Stock prices are rising because the interest rates are so low. A ton of institutional money that was in bonds is now out seeking yield. This moves a ton of money into stocks and, as we see in the article, real estate.
The labor class has been shafted for years by the US dollar being the global reserve currency, causing us to run persistent trade deficits. This has off-shored manufacturing and gutted our capabilities. If the US weakens the dollar and rebuilds the manufacturing base, which they appear to be trying to do with the investment in semiconductors, I think we will be in a much better position. I am happy with the stimulus because it does both, weaken the dollar and invest in US capabilities. We just need to make sure it flows to the correct places.
Except the way the US does it, the Treasury issues debt and then the Fed prints to buy the debt. So when we print $1T, we also take on $1T in debt. I know you mean lowering through inflation but as long as it's done this way I don't see how it matters. If the dollar looses 50%, we then need to issue $2T in debt and print $2T the next time.
No, interest rate are low because they are using them as a tool in a crisis.
That's the key, and also something that's unsolved. History shows that a lot of the money will be squandered in increasing "clever" ways, and it may take until the end of the decade before the public even realizes that it happened.
Granted this is lower than rates were in the 1980s. But if the answer here is you need to keep rates at 10-15% to build sufficient housing I don't see how that's politically tenable.
These are building starts (i.e. permits obtained, but construction not having broken ground yet), but the more complete US Census data at the .gov website shows that completions haven't been far behind starts within the last five years.
I mean ultimately what I want is to pay 35-40% of my take home salary on a mortgage, just I like I pay now in rent.
The reality is though, here in the UK, that I need to save 2-3 years of take home pay, to put down on a deposit for a mortgage that will see me pay 50% of my take home pay, and I will still end up living in an inferior property to what I'm renting.
Meanwhile my landlord, who bought the place I'm in the 90s, is making a profit.
Most people pay for housing by monthly payments, making the nominal value of the house irrelevant if the monthly payment stays the same. Further, you should consider the home owner's "basket of goods" to include the hypothetical rent they'd be paying for an equivalent house. Their mortgage payments and home ownership are then more like taking a loan to buy a fixed-income asset that gets renegotiated annually. A home owner who lives in their home is both a landlord and a tenant.
I'm not a home-owner, and I don't feel shafted. My stock market holdings have kept pace or done better than if I'd purchased a house.
I really dont understand the logic of being OK with paying double for a house, just because the buyer can sell it for the same amount (or higher) afterwards.
I could purchase a 150m2 house with my salary a decade ago. Now I could find a 75m2 house that would be too expensive for me. I dont care about being able to sell the house for more money afterwards, it doesn't matter, because I have to live somewhere anyways. So any profits gained will (probably) be factored into the purchase price of the next house I'm buying.
Are you talking about monthly payment or lump sum? When the lump sum doubles yet the monthly payment is the same, has the cost really changed? To me, no. I was never going to buy lump sum, so I only care about monthly payment.
Yes of course it has. You've just over doubled (interest rates are low but they're not nil) the time it's taken to pay back that loan.
You mean the repayment amount? I'm not sure what you're asking.
Of the lump sum price (principal), interest rate, loan term (time), and monthly payment, you can only change three of the four, for a fixed rate loan. The fourth is defined by the combination of the others.
The only difference is the down payment, which matters because a bigger down payment means more opportunity cost of stock market gains.
This touches on another point. For home owners like myself, inflation is a good thing as it makes my highest monthly expense relatively cheaper.
I know people who refied into 15 year fixed, but the rates have typically been so close I didn't see the point. Just pay more each month on your own and avoid the costs of the refi.
So, if someone already has a 30 year and the 15 year rate isn't much different, refing into a 15 isn't necessary. Just start paying monthly like a 15 and it will get close enough.
Also, if I already had a high rate loan and was refing where the 15/30 rates are very close, I would go 30. That way I can pay it like a 15, but have the flexibility to pay less if, for example, I lost my job.
Finally, this is why it's common to make 1 extra payment each year as it will shave ~4 years off the end of the loan.
https://www.trulia.com/blog/make-one-extra-mortgage-payment-...
Double what? The price someone paid years ago under totally different market conditions?
In the future prices might be halved or double again - act accordingly
No, they don’t, even talking about non-homeowners, because non-homeowners aren’t paying that much more (rents aren’t increasing the way purchase prices are, the rstio between them is increasing), and non-homeowners have nothing to sell, unless you are referring to subleasing as selling.
> But non-homeowners are still paying more for less.
I think you mean “first-time homebuyers”, but that just means it is more attractive to invest elsewhere while renting than jump into personal home ownership. No one is losing anything, certain choices are just becoming less favored.
A fixed loan doesn't change with interest rates either.
Homes are like fixed-income securities. When interest rates go up, the value of existing securities goes down.
