News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by myfavoritedog on Friday June 11, 2021 @11:37AM (#27474769)
4. Excludes motor vehicle manufacturers, manufacturer of motor vehicle equipment, or motor vehicle dealers and medical devices or a digital electronic product or embedded software found in medical settings.

For all the bravado about standing up to powerful interests, this shows you who the most powerful interests are in that space.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by kwiens on Friday June 11, 2021 @11:58AM (#27474988)
We excluded autos because the Massachusetts auto right to repair bill (most recently updated in November) covers this, and there's a nationwide MOU. Tesla is the only manufacturer that has not signed this MOU.

There is a lawsuit around that ballot initiative, and iFixit and EFF just filed an Amicus on Monday supporting the law. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2021/06/eff-files-amicus-brief...

Sometimes it's better to fight the giants one arena at a time.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by t-writescode on Friday June 11, 2021 @06:50PM (#27479470)
What about farm vehicles?
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by jonny_eh on Friday June 11, 2021 @04:27PM (#27478031)
What about "digital electronic product"? Doesn't that exclude phones and laptops?
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by kube-system on Friday June 11, 2021 @04:53PM (#27478341)
There's no comma after that phrase indicating that it's a separate item in the list.

I believe that is intended to be read as "digital electronic product or embedded software found in medical settings."

After all, the description of what the bill does apply to is "digital electronic equipment". Interpreting it to apply to "equipment" but not "products" doesn't really make sense.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by kwiens on Friday June 11, 2021 @08:32PM (#27480176)
Correct. That exemption is for medical equipment.

California's Right to Repair bill, which got very close to passing this year, was solely focused on medical equipment. https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billStatusClient.xh...

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by slim on Friday June 11, 2021 @03:54PM (#27477686)
What you said does not make any sense. What's the problem if the law is overlapping ?
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by efnx on Friday June 11, 2021 @04:12PM (#27477869)
Instead of fighting the auto industry giants over this bill, they left them out - that way they can focus on fighting the info industry giants.

The auto industry giants are still being fought - just not over this bill.

I think that if the laws overlap it will be opposed by multiple industry giants and will be harder to pass. At least that’s what it seems from the post above.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by toomuchtodo on Friday June 11, 2021 @04:25PM (#27478011)
Divide and conquer. Attack each enemy on a separate front.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by fitchjo on Friday June 11, 2021 @11:50AM (#27474896)
Am I being a bit naive to think that this has more to do with public safety? In theory, there is some increased level of regulation/review of the car and medical device manufacturers that limits the risk these repairs aren’t done to an appropriate standard? You can make a trade-off between standard of repair and price for your iPhone that only impacts the device, but cars and medical devices not properly repaired could impact a life.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by joshspankit on Friday June 11, 2021 @12:34PM (#27475423)
You’ve used a grey argument. Apple themselves have argued that one of the reasons they have to limit repair is for public safety (someone could have a battery explode if they pierce it, for example), whereas we could also argue the other side: that if someone modifies their own medical device and gets hurt because of it that they legally only hurt themselves because they had the right to make that choice.

IMO it comes down to this: do we advocate for laws that give companies the ability to decide what is right/safe for the public, or do we advocate for laws that reflect trust in the individual?

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by Wowfunhappy on Friday June 11, 2021 @01:25PM (#27476098)
> IMO it comes down to this: do we advocate for laws that give companies the ability to decide what is right/safe for the public, or do we advocate for laws that reflect trust in the individual?

This is a really great way to put it, and it applies broadly to so many fundamental disagreements in the tech world.

I firmly believe it’s better to trust the individual—so I think users should be able to sideload iOS apps (only if they want to) and install their own root certificates. Others think individuals can’t be trusted, and so we should let tech companies dictate what is safe for everyone else.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by sneak on Friday June 11, 2021 @02:33PM (#27476932)
I agree that individuals should control their own devices.

