News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by recursivedoubts on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:03AM (#27301990)
Well, first and foremost, perhaps the media could pause and reflect on their treatment of anyone who raised the lab leak hypothesis for the past year.

And, were any humility to arise out of that exercise, perhaps they could direct that newfound and unfamiliar trait towards some other things they currently dismiss as "conspiracy theories".

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by bdcravens on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:18AM (#27302093)
The response to "conspiracy theories" is: show us your proof. Otherwise we will wait to give it any credibility. If time and data prove out your claims, then we will give it the proper attention it has earned. (ie, science > social media)
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by texaswhizzle on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:30AM (#27302208)
The problem with this is who is the arbiter on what is, or isn’t, a conspiracy theory. The main stream media in the US seem to innately believe certain claims, without evidence, while also portraying other claims as “conspiracy theories.”

In the case of covid there seemed to be universal belief in the media that covid originated in animals. There was no proof of this claim.

It’s one thing to just simply pick a claim and believe in it. It’s quite another to attack people who are providing an alternative claim.

The same thing rings true with regard to what is a “correct” thing to say. “China Virus” is apparently repugnant. However, naming the country of origin for variants is not. South African Variant is fine.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by IgorPartola on Thursday May 27, 2021 @09:04AM (#27302572)
You are the arbiter. Does the theory hold water? Is there evidence to support it? Is it self-consistent? Conspiracy theories often times fail under scrutiny because for example the amount of people they would involve. Think about the flat earth conspiracy: it would require that every airline pilot, every sailor, every satellite image processor, etc. all be in on the theory. It would only take one of them to show us photo/video/etc. evidence that the earth is in fact flat. And this isn’t just today but over thousands of years. Someone would have come forward by now. I believe there is even a formula for how much time it takes for someone to blow the whistle based on the size of the conspiracy. I think it estimated that the fake moon landing would have become public knowledge within four years.

As for origins of COVID, I personally believe there is a good chance it came from bats, but also a good chance that it came from a lab experiment that had accidentally escaped. The theory that it was deliberately developed as a bio weapon or that it was released on purpose does not seem to hold water as there are no clear plausible beneficiaries of that action.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by bdcravens on Thursday May 27, 2021 @10:35AM (#27303652)
> The main stream media in the US seem to innately believe certain claims, without evidence, while also portraying other claims as “conspiracy theories.”

You can replace "main stream media" with any other group as well. (for example, the group that think masks and vaccines are part of a "plandemic" to undermine our economy and track everyone via 5g towers controlled by lizard people, while giving credence to medications recommended by politicians rather than medical professionals)

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by texaswhizzle on Thursday May 27, 2021 @02:03PM (#27306124)
Other “groups” don’t have national broadcasts and major websites.
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by bingbong70 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @11:01PM (#27311276)
The vast majority of English media is published by 2-3 countries, whatever they believe or are incentivized by their governments/capital-class to publish usually become the mainstream narratives.

This centralized system of information dissemination has tremendous flaws.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by Chris2048 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @10:23AM (#27303500)
But many dismissed the idea outright, not on the basis of lack of proof, but on the basis of some outrage (or implying the existence of counter-proof, 'debunking', or at least consensus of expert opinion)

Further more, the media needs to maintain that standard themselves:

- No more anonymous, un-interrogatable sources;

- No accusations of bad motive (e.g. racism) without proof - such as those implied of the conspiracy theorists.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by bdcravens on Thursday May 27, 2021 @10:38AM (#27303680)
Both of those standards would invalidate many of the claims we're discussing as well.
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by kodah on Thursday May 27, 2021 @04:36PM (#27308108)
I think GPs framework is more aimed at the media and not a message board of pseudonymous nerds. There's an ocean of power on one side and relatively near none on the other.
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by Chris2048 on Friday May 28, 2021 @12:05PM (#27317094)
The claim that the virus originated in the lab? Yes.

The claim that the virus might have originated in the lab? No.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by rufus_foreman on Thursday May 27, 2021 @09:05AM (#27302586)
>> The response to "conspiracy theories" is: show us your proof

No, the response was to ridicule people making those arguments and to censor them.

