News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by ahelwer on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @12:29PM (#27210886)
This has always been obvious to anyone who spent the smallest amount of time working in consumer retail. Customer comes in and wants to buy a patio set they saw in the catalog. You check the database - says there are two in the back. You go to the back. You look for like ten minutes. Patio set is nowhere to be found. Customer has left in frustration by the time you return.

The hard problem has never been the specific form of database used to store info about the real world. The hard problem has always - and will always - be enforcing the correspondence between what's in the database and what's in the real world. This problem couldn't be solved at a single store in a single fairly small city. It's not gonna be solved worldwide.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by version_five on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:41PM (#27211875)
Right. When blockchain became mainstream in 2017, I went to a blockchain for government event, and they had a speaker essentially explaining that blockchain was an immutable database, and that it could be used to replace your existing databases with something that couldn't be corrupted.

This was the "business" interpretation of blockchain for a long time, and people latched on to the database part and imagined all kinds of things that could come out of a more accurate database, without actually understanding how this was achieved.

So we ended up with these use cases where blockchain was supposed to magically solve physical world problems, because "that's what it does", without any causal mechanism.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by mumblemumble on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:43PM (#27212685)
I get the impression that a lot of folks take it as an article of faith that accuracy problems in the database must be due to a shortcoming of the database itself.

But if you replace the database with a spreadsheet, everyone seems to be able to intuitively understand that accuracy problems with the information in the spreadsheet aren't (necessarily) due to shortcomings in the basic idea behind Microsoft Excel. They're more often due to data entry errors, or the fact that it's fundamentally difficult to keep track of everything that happens in the messy, messy real world.

(Realistically, the former is just a special case of the latter.)

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by knorker on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:38PM (#27212619)
Did these people make it clear that blockchain enthusiasts consider any action or modification by "the courts" and "the legislative body of the government" to be "corruption of the database"?
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by trutannus on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:29PM (#27212504)
Governments are the largest perpetuators of the "blockchain for real world assets" silliness. Non technical managers tend to push for these sorts of things to get a "blockchain project" to their name. For some reason the idea of lying to the blockchain isn't something that occurs to them very often.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by version_five on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:23PM (#27214006)
If something is effectively "magic" to someone, even in the base case, an improvement is just another sort of magic.

This is why I don't have a lot of confidence in big-picture types that don't know anything about computer science but hold some parallel business analogies in their head and think they can make decisions on that basis.

On the other side, sometimes interesting and valuable things can happen when you don't have reality as a constraint. I read (but have not verified) that William Gibson's world of cyberspace and internet etc. in the Sprawl books ended up being so attractive largely because he understood almost nothing about computers.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by relaxing on Saturday May 22, 2021 @01:11PM (#27248403)
> I read (but have not verified) that William Gibson's world of cyberspace and internet etc. in the Sprawl books ended up being so attractive largely because he understood almost nothing about computers.

He knew enough to know that computers and computer hackers were not the stuff of noir-action-thrillers, but saw the potential in answering the question: what if they were?

To quote Gibson:

The only computers I’d ever seen in those days were things the size of the side of a barn. And then one day, I walked by a bus stop and there was an Apple poster. The poster was a photograph of a businessman’s jacketed, neatly cuffed arm holding a life-size representation of a real-life computer that was not much bigger than a laptop is today. Everyone is going to have one of these, I thought, and everyone is going to want to live inside them. And somehow I knew that the notional space behind all of the computer screens would be one single universe.

What I had was a sticky neologism and a very vague chain of associations between the bus-stop Apple IIc advertisement, the posture of the kids playing arcade games, and something I’d heard about from these hobbyist characters from Seattle called the Internet. It was more tedious and more technical than anything I’d ever heard anybody talk about. It made ham ­radio sound really exciting. But I understood that, sometimes, you could send messages through it, like a telegraph. I also knew that it had begun as a project to explore how we might communicate during a really shit-hot nuclear war.

…

I knew that cyberspace was exciting, but none of the people I knew who were actually involved in the nascent digital industry were exciting. I wondered what it would be like if they were exciting, stylish, and sexy.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by trutannus on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @05:01PM (#27214410)
> hold some parallel business analogies in their head and think they can make decisions on that basis

The advantage with folks like this is it becomes abundantly clear when they open their mouths that they have no idea what they are talking about most of the time.