I also agree with Apple's implicit claim that if iOS users could sideload apps, millions of idiot iOS users would get their devices owned after they followed some "follow these seven steps to get free $POPULAR_MOBILE_GAME tokens!" guide they found on the web, making the platform less trustworthy overall.

Apple makes a good argument that buying an iPhone is also buying, in a sense, a remote managed security service for the device at the same time. The net effect of this is that millions of people now have devices mostly free of the most egregious malware (and it's limited to just spyware, delivered via the App Store). For most users, this is a better state of affairs (at least in peacetime, or outside of China/Vietnam/Russia/etc).

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by wernercd on Friday June 11, 2021 @03:06PM (#27477264)
and yet, despite occasional problems, the same hasn't happened in the Android sphere with sideloading. Problems? Sure... but not "ZOMG MILLIONS!"

"Apple makes a good argument" Their argument doesn't give near enough excuses for their mafia level racket to shake down businesses of protection money. "Pay us or Joey will break your kneecaps. Its for your own protection."

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by sneak on Friday June 11, 2021 @03:09PM (#27477285)
> and yet, despite occasional problems, the same hasn't happened in the Android sphere with sideloading. Problems? Sure... but not "ZOMG MILLIONS!"

Millions of Android devices have malware problems, yes. I might even agree with a claim that it is ZOMG millions.

Estimates claim that as far back as 2016, a million new Android devices were being infected with malware per month. The current figures are estimated by AV vendors at 4-7 million infections per month.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by joshspankit on Saturday June 12, 2021 @01:10PM (#27485839)
Hot take: it seems more like “This disorder is a blemish on our glossy surface. We must sweep it away so that it no longer exists.”
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by Dracophoenix on Friday June 11, 2021 @03:01PM (#27477218)
It's only a good argument if you assume that Apple is fundamentally interested in consumer security. It isn't. Apple is fundamentally interested in control. Security, however Apple defines it, is a chosen means to the extent that is fulfills the company's primary goal. That's not to say that Apple should behave like a charitable force. A company's goals and decisions are its own prerogative. But as we've seen with the revelations of the Epic trial, the Darth Vader-style rule changes, updates that interfere with the basic operation of the device, etc., you're not just buying into a remotely managed system like a remote desktop at a colocation center. You're buying into the blackbox of Apple's present and future business decisions whether that suits your needs or not. Should security no longer justify the cost to Apple, they'll contort the meaning of the word to suit their ends just like Tim Cook has done to the word "equal" during his congressional hearing.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by sneak on Friday June 11, 2021 @03:04PM (#27477245)
> You're buying into the blackbox of Apple's present and future business decisions whether whether that suits your needs or not.

You don't have to install updates.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by Dracophoenix on Friday June 11, 2021 @03:23PM (#27477416)
You can't downgrade/upgrade the OS to a specific version of an update after a fortnight or thereabouts. That's an artificial constraint applied by Apple. It's not even possible to do so offline with iTunes even if one has the IPSWs. If you check the /r/jailbreak subreddit, talented coders have to hack the SEP and build complicated, low-level-interacting software like futurestore in order to perform a semi-successful downgrade/upgrade.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by Wowfunhappy on Friday June 11, 2021 @03:14PM (#27477328)
iOS updates aren't forced, no.

However, if you install an update to try it out, or because you didn't realize that it would e.g. break 32bit support, you can never downgrade again (unless you happen to be within a two-week-ish period.)

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by Karunamon on Friday June 11, 2021 @03:52PM (#27477672)
Technically, no, but you'll be repetitively bothered by modal popups until you do.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by joshspankit on Friday June 11, 2021 @11:37PM (#27481295)
As well: older versions have known exploits that you (as a locked-out user) are unable to patch.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by Wowfunhappy on Saturday June 12, 2021 @09:13AM (#27484265)
Right, whereas on macOS I literally patched an exploit myself a couple of months ago, because I could inject my own code. https://github.com/Wowfunhappy/Fix-Apple-Mail-CVE-2020-9922
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by Wowfunhappy on Friday June 11, 2021 @03:10PM (#27477293)
Your first paragraph contradicts the second and third paragraphs! If you believe that individuals should control their own devices, why are you in favor of Apple retaining control of every iPhone it sells? Pick one!
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by sneak on Friday June 11, 2021 @03:14PM (#27477325)
I didn't claim to be in favor of Apple retaining control of every iPhone they sell. Please re-read my comment.

