News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by BitwiseFool on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:50PM (#27295918)
The most disturbing and insidious sentiment of online mobs is claiming that the targets are "just being held accountable". Or that such people are just experiencing "consequences". I really can't express just how cold and bloodthirsty such statements seem to be. It's the perfect combination of justifying vicious behavior while also absolving themselves of responsibility.
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by Syonyk on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:20PM (#27296257)
> It's the perfect combination of justifying vicious behavior while also absolving themselves of responsibility.

And Twitter/Facebook/YouTube just grin, raking in the advertising dollars from "engagement." The more people "engaged" in the activity, the better!

I don't think the concept of social media is fundamentally evil. It's dangerous, certainly, but I don't think the core concept must be evil.

Public "social media companies," driven to improve revenue from injecting advertising into streams consisting of repackaging other people's content? Those seem to reliably turn evil.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by throwkeep on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:09PM (#27296138)
Well said. And notice how the refrain changed. For years it was complete denial with "cancel culture doesn't exist". Now the response is, "it's just consequence culture".
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by zxzax on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @06:45PM (#27297088)
Just to be clear, is it "cancel culture" or "consequence culture" when the legal system puts people in jail, or practices capital punishment? Or are those considered something different entirely? If so, why?
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by abnry on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:08PM (#27297258)
The idea of a justice system in a democracy is (a) the laws are agreed upon through the political process and (b) due process and impartial consideration are applied in casting a judgment.

"Cancel culture" is primarily enforcing things that (a) have not reached the same political consensus as codified law, like laws against theft or murder, and (b) are enforced by impulse, hearsay, and mob mentality.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by caddemon on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:22PM (#27297381)
Yeah the thing that concerns me most about "cancel culture" (of what I see) is people openly pushing back on the principle of innocent until proven guilty. It seems to be common to argue that there is nothing wrong with the court of public opinion putting the burden of proof on the accused. Usually this is combined with some comment about how horrible the accusation is versus how supposedly mild it is to be criticized across the internet.

It's human nature to spread rumors and make snap judgements, so I'm not sure how much this can be stopped. But it scares me to see people straight up trying to morally justify it.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by zxzax on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:28PM (#27297448)
I mean, to me that sadly is nothing new. I've known my share of people who just assume by default that people they don't know are jerks, and are hostile toward them. I don't know what you would call it. Untrusting? I can't see where you would cross that line and all of a sudden start calling it "cancel culture" or "consequence culture" or whatever. Is it because it's happening online now?
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by caddemon on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:02PM (#27298877)
The part that is new, or at least recently en vogue again, is how this behavior is seen as a positive. It is explicitly encouraged by current social dynamics. It is even encouraged to some extent in academic or "intellectual" circles.
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by zxzax on Thursday May 27, 2021 @05:55AM (#27301042)
Do you have any studies that actually quantify that? IMO large groups singling out and bullying individuals is not really a new thing, that has been happening for a long time.
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by kian on Thursday May 27, 2021 @10:26AM (#27303543)
Bullying individuals is not new. Arguing that bedrock principles of legal justice like innocent until proven guilty are quaint and antiquated in the face of the 'horrors' of the accusations (odd that they should apply to serial killers, but new modern thought-crimes are so much worse that they should not) is relatively new, especially as a mainstream position in intellectual, academic, and political circles.
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by zxzax on Thursday May 27, 2021 @11:01AM (#27303945)
That has not been my experience, do you have any studies that quantify that? From my perspective, the entire concept of legal rights and due process is what is actually the new thing, considering the total span of history anyway. These were not things that anybody had 1000 years ago, and even now some political entities still don't really have it or consider it valid (unfortunately).
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by caddemon on Thursday May 27, 2021 @06:25PM (#27309339)
As far as institutional memory is concerned, new is anything that hasn't been seen in a couple generations' lifetimes, certainly not 1000s of years. This is also why I included "recently en vogue" in my prior comment, I'm not claiming that this thought process has literally never been seen before. Just that some cultural phenomena display a back and forth pattern, with a timescale such that it will feel entirely new to the current population when it's out in full force. Further, the negative impacts of the extreme adoption are precisely what will push the pendulum back eventually.

