He was complaining of lack of scientific rigorousity with testing (at least in France) and he compared it to the “behind the scenes” of a restaurant’s kitchen.
For example, he was saying that the “informal” rate of contamination of tests were off the charts, but surprisingly, nobody was doing a thorough, official contamination analysis.
What I’m saying with all this is that: your friend thinks she had COVID twice. Or even, her doctor thinks so. But it’s hard to trust anything with our given situation.
PS: I’m not saying she didn’t have it twice. It might be possible. It just sucks how bad we’ve been at science these past 2 years and how easily we’ve been overwhelmed by “operative” tasks.
Edit: his name is Pablo Goldschmidt[0] and he works in France (not in the UK as I originally stated). Here's the interview (in spanish, also WARNING, the site sucks and is full of ads): https://marcelolongobardi.cienradios.com/pablo-goldschmidt-l...
The BD rapid test he used seems to be one which a paper [1] indicates has a lower positive percent agreement than a PCR test.
Rapid tests in general, compared directly to PCR, seem to do even worse with one paper [2] finding a symptomatic sensitivity of 72% and an asymptomatic sensitivity of 58%.
[1]: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33023911/
[2]: https://www.cochranelibrary.com/cdsr/doi/10.1002/14651858.CD...
Day 0: Antigen positive Day 1: PCR positive Day 8: Antigen positive Day 9: Antigen negative Day 10: Antigen positive Day 10: PCR negative Day 11: Antigen negative Then 10+ negatives after
For what it's worth my girlfriend is currently recovering from her second bout of covid. She had it first about a year ago and then second about a month and a half ago. Confirmed by PCR test and antibody tests afterwards as well as totally consistent symptoms. The first time knocked her out totally about a week and left her tired for a few weeks while the second time knocked her out totally for maybe 2 1/2 weeks and she's still quite weak now 6 weeks later, so the second case has been much worse.
Obviously just anecdotal, but getting it twice does happen and the second time apparently can be worse.
So the second time the viral load may be much higher, which leads to worse symptoms.
Do you think this is true in your anecdotal experience?
Her job has just been a bit of a cesspool of cases. It just keeps going around and around and eventually it got her too.
> Previously infected individuals developed higher Ab titers to the vaccine than those who have not been previously exposed. These results indicate that mRNA vaccination rapidly induces a much stronger and broader Ab response than SARS-CoV-2 infection.
[1] https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.04.15.440089v4
The abstract does say that vaccinated people have higher titers than naturally immune people, and this can be considered evidence:
> mRNA vaccination induced much higher Ab levels especially against the RBD domain and significant cross-reactivity against SARS RBD and S1 was also observed.
It does NOT demonstrate that the vaccine provides any response to other parts of the virus. And it almost certainly does not, while getting sick does.
It also DOESN'T address the question of which provides a better response to novel variants of COVID-19.
This is probably not true. But I don't know of any medical evidence one way or the other.
First, your innate immune system could clear the virus, at which point you have no immunity at all.
Second, your immune system could lock to some random piece of the virus that easily mutates.
Third, your immune system could lock on to some random piece that is common. Oops. Autoimmune problem incoming.
Fourth, your immune system could lock to some piece of the spike protein that mutates quickly (apparently the immune system "likes" 3 particular regions around the spike protein --one of which mutates quite freely).
With the vaccine, your immune system is primed to the spike protein and the particular region that is expressed in the vaccine. It's very targeted.
I had Covid, but I went and got the vaccine anyway for exactly these reasons.
But that with the mRNA vaccines, your body is being explicitly taught about the spike protein, nothing more, nothing less. So provided any future infection employs a spike protein, you have immunity. The question is, what are the odds that sars-cov2 would evolve an entirely different mechanism from the spike protein? My impression was that's pretty unlikely, and why there's so much confidence the mRNA vaccines are robust against variants.
I know absolutely nothing about this subject and frankly am unqualified to even participate in this discussion. I'm just hoping someone who is can clarify/correct my understanding if it's totally misinformed.
Covid will not be able to mutate away from using the spike protein, but it will continue to evolve mutations within the protein as it responds to selective pressure. Fortunately, when the body creates an adaptive immune response through antibody or the T-cell receptor, this response is polyclonal. Think of it as not a single antibody to spike but rather a population of antibodies, all targeting a variety of residues on the protein. This is why most immunologists are not terribly worried about the variants that have emerged wrecking all of our immunization efforts—those variants are usually based on just a couple of mutant residues and so will not (generally speaking) be able to evade the population of antibody and t-cell responses that have been generated. You may have heard about monoclonal antibody therapies to covid ... those, unfortunately, are very susceptible to mutation because if a critical targeted residue mutates, you could lose all efficacy of the drug.