The major disadvantage though is these people tend to be the loudest in the space, and are heard more since people tend to want to hear exciting sexy ideas over the mundane reality of things.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by version_five on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @06:25PM (#27215320)
I'm reminded of the pitch I heard from the IBM salesperson talking about the "logarithms" they had that were solving client problems. (Being charitable, maybe he was a slide rule enthusiast)

I find it typically very easy to tell someone is full of crap, but trying to call it does not always work in one's favor. Definitely agree it is a good sign you should get yourself out of the situation

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by dplavery92 on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:17PM (#27213917)
Ha! Was this the "Goverment Blockchain Association" that was meeting in the DC Metro area? I may be have hornswoggled into one of their meetings at the time, and despite my vague enthusiasm for the technology, I felt like I was being sold a timeshare.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by version_five on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @06:18PM (#27215255)
It was actually in Ottawa, Canada, targeting the canadian government. Same as you, I was interested in the tech, and my (non blockchain) company did business with the federal government, so I wanted to see what the hype was about. That was pretty much the end of my interest in the topic.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by psyc on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:49PM (#27211970)
Long ago, I was a department manager at Walmart. Keeping the database even within the ballpark of real inventory was a labor-intensive, annoying, never-done task. My full-time job was struggling to make the point-of-sale replenishment work just tolerably well. It went in waves. Periods where most of the counts seemed pretty good, then periods where it was a mess. After all, it was just me manually locating and counting everything. Too many items with too many places for them to go missing “in the back”.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by papito on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:40PM (#27212651)
Sort of like Zero Inbox. You need to fight and win the battles in order to not lose the war - which you will never win but can definitely lose.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by tjchear on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:28PM (#27212493)
What do you think are the reasons the actual counts get out of sync with db?

I presume it's mostly theft, but are there any other reasons?

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by NikolaNovak on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:34PM (#27212567)
I would venture misplacement is more common than it'd be intuitive to layperson.

Whether an individual item that was returned or moved and is on the wrong shelf on wrong bay or underneath the shelf or in some weird corner; up to a whole skid of stuff mislabeled (skid group SKU is not accurate of the individual SKUs inside) or in the wrong place or not accounted for or counted twice.

A lot of human error during unloading trucks, scanning, counting, inventorying, etc.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by mumblemumble on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @08:50PM (#27216174)
Ah, but if you managed it all with a blockchain, it could be cryptographically verifiable human error.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by newsclues on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:36PM (#27212603)
Mistakes or mis-sorted inventory. Customers move stuff too.

Busy staff, staff that don’t care or don’t know better.

Managed bookstore logistics.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by psyc on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:19PM (#27213954)
Theft, yes. There are other leaks, such as a lazy or rushed employee discarding broken merch without reporting it. Also, customer satisfaction trumps other policies. That is not just PR. If anything about the POS system annoys a customer for 2 seconds, like a barcode that won’t scan, it got circumvented. And again, the warehouse out back was so huge and chaotic, stuff just got lost, to be discovered months later.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by nexuist on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:03PM (#27211398)
It's not a hard problem, it's an impossible problem, because it violates the first law of cybersecurity: physical access means game over. When you start allowing untrained and un-punishable customers to mess with your meatspace database, of course it will lose all semblance of usefulness.

This problem is not hard to solve when you limit physical access, i.e. in a warehouse, pharmacy, or locked room where multiple employees are responsible for checking in and out items. These solutions arose directly out of your conundrum in retail, and investigations are launched when someone discovers a mismatch between inventory and real life (think toxic chemicals, drugs, etc).