Like Glenn Kessler of the Washington Post telling Ted Cruz last May:

"I fear @tedcruz missed the scientific animation in the video that shows how it is virtually impossible for this virus jump from the lab. Or the many interviews with actual scientists. We deal in facts, and viewers can judge for themselves."

Or like "Twitter bans Chinese virologist claiming that coronavirus was made in a lab".

As usual, best summed up by the Babylon Bee:

"World-renowned fact-checking website Snopes has unveiled a brand new fact check rating called "False For Now." This will allow them to provide a rating for claims that are just conspiracy theories uttered by deranged far-right people until they later turn out to be true".

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by Chris2048 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @10:31AM (#27303604)
To be fair, they said the response "to .. is" as in "it ( ought to / should ) be" - not "was"

Point stands though. Lacking the ability to argue the case, the press often derive authority from the ability to slander, censor and humiliate.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by loopz on Thursday May 27, 2021 @01:05PM (#27305318)
Please show citations of that then, of mainstream media doing the: slander, censor and humiliate, instead of just reporting one side or the other as usual.

Heck, US has a mature president now even acknowledging there are two major competing hypotheses. Seeing leaders embracing uncertainty is rare, so it seems humanity is going through a learning phase right now, having to face up to uncertainty and fear.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by Chris2048 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @01:16PM (#27305495)
What do you mean by "citation"? An academic reference, or an example?

There are examples of these in these comments, so if you doubt that these things are true (and cannot find examples in this thread) then please narrow it down to one - this isn't a wikipedia articles, theres as much burden on you to disprove something you disagree with, and you haven't yet stated you disagree with anything.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by loopz on Thursday May 27, 2021 @01:25PM (#27305622)
An example. I didn't find anything concrete in the comments.

So there's nothing further to discuss.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by jtdev on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:21AM (#27302132)
The media didn’t ask for proof of animal origin… in fact the media largely ran with animal origin with zero evidence to back that up.

There’s always been more evidence to support the lab leak theory for those paying attention.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by bdcravens on Thursday May 27, 2021 @10:45AM (#27303765)
According to the article, it's both:

"researchers had assembled an archive of cave-bat-borne coronaviruses"

Researchers were studying viruses that had an animal origin. The lab leak would be from not following proper safety protocols.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by jtdev on Thursday May 27, 2021 @12:14PM (#27304762)
Ah yes, the phrasing tricks have been a media favorite when discussing covid origins… conflating lab origin with natural origin through the almost certainty that the viral material used at the WIV originated in nature is pure intellectual dishonesty.
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by bingbong70 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @11:07PM (#27311315)
What people don't realize is there is an overlap between 'originating from nature" and "originating from a foreign attack", both share a non-lab-leak origin but the latter is not even considered in the countries (US, UK, Japan, etc) with a history of using bio-weapons against citizens/civilians.

Mistaking one for the other is highly probable.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by bdcravens on Thursday May 27, 2021 @10:44AM (#27303750)
The problem with "more evidence" is that much of it has been hearsay. Person A tells person B something. Person B repeats person A's claim to person C. Person A then talks to person C, and person C says it must be true because they've heard it from multiple sources.

I have no doubt there's good evidence pointing to the lab leak origin, but virtually everything I've been exposed to over the last year are typically rumors or graphics shared on social media. Hearing something a lot doesn't give it additional credibility.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by slightwinder on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:16AM (#27302072)
To be fair, the lab-theory was hijacked from the beginning by conspiracy-believers who told everyone it was a bio-weapon and released on purpose. The idea of an accidential leak of reasearch-material is poisoned till today, because any hint of a proof will be fuel for the nutheads. And at the moment there many nutheads and racists aiming at asians because of the pandemia.
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by Zababa on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:36AM (#27302278)
On the other hand, dismissing totally the idea to fight against conspiracy-believers and then go back on your words because of new evidence is exactly what creates more conspiracy-believers. An example of this was the WHO insisting that masks were useless and then telling everyone to wear masks. This is how you lose trust.

Part of the solution would be to say something along the lines of "Right now we don't have enough evidence to make a statement about the origin of the virus, so we'll refrain from talking about it until further evidence is brought to light.".

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by loopz on Thursday May 27, 2021 @01:10PM (#27305379)
If you listen to sane people, they are saying just that.