The only answer to rapidly mutating pathogens is an entire inducible population of neutralizing proteins in each of us and it’s no coincidence that we have this defense. If we didn’t, our species could not be here right now.
Depends if the therapy works on the virus itself, or your body's response to the infection.
I think most of the monoclonal antibodies are working on your body's (over)response, so mutations shouldn't change much. Same with corticosteroids.
But Nucloside/tide analogues on the other hand or anything else working against viral processes/replication, oh yeah.
You may be thinking of the targeted immune modulators against inflammatory cytokines like TNF-alpha (2) and IL-6 (3). Some of those are antibodies, others are pieces of antibody fused to other proteins. Regardless, those types of treatments would not be affected directly by viral mutation, whereas the first type I described above have already been shown to be less effective with existing mutations (4).
1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casirivimab/imdevimab 2. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casirivimab/imdevimab 3. https://www.covid19treatmentguidelines.nih.gov/immunomodulat... 4. https://science.sciencemag.org/content/371/6531/850
Other innate immune processes destroy any extracellular RNA if the virus is ruptured etc.
1. Be super healthy 2. Have full vaccine effectiveness 3. Relatively quarantined
Now you’re gonna have the strongest defense. In the future you won’t unexpectedly get it and have any chance of infecting people around you. You chose when to get it. Smart all around, but very counterculture.
2. Supposedly symptoms and forward-transmission will be milder/less right after a vaccination as opposed to months later.
There have been several studies that suggest vaccination provides stronger immunity to mutations. Here's one titled Vaccine-induced immunity provides more robust heterotypic immunity than natural infection to emerging SARS-CoV-2 variants of concern:
That said, I've also seen oft repeated that what you get is immunity*, aka resistance to the worst symptoms. Mild infections are still to be expected as possible, and Covid 19 will join the ranks of common-cold causing organisms.
What was the cycle threshold? The problem with this whole manufactured pandemic is that all the numbers and tests are bullshit because people are doing bad science. The massive relief bills introduced financial incentives to do bad science. It’s institutional failure at a massive scale.
Is it all a conspiracy? Without a single whistleblower? To what end?
What a strawman. Nobody is saying that COVID doesn't exist. Nobody is saying that people haven't died from COVID. Nobody is saying that excess mortality cannot be attributed to COVID. Are you making a good faith effort to understand what I'm saying? Have you done the google search I referenced above?
The presence of the virus (colonization) is much different than being infected by the virus. There's such a thing as viral load.
> Clinical specimens for sequencing should have an RT-PCR Ct value ≤28.
The sequencing you're referring to does not happen on the samples that I'm suggesting are false positives -- at least, it doesn't happen in the US. The CDC does not want those samples.
[1]: https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/covid-19/downloads/Information-...
Do a google for “COVID PCR ct cycle threshold” and you’ll come across loads and loads of good articles about how the meaning of a positive PCR test is relative to the cycle threshold.
Or one from only Belgium with hospital admissions and posivety rate to correct for the amount of tests taken: https://epistat.wiv-isp.be/covid/covid-19.html
Hospital admissions and deaths follow positive tests like clockwork.
Sure it's possible to fuck up pcr tests if you're doing them badly, but there are no indications that that is happening at a significant scale.
Now that the whole world has gone banana over a virus outbreak, it's really important to look at and understand how these tests work. Just because she tested positive does not mean she was really sick with covid, nor does it mean that the test was defective if we assume she didn't have it. It's not an on/off thing, it depends on how exactly they test and how the results are interpreted.
This sounds like circular logic, or I'm misunderstanding what you mean. How were these "cases" confirmed? By testing? It would help if you cited the figures where the reliability of the tests can easily be seen.
Btw, my point was exactly that the issue isn't with the test itself but the interpretation thereof. Most people do not understand how they work and so they don't understand that even healthy people can test positive depending on the criteria we use to define "positive". But positive doesn't mean sick and it doesn't necessarily mean infectious either. By itself it doesn't mean anything.
You've not supplied any data supporting your false positive hypothesis.
On the other hand, if you had a real infection by the virus, you likely have antibodies for the spike protein and other part of the virus like the shell. So from my layman understanding, the immunity should be more resistant to a mutation of the spike protein.
That being said I also know someone who got Covid 2 times, once in march 2020 and once in april 2021. (Confirmed by PCR the 2 times). The second time was much milder, but still she had to stop working for a week (versus one month the first time). It is still possible it was a defective test the second time, and something else than Covid.