News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by pmoriarty on Sunday May 09, 2021 @06:51PM (#27100589)
"The roots of this phenomenon can be traced back to the 'Protestant work ethic' in the 16th Century - a worldview held by white Protestants in Europe that made hard work and the quest for profit seem virtuous. Sally Maitlis, professor of organisational behaviour and leadership at the University of Oxford, says that "later, the drive for efficiency that arose out of the Industrial Revolution", as well as the way we prize productivity, have "further embedded the value of consistent hard work, often at the cost of personal wellbeing".

The roots of the valorization of work may well have been religious, and maybe Christian (though I very much doubt it's exclusively Christian in its origin), but it's definitely spread throughout much of the world, even among the non-religious and even atheist population.

I can't count the number of times I've heard people praise others as "hard working"... in all sorts of contexts, in many different parts of the world, native or immigrant, hard work is praised to the heavens and one of the best things you can say about a person is that they're hard working.

I almost never hear the value of working hard being questioned, except when the subject turns to burnout. Then everybody nods sagely and agrees that overwork is bad.. the next day they go back to praising hard workers.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by acituan on Sunday May 09, 2021 @10:13PM (#27101982)
The problem is not about being hard working or not hard working. It is about the constraints around that hard work; or lack thereof. In late modern labor society the normativity is to achieve in itself, without any philosophical or ethical constraints that grounds achievement in real meaning. It is a pick-and-choose buffet of values and priorities, that is individually curated - rather than also being synchronized with others, the past and the future - and there is only one rule, that you have to achieve.

The grammar of achievement is performance and excess. Everything is possible, and you must exploit yourself while trying to exhaust the possibilities. Except you can't and therefore it is a slow burn spiritual suicide, until you burnout, get into depression, have autoimmune problems etc and hopefully get a wakeup call. Except your therapist is not going to tell you to take it easy either, because they can't come up with any answer to lack of meaning other than work (and maybe to get a family) either.

Not that there is any evil conspiring forces that have set this up, but it also happens having people exploit themselves in the name of achievement yields more than being exploited by someone else directly; to be told what and what not to do all the time is unnecessary when people are equally capable of auto-exploitation. Everyone carries little walking labor camps in themselves.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by chii on Monday May 10, 2021 @04:00AM (#27103720)
> and there is only one rule, that you have to achieve.... achievement is performance and excess.

and yet, this is what led to most, if not all human achievements and progress. The modern quality of life that most people have come to enjoy is off the backs of people who _are_ doing their utmost to achieve performance and excess (aka, earn more than their spending).

If everyone lived an idyllic, and idle life, we'd have much less modern life amenities and conveniences; stuff would be more expensive, and less wealth all round.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by wildmanx on Monday May 10, 2021 @05:38AM (#27104265)
That's a very narrow view of "human achievements and progress". Did Mozart achieve because he was forced by peer-pressure to work around the clock? Picasso? Miles Davis?

It's pretty sad if we consider Facebook, Google or Apple as the pinnacles of human achievement. Sure it's useful to have a phone in my pocket that can tell me at any time of the day what's the weather in Hong Kong or how to cook Pork Hock. Sure it's nice that I can connect to relatives in Spain or Brazil through Facebook or search for the number of current Covid cases in South Africa. But I could live with those "achievements" having come later if that had not meant a work culture that forces me into burnout.

Same for space rockets bringing robots to Mars, electric cars for the upper class and drilling tunnels under some Bay Area city.

And for those claiming the climate catastrophe is here and we need to act now .. yeah, let's think for a moment how we got here and whether overachieving and overworking have something to do with it.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by Game_Ender on Monday May 10, 2021 @07:02AM (#27104622)
If Mozart had to spend more, or most, of his time gathering food and tending to his basic needs would he have had time to make music? What about the musicians who played it?

Wealth is the ability to do more with less effort. Some of that free labor goes to arts, science, or philosophy and advances humanity. Maybe too much goes toward building even more wealth or a fancier house/things but you would not have the former without the ability to get later.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by wildmanx on Monday May 10, 2021 @07:43AM (#27104856)
I'm not saying we should all be artists and drop any work on improving science or technology. To the contrary, some people really thrive doing that, and who am I to outlaw it.

But this is about working 80+ hours a week to achieve that. Changing the world is possible in 40 hours a week. Or 30, or 20. It may happen more slowly, but it won't leave so many train wrecks of burnout in its path.