Though, media will report what various individuals and agencies report, and they will contradict eachother.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by Zababa on Thursday May 27, 2021 @04:20PM (#27307851)
They are, however these days they don't have much reach. The problem is that public institutions are losing trust, and on one hand they deserve it, but on the other hand people are preying on this paranoia.
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by jkingsbery on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:43AM (#27302353)
There probably were conspiracy theorists doing just that. But there were also articles like the one by Jim Geraghty (https://www.nationalreview.com/2020/04/coronavirus-china-tra...). Compare what he wrote to what is in the recent Atlantic article.

Geraghty:

> And none of the above is definitive proof that COVID-19 originated from a bat at either the Wuhan Center for Disease Control & Prevention or the Wuhan Institute of Virology. Definitive proof would require much broader access to information about what happened in those facilities in the time period before the epidemic in the city.

> But it is a remarkable coincidence that the Wuhan Institute of Virology was researching Ebola and SARS-associated coronaviruses in bats before the pandemic outbreak, and that in the month when Wuhan doctors were treating the first patients of COVID-19, the institute announced in a hiring notice that “a large number of new bat and rodent new viruses have been discovered and identified.” And the fact that the Chinese government spent six weeks insisting that COVID-19 could not be spread from person to person means that its denials about Wuhan laboratories cannot be accepted without independent verification.

Engber:

> Arguments in favor of the “lab-leak hypothesis” remain grounded, as they ever were, in the mere and highly suspicious fact that a coronavirus likely borne by bats, likely from a cave in southwest China, emerged 18 months ago, quite suddenly, in a city very far from southwest China—where researchers had assembled an archive of cave-bat-borne coronaviruses.

As Geraghty recounts yesterday (https://www.nationalreview.com/the-morning-jolt/even-xavier-...), many in the media, rather than assessing the facts themselves, just resulted to name calling against a conservative-leaning but measured writer. I also haven't seen Geraghty (and again, other more measured writers) claim to have definitive proof of the lab-leak theory (as some conspiracy theorists might claim), only that it is a possibility that shouldn't be dismissed out of hand. It is illogical, irresponsible and unscientific to say "well, this theory was picked up by racists, therefore we should dismiss it" rather than evaluating a possibility on it's own merits.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by bingbong70 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @11:10PM (#27311332)
I do find it interesting that the idea of a foreign country dropping covid in China is not even considered.

It's not even considered by the people who are aware of the history of mass anti-Sino biological warfare that took place around WW2 and the decades after.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by jkingsbery on Saturday May 29, 2021 @06:38AM (#27324317)
As the Geraghty article I cited mentions, the Wuhan Institute of Virology leak theory has at best circumstantial evidence, and very well might not be true. And in any case, the claim is not that it was intentional. While not impossible, there is currently zero evidence today that the virus came from anywhere else. There is zero evidence of any cases anywhere before those in China (indeed, before those in Wuhan). China is not known for having lax border crossings, making smuggling in vials unlikely. Wuhan is not close to a border, if someone came to Wuhan already infected, there would be a trail of infected people from the border to Wuhan, or other people would have been infected on a plane if a human carrier brought it in. If someone brought it in during the World Military Games as you seem to think in other posts, the timeline doesn't make sense, since the first cases of COVID weren't for at least a month after, in November (and besides the possible cases by the people who work at WIV, most cases started in December). Your hypothesis does not fit the data.

So I ask you: what evidence, even circumstantial, do you have for making the claim you do?

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by bingbong70 on Monday May 31, 2021 @09:27PM (#27349891)
My understanding is a few labs, including one in North Carolina, were working on this virus and shared samples with labs around the world. Unfortunately, these viruses are now easy enough for a small team anywhere in the world to create with the widely available tools....transporting a payload across borders is trivially easy.

Motives... the Chinese have no incentive to maliciously release a virus in their own country during an event that is tied to national pride and acts as a showcase of Chinese domestic development in Wuhan. The western warhawks on the other hand have a tremendous interest in obstructing any Chinese military cooperation with its peers. The potential motives seem quite clear...with the nice side effect of disrupting Chinese trade as the world recoils from a new downside risk of globalization.

