News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by xapata on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @11:47AM (#27449291)
> Its only the most expensive thing in most people's lives that has doubled in cost in about 10 years.

Most people pay for housing by monthly payments, making the nominal value of the house irrelevant if the monthly payment stays the same. Further, you should consider the home owner's "basket of goods" to include the hypothetical rent they'd be paying for an equivalent house. Their mortgage payments and home ownership are then more like taking a loan to buy a fixed-income asset that gets renegotiated annually. A home owner who lives in their home is both a landlord and a tenant.

I'm not a home-owner, and I don't feel shafted. My stock market holdings have kept pace or done better than if I'd purchased a house.

Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by adflux on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @11:53AM (#27449361)
Non homeowners are paying way more whilst getting less in return.

I really dont understand the logic of being OK with paying double for a house, just because the buyer can sell it for the same amount (or higher) afterwards.

I could purchase a 150m2 house with my salary a decade ago. Now I could find a 75m2 house that would be too expensive for me. I dont care about being able to sell the house for more money afterwards, it doesn't matter, because I have to live somewhere anyways. So any profits gained will (probably) be factored into the purchase price of the next house I'm buying.

Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by xapata on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @12:07PM (#27449526)
> paying double for a house

Are you talking about monthly payment or lump sum? When the lump sum doubles yet the monthly payment is the same, has the cost really changed? To me, no. I was never going to buy lump sum, so I only care about monthly payment.

Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by poooogles on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @12:19PM (#27449708)
>When the lump sum doubles yet the monthly payment is the same, has the cost really changed?

Yes of course it has. You've just over doubled (interest rates are low but they're not nil) the time it's taken to pay back that loan.

Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by xapata on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @07:03PM (#27454488)
Your payments go towards both interest and principal in a proportion that varies over the lifetime of the loan, such that your time frame is set by the terms of the loan. If you get a 30-year fixed rate mortgage, you pay it back in 30 years, regardless of the loan amount or interest rate. Look up "amortization table" if you're curious.
Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by poooogles on Thursday June 10, 2021 @10:25AM (#27461143)
But the only way for the lump sum to double and the repayment to stay the same is to lengthen the loan period?
Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by xapata on Thursday June 10, 2021 @02:20PM (#27463740)
> repayment to stay the same

You mean the repayment amount? I'm not sure what you're asking.

Of the lump sum price (principal), interest rate, loan term (time), and monthly payment, you can only change three of the four, for a fixed rate loan. The fourth is defined by the combination of the others.

Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by xapata on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @02:55PM (#27451647)
It's a 30-year mortgage either way. The time frame is exactly the same.

The only difference is the down payment, which matters because a bigger down payment means more opportunity cost of stock market gains.

Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by nicoburns on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @12:15PM (#27449642)
Your liability has. If the interest rates goes back up to late 20th rates, your monthly payment isn't going to stay the same.
Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by matwood on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @12:32PM (#27449909)
After all the adjustable rate issues from the last housing crisis, I believe most mortgages since them have been fixed rate. I don't care what interest rates do, my mortgage rate is never going up.

This touches on another point. For home owners like myself, inflation is a good thing as it makes my highest monthly expense relatively cheaper.

Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by nicoburns on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @01:00PM (#27450301)
Ah, this may be country-dependant. It's pretty much impossible to get longer than 10 years fixed here in the UK, and the rates are high.
Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by matwood on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @03:19PM (#27451940)
In the US 30 year fixed rate mortgages are common (standard?). Rates have also bumped around record low territory for years.

I know people who refied into 15 year fixed, but the rates have typically been so close I didn't see the point. Just pay more each month on your own and avoid the costs of the refi.

Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by nathanaldensr on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @09:17PM (#27455616)
Rates might have little to do with whether refinancing from 30-year to 15-year makes sense. The most important factor is how long you plan on living in the house compared to the difference in interest paid between the two amortization schedules during that time. The longer you stay in the house, the larger the difference to where paying refinancing fees is virtually free.
Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by matwood on Thursday June 10, 2021 @02:14PM (#27463671)
On the typical fixed rate loan, amortization schedules are a function of rate, time, and payment. If someone wants to accelerate the schedule, they just need to pay more principal each month.

So, if someone already has a 30 year and the 15 year rate isn't much different, refing into a 15 isn't necessary. Just start paying monthly like a 15 and it will get close enough.

Also, if I already had a high rate loan and was refing where the 15/30 rates are very close, I would go 30. That way I can pay it like a 15, but have the flexibility to pay less if, for example, I lost my job.

Finally, this is why it's common to make 1 extra payment each year as it will shave ~4 years off the end of the loan.

https://www.trulia.com/blog/make-one-extra-mortgage-payment-...

Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by foogazi on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @12:31PM (#27449902)
Only if its a variable rate loan
Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by basch on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @12:13PM (#27449618)
Presumably, owing money for 60 years instead of 30 years will cost you much more in the long run. And more baked in interest early in the loan means less recovered when you sell.
Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by xapata on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @02:57PM (#27451679)
How the hell do you find a 60-year loan? Sign me up! Remember, leverage is what makes home ownership a good investment.
Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by basch on Thursday June 10, 2021 @02:24AM (#27457470)
The premise I replied to was the lump sum doubling and the monthly staying the same. The only way for that to happen is to extend the period.
Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by xapata on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:53PM (#27464934)
You forgot interest rates changing, which is the primary cause of the recent home price changes. Remember, the mortgage market has a set of standard terms, like a 30-year-fixed.
Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by foogazi on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @02:37PM (#27451440)
> I really dont understand the logic of being OK with paying double for a house

Double what? The price someone paid years ago under totally different market conditions?