My claim is that for most users of iPhones, the situation of Apple being in control of their device, rather than themselves, results in a better outcome for that user (and is oftentimes explicitly preferred by that user as a result, and is reflected in their purchase of an iPhone).

In fact, Apple delegates control of an iPhone's userspace execution environment to any iPhone owner who wants it: they will give you a signing cert for use in xcode to run any app you want on your own device (no developer subscription necessary). This is how AltStore works, and allows AltStore users to run emulator apps on the iPhones they own.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by Wowfunhappy on Friday June 11, 2021 @03:21PM (#27477395)
> My claim is that for most users of iPhones, the situation of Apple being in control of their device, rather than themselves, results in a better outcome for that user (and is oftentimes explicitly preferred by that user as a result, and is reflected in their purchase of an iPhone).

Okay, but that comes out to the same thing, since I can't buy an iPhone which isn't Apple managed. If Apple offered a choice, that would be one thing—but they don't.

> In fact, Apple delegates control of an iPhone's execution environment to any iPhone owner who wants it: they will give you a signing cert for use in xcode to run any app you want on your own device.

What they give you is the ability to sign up to three apps at a time, all of which expire after seven days. It's not useful for anything but testing.

Plus, you're stuck in the App Store sandbox. You can't downgrade to an earlier operating system, you can't inspect the HTTPS traffic being sent out of your phone, and you can't even run anything that uses a JIT.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by joshspankit on Saturday June 12, 2021 @01:07PM (#27485812)
> What they give you is the ability to sign up to three apps at a time, all of which expire after seven days. It's not useful for anything but testing.

And if they decide to they can flip a switch on their server to disable your account and stop “your” apps from launching.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by sneak on Friday June 11, 2021 @03:50PM (#27477653)
> Okay, but that comes out to the same thing, since I can't buy an iPhone which isn't Apple managed. If Apple offered a choice, that would be one thing—but they don't.

Well, you know this state of affairs well now, so when you buy an iPhone you willingly opt in to these remote management restrictions. There are lots of smartphones you can buy without such cryptographic boot restrictions.

Many people willingly choose iPhones (even given these constraints), and would prefer a remote party manage their device's security.

Apple's argument is a legitimate one, and you should be able to operate in the market in this fashion. Nobody's forced to buy an iPhone if they don't like how the bootloader is configured or the App Store is run.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by Wowfunhappy on Friday June 11, 2021 @04:10PM (#27477850)
> Many people willingly choose iPhones (even given these constraints), and would prefer a remote party manage their device's security.

I mean, but you're making a big assumption there! I buy iPhones in spite of those restrictions, because the only other options have worse processors and cameras, and because most of the people I know use iMessage.

I'd pay double the cost of a normal iPhone for a Security Research Device, if they were available to the general public.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by spicybright on Friday June 11, 2021 @03:37PM (#27477542)
Absolutely when it comes to tech. It's fairly inconsequential sideloading something to your phone.

Medical devices I think should need a someone well versed to work on it.

With cars, the current model most states in the US have is a good middle ground. You can do whatever you want to your car, but it needs to pass a safety inspection every 2 years to drive it legally.

The inspections in my state are fairly comprehensive. Airbags, seat belts, headlight brightness, and structural stability of the frame to name a few.

It also helps the US has a strong car culture with tons of experienced DIY-ers, which I imagine helps.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by Teknoman117 on Friday June 11, 2021 @03:54PM (#27477687)
I think we should just have some pretty clear literature that if you modify a device, the manufacturer is not responsible for any injuries it might cause you.