The US and its allies have a long history of biological warfare against economic competitors. Even the Japanese bio-warfare campaign in WW2 China was supported, partially funded, and fully pardoned by the US/UK...people and history books tend to forget/omit that Imperial Japan received all of its oil and much of its supplies from the US. These supplies being cutoff (aka treaty violation) without FDR's/Churchill's knowledge are what resulted in the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor.

During periods of uncertainty, it's good to remember that America's left hand doesn't always know what its right hand is doing... and vice versa.

I tend to think history is in the process of rhyming again.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unit_731

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unit_Ei_1644

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaimingjie_germ_weapon_attac...

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by yostrovs on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:19AM (#27302110)
To be fair, you are exactly the type that the parent comment was referring to... People that effortlessly dismiss reasonable ideas. You add smears of racism on top of it to make sure the side that you disagree with is hated. Please reflect as the parent comment suggests.
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by yanderekko on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:26AM (#27302170)
Precisely. "This theory is popular with crazy racists" leads to "if you believe this then I am forced to assume that you're a crazy racist and disparage you accordingly" pretty effortlessly in 2021. This sort of bad-faith ad hominem is the real problem.
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by duckfang on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:29AM (#27302202)
You can say that, but I've heard the diatribes that the "China virus" was because they were playing with 5G and viruses and it escaped into bats and those chinamen ate the bats and...(cringe). Just go look up the conspiracies if you think I'm out of line - this is the mild version.

Most of the mouthbreathers talking earlier about the "China virus" labs was predominately with pro-trump, anti-vaxxer, anti-masker individuals (well, starting with trump first). It was political grandstanding at its best, combined with 'us vs them' mentality, and a hefty scooping of conspiracy theory. So yes, the bulk of us thinking peoples justly figured this was what it appeared to be: yet another Anti-Chinese diatribe done by a white nationalist conspiracy nut (aka: trump).

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by slibhb on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:45AM (#27302387)
This post is a great example of the prevailing "everything is political" mentality. You take an empirical question that has a definitive answer (whether or not we'll ever have that answer) and turn it into a political issue.

To you, a theory is invalid if your political enemies embrace that theory.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by duckfang on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:53AM (#27302460)
Of course it's political. The claim is "Chinese military virology lab was experimenting with highly infectious material, and it escaped into the general population."

And back in October 2020, this was published: https://www.dni.gov/index.php/newsroom/press-releases/item/2... . Is this right, or wrong?

This whole pandemic could have been handled as "We are following the medical and scientific establishment on best handling of the pandemic", but that wasn't the case. Instead, we have US states that have 'declared' Covid done, or worse yet have states that forbid companies providing proof of vaccination. The simple requirement of wearing masks, was rarely enforced. Quite a lot of assaults happened because workers at stores said something.

The politicians could have moved out of the way for science. They didnt, and they doubled down. And that got more people killed.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by slibhb on Thursday May 27, 2021 @09:01AM (#27302544)
"Where did covid come from?" is not a poliitcal question. It's an empirical question.

Your decision to turn it into a political question is a dead-end that prevents you from thinking.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by duckfang on Thursday May 27, 2021 @09:22AM (#27302749)
Convenient that you ignore my link:

https://www.dni.gov/index.php/newsroom/press-releases/item/2...

-------------------------

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

ODNI News Release No. 11-20

April 30, 2020 Intelligence Community Statement on Origins of COVID-19

WASHINGTON, D.C. – The Office of the Director of National Intelligence today issued the following Intelligence Community (IC) statement:

“The entire Intelligence Community has been consistently providing critical support to U.S. policymakers and those responding to the COVID-19 virus, which originated in China. The Intelligence Community also concurs with the wide scientific consensus that the COVID-19 virus was not manmade or genetically modified.

“As we do in all crises, the Community’s experts respond by surging resources and producing critical intelligence on issues vital to U.S. national security. The IC will continue to rigorously examine emerging information and intelligence to determine whether the outbreak began through contact with infected animals or if it was the result of an accident at a laboratory in Wuhan.”

-------------------------

Stress on the quote: "The Intelligence Community also concurs with the wide scientific consensus that the COVID-19 virus was not manmade or genetically modified."