(Apart from overall total productivity not necessarily being lower with a 30 hour week than a 50 hour week as the increased energy and motivation can often times easily offset the fewer hours.)

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by throwaway2048 on Monday May 10, 2021 @04:18AM (#27103797)
Its a vast overstatement to say that "all human achievement and progress" is due to people working themselves to death.

Stuff like creative output suffers greatly if you push yourself to the limit, for instance.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by marvin on Monday May 10, 2021 @05:02AM (#27104041)
I am reminded of a commend I read on HN a few years ago.

"Here lies marvin, who valiantly sacrificed his life in the name of progress.

Thanks to his heroic efforts, the trees in GTA 7 look very good."

I'd love to read a proper study on how people experience different types of hard work. I've worked overtime myself, and it's been a memorable experience when it's been for just a few weeks or months, and in pursuit of something that meaningfully advances the world.

But it would not be fun if it was only a peripheral advance, or it happened regularly. For me, it only works if it's something exceptional, to be done a few times.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by dqh on Monday May 10, 2021 @12:21AM (#27102656)
Interesting that you mention autoimmune problems alongside burnout and depression, I hadn’t heard of that possible link before. Do you have any anecdotes on this that you would share?
Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by andrewjl on Monday May 10, 2021 @01:11AM (#27102927)
Not the OP but look into links between stress and inflammation.[1]

[1] https://www.healthline.com/health/inflammation

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by insert_coin on Monday May 10, 2021 @01:40AM (#27103065)
> The problem is not about being hard working or not hard working. It is about the constraints around that hard work; or lack thereof. In late modern labor society the normativity is to achieve in itself, without any philosophical or ethical constraints that grounds achievement in real meaning. It is a pick-and-choose buffet of values and priorities, that is individually curated - rather than also being synchronized with others, the past and the future - and there is only one rule, that you have to achieve.

That is of course not true. Individually curated means synchronized with others as no individual exists in a vacuum; it feeds on others, on the environment, on history, and others feed on the individual, and the environment is modified by the individual, and history written by it. That it is free to evaluate its own future path is not the same as not being also part of something else, much less not take into account the something else.

Achievement in itself is, unparadoxically, and achievement. That you don't agree with it says more about your synchronicity with the rest of society than the opposite.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by acituan on Monday May 10, 2021 @02:19AM (#27103244)
> That is of course not true. Individually curated means synchronized with others as no individual exists in a vacuum ... That it is free to evaluate its own future path

You misunderstand. The question is whether individual value structures converge/approximate to a superstructure outside every individual, not whether individuals can use environment, history, each other etc as an inspiration for their custom tailored lives. The sense of the former was destroyed with the end of modernism. Everything dissolved in an acid vat of infinite relativism. Every normativity other than growth in the market got destroyed/crumbled. And individual achievement is merely the projection of that at the atomized level.

> Achievement in itself is, unparadoxically, and achievement. That you don't agree with it says more about your synchronicity with the rest of society than the opposite.

I take that as a compliment because one of the things I aspire to is to not get dissolved in the blind allegiance to achievement and excess positivity. It usually gets unnoticed but when people excessively project themselves to achievements and future growth; they turn into massive narcissists. And I am not using that in the pejorative sense; they lose a grounded sense of themselves. The freedom from "improving", being able to have leisurely, contemplative time, enjoying "returnless" social encounters for their own sake, having a sense of limits etc counter that. I wish they were valued more.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by insert_coin on Monday May 10, 2021 @02:44AM (#27103348)
> You misunderstand. The question is whether individual value structures converge/approximate to a superstructure outside every individual, not whether individuals can use environment, history, each other etc as an inspiration for their custom tailored lives.

You misunderstand. They of course converge, there is no other alternative but for society to be a reflection of their individuals. You don't like the answer so you pretend what they converge into is not worthy somehow because it doesn't adhere to some high societal morality standard which by the way just so happen to be the morality you ascribe to, which is of course nonsense.

> I take that as a compliment because one of the things I aspire to is to not get dissolved in the blind allegiance to achievement and excess positivity.

> It usually gets unnoticed but when people excessively project themselves to achievements and future growth; they turn into massive narcissists. And I am not using that in the pejorative sense; they lose a grounded sense of themselves.

Oh the irony.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by acituan on Monday May 10, 2021 @04:52PM (#27110789)
Just stop.

