News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by skavi on Monday May 24, 2021 @01:27PM (#27267194)
What is up with the comments in this thread? How are people seeing this as the Indian government taking a stand against censorship or whatever? The same government is upset that Twitter reinstated several accounts critical of the administration.
Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by nindalf on Monday May 24, 2021 @02:26PM (#27267927)
In general, Indians living abroad are highly supportive of the Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Not his party, or his government, or his policies ... just him personally. Hacker News contains many such people. They are responsible for the bizarre comments you've read on this thread.

On a related note, this thread will soon be flagged, like all threads that are even mildly, indirectly critical of Narendra Modi. Enjoy the thread while it's up.

Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by dang on Monday May 24, 2021 @03:11PM (#27268490)
This generalization comes up in every polarized thread about every polarized topic. Literally every side that feels passionately on such a topic feels like the community is outrageously biased against their side. For every sarcastic and aggrieved "anything that supports $X will get downvoted and flagged" or "anything even mildly critical will get $Y", there are isomorphic comments from the opposing side which are just as sarcastic and aggrieved, only with the obvious bit flipped.

In reality, the community is divided similarly to how society at large is divided. But the actual experience of this is extremely difficult to bear when we're all bumping into each other in one big Brownian room. I wrote about this at length here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23308098.

Each side is so upset by the manifestations of the other side that they come to see them as utterly dominating the community. This is out of proportion numerically, but that's because it's not a numerical experience but an emotional one.

We humans place a much greater emphasis on what we dislike than what we like—the bad (e.g. what you disagree with) stands out more than the good (what you agree with), and you are much more likely to notice it and weight it more heavily [1]. This is what leads to false feelings of generality [2]. Unfortunately it also leads to the feeling of being surrounded by enemies or, as I sometimes put it, demons [3]. This dynamic encourages flamewars, because each side feels like it is the righteous underdog in an unfairly biased situation, and anyone who feels that way will feel justified in lashing out in "defense".

If the combatants in such a situation could really see how closely they are mirroring each other, it would surely change something somehow.

I definitely don't mean to pick on you personally, nor the theme of Indian politics in particular; it's just one of many, and this dynamic seems to be universal. I think the next big phase of work we need to do as a community is to develop more awareness of it, and that's work that we all need to contribute to.

[1] https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

[2] https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

[3] https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so...

Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by nindalf on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @02:16AM (#27273369)
Dang, could you share how many times this thread was flagged, if at all? Also, did you or another moderator have to manually unflag it?

Implicit in your comment is the idea that I’m just imagining this, like a paranoid person claiming persecution. But IME, Bay Area Indians are highly supportive of Modi and are highly active on HN. They incite a flame war, flag the thread and the thread vanishes. If a moderator comes across it, they see that there was a flame war and the flag was justified.

I get where you’re coming from - that maybe I’m overestimating the prevalence of apologists for a mass murderer. Maybe I am. But I think you are discounting how effectively they use the mechanics of HN to shut down criticism of their deity.

Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by dang on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @03:09AM (#27273800)
It wasn't heavily flagged and we didn't have to manually unflag it.
Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by nindalf on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @03:20AM (#27273865)
Thanks.

By the way, your explanation of that persecution complex was good. The challenge is people (like me) looking at and thinking “yeah, sounds correct except in my case, where I know for a fact I’m a persecuted minority on HN”

But maybe it’s enough to convince people in general that there’s no such persecution going on, even if there is. That way comments like mine that imply it’s existence end up with -10 instead of +23 or whatever. So fewer tedious comments, but maybe easier for the downvoting/flaming/flagging cabals (should they exist) to take control of the narrative on HN.

You’ve been doing this a long time. So you’ll probably make a good decision, whatever you decide.

Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by dang on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @01:26PM (#27279679)
> “yeah, sounds correct except in my case, where I know for a fact I’m a persecuted minority on HN”

Exactly! that's how we all do it. The weird thing is that even when you become aware of it, it doesn't stop. You simply become aware that you think this way, just as everyone thinks this way, and that despite knowing this, you still feel that you are the noble exception to the universal rule—a human among worms, as it were. It is like an optical illusion that persists even after you know that it is an illusion. However, the awareness seems to have the effect of modulating one's behavior, which is the important thing.

I suppose it's still an open question what really has a chance of shifting this at a community level. Asking people to go against human nature is a tall order. One thing I've tried is pointing people to similar-but-opposite generalizations being made by the other side; or showing them long lists of contradictory generalizations, like here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26148870. I'm not sure it really helps, though.

Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by knolax on Thursday May 27, 2021 @11:36PM (#27311470)
> But I think you are discounting how effectively they use the mechanics of HN to shut down criticism of their deity

I don't care about Modi but I flagged your comments because I'm tired about the endless whining about "them" supposedly manipulating HN. If you don't like Modi tell me why, don't go around strawmaning and generalizing Indian tech workers.

Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by BugsJustFindMe on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:58PM (#27270177)
Entirely unrelated to questions about the balance of the community at large, do you have any sense for how this perspective approach can stand up to things like asymmetric astroturfing (e.g. what are sometimes called "troll farms")?

I don't spend time analyzing HN discourse like I think you probably do as a natural part of your role here, but it occasionally feels (perhaps a little less here?) like the actions of certain entities get a higher percentage of suspiciously blind or low effort defenders and whatabouters than others on high traffic public fora.

nb. Like you, I'm not talking about specifically this thread just the concept in general.

Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by dang on Monday May 24, 2021 @08:29PM (#27271356)
You'd be welcome to email specific examples that you're worried about to [email protected], but based on everything I've seen, the null hypothesis has to be that your perceptions are conditioned by your own passions about said "certain entities", whatever they are. I don't mean to be dismissive (and when people ask us to look into cases they're worried about, we always do); it's just that this is by far the most consistent phenomenon I've observed on HN. Nothing else comes close.

Internet users invest far too much energy into perceptions of "asymmetric astroturfing" and other sinister manipulations. Most of what they think they're seeing is easily shown to be a figment of perceptual bias, driven by their own passions on the topic. When I say "easily shown", I mean even from the public data. People could, but generally don't bother, to check the history of the accounts they accuse. When an HN user was posting about, I don't know, Ansible in 2018, or Forth in 2014, what are the odds that they're a foreign asset or secret shill on $hot-topic of 2021? That's literally what most of this stuff amounts to.

What most needs to happen is for us all to become aware of how these psychological mechanisms function in ourselves, so we can interrupt the process by which they convert into sinister fantasies about others. This isn't unrelated to the "balance of the community at large"—it's at the heart of that question. Not seeing, or not wanting to see, the genuine variation of the community on divisive topics is what leads to sinister fantasies. The odds are overwhelming that the person against you on $hot-topic is not $evil-manipulator, they're simply someone with a different background than you, who is as sincerely persuaded as you are.

Does genuine manipulation also exist? Yes, but even answering 'yes' to that already gives a mistaken impression of the proportions. The group-psychology dynamic I'm describing is responsible for the overwhelming majority of these perceptions. That's why the site guidelines ask people not to go there in the comments, but rather to email [email protected] if they have concerns. Then we can look at the data and see if anything objective can be found.

I hope I haven't bitten your head off! My comments on this can get tetchy because of the number of times I've had to repeat myself on this issue. At some point I'm going to compile all this into maybe a single explanation that can just be linked to.

Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by BugsJustFindMe on Monday May 24, 2021 @10:46PM (#27272112)
I appreciate the continued (even if you hate that it's repeated) commentary, and I feel like my head is still attached.
Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by knolax on Monday May 24, 2021 @08:18PM (#27271272)
It took two comments for a thread about Twitter to turn into HNers identifying and generalizing a racial/national out group.
Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by dang on Monday May 24, 2021 @08:28PM (#27271341)
"Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community."

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by knolax on Monday May 24, 2021 @08:30PM (#27271365)
delete my account
Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by naruvimama on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @03:07PM (#27281026)
Not only abroad but also in India. That is why he is the democratically elected leader of the largest democracy.

And by extension perhaps the most popular or trusted person in the world.

The fact that he rose from poverty with no family connections has rubbed on the wrong side of many princes in waiting and their entourage.

Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by naruvimama on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @11:36PM (#27285972)
By extension people on HN critical of Modi are mostly neither Indian, never been in India or have no clue what they are talking about other than unsubstantiated criticism for political reason.
Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by max_hammer on Monday May 24, 2021 @02:46PM (#27268165)
Anyone having a different opinion than me is wrong ?
Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by renewiltord on Monday May 24, 2021 @02:52PM (#27268264)
No, that’s not true. But in this case, the grandparent comment is correct.

The current Indian Prime Minister is very popular among Bay Area Indians and techies and so they will defend him nearly always.

Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by sharadov on Monday May 24, 2021 @03:16PM (#27268526)
Also India leads the way in shutting down the internet at the smallest sign of dissent, under Modi it has slowly but surely devolved into an authoritarian state

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-50819905

https://www.cnn.com/2021/02/01/asia/india-internet-cut-farme...

Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by sharadov on Monday May 24, 2021 @03:18PM (#27268542)
Oh yeah they love him to death, try having a rational conversation with them and it quickly devolves into personal attacks.
Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by tsycho on Monday May 24, 2021 @07:12PM (#27270796)
That's another broad generalization. I know many Bay Area Indians, and within my personal circles, a majority of them are anti-Modi and have been so pre-Covid too. That said, the amount of unquestionable Trump-like support for Modi is truly baffling.
Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by srean on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @04:42AM (#27274443)
Nindalf's position is not that all Bay Area Indians are blind and aggressive Modi fans. So your observation does not really contest that.

Your honor, I can present many who did not witness me murdering X

Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by nindalf on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @02:02AM (#27273273)
Modi’s personal popularity among ex-pat Indians is because of his elevator pitch - Make India Great Again. These folks left India because of shortcomings they perceived in the country, from cronyism to redtape to lack of opportunities. And Modi is going to fix all of these problems!