So, is it for scientific or political reasons you are ignoring this?

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by slibhb on Thursday May 27, 2021 @09:37AM (#27302926)
Virologists (or the DNI...or anybody) cannot, in fact, look at a viral genome and tell whether it evolved naturally or in a lab. The reason these people make these claims is because they, like you, see everything as political.
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by Chris2048 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @10:35AM (#27303653)
> a white nationalist conspiracy nut (aka: trump)

Sure, Trump seems prone to accepting conspiracy theories (or at least acts like it) - but why "white nationalist"? Seems like people like to sprinkle in these accusations when they thing their audience won't question it - but the evidence is a weak string of unsubstantiated guilt-by-associations.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by loopz on Thursday May 27, 2021 @01:14PM (#27305455)
What about "America First", which supported Weimar Republic in 30's, isn't nationalistic?

The idea was good (hit mark audience that needed respite from all the "great globalization"), but the execution was about treason ("Trump First").

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by Chris2048 on Friday May 28, 2021 @08:24AM (#27314528)
And the "white" part?
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by loopz on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:16AM (#27316390)
Not speaking for others, but having fringe groups as security during official business, doesn't speak well of what other uses there might be for such groups.
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by Chris2048 on Friday May 28, 2021 @12:04PM (#27317070)
That's fairly speculative for an explicit declaration that Trump is a white nationalist, and very much guilt-by-association.

Also, I don't really consider a "white nationalist" to be a "nationalist" by the usual sense of the word (applying to nation), but rather a rarer, more abstract sense of the word (applying abstractly to "groups" such as race). White nationalism isn't necessarily compatible with race-defined nationalism e.g. if you would prioritise foreign whites over domestic non-whites.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by loopz on Friday May 28, 2021 @12:39PM (#27317538)
It must be speculative, that's the entire purpose of associating with such groups and using them as political ammunition. Doesn't stop these people from throwing them under the bus later, if the bet doesn't pan out.
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by eplanit on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:33AM (#27302250)
Your comment makes mostrovs point in the comment above.
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by duckfang on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:46AM (#27302399)
Easy to say that. But when you tear these claims down, they started with anything but factual or substantial.

1. COVID wasnt caused by 5G. Nor vice versa.

2. We've seen MERS, SARS, and other coronavirus diseases previously in the region. This isn't the only one, and wont be the last.

3. "Chinaman virus" is a point that comes from racism. It only highlights racist beliefs, and is no way any proof. (Why wasnt the "Spanish Flu" called "Kansas Kough" - it started on a Kansas military base?)

4. The most vehement supports of this conspiracy also loudly proclaim that masks don't work, and the vaccine is microchipped.

5. Masks work, of different efficacy depending on filter levels

6. No, the vaccine has no microchips.

And if you want to dig deeper, go watch the "Plandemic" video. That's an hour or so of conspiracy, including the elites infected the plebes to make more money.

When 1 conspiracy is chopped off, 2 take its place.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by pseudo0 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @09:00AM (#27302526)
Constructing an extraordinarily elaborate strawman does not make your beating up of that strawman argument any more impressive. Plenty of reasonable people simply asked "isn't it possible a lab with a history of safety issues studying coronaviruses made a mistake" and were immediately hit with these sorts of disingenuous guilt by association arguments.
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by yostrovs on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:37AM (#27302293)
Smears, guilt by association, accusations of racism: this is what You chose to focus on and reject the lab leak theory. You didn't listen to the facts, the issues that seemed strange. The stunning thing is that you continue to cling to smears and accusations of racism as reasonable regarding this topic.
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by slightwinder on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:40AM (#27302324)
Where exactly did I dismiss the Idea? Maybe you should learn to understand how people behave and what responsability is.

BTW https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-56218684

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by throwawayzRUU6f on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:46AM (#27302396)
This has been the saddest part of the pandemic to me. The epistemology of health policy is completely broken - fully reliant on arguments from authority, impervious to contrary evidence, initial beliefs clutched onto until the bitter end. Opinion makers are unable to distinguish between entertaining an idea and embracing it.

This lead to predictable debacles on mask usage, airborne spread, everyone's pet theories of innate population immunity, seasonality of the virus, virus origins, etc.