If you don't have a counter-argument that is not an ad-hominem attack, strawmanning someone's position or shallow namecalling, you don't have to participate. This is not the forum for that.

Here is HN Guidelines for your reference. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

In particular;

> Be kind. Don't be snarky.

> Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive.

> Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize.

> When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names.

> Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something.

Incidentally, this is a good example to the value superstructure I was talking about. It is not a passive culmination of individual preferences, it is an aspirational guidepost sitting outside of us as a reference point. It allows selecting what behavior belongs to what extent and what doesn't. It tells us we can do better and what that better looks like.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by insert_coin on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @07:08AM (#27116578)
Again, that you don’t consider what I wrote a counter argument and are trying to dismiss it as ad-hominem to not have to actually generate a rebuttal or accept it says more about you than the opposite.

Society decides its morals, not I, certainly not you.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by rsj_hn on Sunday May 09, 2021 @09:33PM (#27101739)
I think the real point of the protestant work ethic is that when you have a post-Christian society that replaces church with work, you end up with people effectively going to work-monasteries.

But if you look at the Middle Ages, you'll find something like 100 days off a year, tons of feast days and days off, limited working hours in the remaining days, and not at all a culture that valorized work even thought it was much more deeply Christian than modern Europe. It's all about what you worship.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by Clewza313 on Sunday May 09, 2021 @10:22PM (#27102043)
The vast majority people in the Middle Ages lived off subsistence farming, which doesn't really have "days off". Yes, farming has busier and quieter periods, but many types of work like spinning and weaving were essentially continuous (the amount of work required to clothe a family was ridiculous), and even the quietest "off day" still included things like feeding and milking the animals. Feast days were often also designed around communal events like harvesting or barn-raising, when the entire community got together and basically took turns working at tasks that needed more labor than a single household can provide.
Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by paganel on Monday May 10, 2021 @06:13AM (#27104411)
> which doesn't really have "days off"

My grand-parents were Eastern-European peasants and they certainly had "days off", you were not allowed to go to the field during a religious holiday (and one was not allowed to do it on Sundays, either).

25 years since I last helped my paternal grand-parents to collect hay I can still remember those religious holidays when we'd just sit around the house, not going to the field: July 20th (Saint Elijah), August 15th (Assumption of Mary), August 6th (Transfiguration) and I think also June 29th (Saint Peter and Paul).

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by rsj_hn on Sunday May 09, 2021 @10:28PM (#27102081)
> The vast majority people in the Middle Ages lived off subsistence farming, which doesn't really have "days off".

I think you have an incorrect view of subsistence farming. It does not require constant work, and you do not see constant work in traditional societies. You do see many days off. Now during harvest time there is lots of work, but that is a small period of the year, say 7 weeks out of the year. Other times the farmer has the option of when to plant and how much, when to weed and how much, when to work on processing food and how much. And these fall into familiar patterns from which things like feast days emerge as the interstitial times when the above does not need to happen. The idea of constant backbreaking labor all year long may be appropriate for something like a large Jamaican plantation, but not a small farm in Europe. Of course if it was an American farmer, they would enlarge their farm, bring in more livestock or auxiliary sources of income to fill up whatever daylight was available, and keep adding work until they and all their hired hands were busy all the time. Then they would take the earnings and use it to buy more land and hire more people and expand the work even further. But traditional societies did not organize themselves this way, nor is this something required of farmers.

Here is some data: http://groups.csail.mit.edu/mac/users/rauch/worktime/hours_w...

"The contrast between capitalist and precapitalist work patterns is most striking in respect to the working year. The medieval calendar was filled with holidays. Official -- that is, church -- holidays included not only long "vacations" at Christmas, Easter, and midsummer but also numerous saints' andrest days. These were spent both in sober churchgoing and in feasting, drinking and merrymaking. In addition to official celebrations, there were often weeks' worth of ales -- to mark important life events (bride ales or wake ales) as well as less momentous occasions (scot ale, lamb ale, and hock ale). All told, holiday leisure time in medieval England took up probably about one-third of the year. And the English were apparently working harder than their neighbors. The ancien règime in France is reported to have guaranteed fifty-two Sundays, ninety rest days, and thirty-eight holidays. In Spain, travelers noted that holidays totaled five months per year.[5]