Of course it just so happens that nobody wants to go to a grocery store where they're not allowed to touch the items.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by foobarian on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:34PM (#27211779)
They used to work like that. You would come up to comrade cashier, and tell her what you wanted one by one, and pay. I still remember the shock when I went into a supermarket for the first time. Felt like going to a "authorized personnel only" place.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by evancox100 on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:27PM (#27213257)
So was this in the USSR? Approx what timeframe was your first supermarket visit?
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by waterfowl on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:42PM (#27213473)
this was how things worked before supermarkets in general - you'd ask the general store clerk for x units of y good, think the deli counter or auto parts store model.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by repsilat on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @06:00PM (#27215081)
See "Four Candles" https://youtu.be/OCbvCRkl_4U
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:33PM (#27211754)
> problem is not hard to solve when you limit physical access, i.e. in a warehouse, pharmacy, or locked room where multiple employees are responsible for checking in and out items

Do you know anyone who works in retail, a warehouse or a pharmacy? Nothing is ever where it should be in the quantities the computer thinks it’s in.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by hannasanarion on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:30PM (#27213302)
> This problem is not hard to solve when you limit physical access, i.e. in a warehouse, pharmacy, or locked room where multiple employees are responsible for checking in and out items. These solutions arose directly out of your conundrum in retail, and investigations are launched when someone discovers a mismatch between inventory and real life

If the problem was not hard to solve, there would be no need for investigations into discrepancies.

Even in extremely high-tech warehouses like Amazon, major inventory mistakes still happen. A few weeks ago I ordered a $150 midi controller the size of a license plate and received an $800 synth the size of a snowboard that had an extra incorrect bar code stuck to it.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by nonameiguess on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:31PM (#27213321)
Makes me think of being in the Army. This was actually a problem we solved pretty well, using nothing other than hand-written paper receipts and property records. It was solved by doing hand physical counts every single time you moved anything or opened a room or box or vehicle, and holding whoever signed for the number on the receipt the value of the missing items if anything was missing.

Granted, there was a limit to what you could be held responsible for. I was responsible for breaking the main gun on an Abrams tank once and the sticker value was a bit over $120,000, but luckily they could only charge me a single paycheck.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by bombcar on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:08PM (#27213808)
I'm assuming you hulked out and bent the barrel into a pretzel, and command came back with "well all we can do is dock a paycheck".
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by tshaddox on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:44PM (#27211911)
You're explaining why it's an impossible problem to solve perfectly, 100% of the time. That might very well be the case, but it is not the case that this means "it will lose all semblance of usefulness."
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by nikanj on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @12:31PM (#27210906)
Easy! Let's just make sure the people who stole the two patio sets update the blockchain. I mean, people who steal / ransom / hack bitcoin still update the blockchain, so criminals clearly can follow the rules
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by daniellarusso on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @12:50PM (#27211215)
Or the box got stabbed with a forklift, bent a bunch of the pieces, and they are piled in the back somewhere, and the assistant manager handling it no longer works there.

Or the customer returned it because it was damaged, so now it is in inventory again.

Or, inventory is batched processes, so it will take at least a few hours before inventory is current.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by ska on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @12:53PM (#27211258)
Or some customer moved the boxes behind other product boxes, to "save it".

Etc. etc.

Inventory management is a whole industry of it's own for a reason.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by drewzero1 on Thursday May 20, 2021 @11:43AM (#27222638)
Or the customer emptied a large (inexpensive) package and hid a smaller (more valuable) item inside, leaving the unwitting cashier to scan the larger package at checkout and now counts for both items are off.

Or the vendor discontinued the item and replaced it with a slightly different one, but they both got put in under the same stock number and are hanging on the same hook.

No matter how much we try to perfect the digital world, the real world will always be messy, and interfaces between the two will always be difficult.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @12:34PM (#27210952)
> make sure the people who stole the two patio sets

It probably isn’t stolen. It’s more likely delivered to another store, still on the truck, still at the factory, or was sold and not recorded.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by jcranmer on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @12:43PM (#27211110)
Or someone picked it up to buy it, thought against it, and dropped it off in the wrong place.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by zarq on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @12:39PM (#27211057)
Or someone has it on their cart on the way to the checkout.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by nucleardog on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @12:49PM (#27211204)
Or someone had it on their cart on the way to the checkout, changed their mind, and somehow managed to cram it in a freezer behind some milk or something.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by barkingcat on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:35PM (#27211786)
this happens at Ikea a lot - people take the thing and then decide they don't want it... there's a lot of places for things to go in the warehouse pickup section of an ikea store
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by loceng on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @12:56PM (#27211295)
Well, if they had tracking tags on them that can't get removed then you'd see when the inventory is now gone.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by daniellarusso on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:05PM (#27211425)
Unless the tag could not be damaged, or interference from an electrical issue would not cause reading issues, or there are no other materials or objects that would prevent reading the tag, or the wrong tag was affixed prior to being delivered to the store (swapped).
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by hamiltonkibbe on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:46PM (#27211929)
Easy, affix the tag to the item with a blockchain so you know it cant be removed or tampered with.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by munk-a on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:58PM (#27212102)
Quite correct - everyone knows that blockchains are basically just an immutable database. I read it on hacker news!