Also I will clarify I am speaking from a US-centric perspective. Are you not in the US?

I have seen multiple academic circles seriously come to the consensus that innocent until proven guilty is not good as a general principle. This sort of thing IME occurs on mailing lists or in department meetings, and it has also ramped up considerably in just the last few years. I've never looked for literature on the topic, perhaps the institutions I am affiliated with just suck. But given the many others reporting similar sentiments I suspect there will be some literature on it as a broader phenomenon, at least in the US, down the road.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by zxzax on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:15PM (#27297314)
I guess I'm confused, there are a lot of things in life that become known by hearsay and don't reach the same consensus as codified law. What makes this special? Would it really be any different if twitter actively had daily democratic polling on who should be criticized that day? And how would that be any different from "mob mentality," if large groups of users all decided to impulsively vote the same way?
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by TrispusAttucks on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:25PM (#27297412)
Innocent until proven guilty by a fair trial. Not the other way around.

The entire point of justice was to be less tribal. Social justice now is the opposite. It's who has the biggest tribal cannon they can point at someone they disagree with. Not whether the facts support the claim.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by zxzax on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:34PM (#27297492)
So what is the solution there? Should twitter and facebook have their own internal legal system, decided upon by democratic vote as I was just describing? What would make it inherently less tribal if they did that? Would that stop large groups of people from all deciding to vote as a block and criticize one person all at once? Or is the goal something else? Surely, if this problem were theoretically solvable by a social media site, there should be some different way to operate one?
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by kortilla on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:49PM (#27297617)
The legal system goes to great lengths to prevent it being everyone just voting who is guilty.

Democracy is not for individual cases. Jury selection throws out 95% of people because there are so many biases that make democracy terrible for this kind of analysis.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by zxzax on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:54PM (#27297643)
So to allow any post through, twitter should have a process that randomly selects an unbiased jury of other twitter posters, and have them judge the post before it becomes public? And that process will be administered by democratically elected representatives who ultimately decide on the 5% that doesn't get thrown out? What if you are a person who just happens to hold strong preconceived opinions about a lot of things, wouldn't you be seen as "too biased" for any jury, and get totally excluded from this process? Would that be the system being fair, or would it be another example of "cancel culture" stopping people from being jurors? I don't know, I'm just spitballing here, I'm not a legal expert or anything, but I do know that jury stacking/tampering is a real thing that happens.
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by kortilla on Thursday June 03, 2021 @01:51AM (#27377663)
I’m not sure what your point even is. Twitter should just not allow people to claim other people raped/robbed/etc without pointing to some actual conviction or ongoing trial.

No letting a pool of people decide guilt based on literally no evidence. That’s insane.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by lmm on Thursday May 27, 2021 @12:19AM (#27299354)
- Social media should not allow the broadcasting of unproven allegations that individuals have committed crimes, just as conventional media is barred from doing so until the cases have been heard in court.

- Utility-like services should not be allowed to refuse service to individuals without clear reason.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by zxzax on Thursday May 27, 2021 @06:19AM (#27301161)
#1 seems practically impossible to do, considering that the definition of what a crime is tends to vary between jurisdictions. It may work if on a closed internet and social media that is segregated by jurisdiction.

#2 is already true in some cases, but as usual, the real answer is something like "it depends."

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by lmm on Thursday May 27, 2021 @10:33PM (#27311140)
> #1 seems practically impossible to do, considering that the definition of what a crime is tends to vary between jurisdictions.