That makes them feel good, so they support him.

Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by neither_color on Monday May 24, 2021 @01:54PM (#27267540)
My guess is that people of certain political leanings have seen multiple stories "fact-checked" by Facebook/Twitter/Google as false and suppressed turn out to be true or partially true months down the line. These people are relieved to see another government, any government, give twitter/facebook/google "what's coming to it"
Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by wolverine876 on Monday May 24, 2021 @01:56PM (#27267574)
> people of certain political leanings have seen multiple stories "fact-checked" by Facebook/Twitter/Google as false and suppressed turn out to be true or partially true months down the line.

Nothing is perfect, but what are you referring to specifically?

Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by hn8788 on Monday May 24, 2021 @02:11PM (#27267758)
The Hunter Biden laptop story comes to mind. Twitter was even blocking DMs with a link to the story, but it turned out that what was in it was true, even if it was inconsequential. I also remember seeing a Facebook ad that had a video of Biden saying he was going to end fracking, but since his campaign's official stance was that they weren't going end it, the ad was removed for false information.
Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by wolverine876 on Monday May 24, 2021 @02:17PM (#27267821)
Can you provide some basis for saying it's true? That is not my understanding, but I'm always interested in learning more.
Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by nradov on Monday May 24, 2021 @10:21PM (#27271986)
There is no real doubt that the contents found on Hunter Biden's laptop are authentic. He hasn't denied any of it, nor has any evidence of falsification been found.

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/hunter-biden-laptop-reports-int...

But the whole thing was a big nothingburger.

Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by wolverine876 on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @12:03PM (#27278557)
> There is no real doubt that the contents found on Hunter Biden's laptop are authentic.

Right now, there is a lot of doubt: All I have is some words typed by someone on the Internet.

> https://www.cbsnews.com/news/hunter-biden-laptop-reports-int...

That article barely discusses the laptop, and quotes Hunter Biden saying he didn't know if the proported laptop was even his. It says nothing about authenticity of the contents.

Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by sol_invictus on Monday May 24, 2021 @02:10PM (#27267741)
Politifact and COVID origin
Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by wolverine876 on Monday May 24, 2021 @02:17PM (#27267826)
Any basis for this? The origin is unknown, afaik.
Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by sol_invictus on Monday May 24, 2021 @02:50PM (#27268231)
Problem is and was stating ”lab origin” as a false narrative when we truly just don’t know.

Of course a Politifact that says ”we dont know” is useless and so they have to invent truths to be relevant.

[dead]
Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by suifbwish on Monday May 24, 2021 @04:38PM (#27269428)
You know this how? Last I checked China refused to let anyone audit their labs or medical facilities.
Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by knolax on Monday May 24, 2021 @08:19PM (#27271286)
Last time I checked the US has refused to let anyone audit Ft. Detrick.
Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by newfriend on Monday May 24, 2021 @02:36PM (#27268058)
Not done by a tech company, but here's an example of dubious fact checking:

@MSNBC Oct 9, 2016 FACT CHECK: Trump says Clinton "acid washed" her email server. She did not.

The Claim

Trump says Clinton 'acid washed' her email server.

The Truth

Clinton's team used an app called BleachBit; she did not use a corrosive chemical.

[0] https://twitter.com/msnbc/status/785299708730339328?lang=en

Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by enkid on Monday May 24, 2021 @02:54PM (#27268297)
Except Trump actually thought she used chemicals to clean the server, so there's nothing wrong with this fact check.[0]

[0] https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2016/10/donald-trump-see...

Edit: If you downvoted me, please explain why. I don't get it unless you care more about being on the right side than knowing the truth.

Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by barbacoa on Monday May 24, 2021 @02:34PM (#27268032)
Early in 2020 alternative media discussions that COVID may have leaked from a lab were ruthlessly "fack-checked" and censored from social media for misinformation. Now that we know more these claims have become accepted as a very real possibility.
Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by edoceo on Monday May 24, 2021 @02:47PM (#27268199)
Were they censored? IIRC they were only labeled as "not fact checked" - which at the time was true.

It seems lots of emerging stories should carry that label.

Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by barbacoa on Monday May 24, 2021 @03:03PM (#27268402)
COVID lab theory clams were rated false which means social media platforms throttle their visibility and organizations posting those claims were threatened with suspension.

As politi-facts put it:

"There is no evidence that the coronavirus was made in a lab. The overwhelming consensus among public health experts is that the virus evolved naturally."

Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by TheHypnotist on Monday May 24, 2021 @02:31PM (#27267989)
Either they are the Modi sycophants or just don't like twitter and otherwise have no clue what's going on in India.
Re:Police in India visited Twitter offices over ‘manipulated... by crocodiletears on Monday May 24, 2021 @06:13PM (#27270311)
Twitter's done more to burn its credibility in the west's public imagination than Modi's regime has.