Just to confirm - nobody has ever or will ever make a data entry mistake right? Good, I hoped they wouldn't.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by jameshart on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:51PM (#27213600)
Big package gets delivered. Two people working down the delivery, scanning and tagging every item. Both of them scan and tag opposite ends of the same box with inventory markers. An immutable record is created that says there are two of these things in stock.

Someone buys it. It gets checked out. One of the markers gets scanned, an immutable record is created saying there's still one in stock.

Physical reality has a way of screwing with all the best laid plans of computer systems. As Pat Helland says: there's no transaction rollback when a forklift drives over a box of eggs.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by mdoms on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:21PM (#27211612)
In fact blockchains only exacerbate the problem. In your stock keeping system you can simply correct the error by entering a new stock number. In the blockchain you can... what? Ask every participant in the system to agree to roll back that transaction, pretty please?
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by acdha on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:47PM (#27211941)
This highlights why “slow, expensive database” has not been a common need: you can handle that in an append-only style by publishing correction records but that puts even more strain on an already struggling system.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by la_fayette on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:56PM (#27212834)
Unless you use an erp-system, which most companies have. In such systems, you cannot change things at will, because of compliance. Acctually, if you consider compliance regulations, a blockchain based approach would be useful...
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by jasonwatkinspdx on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:22PM (#27213998)
Pat Helland has a great quip he's used in his talks over the years, along the lines of "it doesn't matter how consistent your database is if a forklift drives over the box in the warehouse."
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by bogota on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:13PM (#27212311)
That sounds like inventory management more than ownership which do obviously have overlap. But why would having something minted on purchase of say a Rolex be bad? Then when you sell it you could transfer that to the new owner. Showing a chain all the way back to the original purchase. This still has the issue of someone who could come into ownership of a minted item without the object and then try and make a convincing fake but this at first glance sounds like a great way to reduce fakes in the market significantly.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by dragontamer on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:16PM (#27212341)
Situation #1: Lets say a thief steals the Rolex from X. It goes through the black market, and now Y claims to own that Rolex.

Lets take situation #2. X realizes that Situation#1 is possible. So X sells his Rolex to Y but fails to disclose that its blockchain-tracked. Now Y has the Rolex (and is out of some money). Now X-claims that Y stole the Rolex from him.

How does Blockchain differentiate from #1 (where the Rolex should be returned to X) and #2 (where the Rolex should be returned to Y) ? The only way to solve this issue is to ensure that Y transacts on the _same_ blockchain.

Which... isn't the case at all for NFTs, Bitcoin, DOGE, and etc. etc. There are so many blockchains (and each NFT basically makes its own blockchain). It is very easy for X to transact on the wrong blockchain to fool Y right now. (or off-blockchain, by transacting in USD for example).

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by Grimm1 on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:10PM (#27213832)
In your case was the patio set sold to another customer or was it a logistics issue at the supplier etc or is there no way to know what the problem was? I think those are all separate problems that may have various solutions, and the only one that blockchain to my knowledge would even be remotely useful for is knowing where in the chain those sets not being in the store happened at.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by arberx on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:15PM (#27211543)
Stores aren't a great example.

Let's take houses, where the buyer and seller both need a title company to validate and transfer ownership. This process is extremely inefficent, and costly. It's pretty reasonable to imagine a public ledger replacing this process.

The real world enforcement of such thing is really the only hurdle.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by yojo on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:24PM (#27211653)
Back to the point of this article: if someone steals my private key, do they now own my house?

What about liens? Will I as the owner agree to let an unpaid contractor put a lien against my title? Or can they somehow do it without my consent? If so, how do you stop bad actors from putting liens on everything?

