a lot of effort goes into trying to reconstruct this.

Just put a dang video camera in the cockpit.

I've also, for decades, advocated a camera that records flight operations at an airport. Just stick a couple in the tower pointed at the runways. Note that in the Concorde disaster, there was no video of the take-off. They had to rely on eyewitness testimony, which is notoriously unreliable. The only video came later from some passenger in a car who happened to have a video cam at hand. That accidental video proved valuable. (It's a horrifying video.)

I was surprised at all the vitriol opposition to pointing a camera at the runways. People confidently told me it would cost millions of dollars, and was completely infeasible. Jeez, anyone could buy a security camera that recorded on a loop for a few hundred. Every convenience store had them.

Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by zeusk on Saturday June 19, 2021 @06:41AM (#27559409)
Couple of issues here; the first and foremost - recording people at their workplace. We can all argue how privacy is unreasonable in public but recording let alone pilots but anyone continuously at work will receive big pushback.

Also video occupies much more data than most other streams of information stored on blackbox. This coupled with the fact that anything aviation related takes decades to get into widespread use and it was only quite recently that solid state storage became so dense and ubiquitous.

Video surveillance at airports is getting more widespread, just search for SFO asiana.

Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by WalterBright on Saturday June 19, 2021 @06:47AM (#27559447)
It's the same issue with the audio recording. The solution is it's in a loop, and those recordings are almost never released.

As for video, VHS quality is about 1Gb per hour. Meaning you can put 64 hours on an ordinary USB stick about the size of my thumbnail. Furthermore, video recording has nothing to do with flying the airplane, so there are no safety/certification issues. It doesn't even have to be in a crashproof box.

I know that airports now have video surveillance, but those cameras are pointed mostly at the tarmac for security purposes, not at the runways for flight ops.

Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by WalterBright on Saturday June 19, 2021 @06:58AM (#27559505)
BTW, I can buy a dashcam for $100 that records HD in a loop and plugs into a cigarette lighter. I'm not buying there's any technical or cost issue with installing one in the cockpit. I will buy that the problems are all bureaucratic in nature.

Just make a secure bracket for it, and a 12V feed.

Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by zeusk on Saturday June 19, 2021 @11:11PM (#27566794)
If you have that to add, I am pretty sure you don't have any formal experience with aviation.

Even the nuts and bolts that go on aircraft can cost >$100. The problems are not all bureaucratic, and I get HN's hate of bureaucracy but for life-and-death matters - I'd rather default to caution than move fast and break necks attitude of SV/Tech.

Just to give you an example, lookup the swissair in-flight entertainment fire incident. Tacking couple of screens and media server onto an existing plane should be fine right? turns out not really and 215 people paid the price of that decision with their lives.

Privacy aside, being watched does affect decision making.

If you think recording people at their jobs will make things safer, why not apply it for the least safe mode of transportation first - why doesn't the gov/NHTSA mandate a video and data recorder in your car and the police and insurance can take a look at it next time you crash to decide who/what caused it.

Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by RogerL on Sunday June 20, 2021 @02:12AM (#27567587)
> If you have that to add, I am pretty sure you don't have any formal experience with aviation

Walter Bright is an aerospace engineer, programmer of flight critical systems of airliners, son of Charles Bright. You are way off on your accusation.

citation: https://www.amazon.ca/Jet-Makers-Charles-Bright-ebook/dp/B00...

Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by theamk on Sunday June 20, 2021 @12:58AM (#27567210)
No need for video recording on general aviation, but a public transport is a completely different thing.

Any time I enter a bus in my town, I see that it has a number of cameras, which point to the road, to the passengers, and to the driver as well. Why should a plane be different?

Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by wolrah on Monday June 21, 2021 @12:22PM (#27580697)
> Just to give you an example, lookup the swissair in-flight entertainment fire incident. Tacking couple of screens and media server onto an existing plane should be fine right? turns out not really and 215 people paid the price of that decision with their lives.

I'm not super familiar with this one, but based on a quick skim of the TSB report (http://www.tsb.gc.ca/eng/rapports-reports/aviation/1998/a98h...) it looks like the issue here was not the IFE itself but a poor installation that significantly differed from the certified configuration and resulted in chafing on power wires.

It's also worth noting that this happened in the '90s when networked personal IFE systems were still in their infancy. It's 2021, there are no unsolved problems in installing a few cameras in an aircraft. A lot of them already have cameras accessible through the IFE, putting one more in the cockpit and a hardened DVR in the back isn't exactly rocket science.

Yes, aviation stuff often has a few zeroes added on to the price tag for good and bad reasons, but we're basically talking about a dashcam here. Low triple digit prices for non-aviation hardware, so even if you multiply the price times 100 it's still not really significant compared to the cost of an airliner.

There are no good technical reasons to not have video.

Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by perl4ever on Sunday June 20, 2021 @02:13AM (#27567595)
>why doesn't the gov/NHTSA mandate a video and data recorder in your car

The automakers were already "voluntarily" putting EDRs in cars, so no need to mandate it.