In the future prices might be halved or double again - act accordingly

Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by em-bee on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @12:05PM (#27449506)
i am confused by your first sentence. what do non-homeowners sell?
Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by adflux on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @12:08PM (#27449536)
Some people say "Well, you're paying more but you can also sell it for more afterwards". But non-homeowners are still paying more for less. That's the argument I am trying to make (poorly)
Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by dragonwriter on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @12:26PM (#27449822)
> Some people say "Well, you're paying more but you can also sell it for more afterwards".

No, they don’t, even talking about non-homeowners, because non-homeowners aren’t paying that much more (rents aren’t increasing the way purchase prices are, the rstio between them is increasing), and non-homeowners have nothing to sell, unless you are referring to subleasing as selling.

> But non-homeowners are still paying more for less.

I think you mean “first-time homebuyers”, but that just means it is more attractive to invest elsewhere while renting than jump into personal home ownership. No one is losing anything, certain choices are just becoming less favored.

Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by xapata on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @12:12PM (#27449595)
My rent doesn't change with interest rates.
Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by JKCalhoun on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @12:18PM (#27449704)
That's true, rent keeps going up?

A fixed loan doesn't change with interest rates either.

Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by xapata on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @03:00PM (#27451708)
Rent increases are a cause of inflation (as part of the basket of goods that defines inflation), which in turn causes interest rate increases, which then cause home price decreases.

Homes are like fixed-income securities. When interest rates go up, the value of existing securities goes down.

Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by matwood on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @12:34PM (#27449935)
Daily no. But higher interest rates and high inflation absolutely leads to higher rents each year when your lease renews (unless of course your in some rent controlled environment).
Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by sremani on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @12:24PM (#27449792)
So does my mortgage that is why it is called 15 year FIXED.
Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by xapata on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @03:02PM (#27451741)
Yes, as I said, you care about the monthly payment, not the lump sum price of the house.
Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by xwdv on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @12:37PM (#27449969)
No, but in 20 years you’ll be paying rent with expensive 2041 dollars while the 30 year fixed rate mortgage is still being paid in cheap 2021 dollars.
Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by xapata on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @03:03PM (#27451751)
Yes, but it turns out I came out ahead from 1990-2021 by having all my investments in the stock market instead of housing.
Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by ItsMonkk on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @12:33PM (#27449924)
Here's why this matters to you. When the Fed funds rate is at 10%, the mortgage rate is 13% or so. That says that the risk that you have is 3% above the risk free rate.

When the Fed funds rate is 0%, your mortgage rate is 3%, that same difference in the Fed Funds rate.

But wait, think of that like we think of absorption. If I have a capacity to absorb of 1L and can absorb 50% of a liquid, then I will break when 2L is poured. If I bring my absorption rate to 98%, then I now break at 50L. If the government can absorb at 99.99% rates and you absorb at 97% rates, they can absorb 10000L while you can only absorb 33L.

If you want the government to control every decision regarding money in the future, you want the interest rate to be as low as possible. If you want people to use free markets to decide where money flows, you want high interest rates. Why is politics so contentious? Interest rates are dropping.

Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by xapata on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @06:25PM (#27454093)
> ... that same difference in the Fed Funds rate.

The differential between mortgage rates and the federal funds rate is only driven in part by regulation. The rest is market forces and the perceived risk of rising inflation. If we had certainty on how inflation would change for the next 30 years, mortgage rates could be pushed to a negligible margin above the federal funds rate.

> If you want the government to control every decision regarding money in the future, you want the interest rate to be as low as possible. If you want people to use free markets to decide where money flows, you want high interest rates.

You haven't explained this assertion. I see it a different way. If we want consumer demand to decide how capital is invested, then we want more inflation. Inflation transfers wealth from creditors to debtors. Debtors spend their money, which indicates what's useful to produce. If we want a handful of bankers to make guesses (and often guess incorrectly) about what people will want to buy, then we want low inflation, transferring wealth from debtors to creditors.

The problem with (excessively) low inflation and supply-side economics in general is that the suppliers must make their choices with a decreasing level of information on what will be demanded. It's only through consumer demand and its pressure on supply that reveals what's important through market forces. Otherwise we may as well go back to central planning.

Note that I'm not advocating for fluctuating inflation. All parties benefit from stable inflation rates. Uncertainty is dead weight loss.

Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by wallacoloo on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @03:04PM (#27451765)
> Most people pay for housing by monthly payments, making the nominal value of the house irrelevant if the monthly payment stays the same.

Except homeowners get price exposure to the value of their home on the market. If you purchase and then go through a downturn which devalues your house, now you’re in the hole: you can’t use the sale price of the home to pay off the loan, so you’re stuck in that home until its value climbs again or you earn enough to pay off the loss.

Higher values means it takes longer for you to cover any % decline with wages, so you lose mobility for longer in a downturn. Irrelevant if you truly want to live in that place for 30 years, but not many people can actually make that commitment.

Re:If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pens... by xapata on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @06:14PM (#27453995)
> Except homeowners get price exposure ... you’re stuck in that home until its value climbs again or you earn enough to pay off the loss.

> ... Higher values

Higher values at the time of purchase or at the time of sale? The latter doesn't jive with the idea of being "underwater" on the loan, since you'd have benefited from the price exposure.

Higher values at the time of purchase is relative to what the home was worth in the past, but our efficient market theory tells us that the price today can be considered neither high nor low (yes, Shiller might disagree).

I guess you're pointing out that interest rates are near zero, so that there's really only one way for them to go. I'm not so sure, because in some ways it's a Zeno's Paradox situation. I don't always care about the number of basis points the interest rate has changed, but the percent change of the interest rate. I get more benefit from the rate going from 4% to 3% than I did when it went from 5% to 4%. We can always get closer to 0%, because there's an infinite number of subdivisions we can make.