The court is the authority on this. Title companies provide the valuable service of ensuring the state of the world matches what the seller claims.

We don’t need blockchain for this, a regular DB is sufficient.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by tshaddox on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:48PM (#27211964)
> Back to the point of this article: if someone steals my private key, do they now own my house?

> We don’t need blockchain for this, a regular DB is sufficient.

If someone makes you sign over your car title to them under duress, do they then own your car? In most jurisdictions (let's use the USA for now), of course not. Assuming you have reasonable access to fair treatment by the legal system, that transfer would not be considered valid, and in fact the whole act would likely be a very serious crime. This is true regardless of how the ownership is officially represented: whether a blockchain, or a government database, or a pink slip with names written on it, etc.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by PragmaticPulp on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:01PM (#27212151)
Exactly, which is why an immutable record isn't as great as it sounds for these purposes. If everything is moved to the blockchain but that blockchain requires the exact same government override access to handle common problems, what's the point?

In a hypothetical blockchain ownership society, we'd probably end up paying extra insurance on our ownership as well as extra fees to a 3rd party to retain custody of our ownership tokens.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by slaman on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:26PM (#27213239)
Insurance scams would be a laugh too.

"All my assets got transferred to a random address! You should probably reimburse me because I was clearly hacked."

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by yojo on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:58PM (#27212100)
If the block chain is not the source of truth, and an external body can enforce changes on it, how is it in any way better than a database under control of the state?
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by tshaddox on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:04PM (#27212200)
Sufficiently powerful external bodies can always use force to do things regardless of what any particular database says. This isn't a problem with any particular type of database.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by Analemma_ on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:23PM (#27212417)
Exactly, so what is gained by switching to blockchain if it can't solve this issue?
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by a1369209993 on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @05:51PM (#27214979)
The point of blockchain isn't that the government can't steal your house; the (well, a) point of blockchain is that the government can't pretend you never owned your house in the first place. It establishes reliable records; that doesn't magically give it the ability to enforce those records.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by tshaddox on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:32PM (#27212545)
It's absurd to expect any software change to somehow physically prevent people from taking your things. This "vulnerability" isn't worth talking about when evaluating software.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by yojo on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:38PM (#27212630)
It is almost impossible for someone to physically steal my house. Certainly improbable. And it would be easy to recover with the help of the police.

It is by comparison easy for someone to steal crypto keys, or for them to be lost.

If we add a solution that allows us to fix the stolen or lost keys issue, then we eliminate the primary values of the block chain, decentralized trust and immutability.

So now we’re using a really complex database (potentially with POW energy use) for something that seems equally well solved by simpler tech.

So why would we want to use the block chain for this?

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by anyfoo on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:09PM (#27213022)
Right, so just use a normal database then. Shard and/or replicate it if you must. It's orders of magnitude more energy efficient, easier to mutate, maintain, and upgrade, and seems to solve the problem at least as adequately.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by mdoms on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:36PM (#27212595)
So the eternal question remains, what problem is blockchain solving here?
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by yongjik on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:12PM (#27213052)
...Lack of blockchain adoption?
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by arberx on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:06PM (#27212218)
Enforcement and source of truth are separate entities/problems.

The blockchain can be the source of truth, but that truth might not be enforced.

The difference between it, and a centrally controlled entity is the truth cannot be altered (at least in an easy way) on a blockchain.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by hannasanarion on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:36PM (#27213393)
First of all, blockchain isn't the only technology that prevents alteration. any regular database can be run in append-only mode and can be published.

The only difference between blockchain and any other database in append-only mode is that there is no access controls or identity verification on the blockchain, so fraud is way easier (and that's why over $1 billion in crypto is stolen every year)

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by arberx on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @06:41PM (#27215447)
"no access controls" -- trustless.

Pretty big difference.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by jfengel on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:28PM (#27212494)
If it's officially represented by a blockchain, there's no power on earth capable of fixing it. Even if the government came and threw them in jail and confiscated their accounts, you couldn't get legal title to your car back.