Alleging that someone has done something that happens to be a crime aren't a problem, the problem is wilfully alleging crimes outside the court system. The overwhelming majority of the posts that cause these problems either explicitly claim that someone has committed a crime, or explicitly claim that someone has committed an act that is well known to be a crime.

> #2 is already true in some cases

Not really in the US AFAICS? Certain narrowly defined groups are protected against being denied service by private businesses, but there's no broad general protection.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by philwelch on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:44PM (#27296493)
Whenever the talk of “consequences” starts, I’m reminded of a quote:

“There is freedom of speech, but I cannot guarantee freedom after speech.” —Idi Amin

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by bendbro on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:25PM (#27297408)
Yeah, the "freedom of speech doesn't mean freedom from consequences" response that some liberals give has always puzzled me. It is internally inconsistent for a liberal ideology.

1. They believe that "wage slavery" exists. That is, an employee may freely agree to employment conditions under a capitalist view, but under the liberal view, they have not freely agreed since various coercive forces exist that force them agree to the employment conditions. So if a liberal believes a "freely" agreed to job is actually not free due to coercive conditions, then a liberal should also believe that free speech is not free when coercive conditions exist that control speech.

2. The idea that any consequence of free speech is acceptable is easily countered: the consequence of you calling an insane person stupid is they kill you. Obviously no normal person would think that is acceptable. So every normal person, including those liberals with internal inconsistency in this argument, know that the argument should actually be about what consequences are warranted in response to speech.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by bitwize on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:03PM (#27298881)
> The idea that any consequence of free speech is acceptable is easily countered: the consequence of you calling an insane person stupid is they kill you.

"[John] Solomon is hiding because he is a coward who enjoys belittling other people from behind a safe veil of invisibility. His is like many sites on the internet, who mock and insult while lacking any courage to own their own words. In public, these cowards would not dare to say the same things, because they know full well that someone just might come after them, knock their yapping blocks off, or in a worst case scenario, go to their house one night and kill them." --Jennifer Diane Reitz, on someone who gave her webcomic a bad review.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by alisonkisk on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:55AM (#27302484)
Wow, that's quite a Self-Aware Wolf.
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by didibus on Thursday May 27, 2021 @12:19AM (#27299355)
If you're interested in learning about the values held by liberals, as one myself, I recommend you read the UN declaration of human rights https://www.un.org/en/about-us/universal-declaration-of-huma... as I think it does the best job at summarizing the general values held by liberals.

Now don't get fooled by what you've been told. Internet Mobs and liberals are unrelated groups, but there are politically inclined groups who are pushing an agenda to discredit liberals by association, this is a fallacy, if you want to learn more about that here's the wikipedia entry: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Association_fallacy

> the argument attacks a person because of the similarity between the views of someone making an argument and other proponents of the argument

So please, don't fall for this, there is no way to know what political values the people refered too in the article that were part of the mob had, lots of internet mobs are conservative, libertarian, communist, socialist, etc. just as well.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by bendbro on Thursday May 27, 2021 @01:02AM (#27299579)
Great, so then you must agree, only a complete idiot would call themselves a liberal and also believe free speech should have negative consequences.

One of the liberals I respect most, Noam Chomsky, agrees: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=zwojLDxOWGA

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by didibus on Thursday May 27, 2021 @02:06AM (#27299894)
It's only a 5 min read, I recommend it, you might find you have more shared liberal values then you thought, but if you're not going too, let me point out some of the relevant ones here:

Article 12 > No one shall be subjected to arbitrary interference with his privacy, family, home or correspondence, nor to attacks upon his honour and reputation. Everyone has the right to the protection of the law against such interference or attacks.

This is a liberal value. False accusations go against this, so would most of the US politcal tactics employed to smear and discriminate other parties. It's rampant in today's society, in fact you did just that, by trying to compare people who disagree with you as "idiots". You took attack on their reputation.