The peasant's free time extended beyond officially sanctioned holidays. There is considerable evidence of what economists call the backward-bending supply curve of labor -- the idea that when wages rise, workers supply less labor. During one period of unusually high wages (the late fourteenth century), many laborers refused to work "by the year or the half year or by any of the usual terms but only by the day." And they worked only as many days as were necessary to earn their customary income -- which in this case amounted to about 120 days a year, for a probable total of only 1,440 hours annually (this estimate assumes a 12-hour day because the days worked were probably during spring, summer and fall). A thirteenth-century estime finds that whole peasant families did not put in more than 150 days per year on their land. Manorial records from fourteenth-century England indicate an extremely short working year -- 175 days -- for servile laborers. Later evidence for farmer-miners, a group with control over their worktime, indicates they worked only 180 days a year."

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by Clewza313 on Sunday May 09, 2021 @10:45PM (#27102168)
That article equates "work" with farming alone, which is a common but fallacious trope. A subsistence farming household has to manufacture virtually everything they need, and in your "small farm in Europe" setting, spinning and weaving alone consume essentially all the working hours of one person in a family:

Put into working terms, the basic clothing of our six person farming family requires 7.35 labor hours per day, every day of the year. Our ‘comfort’ level requires 22.05 hours (obviously not done by one person).

https://acoup.blog/2021/03/19/collections-clothing-how-did-t...

The main difference between the subsistence farmer and the wage worker -- and ACOUP goes into this in detail -- is that the subsistence farmer has to optimize for security over productivity, meaning that the marginal returns for working harder/longer hours are much less. Working twice as hard to till twice the fields won't help when a summer frost nukes the whole crop.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by artem247 on Monday May 10, 2021 @08:01AM (#27104988)
I'm not sure why exactly subsistence farming households would have to manufacture everything -- farmer can sell produce on the market and buy stuff.

You quote quite a long article - yet you do not give the full data. 7.35 labor hours per day whole year is to produce 21 sq meters of cloth, using estimates about ancient world, not pre-modern Europe.

20 sq meters of cloth using a bit more modern (Middle ages) estimate would give you 3 hours per day whole year by one person. Also keep in mind that those farmer households would not change their clothes every year (and that's an understatement)

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by TheCoelacanth on Monday May 10, 2021 @01:16PM (#27108368)
> I'm not sure why exactly subsistence farming households would have to manufacture everything -- farmer can sell produce on the market and buy stuff

That doesn't lower the total amount of labor required. Someone still has to make the garments. Garments were also very expensive, and most farmers wouldn't have had enough surplus crops to purchase them.

> more modern (Middle ages) estimate would give you 3 hours per day whole year by one person

That's after the invention of the spinning wheel, which didn't exist for ~90% of the Middle Ages. The second estimate from just before the invention of the spinning wheel (1300s) is close to the ancient estimate.

> Also keep in mind that those farmer households would not change their clothes every year (and that's an understatement)

One garment per year. That doesn't mean they throw away the old garment. They might keep it as a spare or repurpose it for other uses. He also justifies this estimate based on historical data for people who were issued garments by their employers (slaves and soldiers). Cato the Elder recommended issuing slaves one garment every two years, and was infamous for being cruel and parsimonious towards his slaves, so that is probably about the bare minimum for subsistence. Soldiers in the Roman Republic were issued two garments per year.

Assuming that subsistence farmers aimed for a standard of living above that of the most poorly treated slaves seems like a reasonable assumption.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by watwut on Monday May 10, 2021 @04:29PM (#27110529)
> farmer can sell produce on the market and buy stuff

They used to produce most of stuff by themselves, because functional market requires good roads and a lot of people. And if course, if you are buing it, you need to produce a lot more food, so that you can sell it or exchange it.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by artem247 on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @12:24PM (#27120064)
>> They used to produce most of stuff by themselves, because functional market requires good roads and a lot of people

Do you have any data that supports it?

I think it is fair to say that at least in Europe both Western and Eastern from onset of Middle Ages people living in villages were actually able to travel to the adjacent towns and to yearly market fairs. That wasn't a daily trip of course but I do not see an issue of farmer exchanging some bags of flour for some clothes once in two years.

>> And if course, if you are buing it, you need to produce a lot more food, so that you can sell it or exchange it.