From 15 years ago, standards were set so that data can be retrieved after an accident and such:

https://www.nhtsa.gov/sites/nhtsa.gov/files/fmvss/EDRFinalRu...

Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by jacquesm on Saturday June 19, 2021 @10:15AM (#27560613)
No, if you're a pilot in charge of a few hundred lives + the lives of a few hundred more in case you crash on the ground your 'privacy at work' is trumped by the responsibilities you have taken on. That's not a good argument. What is a good argument is that people might behave different if they believed that there would be consequences for their actions, and this might either be a negative (if they don't act for fear of repercussions) or a positive (if they don't perform acts that could endanger the aircraft knowing that these are recorded).
Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by chrisseaton on Saturday June 19, 2021 @08:17AM (#27559835)
> recording let alone pilots but anyone continuously at work will receive big pushback

I think we can say that when you have hundreds of people's lives in your hands you are accepting a higher level of oversight and invasion of privacy.

The same reason some people in some careers have to go through deeply invasive background checks.

Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by tomrod on Saturday June 19, 2021 @08:46AM (#27559996)
We record bus drivers, for goodness' sake. We should be able to record pilots.

I agree that a hardened process relying on multiple SSD (that are then uploaded and wiped after landing at an airport) would be a good technical direction.

Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by Anarch157a on Saturday June 19, 2021 @11:33AM (#27561373)
This already happens. At least here in Brazil, offices have security cameras in pretty much every environment, except the restrooms.

An office is a shared environment, usually not owned by the people who work there, that exists only for job related activities. Just like companies can monitor your company issued email, network traffic and cell phone, they can monitor your activities in the workspace.

I'm a privacy advocate, I avoid Google and Facebook as much as I can, but even I understand the difference between private and professional life. One has an assumption of privacy, the other doesn't.

Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by algorias on Saturday June 19, 2021 @02:03PM (#27562767)
Note that this is not the case in all jurisdictions. In many European countries, the company cannot monitor employees' corporate emails without specific justification.
Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by willis936 on Saturday June 19, 2021 @08:31AM (#27559908)
There isn't an inch in Taipei that doesn't have a CCTV on it.

In the US I see cameras at every gas station, donut shop, drug store, liquor store, and lab I go into. None of these places are as high stakes or high security as an airport.

Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by glycine on Saturday June 19, 2021 @08:00AM (#27559761)
why we cannot just delete record when airplane take off next time? if airplane landing safely, we do not need record anymore.
Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by RogerL on Sunday June 20, 2021 @02:27AM (#27567664)
> Couple of issues here; the first and foremost - recording people at their workplace. We can all argue how privacy is unreasonable in public but recording let alone pilots but anyone continuously at work will receive big pushback.

Casinos do it. Banks do it. Convenience stores do it. The TSA records it's workers and you when you go through security. This doesn't seem like much of a hurdle.

For example: https://www.jwincorporated.com/projects/ohare-international-...

Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by rabeener on Monday June 21, 2021 @10:12PM (#27587218)
You’re arguing against monitoring equipment in the cockpit in an article that’s about people arguing against monitoring equipment in the cockpit. Thanks for making me laugh today. I appreciate you.
Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by bregma on Saturday June 19, 2021 @07:13AM (#27559566)
"If the people in the cockpit aren't doing anything wrong, they have nothing to worry about".
Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by abraae on Saturday June 19, 2021 @07:49AM (#27559712)
A reasonable argument for stoners lighting up in the supermarket carpark.

Not so for someone flying several tons of metal that will absolutely fuck up the lives of many people if they aren't paying full attention.

Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by josefx on Saturday June 19, 2021 @10:12AM (#27560592)
> Jeez, anyone could buy a security camera that recorded on a loop for a few hundred.

It probably isn't that easy, at least for the runways. Remember that Uber crash where they tried to convince everyone that the cyclist was near impossible to see? The dash cam used to record that video was standard, but also completely unable to handle even a well lit road at night. Good cameras and the weather proofing they need out in the open (they should still work after a snow storm) will cost a lot more, probably not infeasible but still a decent amount of cash.

Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by dwild on Saturday June 19, 2021 @11:04AM (#27561043)
> the weather proofing they need out in the open

He suggest to put one in the tower. There's no need to weather proof anything, or else poor controllers ;). In theory the tower see the runways well enough, or else the airport isn't well designed and the tower doesn't fill its own purpose.

> The dash cam used to record that video was standard, but also completely unable to handle even a well lit road at night.

Weren't we still able to see the cyclist? Weren't we able to boost the contrast to see her even better?

Sorry for the sarcasm, but even the worst camera show more than no camera at all... You can't argue that seeing a cyclist badly is worse than not seeing that same cyclist at all.

All it takes is a 100$ camera and you would get so much more evidence.

Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by RogerL on Sunday June 20, 2021 @02:34AM (#27567699)
These cameras are everywhere. I've been doing this stuff in one way or another since 2008 or so. Did it for the Air Force (mounted on the tower) and for more commercial applications. It's a solved problem, and it is not particularly expensive.

Surely you've seen CCTV or other cameras in an outdoor enclosure before? You are being tracked from parking lot to boarding in some airports. We can put a few cameras up to watch the runways and taxiways.

https://airportimprovement.com/article/new-camera-system-ena...

Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by the-dude on Saturday June 19, 2021 @07:06AM (#27559534)
Although I don't necessarily disagree with your arguments, using security cameras on the tower would probably give you very little : the distances are huge.

Imagine the footage of the average shop robbery, which most of the time is already useless. And UFOs.

Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by WalterBright on Saturday June 19, 2021 @07:10AM (#27559550)
It'll tell you the positions, directions, and speeds of the traffic on the runways, which are a big deal.
Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by the-dude on Saturday June 19, 2021 @07:20AM (#27559596)
Don't they have ground radar for this?
Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by WalterBright on Saturday June 19, 2021 @07:27AM (#27559621)
Maybe they do now, at some airports. Radar is far, far more expensive than a dashcam set in the tower.
Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by ajarmst on Saturday June 19, 2021 @11:22AM (#27561252)
It would be less useful than you’d think. Pilots are trained to articulate what they are doing and generally follow very well-practiced procedures. Another pilot can quite accurately reproduce what a pilot is doing just from the transcript, and the warning horns and other indicators are quite expressive of other things. The audio is good enough to hear breakers opening. Anything a video camera could see out the window that would be relevant will be remarked upon by pilots.
Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by wizzwizz4 on Saturday June 19, 2021 @12:00PM (#27561628)
In the vast, vast majority of cases, yes. However, black boxes are only used in the minority where something has gone horribly wrong.
Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by WalterBright on Saturday June 19, 2021 @02:21PM (#27562940)
I've watched enough Aviation Disasters to know this isn't always good enough.
Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by ajarmst on Sunday June 20, 2021 @01:06AM (#27567254)
Which episode has a crash that (1) they failed to find a primary cause for and (2) would have been solved had they had video?
Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by unishark on Saturday June 19, 2021 @08:26AM (#27559884)
I have no doubt that it would cost millions. If it's important enough to do, it's important enough to spend extra on a (supposedly) reliable and secure system with some massive 24/7 maintenance contract. Unlike convenience store cameras that can just use off-the-shelf products and still deter criminals by just being there even when broken.
Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by bruce343434 on Saturday June 19, 2021 @07:39AM (#27559664)
If I was a pilot I'd hate to be constantly surveilled by a camera, even if the footage is "never reviewed". In fact, it's got nothing to do with being a pilot.
Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by fakedang on Saturday June 19, 2021 @07:58AM (#27559752)
If I was a private pilot, sure (and I am one). If I am a commercial pilot ferrying hundreds of passengers or millions of dollars worth of cargo, I'm no different from a public transit employee (or a public employee for that matter), in which case I damn well have to put up with being surveilled on camera.
Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by garaetjjte on Saturday June 19, 2021 @12:40PM (#27562002)
>even if the footage is "never reviewed"

Why the scare quotes? It would be literally never reviewed unless incident occurs, as it would be on overwriting loop.

Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by missedthecue on Saturday June 19, 2021 @10:39PM (#27566634)
I don't even see why it would be network connected. You could make it in such a way that the only method to view the video is to open the black box.
Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by dwild on Saturday June 19, 2021 @11:12AM (#27561139)
I can see the privacy issue, but your voice is already recorded. A camera wouldn't infringe that much more on your privacy...
Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by gccs on Saturday June 19, 2021 @07:56AM (#27559747)
Don't buy a Tesla then. They have cameras pointing at you and recording while driving.
Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by bigbillheck on Saturday June 19, 2021 @09:35AM (#27560349)
> Don't buy a Tesla then

Way ahead of you on that one.

Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by astrange on Saturday June 19, 2021 @08:25AM (#27559882)
So do taxis, and any other car with driver assistance (though those don't save the video, they just watch if your hands are on the wheel.)
Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by ericd on Saturday June 19, 2021 @09:43AM (#27560398)
That’s opt-in, at least in the US, and for the moment.
Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by cj on Saturday June 19, 2021 @10:28AM (#27560694)
(Just curious) what features become unavailable when you opt out? Or in other words, why would anyone opt in?
Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by ericd on Saturday June 19, 2021 @08:50PM (#27565990)
I didn’t look too closely, since I just wanted to make sure it was off, but iirc they said they only upload the footage around the time of a crash to see how effective the safety systems were, and to get a sense of what to improve”. Basically one of those “please waive your privacy in the name of science” types of deals. Didn’t dig through any privacy policies, though, I’m sure Googling will yield a better answer.
Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by bruce343434 on Saturday June 19, 2021 @01:47PM (#27562596)
I'm not gonna?
Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by beebeepka on Saturday June 19, 2021 @11:17AM (#27561197)
Haha. Even public transport has had cameras for years.
Re:The inventor of the black box was told to drop the idea by gaucho32 on Saturday June 19, 2021 @05:58PM (#27564870)
Dude, every single mishap since airplanes became reliable was pilot error at the root. It's never not pilot error. The FAA is a jobs program, similar to the old TVA, and note that all mechanics and pilots are still unionized. Governments have ensured that there will be no meaningful innovation in air breathing aviation, hence the space race...go ABOVE the bureaucrats.