Article 23 > Everyone who works has the right to just and favourable remuneration ensuring for himself and his family an existence worthy of human dignity, and supplemented, if necessary, by other means of social protection

Wage slavery is a catchy attention seeking way of saying that this right is being breached by a lot of employers.

Article 19 > Everyone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression; this right includes freedom to hold opinions without interference and to seek, receive and impart information and ideas through any media and regardless of frontiers.

This is where it gets tricky. It is your right to be allowed to tell others on social media about any information or ideas you hold. So it seem to make sense that one could tell people that their ex was abusive and a scumbag. And in turn it is fine for others to tell the ex they believe what they think of it.

But what if your ideas are an attack on someone's else honor or reputation? Are you still free to express them? Would it not then breach the other right to not have honor and reputation attacked?

Well yes, this is a dilemma. One where different people lean more on one right or the other. In the US, people lean more on the right to speech, so it tends to be free game to say whatever you want and thus internet mobs are okay.

Now what I think is that there is no real contradiction. You have the right to express yourself freely, but not to hurt someone else's reputation. So expressing lies and falsehoods to attack someone goes against that person's rights, and your right to express yourself freely is for things you believe to be truthful, or things which don't attack someone's reputation only.

That said, and I won't quote them here, other liberal values say everyone is innocent before proven guilty and have the right to a fair trial. So it would be to the person whose reputation they feel attacked to prove that the other person did in fact express lies and falsehoods to attack their reputation, and that person would need a fair trial and be treated innocent until guilty. Similarly no penal offence can be taken against someone just because there is somebody claiming they are abusive and were harassed by them, a fair trial must be held.

That leaves us with how things are exactly right now. Everyone is free to say what they want to anyone else, and everyone is free to any idea they hold of others. And for the government to interfere in any way, there'd need to be a fair trial that proves that one person's speech was a real attack on someone's reputation, and not just sharing their truths.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by LeCow on Thursday May 27, 2021 @03:24AM (#27300326)
"wage slavery"

Part of liberalism is accepting your own flaws and failures. Go and get another job.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by bendbro on Thursday May 27, 2021 @02:44AM (#27300128)
I don't know why you think I disagree with the idea of liberalism. I simply think if someone is a liberal, they should believe purely disagreeable speech should not have consequences; else, they are an idiot.

There are of course more complexities where speech should result in consequences, but in general, if someone says something than another otherwise unrelated person simply disagrees with, the speaker should not have their relationship with their friends, family, employer, customers, businesses they use, etc harmed. This should be enforced sometimes by law, and sometimes by culture, depending on the rights in play in the particular situation, as you outlined above.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by krapp on Thursday May 27, 2021 @06:21AM (#27301173)
>There are of course more complexities where speech should result in consequences, but in general, if someone says something than another otherwise unrelated person simply disagrees with, the speaker should not have their relationship with their friends, family, employer, customers, businesses they use, etc harmed.

So you do agree that freedom of speech doesn't mean freedom from consequences after all.

This is exactly what people who say that also believe. They're not supporting harassment, slander or the suppression of non-harmful political speech, nor are they claiming all consequences for speech are equally valid. Rather, simply stating that there are "complexities where speech should result in consequences."

Where the two sides actually differ (when one strips away the strawmen, trolling and bad faith arguments every iteration of this conversation generates) is what speech should be considered "purely disagreeable" (which is a purely subjective term) and what consequences are valid, which can only be determined on a case by case basis, in context.

I personally believe hateful speech should have consequences, even when it isn't explicitly and immediately threatening harm on a specific individual. An employer has the right not to associate with an employee who publicly makes bigoted statements on social media which the public has associated with the company. The public has the right to oppose such speech where it exists, and to try to convince employers to take action.

An actor or public figure whose politics I disagree with can and should be publicly criticized, and their suffering some financial harm due to the public boycotting their work is a legitimate consequence of their views.