Modify a dishwasher and now it fills your kitchen with soap bubbles? Modify a CPAP machine and get killed by it? Not the manufacturer's fault.

The US is too litigation happy as it is...

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by bastijn on Friday June 11, 2021 @04:05PM (#27477803)
By passing a right to repair on medical devices you also open up the aftermarket for repairs. Would you like to be handed a medical device by your insurance company that has been repaired by an untrained person that considers himself to be a handyman? Or be put in a scanner that was repaired by a service engineer from a broker that is cutting corners to win in the competing market.

Without clear quality and regulatory control there must be an objective method to discern between personal repairs and non-personal ones.

Disclaimer: didn't read the actual right to repair being passed in detail. Not sure if it does discern already.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by timzentu on Friday June 11, 2021 @05:29PM (#27478742)
But if the insurance company doesn't want to be liable for it it would require a certified and/or bonded tech. In the US cars don't even require this to be stringent. You don't need any schooling to become ASC Certified mechanic, just take a test, no limiting factors for how often you need to recertify, or if you fail it so many times you need to school/train. At least in Canada you need to go to school, and then be a journeyman for a number of years before you can actually be a mechanic.

To really fix it we need a non-profit group to be in charge of the certification, preferably one who can be held accountable for failure due to their certification. My removing the incentive for profit we make it so the Medical industry won't try to control it, the insurance industry to mitigate their requirements, and government from trying to have political agendas pushed.

I have more that I would love to put in here but my employer has opinions that might differ from mine, and can be directly involved with some things that the law can impact.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by rascul on Friday June 11, 2021 @06:37PM (#27479360)
> In the US cars don't even require this to be stringent. You don't need any schooling to become ASC Certified mechanic, just take a test, no limiting factors for how often you need to recertify, or if you fail it so many times you need to school/train.

There's no legal requirement in the US federally, or in any state I'm aware of, to have any certifications for general automotive repair. The EPA does require it for working on air conditioning systems, though. [0] However, many employers do require certification and/or will assist in getting the certifications. Some of the smaller shops are more likely to have mechanics without certifications or with expired certifications (I believe ASE certs are five years). ASE does require hands on experience for their certifications in addition to the test, though. [1]

The BLS also describes this, probably better than I do. [2]

[0] https://www.epa.gov/mvac/section-609-technician-training-and...

[1] https://www.ase.com/work-experience

[2] https://www.bls.gov/ooh/installation-maintenance-and-repair/...

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by Wowfunhappy on Friday June 11, 2021 @03:57PM (#27477719)
IANAL or even a law-enthusiast, but surely we already have case law on this if nothing else? You can't sue the car company if you remove the breaks in your car... right?
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by kube-system on Friday June 11, 2021 @04:35PM (#27478139)
I'm not a lawyer either, but I'm fairly sure that "we didn't cause the harm" is a good defense to a claim that they caused harm.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by kube-system on Friday June 11, 2021 @04:33PM (#27478116)
> I think we should just have some pretty clear literature that if you modify a device, the manufacturer is not responsible for any injuries it might cause you.

That's not nearly nuanced enough. Manufacturers should still be responsible unless they can prove you caused the failure. We currently require this standard for something as simple warranty coverage, we ought to require it for something as severe as death.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by joshspankit on Friday June 11, 2021 @11:35PM (#27481280)
For reference, see “It’s clear you caused water damage because the water damage sticker changed colour. Warranty claim denied” from not too long ago. Spoiler: It was regular moisture from being in the pants pocket during a warm day.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by kube-system on Friday June 11, 2021 @04:26PM (#27478021)
> With cars, the current model most states in the US have is a good middle ground. You can do whatever you want to your car, but it needs to pass a safety inspection every 2 years to drive it legally.

Only 4 US states have biannual safety inspections. Another 11 have annual inspections. The other 35 states + DC do not have safety inspections.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vehicle_inspection_in_the_Unit...