Unless you include a backdoor in the blockchain, but that would make the whole thing moot. You could issue a new title and mark the old one as legally invalid, but again, that leaves you open to all the problems that the blockchain was supposed to solve.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by arberx on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:33PM (#27211760)
There can be mechanisims for recovery. Social recovery wallets, multi-sign wallets, DAOs all can be part of the solution to loss of keys.

The question really is: is this all necessary? And are inefficencies/issues/costs with current centralized gov systems worth replacing?

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by yojo on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:04PM (#27212204)
There are undoubtedly technical solutions for resyncing the block chain to reality. But once you need them, you’re effectively saying the block chain is not the source of truth, and it’s governed by the same inefficient system that managed titles before.

At this point it is effectively a complicated solution to a simple problem - record all bits about property ownership in a publicly available place. It is unclear to me what properties the block chain has that makes it superior to a database with backups.

So I would argue that it’s not necessary and makes a complicated system more complicated, not less so.

What would really help is digitization of the records, which is a political and bureaucratic problem more than a technical one. There are undoubtedly better/worse implementations, but a block chain solution feels like it’s probably on the “worse” end of the spectrum.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by notafraudster on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:16PM (#27212344)
It seems the unstated proposal here is that cryptography will reduce the burden necessary to validate a title. Maybe.

Let's say the house is in a town that has 100 houses and the current title verification process is that you go to the town hall, which is open from noon to 2PM on Thursdays and every other Tuesday, and you ask Ethyl, who is 71 and has cataracts, to go check the title and verify the owner is who you say it is. She takes the title document from you and then goes to an original master and checks the names. There was a flood in the town hall, so houses 21-40 had their original documents damaged in the box but there's an attestation process that applies in that case. Also, a bylaw requires that Ethyl only deals with a licensed title verification agent, of which there is one in the town, and he doesn't work Tuesdays.

This is burdensome! Both Ethyl and the verification agent are probably rent seekers!

It seems like your pitch is "if instead of this, the town webpage had a cryptographically signed register that simply notes who owns everything, then you could just go on the webpage and verify it yourself."

That would be simpler! But not because of blockchain. It's also the case that in a non-blockchain world, the town could put the ownership on a traditional database online, and give owners PINs that can be used to do the title verification. Or just list all the owners publicly by name and make the town webmaster the central trusted authority that the changes are not fraudulent. Or they could even make the ledger cryptographically signed exactly like a blockchain but with the contents centrally stored rather than distributed/public.

So it's still hard for me to think how you can separate the blockchain pitch "processes would be more efficient if we designed them to be efficient", blockchain or not.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by nonameiguess on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:09PM (#27213819)
Other problem is ownership transfer isn't even necessarily the bottleneck to liquidity of real estate. Most real estate is still occupied by people using the property for some reason, either for a place of business or because the live there. Moving their business or family to a new piece of land and someone else onto theirs requires changing school districts, updating bank records, work records, canceling utilities, physically moving all of the objects, packing, unpacking. All of that is much more cumbersome than transferring the legal ownership rights to the lot. Housing stock will never have high liquidity regardless of how you record ownership. If you want liquidity while exposing yourself to real estate as an investment vehicle, that's why REITs, MBSs, and CDOs exist. You don't want to trade physical houses.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by topkai22 on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:32PM (#27211746)
While I agree real estate transactions are ripe for innovation, the problem is that real estate law and title can be complicated, with legal encumbrances on a property and title that are not digitized in any way. Some (such as traditional rights of access) may not even be written down. A title company is supposed to help with all that.

Making these sorts of encumbarances be written to a digitized ledger to have legal would definitely be a good innovation, but a blockchain solution isn't necessary or even desirable for a ledger. A government run database is just fine.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by hobs on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:22PM (#27211628)
right, but there's no reason for that ledger to be on the blockchain - since property rights are always enforced by the government we should just have a public ledger that is akin to the ledger the gov records about driver's licenses.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by walleeee on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:58PM (#27213695)
Incidentally, the organization which keeps a central record of personal and commercial drivers' licenses in the United States (AAMVA, American Association of Motor Vehicle Administrators) is nominally non-governmental, although it works closely with state and federal jurisdictions as well as with 3rd parties. And it gets by fine with a conventional DB, although they have shown some interest in blockchain tech IIRC
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by arberx on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:36PM (#27211791)
A centralized goverment is one mechanism of enforcement yes.