A politician, even a sitting President of the United States, who spreads lies and misinformation can be criticized, fact-checked or even banned from social media. And yes, social media platforms should have the right to determine what can and cannot appear on their platforms, and to moderate that content beyond strict legality.

All of that is clearly within the long-established and generally agreed upon boundaries of free speech and freedom of association. None of it is a carte blanche endorsement of harassment.

We may disagree about the details, or be in violent agreement, but everyone is drawing a line in the sand somewhere.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by lordloki on Thursday May 27, 2021 @09:23AM (#27302754)
"An actor or public figure whose politics I disagree with can and should be publicly criticized, and their suffering some financial harm due to the public boycotting their work is a legitimate consequence of their views."

So you think it's perfectly acceptable to attack an individuals livelihood because you disagree with them? The political climate in the US is split pretty evenly at the moment, so in your view we would have no actors or public figures expressing a political opinion. No matter what the opinion is there would be individuals, like yourself, who disagree with it and therefore the speaker should be cancelled. If everyone felt that way then nobody would be allowed to say anything because all expression would lead to cancellation. This goes completely against freedom of the individual as well as freedom of speech. It is a direct slide into authoritarianism and is diametrically opposed to liberalism. OP is correct you are not a liberal you are an authoritarian.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by didibus on Thursday May 27, 2021 @10:28PM (#27311110)
I think there's different scenarios.

1. Someone loses popularity and thus their business suffers from it.

This is totally fine. I'm free not to purchase your books, music, products, services, etc. even if simply because I disagree with you on some things.

2. Someone is fired because people disagree with their ideas or thoughts.

Now this can be wrong and it can also be alright:

2.1 Someone expressed an opinion which respected other people's rights, but where a lot of people disagreed with. E.g.: I think we should invest heavily in the military to defend our borders.

In this case, this is not acceptable grounds to fire them. People have the right to hold and express their ideas freely without repercussions.

2.2 Someone expressed an opinion aimed at the destruction of other people's rights. E.g.: Black people should not be given equal treatment under the law. Women are not fit to work. White people deserve to rule over others.

In this case it is acceptable to fire them, because they attacked other people's rights, and that deserves consequences. BUT not without a fair trial. You still owe a fair trial to prove that they indeed engaged in activities aimed at the destruction of other people's rights. So in this case the person being fired should choose to sue if this happens.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by bendbro on Thursday May 27, 2021 @01:01PM (#27305264)
Yes, I totally agree that the argument should be about "... what speech should be considered 'purely disagreeable' (which is a purely subjective term) and what consequences are valid". As I said in my very first comment, "... the argument should actually be about what consequences are warranted in response to speech".

> I personally believe hateful speech should have consequences, even when it isn't explicitly and immediately threatening harm on a specific individual

My problem with that is it makes large swaths of modern left politics uncriticizable, since any criticism of those politics will be construed as hate. Right wing politics were also once uncriticizable, in the "war on christmas" days, but that has since faded.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by krapp on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:02PM (#27310154)
>My problem with that is it makes large swaths of modern left politics uncriticizable, since any criticism of those politics will be construed as hate.

Except it doesn't, because people criticize the modern left all the time, to the point that "the left" (or now the "woke left") has become a pejorative on its own. On Hacker News dunking on the left is practically a sport. And as far as hate goes, everything "the left" says, does and believes gets construed as hate as well.

But that's not a free speech issue, that's just a speech issue. Criticizing politics is criticizing people and their identity and worldview. People will inevitably take such criticism personally.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by alisonkisk on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:57AM (#27302503)
That person is being coy about the difference between Liberal and Progressive and Social Activist, perhaps because they are unaware of the meaning of "liberal" in American politics.
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by didibus on Thursday May 27, 2021 @09:53PM (#27310900)
> I don't know why you think I disagree with the idea of liberalism

If you agree with the ideas of liberalism, by definition that would make you a liberal, but from the way you talked about "liberals", it sounded like you excluded yourself from that group, which would mean you disagree at least partly with the ideas of liberalism.