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by Too on Saturday June 12, 2021 @02:46AM (#27482192)
If one thinks that self driving cars are scary. Imagine having Look ma! I improved the autopilot in my Tesla!! driving on public roads or being sold 2nd hand.

Car SW that can control the vehicle motion goes through very rigorous ISO processes, it's not something you just casually tinker with as an individual. Given its hard to visually inspect, one needs a way to understand if a car has been modified or not. This article also on the front page here yesterday explains the complexity and cost of integration verification https://spectrum.ieee.org/cars-that-think/transportation/adv...

Enabling serious third party aftermarket companies that have gone through same level of certification, nothing against that, but individuals, not so sure.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by Wowfunhappy on Saturday June 12, 2021 @08:32AM (#27484012)
There's an additional wrinkle for cars that make them unlike other devices, which is that they drive on public roads. I can't drive on a public road without a license, and neither should software.

But if little Johnny wants to drive his Tesla around a private racetrack with homespun Autopilot software, by all means! It's hardly the weirdest hobby, and who knows—maybe he'll grow up and form a startup that uses modified Tesla's to transport products in large warehouses. That's how innovation happens.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by _Understated_ on Saturday June 12, 2021 @06:55AM (#27483534)
> Look ma! I improved the autopilot in my Tesla!!

I see where you are coming from but right now, if autopilot kills someone, then Tesla are on the hook for it (ok, there may be grey areas but ultimately, they made it so that has to point back to them in a big way when it comes to court cases). However, if I jailbreak my autopilot and kill someone, it's me that has to face the music!

I don't see the harm in scaling the jailbreak hoops you need to jump through.

For example, if I wanted to safely jailbreak my iPhone, there is nothing stopping Apple having an official app that you need to get a special key from Apple for. Maybe a phone call or something, or an email to support. It would come with a caveat that says your jailbroken phone forfeits any warranty claims. Fair enough.

When you are talking about jailbreaking a Tesla, there could be other layers. Like, for example, you have to go to a Tesla dealer where they explain the legal and support ramifications and whatnot. Then you sign a bit of paper with witnesses. Then they send you out a usb dongle in the post after a few days etc. Maybe, though with the Tesla, there would be limits. Like, you can't get the source code, or you are only able to to X things with it.

You get the idea... there could potentially be a scale for stuff like this.

I'm just chucking stuff out there, this isn't a realistic example so please put your pitch forks away :)

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by wiz21c on Friday June 11, 2021 @02:09PM (#27476660)
> IMO it comes down to this: do we advocate for laws that give companies the ability to decide what is right/safe for the public, or do we advocate for laws that reflect trust in the individual?

In the US, I think, some companies sell weapons and nobody seems to care if people can hurt themselves with them.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by ff317 on Friday June 11, 2021 @03:33PM (#27477499)
The comparison is more appropriate than you maybe even intended. Cars are considered weapons (e.g. driving at someone is assault with a deadly weapon), and cars are very dangerous in general and kill lots of people (and not just the drivers!). Yet, we still want right-to-repair on cars.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by naikrovek on Friday June 11, 2021 @04:33PM (#27478122)
we HAVE right to repair on cars, and we've had it for decades. it's why the OBD-II port is standardized and mandated. it's why you can buy tools built only by the auto manufacturers for working on their own cars. it's why auto manufacturers are required to sell every part and every tool to end customers for at least 10 years after a model year is no longer manufactured. it's why third-party replacement parts are available AT ALL.

people forget all this. this is the same thing people want for farm vehicles and personal electronics.

we got it done for cars and trucks in the late 1980s. I don't understand why it's so hard to get lawmakers on the side of the customer --their constituents-- today.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by vageli on Friday June 11, 2021 @03:36PM (#27477533)
It's ridiculous they sell knives in supermarkets, where anyone could procure them and without background checks.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by eganist on Friday June 11, 2021 @12:47PM (#27475618)
> that if someone modifies their own medical device and gets hurt because of it that they legally only hurt themselves because they had the right to make that choice.