And yet - there are zero calls for introspection, blameless post-mortems. Nobody seems to care.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by loopz on Thursday May 27, 2021 @01:19PM (#27305546)
This is just "bread and circus". Those who look deeper down will see more going on underneath the layers of policymaking. Though, the real workers will need support for new ideas and improvements later.
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by recursivedoubts on Thursday May 27, 2021 @01:23PM (#27305585)
tragically underrated post

i view the last decade (perhaps two) as a complete shattering of nearly all epistemology and social trust

we are all now wandering in a forest of mirrors

or perhaps, rather, this is not a new condition, and we merely understand it

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by loopz on Thursday May 27, 2021 @01:32PM (#27305723)
Nobody expects the Spanish I^Hpandemic, that only happens once every 100 years or so. This should be expected, and the previous administration did everything to demolish whatever was left of pandemic response teams and plans, before it hit.
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by dstroot on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:42AM (#27302344)
Media’s role is to a) entertain us, or b) inform us.

Under a: say whatever gets you clicks. Period.

Under b: hypotheses and theories cannot be reported as truths. Hard evidence is needed. There are two ways a virus evolves- naturally or guided/engineered. Without proof of the latter it is safe to assume former. No humility needed. If/when we have evidence of latter we can now report that.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by moolcool on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:29AM (#27302205)
There's legitimate stories where there's a lot of smoke, and a lot of credible speculation (the Epstein story and lab-leak theory are two good examples). The problem is that these get coopted by qanon and affiliated groups and start to become less credible in the public eye as a result. There's some tragic irony to the fact that potentially well-meaning crackpots are being used as a smokescreen for those who are actually doing wrong.
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by slibhb on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:38AM (#27302303)
This is not what happens.

What happens is, people discuss something plausible for which there exists circumstantial evidence (e.g. lab leak theory). Then, the media, left and right, pretends it has defininitve answers and uses "q anon" as an excuse to claim the plausible theory is wrong.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by moolcool on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:43AM (#27302349)
Why can't both be true? Actual qanon types absolutely latch on to stories like this-- kind of a broken clock situation.
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by slibhb on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:48AM (#27302419)
Why do we care about q anon? Why has this tiny group of flat-earthers (at least half of whom are probably screwing around on the internet) become nationally known?
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by moolcool on Thursday May 27, 2021 @09:02AM (#27302546)
Because there's a hell of a lot of them. They also have a tendency to do things that effect others; like vote, and commit armed insurrections of the capitol.
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by slibhb on Thursday May 27, 2021 @09:10AM (#27302637)
There aren't a lot of them. Several hundred invalids rioting is not a lot.

The left wants to pretend that there are all these loony q anon believers just like the right wants to pretend all left-wingers are antifa anarchists. In reality, these are tiny groups that most Americans find utterly repulsive. And, perversely, the media's breathless coverage of these groups is boosting their membership.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by moolcool on Thursday May 27, 2021 @09:22AM (#27302742)
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by LargeWu on Thursday May 27, 2021 @09:12AM (#27302664)
Because they are among the most rabid supporters of the previous president. I don't think it's outlandish to say there was a positive feedback loop between the two, and it directly affected both policy and messaging, including public health. Just look at the resistance to getting the vaccine among these people - it threatens the herd immunity that is one of the goals of the vaccine program. This is due in no small part to the mixed messaging from the prior administration.
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by slibhb on Thursday May 27, 2021 @09:38AM (#27302940)
You're making a claim that vaccine hesitancy is about being a rabid conspiracy theorist (or "mixed messaging). I don't think you're right.

People don't like getting vaccines for rational reasons like: they don't like getting shots (much less 2), they're worried about side effects (which are real), they don't trust new technology (like mrna vaccines), and so on.

