News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by TulliusCicero on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @02:50PM (#27054057)
> some of them not as big as claimed in popular media

I think this depends on what popular media is to you. My wife is a big time feminist who hates any discussion of gender differences in personality, and going by the sources she reads, pretty much all differences that we can observe today are just due to culture. This is not an uncommon position within progressive circles.

Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by pengaru on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:12PM (#27054318)
At this point we have substantial accounts from enough transgender people describing personality and behavioral effects of HRT to know Testosterone plays a significant role in things like assertiveness and aggression, at least.

This American Life did an episode on the subject that's worth a listen.

https://www.thisamericanlife.org/220/testosterone

Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by TulliusCicero on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:15PM (#27054358)
Cool, I'll check it out. On a similar note, there's this cool little article about transgender guys and the differences they noticed: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/local/wp/2018/07/20/feat...
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by Workaccount2 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:46PM (#27054742)
>This is not an uncommon position within progressive circles.

Many if not most progressive ideals are predicated on "the blank slate" theory being true. It's not a matter of common/uncommon opinion, it has to be true. It's an axiom of modern progressive theory. What happens when one of your axioms is anything other than rock solid?

This is why the claws come out so fast when you bring up genetics in progressive groups.

Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by throwaway3699 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:08PM (#27054265)
Yeah, sadly the conversation is dominated by extremists. The answer to nature or nurture is probably just 'both'.
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by klyrs on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:13PM (#27054339)
Good science validates, disproves, or quantifies common sense. The nature vs nurture question is especially complicated, because a proper study effectively requires horrible experiments on isolating children from "culture" starting from infancy -- and that's under the optimistic assumption that culture isn't absorbed in the womb
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by TulliusCicero on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:32PM (#27054563)
The idea that the article uses is that if you find commonalities across widely dispersed and different cultures, that strongly points to a common biological cause.
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by Workaccount2 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:50PM (#27054807)
Twin studies have done a lot of work in this area. Two genetically identical children, separated at birth and raised in 2 separate families.

At least from these studies, genetics play a far larger role than expected.

Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by excepttheweasel on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @04:46PM (#27055567)
How do twin studies separate those children from the culture they're raised in?
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by francisofascii on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:19PM (#27054401)
If you were to study children from a diverse range of cultures, and found similar results regardless of culture, could you come to a conclusion? Might be easier than the removal of culture.
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by klyrs on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:42PM (#27054685)
Did those "diverse range of cultures" arise separately, or did humans originate in one location and spread their culture from there? Contrast to a drug trial -- imagine you only test penicillins, and nobody gets a placebo or a non-treatment, could you come to a conclusion? Are the potential outcomes / conclusions of the experiment the same as an experiment where there are placebo and non-treatment controls?
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by seneca on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @05:10PM (#27055886)
> Did those "diverse range of cultures" arise separately, or did humans originate in one location and spread their culture from there?

If you define cultural influence as broadly as pre-historic shared origins, I fear you've stepped into the territory of unfalsifiable claims. Interesting conversationally, but useless scientifically.

Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by klyrs on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @05:41PM (#27056171)
If you'd like to claim that one culture is totally independent from another culture, there's a pretty big burden of proof there and I reject it out of hand. Humans don't spontaneously materialize, abandoned infants rarely survive to adulthood, and nearly all cultures interact with their neighbors in some form or another (so even if they started independent, they won't remain so for long)

Moral monstrosity aside, it should be possible to answer nature-vs-nurture questions by raising humans from infancy in a robo-nursery where they only interact with other such "culturally pristine" humans. Seed a dozen such communities and watch their culture evolve over several generations, and you'd have a pretty good basis to draw conclusions on nature vs nurture.

Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by nairboon on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @06:10PM (#27056457)
How will you teach them a language in the robo-nursery without adding any culture?
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by klyrs on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @06:20PM (#27056552)
I wasn't imagining any such education, just provision of physical needs. More like commercial chicken farming, less like an actual nursery you'd send a child to. I did say this was monstrous, after all. One may hope that altruism, compassion, and child-rearing are human nature, and the robo-nursery could be phased out.
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by systemvoltage on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:33PM (#27054576)
> Good science validates, disproves, or quantifies common sense.