When the Fed funds rate is 0%, your mortgage rate is 3%, that same difference in the Fed Funds rate.
But wait, think of that like we think of absorption. If I have a capacity to absorb of 1L and can absorb 50% of a liquid, then I will break when 2L is poured. If I bring my absorption rate to 98%, then I now break at 50L. If the government can absorb at 99.99% rates and you absorb at 97% rates, they can absorb 10000L while you can only absorb 33L.
If you want the government to control every decision regarding money in the future, you want the interest rate to be as low as possible. If you want people to use free markets to decide where money flows, you want high interest rates. Why is politics so contentious? Interest rates are dropping.
The differential between mortgage rates and the federal funds rate is only driven in part by regulation. The rest is market forces and the perceived risk of rising inflation. If we had certainty on how inflation would change for the next 30 years, mortgage rates could be pushed to a negligible margin above the federal funds rate.
> If you want the government to control every decision regarding money in the future, you want the interest rate to be as low as possible. If you want people to use free markets to decide where money flows, you want high interest rates.
You haven't explained this assertion. I see it a different way. If we want consumer demand to decide how capital is invested, then we want more inflation. Inflation transfers wealth from creditors to debtors. Debtors spend their money, which indicates what's useful to produce. If we want a handful of bankers to make guesses (and often guess incorrectly) about what people will want to buy, then we want low inflation, transferring wealth from debtors to creditors.
The problem with (excessively) low inflation and supply-side economics in general is that the suppliers must make their choices with a decreasing level of information on what will be demanded. It's only through consumer demand and its pressure on supply that reveals what's important through market forces. Otherwise we may as well go back to central planning.
Note that I'm not advocating for fluctuating inflation. All parties benefit from stable inflation rates. Uncertainty is dead weight loss.
Except homeowners get price exposure to the value of their home on the market. If you purchase and then go through a downturn which devalues your house, now you’re in the hole: you can’t use the sale price of the home to pay off the loan, so you’re stuck in that home until its value climbs again or you earn enough to pay off the loss.
Higher values means it takes longer for you to cover any % decline with wages, so you lose mobility for longer in a downturn. Irrelevant if you truly want to live in that place for 30 years, but not many people can actually make that commitment.
> ... Higher values
Higher values at the time of purchase or at the time of sale? The latter doesn't jive with the idea of being "underwater" on the loan, since you'd have benefited from the price exposure.
Higher values at the time of purchase is relative to what the home was worth in the past, but our efficient market theory tells us that the price today can be considered neither high nor low (yes, Shiller might disagree).
I guess you're pointing out that interest rates are near zero, so that there's really only one way for them to go. I'm not so sure, because in some ways it's a Zeno's Paradox situation. I don't always care about the number of basis points the interest rate has changed, but the percent change of the interest rate. I get more benefit from the rate going from 4% to 3% than I did when it went from 5% to 4%. We can always get closer to 0%, because there's an infinite number of subdivisions we can make.
Given supply constraints, I agree that easy money probably does drive up prices. But without artificial constraints, any rise in price would just dissipate back into higher supplies. That's why you see QE result in higher housing costs, but not higher car prices.
[1]https://www.wsj.com/articles/what-housing-crisis-in-japan-ho...
Why would you expect house prices to go up when there's a ridiculous oversupply of housing. There's only 55M households in Japan, and there's ~9M vacant homes. That's ~14% of homes.
Housing is an expense unless there's someone to live in it and pay rent.
[1]https://livejapan.com/en/in-tokyo/in-pref-tokyo/in-tokyo_sub...
It arguably has STILL not deflated.
At one point, the Emperor's Palace alone was worth more than all the real estate in California: https://www.scmp.com/magazines/style/news-trends/article/309...
I guess if you believe those valuations made sense, then sure.
The problem isn't "printing money", inflation is a good thing as it encourages investment and maintains the movement of money. The problem is that printed money is only being put towards one purpose - capital markets - so the capital markets are what inflates (at the expense of everything else). If the printed money was being used on infrastructure payments, or some other distributed investment, the inflation would go to general labor first, which then would spread the inflation across the entire economy as they made individual purchase decisions.
For homeowners, it is the most expensive thing, but homeowners are winning on it because they get the value of the asset appreciating.
For non-homeowners, the reason CPI isn’t going up is that rents aren’t rising with purchase prices, its the purchase:rent ratio going up. So it isn’t hurting them, either.
More likely is that they have no where else to part their money anymore.
All that money's gotta go somewhere. Hey, at least the CPI isn't going up right? Its only the most expensive thing in most people's lives that has doubled in cost in about 10 years. Same thing for stock prices, and slowly other commodity prices are catching up as well.
Non-homeowners are being shafted by this fed/ecb policy. Every year the gap between poor and rich grows larger as a result.