Well, while this applies to medical devices, worth noting this doesn't apply to cars, for which safety inspections have existed in many states for quite a while.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by joshspankit on Friday June 11, 2021 @01:12PM (#27475958)
I’d argue that it does apply to cars as safety inspections don’t apply when you keep a vehicle within the bounds of private property.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by noizejoy on Friday June 11, 2021 @03:55PM (#27477702)
Would that be similar to having an iPhone never connected to the Internet?
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by kube-system on Friday June 11, 2021 @04:41PM (#27478206)
While Apple has made that argument, their devices are not primarily intended to support life, and the vast majority of failures due to bad repairs don't kill people.

And often with medical devices, they may often be supporting the life of someone other than the original purchaser and sole maintainer.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by JAlexoid on Friday June 11, 2021 @12:33PM (#27475403)
These laws obligate the manufacturer to release maintenance and repair manuals, like the ones they provide to the authorized service centers; and ban all litigation related to someone providing unauthorized services, etc...

Depending on the law, it may also require more documentation, ban on total lockdown of devices and obligation to sell spare parts(but you often can buy genuine spare parts through service centers)

Right to fix also doesn't cover warranties, as you will loose your warranty when doing it yourself.

For cars or medical equipment - that's clearly political influence, masquerading as "public safety".

There's nothing stopping me from modifying my car to be very dangerous right now, without even affecting my warranty. The difference - I cannot install a third party keyfob, because the protocol is locked down.

The kind of medical equipment that hospitals require, already comes with multi-decade support. And your CPAP device can be serviced by someone without manufacturer specific training(that costs a fortune, for little practical value).

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by TaylorAlexander on Friday June 11, 2021 @01:33PM (#27476220)
> Right to fix also doesn't cover warranties, as you will loose your warranty when doing it yourself.

The Magnussen-Moss warranty act of 1975 states (IANAL) that a repair cannot void the warranty unless the manufacturer can prove that your repair caused the damage in question.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnuson%E2%80%93Moss_Warranty...

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by kube-system on Friday June 11, 2021 @04:47PM (#27478272)
This is correct. Those "warranty void if broken" stickers are only worth as much as they mislead people into not bothering to push for warranty claims. (and if it's on something that's not a "consumer good")
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by TaylorAlexander on Friday June 11, 2021 @01:38PM (#27476272)
Louis Rossman gave an example which I believe really happened. A surgery chair that cost tens of thousands of dollars needed a new riser motor. Just an electric motor to move the chair up and down. But the company that makes the electric motor had an agreement with the chair manufacturer not to sell replacement parts. So the only recourse instead of replacing a $500 motor is to replace an entire surgery chair for tens of thousands of dollars.

Given the cost of medical care in this country I think it would be a very good thing if that agreement not to sell parts was against the law. Surely an electric motor to raise a chair up and down could be replaced with the correct part without compromising anyone’s safety.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by znpy on Friday June 11, 2021 @02:47PM (#27477071)
> Given the cost of medical care in this country

although in this specific case in example, if the country you're talking about are the US, having access to the $500 motor only means wider profit margins for the hostpital, not necessarily lower bills for hospitalized people.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by TaylorAlexander on Friday June 11, 2021 @02:53PM (#27477143)
Perhaps, but it’s clear we must both lower costs (fix repair laws) and provide free medical care for everyone. So fixing repair is one important step towards an end goal of health care for everyone.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by spicybright on Friday June 11, 2021 @03:40PM (#27477568)
I agree, but I'd also say there's a line between inconsequential things like a chair motor, and something giving life support to someone.

It would suck to die because the repair guy didn't solder the wire correctly.