Well, yeah, that's generally an intention when you are a farmer :) Also farmers were serfs often and had to give up some part of what they gathered.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by rightbyte on Monday May 10, 2021 @05:01AM (#27104030)
I think you have a point. I mean making butter with a stick - how long does that take? Household work was probably alot ontop of payed work.
Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by watwut on Monday May 10, 2021 @03:46AM (#27103661)
The article equates the holiday with "doing nothing". Just on top of head, animals still needed daily care. They needed food, milking, being taken outside, made mess that that day as much as normally. You would still have to take eggs away of chickens. And that is just stuff I vaguely remember my grandma talking about. The holiday, including Christmas, was not "do nothing whole day" affair.

People still needed food during holidays, which means food preparation that day also more work before holidays. Holidays themselves had to be prepared. The special holiday cloth had to be decorated and sewn. All that is work. Work/leisure trade off for organizing "bride ales" and such is an additional work. Just like the Christmas today are basically a lot of work, cleaning, cooking, gifts shopping and stress before celebration in exchange of two days of rest.

It is also odd to equate The ancien règime in France with like a lot of leisure, since it led to quite a lot of social issues - poverty, famine and such.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by birdyrooster on Monday May 10, 2021 @05:05AM (#27104055)
Hired-hands? Sorry but in America we had a majority of the population in the south as chattel slaves. I assumed at first you were talking about recent memory but then you went back to Medieval times, so I should clarify.
Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by jonnyone on Monday May 10, 2021 @12:46AM (#27102798)
Work is not replacing church. In the Middle Ages, there was farm work performed by peasants. As far as 100 days off, if we take 52 weekends a year, we're a little over that same amount for those who don't work weekends (which is the majority of single job holders). Broadcast media replaced the church as a moral arbiter and now we are sort of in a phase where some are attempting to rebuild that church of television with the internet.
Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by andrewjl on Monday May 10, 2021 @12:06AM (#27102580)
By the time Protestantism came about, this type of life was only present in the countryside and receding fast.
Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by Thlom on Monday May 10, 2021 @05:18AM (#27104143)
Including weekends I have ~135 days off a year per law.
Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by rStar on Sunday May 09, 2021 @09:55PM (#27101880)
>I can't count the number of times I've heard people praise others as "hard working"... in all sorts of contexts, in many different parts of the world, native or immigrant, hard work is praised to the heavens and one of the best things you can say about a person is that they're hard working.

this reminds me of how, in the US at least, society has settled into the pattern of saying "thank you" to the "heroes" who fight our wars, protect us from fire and keep our for-profit prisons full. it's because the rest of us have no interest in doing any of those things, so we blow smoke up their proverbial *. fuck the protestant work ethic, and fuck being guilted into wage slavery, for at least, you know, the period of your life that lasts from the time your young and healthy until you die.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by ChrisMarshallNY on Sunday May 09, 2021 @08:10PM (#27101154)
> though I very much doubt it's exclusively Christian in its origin

You should see the Japanese go at it. I hear the Chinese are every bit as bad (996). Not many Christians, there.

The Japanese take a certain pride in it. I feel that their efficiency suffers, and burnout is a big problem, there.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by theshrike79 on Monday May 10, 2021 @02:50AM (#27103373)
The Japanese working culture might be the only one worse than the American one.

In Japan you need to be at the office before your boss and can't leave before they do. And this goes all the way up, meaning that the lowest employees practically live at the office.

Combine this with a culture that doesn't really allow questioning your superiors makes for a really stressful work life.

One anecdote I heard was that a company had a one hour meeting with the Big Boss, who told what he wanted people to do. After that they had a two-hour meeting where they figured out what the boss meant. It was not proper to ask questions directly from the big boss.

Americans on the other hand glorify working two or three jobs, suffering 80-100 hour work weeks is a badge of honour. And they still just barely manage to get a living wage.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by ChrisMarshallNY on Monday May 10, 2021 @07:49AM (#27104901)
> One anecdote I heard was that a company had a one hour meeting with the Big Boss, who told what he wanted people to do. After that they had a two-hour meeting where they figured out what the boss meant. It was not proper to ask questions directly from the big boss.

Totally believe that. I worked at a Japanese company for 27 years, and attended a lot of meetings. Japanese managers pretty much spend their entire career in conference rooms.

The Chinese, however, have the concept of "996," which means "9AM to 9PM, six days a week." The Japanese also do that, but it's not quite as explicit.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by samatman on Monday May 10, 2021 @03:10AM (#27103477)
It is not. At minimum, South Korean and Mainland Chinese working culture is worse than American. Taiwanese as well.