I think people should get vaccinated. But I understand why someone wouldn't and it has nothing to do with believing in q anon. It's like paying your taxes: I don't like paying my taxes but I do it because 1. I drive on the roads and 2. it's illegal not to. If not paying taxes was legal, I hope I'd still pay (because I drive on the roads) but a lot of people wouldn't (even though they should) for reasons that have nothing to do with being a conspiracy theorist.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by moolcool on Thursday May 27, 2021 @09:50AM (#27303096)
Comments like this (and many others in this thread) are so indicative to me of the bubble a lot of tech people live in. I personally know several people who are extremely vulnerable to the coronavirus (by age, location, and preexisting medical conditions) who are refusing the vaccine based on the premise that it was designed somehow to kill/sterilize/control them. Spend some time sleuthing on Facebook and you'll find groups with tens of thousands of people with this kind of mindset. I think there's a tendency for people on HN in particular to downplay this phenomenon because it directly implicates big tech in a very big way-- social media is a veritable incubator for these ideas.
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by loopz on Thursday May 27, 2021 @01:21PM (#27305570)
Maybe both are true? ;)
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by scarmig on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:33AM (#27302251)
This isn't about the public eye, primarily. It's about the "expert" voices in media who report on these things.

Most of what can reasonably called the mainstream media was misrepresenting lab leak theories as racist QAnon ramblings for a year before it entered the "it's okay to believe this" realm. This kind of dismissal ends up being the default mode for any idea which doesn't fall within a very narrow approved view of reality.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by LatteLazy on Thursday May 27, 2021 @11:29AM (#27304263)
Still waiting for the actual evidence...
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by arbitrage on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:25AM (#27302154)
the media has an interest in being right with their reporting. they won't apologise and say they were wrong; why would their customers continue reading & sharing their content if they're so fallible?

it's perverted interests and motivations.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by JoBrad on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:35AM (#27302272)
Respected media outlets frequently post retractions. That’s part of what makes them respectable, and attracts readers who are looking for honest reporting.
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by mschuster91 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:08AM (#27302024)
> Well, first and foremost, perhaps the media could pause and reflect on their treatment of anyone who raised the lab leak hypothesis for the past year.

Most didn't stop at "maybe this escaped from the lab in Wuhan", but went down the real rabbit hole accusing the Chinese government of manufacturing and releasing a bioweapon.

In any case there won't be any proof ever for any origin theory, the Chinese government has made certain of that.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by yanderekko on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:28AM (#27302185)
>Most didn't stop at "maybe this escaped from the lab in Wuhan", but went down the real rabbit hole accusing the Chinese government of manufacturing and releasing a bioweapon.

I don't think it's fair to say that "most" of these people thought it was deliberately released, whether or not they believed it was a bioweapon.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by jghn on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:13AM (#27302052)
This is precisely why it is so touchy. There’s been a strong correlation between people who believe lab leak and people who believe the Chinese were doing something bad.

As an anecdote, someone recently asked me if we could tell if the COVID genome had come via animals/natural origin or engineered in some way. I said that most likely, yes that should be possible. Their immediate reaction was that this meant I didn’t believe in lab leak. That’s not at all what I had said

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by pjc50 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:15AM (#27302068)
> if we could tell if the COVID genome had come via animals/natural origin or engineered in some way. I said that most likely, yes that should be possible

How?

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by garblegarble on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:18AM (#27302101)
There's quite a comprehensive document compiled by a virologist on reddit discussing what the options for engineering would be, and what traces they would leave, I found it quite interesting: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1kAHSEx9-eIyVIahczH8itHaUm9j...
Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by baybal2 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:27AM (#27302180)
No engineering, I want to underline it. This is not precluding a natural virus leak with, or without gain of function experiment involvement.

Current facts on the ground:

- 1st response to CoVID occurrence was certainly in Wuhan.

- The closest wild strain of CoVID happens in bats living thousand kilometres from Wuhan

- Wuhan had two institutes which, on record, did gain of function experiments on bat coronaviruses

- SARS had a record of lab escapes past the previous pandemic even without live animal hosts.

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by jghn on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:45AM (#27302384)
The story with the miners[1] has caught my attention. A group of miners fell ill w/ a SARS-like virus via bat droppings. In retrospect it sounds a heck of a lot like COVID. Wuhan was known to have investigated the case. Perhaps a researcher manages to get infected, or something like that.

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7606707/

Re:If the Lab-Leak Theory Is Right, What’s Next? by jghn on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:41AM (#27302334)
garblegarble's link explains it better than I could, but the tl;dr is that there are patterns that occur with natural evolution. Messing with those patterns would look, well, unnatural.