https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pointing_and_calling
I think it works by recruiting more of your body & brain to the task of attending to something.
Maybe the anxious could video themselves doing it, and watch it back later.
For a while I used to greet people with the greeting they’ve just given me: they say “hello”, I also say “hello”, they say “good morning”, I say “good morning”. Fine until my sister greeted me with “happy birthday”, though I did at least notice and stop myself after one syllable.
More seriously was when I was following a different automated greeting. I was in hospital with testicular torsion and the doctor asked “how are you?” — my polite British “fine thanks how are you?” was entirely out of my lips before I realised that this answer was not there one I wished to give and I had to add “well expect for this…”
When I'm not able to stop myself I have been forced to say, "happy birthday ... to me". Others must think this silly reply means it's more like too many birthdays.
Me: You too.
Me (literally done this): You too! <smack forehead />
- Samuel L. Jackson's character in Long Kiss Goodnight
I also do this for keys, wallet, phone, sunglasses, and have Tile on everything. ADHD = expert mob cleaner: body disposal-division
Is there a way of using point and call, or a similar method, for helping with that?
Point at pill bottle. Taking my pill on Saturday.
Or something like that?
Works with lots of other stuff, like hot stove tops. It can be a bit infantilizing to the other party unless they're also au fait and on-board with the technique.
One of my roommates in college was carrying in groceries, put his keys down on the counter, and went out to get a second load. I was reading a book, passed the door, locked it, and walked upstairs, completely oblivious, stranding my roommate outside.
They referred to this as "getting Lars'ed out" from then on.
It actually worked out quite well!
Drives my wife crazy.
It all passes the wife-test too!
I replaced everything with LEDs and stressed that the price of leaving the lights on was less than being 2 minutes later to work and absolutely nothing compared to getting fired for being late.
Which is great, except for the time I got a phone call as I was leaving the car and forgot the keys in the ignition. Gotta stick to the routine for it to work!
You'd expect this would transfer to the "well, are you sure you counted", but I'm never actually anxious about that. I think it works similarly to mnemonics, where the simple act of making a mnemonic for something makes it memorable, and it doesn't matter if it's a good mnemonic or not. In this case, I have "proof" I have done the things that make me anxious, and it doesn't matter if it's "good" proof or not, I just don't feel the anxiety.
When I'd leave the house in the morning, there were always five things I needed to have with me: Wallet, phone, badge, glasses, and smokes.
Once a month or so I'd get to work and realize I had left one of these at home. It was a tragedy to be caught an hour from home without my phone or glasses. It was annoying to be without my wallet, cigarettes, or badge.
So I decided to regiment this. Wallet always in the front right pocket, badge always clipped to belt, phone in left back pocket, cigs in front left pocket, and glasses in my backpack. I would pat each location and say out loud, "wallet, badge, phone, smokes, ... glasses".
It didn't work. I quickly just went through the motion of patting and saying without actually verifying the fucking things were there. The first time I forgot an item was a mini existential crisis. ("If I can't account for these simple EDC items when I'm trying to, what hope is there?")
WFH has solved the badge issue. ApplePay mitigates the wallet issue. Glasses are still forgotten sometimes, but my eyesight isn't that bad when I'm out and about (it was only terrible to be without glasses when I worked at a computer in an office). So I guess the situation just solved itself.
I only need to confirm my e-cig is with me. Everything else is either I remembered it or "oh well". And if I quit that, then I'm free :)
Not always going to work but if I need to remember to bring a bag with me I put my car keys in the bag; harder to forget.
Nowadays, maybe an electronic lock would be an easier solution, though I'm not sure that would satisfy the urge to be sure it was locked, would he trust it?
Me, being unused to how their alarm worked, was unsure if I set it.
I set the alarm, locked the door, hear it beep, waited outside until it stopped beeping, then I thought to myself "was the alarm really on?". I unlocked the door, opened it, setting off the alarm, which I turned off with my code.
Goto 10
This repeated a few times until some larger alarm somewhere else in the house started blaring loudly that could probably be heard across the neighborhood. So I disabled it one more time, and just left it well enough alone since I couldn't get out of the loop without some other way of verifying things.
Since this is Hacker News, I'm surprised that you haven't come up with some more elaborate system, e.g., properly locking the door closes a circuit, and you can check the status of the circuit remotely.
My wife and I had the exact same response to the baby wearables or gadgets that promised to tell us if our baby was still breathing up in her crib. We weren't worried about that, so the notion of adding something that would almost-certainly be a flaky indicator seemed guaranteed to increase anxiety.