Don't know if that list is exhaustive; it might be.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by wildmanx on Monday May 10, 2021 @05:27AM (#27104208)
The opposite of "hard working" is not "good work-life balance", but "slacking off".

And that's one of the roots of this cult. You don't want to be perceived as slacking off, so you sacrifice work-life balance and work overtime. That's such an enormous misconception. You can be very focused 9-to-5, and then you go home and don't look back until next morning at 9 am when you again are as hard-working as the day before. Somebody who is 12 hours a day at the office but spends half the time chit-chatting at the water cooler and browsing facebook is not "hard working".

Hard-working and work-life balance are not opposites. That's something people really need to understand.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by chasd00 on Monday May 10, 2021 @07:34AM (#27104792)
I’ll add that working hard doesn’t mean being effective or productive. I can go dig holes in my backyard 24x7 which is very hard work but does nothing. Some people can be very effective 9 to 5 and push progress much further than many others working 14 hr days doing the digital equivalent of digging holes.
Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by bambax on Monday May 10, 2021 @07:24AM (#27104736)
> even among the non-religious and even atheist population

Just because one proclaims to not believe in God doesn't free them from the values that were drilled in their head during childhood. So many people proclaim to be "atheists" but otherwise strongly believe in and defend Christian values (Bill Gates is a prominent example).

It's not just childhood, it's social pressure. It's extremely hard to publicly hold values that go contrary to the group, even more so when those contrarian values don't bring success and therefore don't have much to show for themselves.

Diogenes was a true hero.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by zarkov99 on Monday May 10, 2021 @07:58AM (#27104967)
Hard workers should be praised. It is hard and it works. It is the only lever we actually have some control over to move forward in life.

On the other hand there is nothing admirable about taking it easy. Anyone can do it and it does not lead to any achievement. Of course some people care about achievement and some do not, that is fine, but lets not pretend hard work is not necessary for it.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by analog31 on Sunday May 09, 2021 @08:09PM (#27101139)
Nassim Taleb suggests that it's not an outgrowth of religion.

[n] https://medium.com/incerto/religion-violence-tolerance-progr...

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by crispyambulance on Sunday May 09, 2021 @07:26PM (#27100857)
The Protestant/Calvinist work-ethic is definitely a factor especially, IMHO, in technology work. It stretches over to Asian non-Christian cultures too, but I suspect that's because it's an export which they've accepted as their own because it happens to jive with the strict authoritarian hierarchies which are common in Asian countries.

You can see it in Stackoverflow as well. The gamification encourages people to prove they are "worthy" of even deigning to ask a question by showing they've done "the work". Those who haven't are subject to humiliation and dismissal, regardless of need or authenticity.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by zepto on Sunday May 09, 2021 @08:37PM (#27101344)
You can see the ultimate expression of Calvinism/Protestantism in Bitcoin too, where authority over what counts as money is granted to machines that can prove that they have done ‘work’. This proof is not judged by a human, but rather by the laws of mathematics and physics - I.e. the creations of God, thus Bitcoin is a money whose purity is sanctified by an offering of work done for its own sake.
Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by judge2020 on Sunday May 09, 2021 @09:42PM (#27101793)
That view implies and required the acceptance of a God, though - it's like saying that gravity itself is the ultimate expression of protestantism (not sure if your post is supposed to be a /s).
Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by jonnyone on Monday May 10, 2021 @12:50AM (#27102814)
No, not necessarily. You can be psychologically influenced by a society imbued with religious moral undertones to the point where you unwittingly want to "prove yourself" to "some omnipotent other." I think it's fairly common, actually.
Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by zepto on Monday May 10, 2021 @10:42AM (#27106476)
It only presupposes that ‘God’ is a symbol for an enforcer of laws that are above human laws. This is self-evidently a pre-requisite for Bitcoin.
Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by ihsw on Sunday May 09, 2021 @09:15PM (#27101613)
It is self-evident that BTC was invented specifically in rejection of and in opposition to being judged by humans. One could easily compare this to the importance of purity in religious contexts but it would be foolish to assume there is any connection.
Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by zepto on Monday May 10, 2021 @10:40AM (#27106462)
> it would be foolish to assume there is any connection.

Given the history of human ideas, it would be equally foolish to assume there was not.

