News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by okareaman on Saturday May 15, 2021 @02:04PM (#27167457)
We take care of children, old people, disabled people, and others that can't take care of themselves. We will likely have to take care of low skilled individuals who can't do a job better or more economically than a robot. Universal Basic Income is one proposed solution but faces opposition due the attitude that able bodied people should have to work for a living. This becomes harder and harder for people who can't learn to keep up and get left behind. The need for UBI seems like a forgone conclusion at this point.
Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by neilv on Saturday May 15, 2021 @06:58PM (#27169726)
> We take care of children, old people, disabled people, and others that can't take care of themselves. We will likely have to take care of low skilled individuals who can't do a job better or more economically than a robot.

It's not just "low-skilled" people who will have trouble finding good employment. It's most people.

I like the idea of a society sharing the wealth from resources, cooperation, and technological advancement, and trying to ensure that everyone is lifted up by it.

I'd like to be careful of language around that, since I often hear comments from people who happen to be benefitting from the status quo (for now), talking down about people who aren't benefitting.

For example, some people hear about how "we" need to take care of others, and they seem to think it means asking "meritorious" them "for a favor, to benefit those less meritorious." But I think more appropriate is that the we is society, and that we need to revise our rules and conventions, because they're unfair, reward the wrong things, etc.

Right now, our rules and conventions seem to be under something like regulatory capture. So, exploiters benefit wildly disproportionately, and some of the rest of us (myself included, at times) effectively ride the coattails of that economic setup.

I propose that those of us who are currently making tech money would do well to speak up for those currently getting less a share of society. One reason is that it seems the right thing to do. Another reason is that, while we may be benefitting now, we might not later, and current rules&conventions are to listen to those with money, so we should speak up while we can.

Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by meowkit on Saturday May 15, 2021 @05:54PM (#27169369)
> due to the attitude that able bodied people should have to work for a living.

This reads as though this shouldn’t be the case. People need to contribute to society, and not everyone will be an artist or pursue their passion if freed from labor.

I no longer support a UBI (unless we’re in a post scarcity society), but I do support a CBI.

Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by okareaman on Saturday May 15, 2021 @06:01PM (#27169421)
I hadn't heard of CBI but I found these:

Andrew Yang and Mark Cuban debate UBI vs CBI https://podverse.fm/clip/__ihv7eFk

Citizen’s Basic Income in Scotland https://www.alliance-scotland.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2017...

I look forward to learning the difference, which doesn't seem that great at first glance

Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by lucassen on Saturday May 15, 2021 @06:30PM (#27169598)
that scottish reference seems to explain CBI exactly as I have understood UBI.
Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by jpttsn on Saturday May 15, 2021 @02:10PM (#27167511)
It is a foregone conclusion only because of assumptions that conspire to make the argument circular.

I think you’re mischaracterizing some part of the opposition with “should have to work”. To my school of UBI skepticism, it’s not at all about Lutheran work ethic as a deontological good.

To clarify: I don’t believe we take care of elderly/disabled/children solely because it’s “the right thing to do”. Instead I believe we do it due to other conditions e.g. “it could be me one day” and “it’s just a few people so we can afford it”. Based on that, I think the stance will change if the conditions change.

Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by nynx on Saturday May 15, 2021 @02:28PM (#27167650)
That doesn't change anything. You can rephrase why UBI is a good idea to: "it could be me who can't compete against automation someday."
Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by jpttsn on Saturday May 15, 2021 @03:26PM (#27168115)
Well, it hasn’t worked yet for that, while taking care of elders has.

Where I live, optometry and dental medicine are carved out of socialized healthcare. Hard to reconcile that with the purely utilitarian theory.

I think the “few people” aspect is important in practice. If the prevalence is too great, it could stop feeling like an accidental curse of fate. Just theorizing.

Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by okareaman on Saturday May 15, 2021 @02:25PM (#27167625)
I'm curious as to what you propose as an alternate solution
Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by mindslight on Saturday May 15, 2021 @03:10PM (#27167979)
The actual problem is not that there is less work for humans to do, but that the remaining work is divided unevenly. Currently, personal overproduction just gets eaten up by the hedonic and financial treadmills, while the underemployed see little benefit from developing skills for jobs that are already taken. Significantly dropping what is considered "full time" employment would be a good start. A target of twenty hours per week is a good immediate target, as well as getting rid of that "exempt employee" loophole.

Longer term, if we wish to continue having a distributed economy, then the gains of automation need to accrue to people directly, through something resembling ownership. Basic Income should only ever been seen as a social safety net. Collecting most of the wealth by a centralized entity ("government") to distribute back out to people is fraught with political hazard, if it is even possible to sustain.

Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by jpttsn on Saturday May 15, 2021 @03:01PM (#27167911)
I don’t have one.
Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by Consultant32452 on Saturday May 15, 2021 @04:37PM (#27168777)
UBI only sounds good if you don’t understand human motivation and game theory.

If 10% of the population doesn’t have to work I can justify I’m helping those in need. If 70% of the population doesn’t have to work there’s zero chance I’m working.

Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by okareaman on Saturday May 15, 2021 @05:28PM (#27169197)
I think you are under-estimating the number of people who like having a job. Many retired people report not liking having nothing to do. The challenge will be to create more opportunities for people to learn, socialize, do something creative, find a hobby or some outdoor activity. I think it will be a better world when we transition people away from being wage slaves and enjoy the benefits of the creative activities of newly freed people.
Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by Consultant32452 on Saturday May 15, 2021 @08:28PM (#27170183)
It's not about what the "non-productive" people will do to entertain themselves. They will socialize, pick up a hobby, spend time with their family, etc. There's no concern about them whatsoever. It's the rest of the population, the minority that is the most competent. These people, by definition laid out in the premise, cannot be replaced by one of the non-productive people because the non-productive cannot outcompete the robots. Let's imagine that robots get so good that only the most competent 30% of the population must work, in the traditional sense of the word work, to maintain the infrastructure, keep the robots going, whatever that looks like.

Why would anyone in the most competent 30% of the population be willing to accept a deal where they must work because they are the most competent, but the less competent people get to spend all their time traveling, socializing, enjoying romantic relationships, etc? And remember, they must ALL accept this deal because if any significant percentage of them drops out the infrastructure isn't maintained.

Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by mynameishere on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:37PM (#27170760)
Once you get down to 30 percent, you have an inner party/outer party situation within the 30 percent itself, in which society (as far as they are concerned) is mostly limited to those two groups, and their interplay. I mean: The 30 percent aren't really aware of the 70 percent, even when their upkeep comes out of every paycheck.

When you add up everyone on social security, disability, government make-work jobs (which includes 95 percent of the military) and the assemblage of programs (section 8, EBT, medicaid) that constitute modern welfare, you are pretty much at 30/70 now. So...to answer your question, why are you accepting the deal as we speak?

Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by Consultant32452 on Sunday May 16, 2021 @09:31AM (#27173586)
You answered your own question. Most of the unproductive still have to show up and pretend to be net inputs.

Sure, some will accept a system where the less productive stop pretending and just brazenly take. But most won’t. The fairness/justice system is ingrained in primate dna. It would take an evolutionary time scale to remove it and the productive would kill the nonproductive either directly or indirectly long before that happens.

Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by wmf on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:30PM (#27170457)
Maybe they could live in Elysium.
Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by 1123581321 on Saturday May 15, 2021 @05:51PM (#27169350)
Retirement is instructive as the intention of the retired to stay busy doesn’t match what they, in aggregate, actually do. We should expect similar difficulty with younger ages if we expand retirement to them.
Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by noT1 on Saturday May 15, 2021 @04:45PM (#27168846)
Depends on your definition of work.

Culturally it tends to lean in a direction I’d call “make some richer person happy for a portion of nation-state scrip.”

If you take a more scientific, physical, definition, raising kids is work. Learning anything is work.

Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by Consultant32452 on Saturday May 15, 2021 @04:50PM (#27168894)
I feel it only makes sense to stick to the definition implied in the original post. If you change the definition, you’re having a completely different discussion.
Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by noT1 on Saturday May 15, 2021 @05:27PM (#27169194)
Then why are you bringing up game theory?
Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by Consultant32452 on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:01PM (#27170588)
The point is to apply game theory to the given premise, not change the premise in some way. Once you consider, even for a moment, how all the players in the proposed system would respond to their situation it obviously would not work.
Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by noT1 on Sunday May 16, 2021 @03:13PM (#27176165)
I get what you mean, but you would expect people to import game theory yet importing anything yourself just confuses the whole thing?

Politics aren’t manipulated and how things work are organic. So we should just be happy since look at this math, cause behavior and statistics aren’t game-able.

Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by llimos on Sunday May 16, 2021 @03:59AM (#27172016)
That's the 'B' in the UBI. If people want more than the basic, they'll work. Just like today, most people don't stop building a career once they have a basic salary.
Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by Consultant32452 on Sunday May 16, 2021 @09:52AM (#27173713)
You’ve broken the premise. We instituted UBI because robots are so good nobody can justify paying you for your work. You don’t get to come behind that and say you’ll work for additional compensation.

And the place it falls apart is the other side. Why would the 10% most competent people work a traditional job when everyone else can leisure travel, take up hobbies, spend time with family, or focus on romantic relationships?

Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by llimos on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @08:09AM (#27193586)
> We instituted UBI because robots are so good nobody can justify paying you for your work

Not nobody. There's enough work for some people. Just not enough for everyone, working 45 hours a week.