It's really tough to draw that line though, and it's in the manufactures interest $ + lawsuit wise to play it safe.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by TaylorAlexander on Friday June 11, 2021 @04:50PM (#27478307)
Regulating the quality of repair is a separate issue from sourcing parts. The hospital and their insurance company will be well inclined to make sure that repairs are done properly, but we should let the people who own the chair (and some oversight board) decide policy for those repairs, not equipment manufacturers who have a vested interest in selling new equipment.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by noizejoy on Friday June 11, 2021 @04:02PM (#27477768)
Money wasted leads to money not available for life support.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by wdn on Friday June 11, 2021 @04:58PM (#27478399)
You do understand the reason why US has such high health care cost is because the only player getting screw is the payer, also known as the patient.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by znpy on Friday June 11, 2021 @05:46PM (#27478892)
yes, but nah.

the reason the US has such high healthcare is because healthcare is both private and paid-by-insurance.

a lot of other nations have free healthcare, both in the american continent and in Europe.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by dragonwriter on Friday June 11, 2021 @05:49PM (#27478917)
> the reason the US has such high healthcare is because healthcare is both private and paid-by-insurance.

Lots of countries have combined public/private systems and get equal or better results with lower per capita and per GDP expenditure than the US.

The US has expensive healthcare because it has an exceptionally poorly designed public/private system, not because it has a public/private system.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by Causality1 on Friday June 11, 2021 @12:42PM (#27475545)
Would you rather have amateur repairs being done by someone who has access to proper documentation or by someone who does not?
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by waych on Friday June 11, 2021 @02:22PM (#27476796)
This assumes that the first party seller is competent, motivated and capable of using their first party documents to good effect performing repairs. Consider the Apple Genius bar for an easy counter example.

edit: may have misinterpreted what you wrote. Nobody should have to have amateurs perform repairs, whether they are first party or not.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by Causality1 on Friday June 11, 2021 @05:46PM (#27478891)
Nobody should be forced to use an amateur, certainly. I'm saying that if you can't afford a professional repair, you want the amateur to have access to the best information available, whether that person is you or someone else.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by Veedrac on Friday June 11, 2021 @06:18PM (#27479179)
This is the wrong place to regulate that. If buildings need to adhere to certain fire safety requirements, you have a law that says people modifying the property need to follow those requirements. You don't make a law that says only the original builder of the house is allowed to repair the house.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by valine on Friday June 11, 2021 @12:23PM (#27475301)
Also right to repair obviously can't apply to an implanted device. Those devices are hermetically sealed and disposed of after explant.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by TedDoesntTalk on Friday June 11, 2021 @12:30PM (#27475374)
Medtronic insulin pumps are routinely hacked by their owners:

https://www.google.com/amp/s/medicalxpress.com/news/2019-06-...

Sorry for the Google amp link.

There’s also this kind of medical device hacking (again not black hat):

https://hackaday.com/2020/07/15/diy-dongle-breathes-life-int...

And open-source ventilator software:

https://hackaday.com/2020/03/30/professional-ventilator-desi...

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by zeusk on Friday June 11, 2021 @02:48PM (#27477082)
Right to repair isn't exactly supporting homebrew software although it'd help to have schematics.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by syshum on Friday June 11, 2021 @12:30PM (#27475371)
Public Safety is never a reason to oppose Right to Repair, to the extent there are safety concerns they can be elevated with out needing to curb independent or self repair

That said, Safety is red herring that the industries use to justify their anti-consumer actions with zero actual data to back their position.

The Record are cars is clear and estiblished people self repair and use independant repair all the time to fix mechnical safety systems like breaks with no systemic issues or damage to public safety

For medical devices I have yet to see any data the independent repair causes any harm, in fact I believe the the US Government has a study that states Independent Repair of Medical Equipment is critical to maintaining the US Health System, so in the case of Health Care prohibitions on independent repair may CAUSE public health issues by taking critical equipment out of service waiting on "authorized" repair or parts

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by vikingerik on Friday June 11, 2021 @12:21PM (#27475279)
Let's interpret this the right way: this doesn't mean "we're not going to handle motor vehicles or medical", it means "motor vehicles and medical are out of scope for this measure." They can be handled separately, and that's reasonable given the greater safety concerns of those industries.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by JAlexoid on Friday June 11, 2021 @12:40PM (#27475526)
Right to repair started out as a demand by farmers to be able to repair their John Deere's.