Atheists do a lot of things religious people do because they are still part of a tradition even if they don’t ‘believe’.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by halflings on Sunday May 09, 2021 @08:25PM (#27101255)
> You can see it in Stackoverflow as well. The gamification encourages people to prove they are "worthy" of even deigning to ask a question by showing they've done "the work". Those who haven't are subject to humiliation and dismissal, regardless of need or authenticity.

I don't see how stackexchange's policy is related to the article, or "Protestant/Calvinist work-ethic". They are banning low-effort questions (e.g "File couldn't be opened" when the person just has a typo in a file path) because they devalue the platform, waste time that could have instead been spent on useful questions.

> I suspect that's because it's an export which they've accepted as their own because it happens to jive with the strict authoritarian hierarchies which are common in Asian countries.

Or they independently developed a glorification of hard-work from other sources. It's nothing new. All the Abrahamic religions do, and the same is true for secular ideologies such as communism.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by kortilla on Sunday May 09, 2021 @09:10PM (#27101573)
Are suggesting Japan’s salaryman was an import from Christians?
Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by unishark on Sunday May 09, 2021 @10:15PM (#27101991)
I've always viewed the Calvinism theory as a kind of anti-American theory that violates Ockham's razor. The desire to prove one's self by overworking strikes me as an innate adolescent approach to competition. Whether it's to impress your peers at a casual sport or at your job. If some cultures achieve progress in a more healthy way, then that's the interesting and unnatural situation which needs investigating.
Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by yeetman21 on Sunday May 09, 2021 @09:03PM (#27101530)
people want others to show that they at least tried to put effort into something before calling for help, this is not a bad thing
Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by WalterBright on Monday May 10, 2021 @01:52AM (#27103117)
Colonial Americans, before the industrial revolution, worked very hard and died young. The proof is in their bones, all showing signs of overwork.

Subsistence farming is no picnic.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by goodpoint on Monday May 10, 2021 @06:46AM (#27104547)
> Subsistence farming is no picnic.

The majority of traditional cultures practicing subsistence farming often work much less than 40h/w, still today.

During the middle ages it was common in many cultures to have less than 200 working days per year.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by WalterBright on Monday May 10, 2021 @06:26PM (#27111644)
I bet they're not making their own thread, cloth, clothes, and a lot of the other things provided by an industrialized world. Doing those things the old way is very, very labor intensive.
Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by Datagenerator on Monday May 10, 2021 @01:29AM (#27103023)
This, thank you for the paradoxical views most have on the 'hard workers'. Up until mental problems become undeniable these people are exploited.
Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by eat_veggies on Monday May 10, 2021 @12:00AM (#27102549)
Yes, that's a major point in Weber's original formulation of the Protestant work ethic—the secularization of those values and practices. In other words, the puritans wanted to live this way; we have to.

If the phenomenon seems like it's global now—even appearing in parts of the world that Protestantism never touched—then that's because, well, capitalism is global.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by missedthecue on Monday May 10, 2021 @01:06AM (#27102891)
You have to live like them?

I have a strong suspicion you work nowhere near as hard or long as the Puritans did.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by keyle on Sunday May 09, 2021 @08:50PM (#27101437)
"An idle mind is the devil's workshop" was the exact quote.
Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by refurb on Sunday May 09, 2021 @10:31PM (#27102095)
And the reason why that culture permeates East Asia?
Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by jhbadger on Sunday May 09, 2021 @10:50PM (#27102196)
Confucianism has a work ethic that while not exactly the same as the Western/Christian one, has a lot of similarities. Although Confucius was Chinese, these ideas spread into other East Asian countries that were under historical Chinese influence like Japan, Korea, and Vietnam
Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by routerl on Monday May 10, 2021 @06:45AM (#27104541)
> The roots of the valorization of work may well have been religious, and maybe Christian (though I very much doubt it's exclusively Christian in its origin), but it's definitely spread throughout much of the world, even among the non-religious and even atheist population.

The article is referencing "The Protestant Work Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism", which is a seminal work on the history and structure of labour. It does not, in any way, imply that this is a religious phenomenon any more than capitalism itself.

Re:Why do we buy into the 'cult' of overwork? by thomastjeffery on Sunday May 09, 2021 @07:51PM (#27101026)
Most values that exist in religious doctrine and culture end up spreading to secular culture.

Issues like sexual shame, circumcision, censored language, etc. are all commonplace in America because they are actively promoted by religious conservatives and (for the most part) passively ignored by critics.

It's difficult to be critical of values that religious institutions have without being generally dismissed as overly antagonistic.