No reason there can't be others. One that doesn't require blind faith/trust.

Arguably police are decentralized mechanisms of enforcement, no reason to formalize that responsibilty in a DAO.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by pavel_lishin on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:44PM (#27211907)
It still requires blind faith and trust, but now you're trusting a combination of computer code that cannot apply common sense to transactions, and human programmers and bad actors, who can through accident or malice do a great job of fucking up your day.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by munk-a on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:02PM (#27212156)
And, since the government still would retain rights to seizing property under eminent domain or force the sale of a property for other reasons... you'd still need to put your blind faith and trust in the government to not seize your property. Essentially you've just increased the numbers of actors you need to all explicitly trust.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by hannasanarion on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:42PM (#27213467)
In what way is "these papers signed by these people in person, countersigned by notaries, postmarked on this date, after a thorough identity and title verification process conducted by these people, copied and hand delivered to bank, realtor, broker, seller, buyer, city, and state" blind faith

But "I found a message on the internet with a secret number attached" is not blind faith?

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by skywhopper on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:12PM (#27212289)
How do you enforce ownership without the state? If I take your house from you, what incentive do I have to care what the blockchain says?
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by Maken on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:43PM (#27211899)
I can already picture cities full of forever inhabitable houses because somebody died unexpectedly or lost his private key.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by abduhl on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:17PM (#27211567)
I get to your last line and all I can think: "Wow, it's so simple, implementation is the only detail we haven't figured out yet."
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by arberx on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:37PM (#27211813)
Just because there isn't a solution/implementation currently, doesn't mean there won't be.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by knorker on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:40PM (#27212649)
No, real estate is even worse.

Surely you need a backdoor for courts to fix problems? And if you have a backdoor, then what's the point of the whole fucking blockchain?

I say this having bought a house, and knowing the BS paperwork and costs involved.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by toomanybeersies on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:13PM (#27212302)
You don't need blockchain to establish such a system. Australia has been using the Torrens title system [1] since the 1800s, which is essentially a (semi) public register of titles and transfers.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Torrens_title

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by GeorgeDewar on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:11PM (#27213842)
New Zealand too, and it really is as good as it sounds. Transacting property can be done very quickly, safely and cheaply, and no title insurance is required.

The register is of course just a normal relational database.

One key to the success, though, is a large and mature body of legislation and processes to ensure that the register really is always correct.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by Ekaros on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:58PM (#27212873)
Government run public digital database might be much simpler and efficient solution. No point involving blockchain for something where it is not needed.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by skywhopper on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:10PM (#27212276)
How would you validate that the transactions related to the house on the blockchain is correct? What do you do if you inherit the house from someone who neglected to leave you the private key? You can come up with solutions to all the problems and you’ll have reinvented the entire existing process, which is inefficient and costly for a reason.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by mdoms on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:22PM (#27211629)
The process of transferring real estate ownership is messy and expensive for all kinds of reasons that aren't solved by a distributed append-only database.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by RandomLensman on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:05PM (#27212955)
If it is unclear to start with which titles are valid, then filling the ledger will be an issue, i.e. the effort is in creating a clean register and not with the register "mechanics".

Btw. there are also countries with very well maintained registers where this is not a problem at all at present.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by intotheabyss on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:45PM (#27213505)
Developers in crypto know about the oracle problem better than anyone. It's not some sort of revelation. The oracle problem has been discussed ad nauseum within the community since at least 2011/2012.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by Slartie on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:50PM (#27213581)
If that is so, then why are there still "developers in crypto" left?

Shouldn't you expect from smart people that they eventually realize the conceptual infeasibility of what they are trying to accomplish?

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by intotheabyss on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:05PM (#27213774)
Well the oracle problem has been solved for something as simple as price feeds. So today you can easily get price feeds from any pair of assets into the blockchain in a decentralized way.