This "greater safety" concern is nothing but masquerade.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by ping_pong on Friday June 11, 2021 @02:12PM (#27476706)
The best way to kill something is by saying "yes, we'll get to that next, don't worry!" and then never get to it.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by spicybright on Friday June 11, 2021 @03:42PM (#27477586)
it can go both ways. Yes you're right, but making huge changes that disturb every industry makes a hell of an opposition to fight.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by neallindsay on Friday June 11, 2021 @11:41AM (#27474816)
Plus it gives Apple an out as soon as they release a car, which is extremely weird.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by nolok on Friday June 11, 2021 @11:50AM (#27474897)
If that metric is true doesn't that already give google, lg, samsung, ... an out ? "manufacturer of motor vehicle equipment" is sufficiently large to include everyone we want that law for.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by matheusmoreira on Friday June 11, 2021 @04:04PM (#27477792)
Restrictions on medical devices are very reasonable though. They aren't something people can freely hack on. Errors can cause decisions to be made based on incorrect information, expose people to radioactivity...

Even the GPLv3 makes an exception for this class of device.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by a1369209993 on Friday June 11, 2021 @11:43PM (#27481328)
> Even the GPLv3 makes an exception for this class of device.

Citation very fucking needed, because exceptions for specific fields of work directly contradict the underlying principles of the GPL, and indeed [0] contains no occurence of the word "medical".

0: https://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-3.0.txt

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by matheusmoreira on Saturday June 12, 2021 @01:41AM (#27481877)
> A "User Product" is either (1) a "consumer product", which means any tangible personal property which is normally used for personal, family, or household purposes, or (2) anything designed or sold for incorporation into a dwelling.

The anti-tivoization text in the license applies to these User Products. Medical devices are not included in the definition.

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by a1369209993 on Saturday June 12, 2021 @02:07AM (#27482003)
If it's "normally used for personal, family, or household purposes" or "designed or sold for incorporation into a dwelling", then anti-tivoization applies regardless of whether it's medical in nature. Conversely, if it's not either of those, then it's not a "consumer product", also regardless of whether it's medical. There are problems with that section, but "GPLv3 makes an exception for medical devices" is not one of them.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by Too on Saturday June 12, 2021 @02:18AM (#27482061)
This makes no sense, GPL is a big aid, but not a prerequisite to enabling custom repairs. And vice versa, having access to the source code of an x-ray machine doesn't increase risk of modification. Device can still block FW updates based on signatures.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by avs733 on Friday June 11, 2021 @02:37PM (#27476967)
These are also two classes of consumer facing product that are most regulated and likely to contain electronics

(I'm excluding cribs...because my partner laughed at me when I suggested building our crib and told me that was fine as long as I followed all the rules)

Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by TruthSHIFT on Friday June 11, 2021 @12:05PM (#27475084)
So, what is actually included? Isn’t everything electronic now?
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by inops on Friday June 11, 2021 @12:34PM (#27475427)
It's "digital electronic product...found in medical settings", I'd imagine
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by boomboomsubban on Friday June 11, 2021 @01:35PM (#27476248)
So how many nurses need an iPhone to exempt Apple? Or would something like a COVID tracking app make it a digital electronic product found in a medical setting?
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by jonny_eh on Friday June 11, 2021 @04:28PM (#27478057)
It's comma soup, there's no way to parse this reliably.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by boomboomsubban on Friday June 11, 2021 @06:03PM (#27479049)
The sole "and" combined with the bill's use of "digital electronic product" outside of section four makes it fairly clear that it's only discussing medical devices. "You have the right to repair digital electronic product's except digital electronic products" doesn't make much sense.
Re:New York Senate passes Right to Repair bill by exporectomy on Friday June 11, 2021 @12:38PM (#27475469)
Hard to parse all those commas and conjunctions. Are you sure "digital electronic product" isn't related to medical devices?