> Why would the 10% most competent people work a traditional job when everyone else can leisure travel, take up hobbies, spend time with family, or focus on romantic relationships?

Because they want a bigger house/car/yacht

Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by elygre on Saturday May 15, 2021 @04:41PM (#27168812)
Looking at what drives pretty much everybody I know, there is about a zero percent chance that any sizable portion of the population will chose to not work.
Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by jimmaswell on Saturday May 15, 2021 @05:56PM (#27169390)
Looking at people I know, they'd just sit around and smoke weed all day if they didn't have to work. I'd be interested to know what portion of the population is which.
Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by Consultant32452 on Saturday May 15, 2021 @04:42PM (#27168822)
Then there’s no need for UBI.
Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by wmf on Saturday May 15, 2021 @05:33PM (#27169230)
If everybody wants to work but nobody will employ them then UBI is still needed.
Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by Consultant32452 on Saturday May 15, 2021 @08:33PM (#27170211)
Sure. Now let's imagine you're in the top 10% of competence that has to work and I'm in the 15th percentile so I don't have to work because the robots outcompete me. Why would you work all day at a traditional job knowing that I get to do whatever I want all day? I get to travel, spend time with my family, enjoy my hobbies, focus on romantic relationships, all while you're working. And not just me, 90% of everyone on the planet gets to just do whatever we want while you must work. Would you accept that deal? Do you think the majority of the most competent people on the planet would accept that kind of deal?
Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by gumby on Saturday May 15, 2021 @07:14PM (#27169806)
I struggle to understand the problem you’re trying to describe. So what if you don’t feel like working?
Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by amelius on Saturday May 15, 2021 @02:07PM (#27167484)
Where did the low-skilled people in the movie Idiocracy (2006) get their money from?
Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by dbish on Saturday May 15, 2021 @03:08PM (#27167968)
Well, I think in that case everyone was low skilled, probably not what we want to emulate
Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by kittiepryde on Saturday May 15, 2021 @03:14PM (#27168019)
They were mostly employed by Brawnee, which what the company that made energy drinks.
Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by arthurcolle on Saturday May 15, 2021 @06:38PM (#27169631)
"UBI is what the people craveee!" - Idiocracy 2, circa 2024
Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by Animats on Saturday May 15, 2021 @04:35PM (#27168755)
We will likely have to take care of low skilled individuals who can't do a job better or more economically than a robot.

Not since the Reagan era. That's why there are homeless camps.

Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by okareaman on Saturday May 15, 2021 @04:54PM (#27168919)
There are many programs to help homeless people in camps who are functional. The homeless problem is more about non-functional people who refuse help due to drug addiction and mental illness. We need laws that allow communities to force these people into rehab. We need money for rehab. Most Americans don't want to spend the money to do this. I don't know how it is in other countries.
Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by pasquinelli on Saturday May 15, 2021 @06:02PM (#27169424)
there's plenty of work for everyone to do. there's plenty of work that needs doing. the problem isn't that there are extra people, the problem is that we live under an economic system that can't use everyone, that disincentivizes work that needs doing, work that would make life better for everyone.

only when you think the only work that needs doing is work that makes someone's boss money does it look like there are all these extra people that need to be taken care of because there's nothing they can contribute.

Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by ur-whale on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:03PM (#27170333)
> We will likely have to take care of low skilled individuals who can't do a job better or more economically than a robot

That might soon include almost all people in society.

Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by reducesuffering on Saturday May 15, 2021 @03:07PM (#27167960)
If there are any people that can do a job better than a robot, then the answer is very heavy education and genetic engineering for improved IQ and work ethic, to constantly improve humans to be able to achieve more without personal strain.

Remember back in the 1400’s there was little education and what like 95% farm work. Developed nations have reduced farm work to like 5% of the population, through education and better nutrition, to focus on improved medicine and leisure. See the Flynn effect.

Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by mikem170 on Saturday May 15, 2021 @03:47PM (#27168330)
> the answer is very heavy education and genetic engineering for improved IQ and work ethic, to constantly improve humans to be able to achieve more without personal strain

That sounds like a lot of work. Isn't tech supposed to make life easier?

Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by okareaman on Saturday May 15, 2021 @04:08PM (#27168534)
> genetic engineering for improved IQ

Sounds like Eugenics

Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by reducesuffering on Saturday May 15, 2021 @04:54PM (#27168923)
By upgrading everyone not excluding
Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by throwaway_dcnt on Saturday May 15, 2021 @06:11PM (#27169483)
What if I choose to stay natural?
Re:A World Ruled by Persons, Not Machines by arthurcolle on Saturday May 15, 2021 @06:39PM (#27169636)
"Scheduled obsolescence"