Because I stick to the 'mental rules' of only rubbing it off once the task is completed, if I'm uncertain if I've done the thing / task I can look down to my hand to see if that mark is still there or not. If it is - U-Turn time!
It Works pretty well (as always, mileage may vary) even for multiple things if needed although the random letters/marks on the back of your hand can make people curious but if it does I simply say - It's a list of stuff I need to do.
Field Notes has been my favorite, though I'm experimenting with different brands. Pentel Kerry is my pencil.
https://fieldnotesbrand.com/products/original-kraft
https://www.jetpens.com/blog/pentel-sharp-kerry-a-cool-mecha...
Field Notes 3.5" x 5.5" notebooks are the size of a folded index card with only a few pages in them. So they comfortably fit in my pocket. Staple bound is relatively weak, but their relatively cheap price means that you can just keep buying them as they wear out (moving your legs / walking / etc. etc. slowly weakens the paper and tears it apart).
Realistically speaking, a Field Notes 3.5 x 5.5 is well balanced: I seem to run out of space roughly as the staple binding wears out. (I know people don't want to "waste paper" but.... I haven't found a good strategy for that. The small size and "disposable" nature of these Field Note books are superior in my experience)
Pentel Kerry is a "shrinking" pencil. It has a small size when its stored, but when you pull the cap off and put it on the back, it "grows" slightly and has a better balance for writing. Its a very slight effect, but the "smaller stored size" makes for a nifty pocket-pencil.
---------
> I make a mark on the back of my hand in ball-point and ONLY rub it off when the job is done. Eq (using your example) if I knew I had to lock a door on the way out I would write either an 'L'(ocked) or a D(oor) on the back of my hand.
Never erase in your pocket notebook (despite using a pencil). Just add more information later: cross out old information with new dates, if you're out of space write down a page-number where you can see more information on a particular subject.
I will say that after going through CBT and becoming an amature expert on OCD as a sufferer, a therapist would argue that this behavior of checking your photo is a form of compulsion. It works for dam sure but you're never really going to be able to go to sleep without some form of checking when the obsessive thoughts start.
Anyone who has gone through treatment knows the ultimate goal is to weaken the reaction of the obsessive thoughts which is what exposure therapy is all about.
Just a quick story, my laddering technique for achieving peace was to eventually get to a comfort level where I can sleep with the door wide open all night. Well, I didn't get that far but I did sleep with all my doors unlocked for a couple nights.
Lastly, I can safely say that I now check all my doors once these days with the exception when I'm stressed at work. I'll check them once before going to bed and if I brush my teeth between checking the door and actually walking to bed, I might check them once more. But this is a seldom occurrence these days.
But what seems to have cured me for good is having children. I'm just waaaay too tired now to even consider going back to check the door. Screw it, what am I gonna do? Oh dear, baby #1 was sick on me again. Hey, baby #2, don't run off without me! Baby #1, put that hat back on again. No more snacks until it's back on. Baby #2, what did I say about running off? What is it I was worrying about? Can't remember. Goto 1
You've illuminated the key point I think. I struggled with this as well, and finally just forced myself to abandon the door, and struggle with the feelings. If you can do it ONCE, it gets easier from there. I admit I was a light case compared to the hair dryer, but the more times you can push through the compulsion -- with the aid of whatever tricks you can come up with -- the easier it gets.
I still remember one time when I was staying at a friends place in a different city, I took his key to get back early and the key broke in the lock so he came back to me trying to get the bit of key out of the door so someone else could open it. We were all very drunk. It was quite traumatic!
Not to mention the potential of having someone lock you inside, taking the key, and then something bad like a fire happening while you're stuck.
That being said, for a door all your objections are pretty reasonable, the only use for key-retaining locks I know of is fairly specialized, but interesting in how similar it is to the reminders people dealing with OCD use.
Totally did backtrack unreasonable distances just to check if I had closed the door.
It's all fine when it's my door. Worst case scenario, I get robbed.
However it's more of a problem when it's someone else's door. Worst case scenario, they get robbed, and that's a different story. Or pets get out...
Obviously I can't take the door on my front seat... So my solution is to take a picture of me trying to open the door, a kind of proof that it's closed.
And, would you know it, it works! When I get anxious, I pull out my phone and look at the pictures.
It's getting better, actually. I believe I'm fixing it slowly. Good riddance!