Sorry if I was wrong, you consider yourself a liberal then?

> they should believe purely disagreeable speech should not have consequences

You have the right to be disagreeable, but others have the right to hold ideas and opinions of you and tell others about them too, unless as a direct attempt to discredit you. I think the confusion here is because the word "consequence" is too vague.

If you're a disagreeable person, and no one wants to hangout with you or be your friend anymore as a result of finding you obnoxious. Well ya that's in everyone's rights, nobody is obligated to like you.

But you have rights too, the right to dignity, a livable wage, to your reputation, etc. And so this is where there can't be consequences that would breach your own rights, which are universal to all, even obnoxious disagreeable people have them, so do gays, trans, women, blacks, asian, muslims, etc.

So what you have to do is show that your rights have been violated, and now you have a case.

If you get fired for something you are accused of which is false, I'm pretty sure you do have a case and can go to court, prove it was false and thus slender, and you'll get your job back, and penal offence can be taken to the lier.

> This should be enforced sometimes by law, and sometimes by culture, depending on the rights in play in the particular situation, as you outlined above.

Now I think you're bringing another dimension. If people don't like Joe, and they get fired on ground that he's obnoxious, despicable, repulsive, make others feel unsafe, etc. Does that go against Joe's rights?

This is a tricky one. The first issue is what do we mean by disagreeable? Because that could mean that Joe is breaching other people's rights.

Article 30 > Nothing in this Declaration may be interpreted as implying for any State, group or person any right to engage in any activity or to perform any act aimed at the destruction of any of the rights and freedoms set forth herein

See, Joe doesn't have the right to engage in activities aimed at the destruction of any of the other rights. And this supersedes his rights as well. So he has the right to speech, but to not speak against other people's rights.

So now if by "disagreeable", we mean that Joe is actively taking part in propagating the idea that women are not fit to work and should instead be housewives. Well based on Article 30, Joe doesn't have the right to say that and he's infringing on women's rights, and so consequences can very well apply, even losing his job.

Now if by disagreeable we mean that Joe is simply someone who is always the devil advocate, or who is ackward socially, etc. Well ya then it be a pretty big violation to fire Joe purely on those grounds.

Now also, Joe doesn't have the right to "keep his job no matter what", but he has the right "to protection against unemployment", and to "economic indispensable for his dignity and the free development of his personality".

So in theory, it's fine to fire Joe just because he's an asshole, but he should still be given protection against unemployment and provided with ways to have economic prosperity required to keep his dignity and develop his full personality.

So you see, you cannot discriminate against other people's rights, because others have rights that protects against discrimination, but you are allowed to discriminate against someone who is actively engaging in discrimination. This is perfectly consistent. But dont get me wrong, there should still be a fair trial, you're innocent until proven guilty, and until it's been shown that you were discriminating yourself, you shouldn't be discriminated against.

But most courts have failed to look into such issues and to hold trials and all that related to these issues. So it has entered the social sphere instead, unfortunately, and now everyone is trying to pretend like they are being discriminated against left and right in order to justify their own discrimination of others. It's a shame really.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by UnpossibleJim on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:11PM (#27296166)
It shows that witch trials haven't gone away; they never really did. They just became more technologically savvy in their influence, both publicly and politically.
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by specialist on Thursday May 27, 2021 @11:03AM (#27303966)
Socrates was an early victim of "cancel culture".

Every generation thinks they discovered sex. Kids rebel against the hierarchy. Elders complain about "kids these days."

Lather, rinse, repeat.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by imgabe on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:12PM (#27298948)
The "consequences" thing is one of my biggest pet peeves.

Literally everything is a consequence of something else. If you cut someone off in traffic, they might hunt you down and shoot you. That is a possible consequence. It doesn't mean it's a just or appropriate consequence or that we as a society should allow it.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by zxzax on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @06:39PM (#27297030)
So how could responsibility be ensured? Make a social media site where people can't criticize each other at all? Require all posts to go through third party fact checkers?

