News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by abnry on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:08PM (#27297258)
The idea of a justice system in a democracy is (a) the laws are agreed upon through the political process and (b) due process and impartial consideration are applied in casting a judgment.

"Cancel culture" is primarily enforcing things that (a) have not reached the same political consensus as codified law, like laws against theft or murder, and (b) are enforced by impulse, hearsay, and mob mentality.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by caddemon on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:22PM (#27297381)
Yeah the thing that concerns me most about "cancel culture" (of what I see) is people openly pushing back on the principle of innocent until proven guilty. It seems to be common to argue that there is nothing wrong with the court of public opinion putting the burden of proof on the accused. Usually this is combined with some comment about how horrible the accusation is versus how supposedly mild it is to be criticized across the internet.

It's human nature to spread rumors and make snap judgements, so I'm not sure how much this can be stopped. But it scares me to see people straight up trying to morally justify it.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by zxzax on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:28PM (#27297448)
I mean, to me that sadly is nothing new. I've known my share of people who just assume by default that people they don't know are jerks, and are hostile toward them. I don't know what you would call it. Untrusting? I can't see where you would cross that line and all of a sudden start calling it "cancel culture" or "consequence culture" or whatever. Is it because it's happening online now?
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by caddemon on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:02PM (#27298877)
The part that is new, or at least recently en vogue again, is how this behavior is seen as a positive. It is explicitly encouraged by current social dynamics. It is even encouraged to some extent in academic or "intellectual" circles.
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by zxzax on Thursday May 27, 2021 @05:55AM (#27301042)
Do you have any studies that actually quantify that? IMO large groups singling out and bullying individuals is not really a new thing, that has been happening for a long time.
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by kian on Thursday May 27, 2021 @10:26AM (#27303543)
Bullying individuals is not new. Arguing that bedrock principles of legal justice like innocent until proven guilty are quaint and antiquated in the face of the 'horrors' of the accusations (odd that they should apply to serial killers, but new modern thought-crimes are so much worse that they should not) is relatively new, especially as a mainstream position in intellectual, academic, and political circles.
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by zxzax on Thursday May 27, 2021 @11:01AM (#27303945)
That has not been my experience, do you have any studies that quantify that? From my perspective, the entire concept of legal rights and due process is what is actually the new thing, considering the total span of history anyway. These were not things that anybody had 1000 years ago, and even now some political entities still don't really have it or consider it valid (unfortunately).
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by caddemon on Thursday May 27, 2021 @06:25PM (#27309339)
As far as institutional memory is concerned, new is anything that hasn't been seen in a couple generations' lifetimes, certainly not 1000s of years. This is also why I included "recently en vogue" in my prior comment, I'm not claiming that this thought process has literally never been seen before. Just that some cultural phenomena display a back and forth pattern, with a timescale such that it will feel entirely new to the current population when it's out in full force. Further, the negative impacts of the extreme adoption are precisely what will push the pendulum back eventually.

Also I will clarify I am speaking from a US-centric perspective. Are you not in the US?

I have seen multiple academic circles seriously come to the consensus that innocent until proven guilty is not good as a general principle. This sort of thing IME occurs on mailing lists or in department meetings, and it has also ramped up considerably in just the last few years. I've never looked for literature on the topic, perhaps the institutions I am affiliated with just suck. But given the many others reporting similar sentiments I suspect there will be some literature on it as a broader phenomenon, at least in the US, down the road.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by zxzax on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:15PM (#27297314)
I guess I'm confused, there are a lot of things in life that become known by hearsay and don't reach the same consensus as codified law. What makes this special? Would it really be any different if twitter actively had daily democratic polling on who should be criticized that day? And how would that be any different from "mob mentality," if large groups of users all decided to impulsively vote the same way?
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by TrispusAttucks on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:25PM (#27297412)
Innocent until proven guilty by a fair trial. Not the other way around.

The entire point of justice was to be less tribal. Social justice now is the opposite. It's who has the biggest tribal cannon they can point at someone they disagree with. Not whether the facts support the claim.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by zxzax on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:34PM (#27297492)
So what is the solution there? Should twitter and facebook have their own internal legal system, decided upon by democratic vote as I was just describing? What would make it inherently less tribal if they did that? Would that stop large groups of people from all deciding to vote as a block and criticize one person all at once? Or is the goal something else? Surely, if this problem were theoretically solvable by a social media site, there should be some different way to operate one?
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by kortilla on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:49PM (#27297617)
The legal system goes to great lengths to prevent it being everyone just voting who is guilty.

Democracy is not for individual cases. Jury selection throws out 95% of people because there are so many biases that make democracy terrible for this kind of analysis.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by zxzax on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:54PM (#27297643)
So to allow any post through, twitter should have a process that randomly selects an unbiased jury of other twitter posters, and have them judge the post before it becomes public? And that process will be administered by democratically elected representatives who ultimately decide on the 5% that doesn't get thrown out? What if you are a person who just happens to hold strong preconceived opinions about a lot of things, wouldn't you be seen as "too biased" for any jury, and get totally excluded from this process? Would that be the system being fair, or would it be another example of "cancel culture" stopping people from being jurors? I don't know, I'm just spitballing here, I'm not a legal expert or anything, but I do know that jury stacking/tampering is a real thing that happens.
Re:Life after an internet mob attack by kortilla on Thursday June 03, 2021 @01:51AM (#27377663)
I’m not sure what your point even is. Twitter should just not allow people to claim other people raped/robbed/etc without pointing to some actual conviction or ongoing trial.

No letting a pool of people decide guilt based on literally no evidence. That’s insane.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by lmm on Thursday May 27, 2021 @12:19AM (#27299354)
- Social media should not allow the broadcasting of unproven allegations that individuals have committed crimes, just as conventional media is barred from doing so until the cases have been heard in court.

- Utility-like services should not be allowed to refuse service to individuals without clear reason.

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by zxzax on Thursday May 27, 2021 @06:19AM (#27301161)
#1 seems practically impossible to do, considering that the definition of what a crime is tends to vary between jurisdictions. It may work if on a closed internet and social media that is segregated by jurisdiction.

#2 is already true in some cases, but as usual, the real answer is something like "it depends."

Re:Life after an internet mob attack by lmm on Thursday May 27, 2021 @10:33PM (#27311140)
> #1 seems practically impossible to do, considering that the definition of what a crime is tends to vary between jurisdictions.

Alleging that someone has done something that happens to be a crime aren't a problem, the problem is wilfully alleging crimes outside the court system. The overwhelming majority of the posts that cause these problems either explicitly claim that someone has committed a crime, or explicitly claim that someone has committed an act that is well known to be a crime.

> #2 is already true in some cases

Not really in the US AFAICS? Certain narrowly defined groups are protected against being denied service by private businesses, but there's no broad general protection.