Why are there developers in crypto? Because it's very cool and interesting? I'm currently working on building applications for Starkware and layer 2 networks and I'm loving it. It's totally wild what you can do with programmable money, like https://alchemix.fi/ where you can get loans that repay themselves by providing liquidity to yield aggregating protocols. Totally new way of thinking about money and value. I think it's funny when people think this is useless. I suspect they wouldnt be saying that if they actually developed applications on the EVM

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by transpostmeta on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:07PM (#27213787)
It's not infeasible. The smart contract in the block chain just pays a third party to access real world data. The business model of the oracle provider is to provide accurate data and get paid for it. It works well enough for data that is public.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by tshaddox on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @12:52PM (#27211237)
Okay, but surely this is rare? I’ve used online stock checks for retail stores and found them to be accurate the overwhelming majority of the time. Obviously it’s going to occasionally happen that someone stole an item or has an item in their cart when you check, but that hardly means that inventory databases are useless.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by hirundo on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @12:59PM (#27211338)
That's not my experience. Last month I tried to buy a specific vacuum cleaner at Lowes. Online said it's in stock. It wasn't. Another nearby Lowes said it was in stock. It wasn't. I finally got smart enough to call the third Lowes instead of driving there. The guy said "it shows as in stock but let me check". They know. It wasn't.

This has been roughly par for the course in my experience, and not particularly with Lowes.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by na85 on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:03PM (#27211394)
Inventory databases are not useless as you have correctly observed. However, blockchains offer zero advantages over conventional inventory databases.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by daniellarusso on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:11PM (#27211494)
When you say accurate, do you count the number of available items on the shelf, or are you just looking for at least 1 of something?

It seems to matter more when there are only 1 or 2 ‘available’, but I have seen at Lowes where the packet has been ripped open and a piece of the assembly is gone, or it looks like it was returned, but with the wrong item in place.

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by majormajor on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:33PM (#27211758)
If you find it already accurate the overwhelming majority of the time, what improvement do you think blockchain would bring?
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by notahacker on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:10PM (#27211477)
It's much, much, much more common than "database owner falsifies records, leaving no trace behind, but is otherwise completely trustworthy" which is the issue with real world inventory management blockchain purports to solve
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by he0001 on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @12:58PM (#27211331)
Nah, I’ve been doing inventory counts where I’ve been counting nuts and bolts for the sole purpose to update the inventory databases. These were nuts and bolts for trains but the inventory database were not correct for different reasons.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by com2kid on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:24PM (#27211657)
I used stock check at QFC with their app a few weeks back, product wasn't there. I asked an employee "we haven't carried that product for months."

Not a very good experience!

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by Edman274 on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @12:57PM (#27211310)
Microcenter deliberately lies about the stock of graphics cards on their website by saying that there are none in stock - even if they have some at the physical store itself - because, as overheard from a long term employee: "Just imagine what would happen if we said we had a graphics card online. It would be pandemonium. We set the stock at zero. If they come in, they'll be sold anyway."
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by mdorazio on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @12:55PM (#27211281)
Not sure where you're shopping, but I've found them to be highly inaccurate the majority of the time. Useful for telling me where something is located, but generally useless for actual quantity accuracy. This is for stores like Home Depot, Lowes, and Target.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by edpichler on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:06PM (#27211444)
Even though this happening often, software is still the best solution we have. They know that, and they don't stop using a system for it. Moreover, the same correlation problem would happen (even worse) by using paper for the records.

So, why should we stop using blockchain?

Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by hannasanarion on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:30PM (#27211724)
Blockchain doesn't solve any of the problems and in fact introduces new ones (like non-reversible theft). The question is why should we start using blockchain?
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:19PM (#27211590)
Because it isn't fundamentally better at this task than existing solutions?
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by skywhopper on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:15PM (#27212331)
Blockchain in the form of something like Bitcoin is probably the worst possible database for this sort of ledger. It’s wildly inefficient, slow, and subject to failures of all sorts. If it’s a public blockchain with public nodes, it’s subject to being attacked by malicious actors. If it’s entirely controlled by the legal authority, then there’s no reason to use a blockchain.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by edpichler on Thursday May 20, 2021 @03:15AM (#27218307)
I got a lot of downvotes. I wrote my question to discuss and to learn from other people's arguments, not to offend anyone.
Re:Real world ownership is not a use case for blockchain by ianai on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:12PM (#27211502)
Because a major national power is outlawing it.