To put it another way: If, in your opinion, twitter users are not subject to accountability based on the chaotic randomness of public opinion, then who are they being held accountable to? Who even determines what a "consequence" is in that scenario, or what the threshold for that bloodthirsty behavior is? Honest questions here, I really don't know what the solution is.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by exporectomy on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @06:57PM (#27297192)
How about more employee friendly labor law so people can't get fired because of public pressure? Without teeth, this mob justice will be less of a real world problem and more contained to social media.
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by zxzax on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:00PM (#27297204)
So what would that look like? Would employers no longer field public complaints about potential problem employees, under any circumstances? In effect, they would be required to always side with the employee in case of a dispute?
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by lmm on Thursday May 27, 2021 @12:23AM (#27299372)
It would look like France, Japan, or, y'know, most industrialised countries. Employers would be required to give cause for any firing, and follow a documented process in which the employee has certain rights (e.g. the right to be assisted by a union representative, see the evidence against them, respond to allegations).
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by zxzax on Thursday May 27, 2021 @05:52AM (#27301018)
In some cases, that is how it already works in the US: https://www.nlrb.gov/about-nlrb/rights-we-protect/your-right...

As usual with legal stuff, the answer really seems to depends on the nature of was posted, and the employment contract that is in place.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by lmm on Thursday May 27, 2021 @10:29PM (#27311122)
> In some cases, that is how it already works in the US: https://www.nlrb.gov/about-nlrb/rights-we-protect/your-right...

Not really. Per your link, employees are protected in a very narrow subset of cases - where what they are doing on social media is 100% protected labour activity. But firing employees arbitrarily for social media posts (outside of those narrow protections) is completely fine. That's completely backwards from how it works in most of the developed world, where the burden of proof is on the employer who must show that the firing was for a permitted cause, rather than the employee having to show that they were fired for a non-permitted cause.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by exporectomy on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:46PM (#27297590)
Perhaps it would exclude complaints about what they do in their job but firing someone for things they do that are unrelated to their job could be protected, like what happened in their personal relationships or what they posted on the internet if it's not part of their work.
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by mcguire on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @09:33PM (#27298358)
Picture someone you really dislike, for some good reason. Now imagine you hired that person before they did whatever, or before you found out. Now you're stuck with them. Now your company is known primarily for what they did and you are losing business.
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by lordloki on Thursday May 27, 2021 @09:27AM (#27302795)
If everyone knows the company can't fire them, then why target the company in the first place?
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by mcguire on Thursday May 27, 2021 @03:17PM (#27306960)
The company is paying George the Putrescent Person to do nothing, because nobody there wants to work with him, either?
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by exporectomy on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:01PM (#27310146)
So basically the way it was with overt racist and sexist hiring before that was illegal? The solution is to suck it up and let the other employees who are too bigoted to cope quit.
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by zxzax on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:58PM (#27297666)
That seems to hinge a lot on having a specific and consistent definition of what "related to the job" and "part of their work" means that won't unfairly affect some companies, maybe there is an established legal definition of that somewhere?
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by exporectomy on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:08PM (#27297742)
The legal system manages to work out vague definitions. Here's an excerpt from New Zealand's employment law regarding unjustifiable dismissal:

"The test is whether the employer’s actions, and how the employer acted, were what a fair and reasonable employer could have done in all the circumstances at the time the dismissal or action occurred."

How's that for specific and consistent! Yet it still provides protection against capricious firing.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by zxzax on Thursday May 27, 2021 @05:53AM (#27301027)
Some US states do have laws of that type, though not all of them. In general, the answer to any kind of employer abuse is mostly the same as always: unionize.
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by matheusmoreira on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @09:11PM (#27298182)
The truth is these people are looking for acceptable targets they can safely lash out against.