The problem is even more insidious - good science is prevented from being conducted for political reasons largely by extreme progressives. It is unsettling to me that we have so much politics mixed in with scientific understanding of humans.

The chilling effect of this is that no professor or researcher would these days attempt to conduct good science around gender differences - they fear their life, liberty and right to pursuit a prosperous career.

Just look at the number of gray comments in this thread - it shows how intolerant, childish and absolutely infuriating it is to discuss something that should not be contentious or confrontational. We're not acting like adults.

Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by klyrs on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:47PM (#27054756)
I'd encourage you to read your own comment here. You're pointing a finger at "extreme progressives" and calling folks intolerant, childish and confrontational. Does this framing facilitate a reasoned conversation, or further polarize it?
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by throwaway3699 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @04:03PM (#27054948)
How can we un-polarize science of we cannot discuss it?
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by klyrs on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @04:15PM (#27055102)
Here it is, being discussed. Therefore, we can discuss it. Can we do so without name-calling? That seems to be a good place to start.
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by google234123 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @04:24PM (#27055233)
Imagine trying to discuss the US's stem cells laws/prohibitions in the early 2000s without being able to "point fingers at" Bush, the far right, or religion.
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by klyrs on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @04:39PM (#27055462)
Been there, done that, didn't buy the t-shirt. Calling one's opponent an "extremist" was insultingly reductive then, just as it is now.
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by guerrilla on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:31PM (#27054549)
Indeed, I meant popular in general. It's interesting you bring that up though because that's precisely what started me on this. A feminist friend and I disagreed on that and so we looked into it both came out with more nuanced views. The science does not support gender essentialism nor does it support the tabula rasa kind of thing her and your wife were advocating. The answer is that it's nature and nurture and we just don't know how much of which yet.

Somewhere there's an entire Wikipedia page on people debating whether this is legitimate research or somehow sexism. I thought all of their arguments were pretty poor though. It's kind of a scary situation though that some people are so hostile to even looking into it at all.

I think it's going to be really hard to figure out how much is biological vs. cultural but I suspect society may get to some of those experiments before science at this rate.

Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by tasogare on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:18PM (#27054381)
> and going by the sources she reads

This is the real source of the problem. Not that multiple kind of sources exist (religious, scientific, fiction work, etc.) but that one kind try to pass as something it is not. This is particularly pervasive in fields like sociology where political essays are masquerading as science when it is in fact not. Sooner or later reality will come back, but a lot of time and money is wasted in the process, both by universities and public policies.

Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by zozbot234 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:23PM (#27054445)
> This is particularly pervasive in fields like sociology where political essays are masquerading as science when it is in fact not.

The "is vs. ought problem" strikes again, it seems. There are plenty of politically-motivated folks in "soft" social studies who can't quite tell the difference between talking about the world as it is, vs. what we might want it to be like. The more rigorous social sciences are a lot clearer on always striving for a clear distinction between "positive" (i.e. "descriptive") and "normative" talk.

Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by 13years on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:33PM (#27054573)
Furthermore, when we can not distinguish between "is vs. ought", then we have a complete lack of understanding of the world.

This becomes a circular problem, in that our lack of understanding means that we propose the wrong solutions for attempting to move towards the "ought" often with many undesirable results in direct opposition to the intentions.

Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by bourgwaletariat on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @04:05PM (#27054984)
I'm sorry to hear that. Feminism has done a lot of real damage to our society and to the lives of children, men, women and families.

> hates any discussion

hates. Hate is ruining us. She hates discussion. Discussion?

"We are not discussing this. My belief is correct. There will be no discussion. My way or the highway."

It's destroying us. Just like feminism. Feminism is not about equality. It's about power, mostly about people who feel entitled to more power, who already have more.

Feminism, in its attempt to give women more power, has eliminated their power... to not work. Now, they are forced to go to work, in a dual income family, just to raise a child. That wasn't necessary 50 years ago. Women have always worked if they wanted to. In their attempt to fight the corporataucracy they have given it more power by doubling the work force, increasing the supply of workers, and thus suppressing wages.

Same reason there's a push to get more women in tech. To make tech workers cheaper -- not empower women. It's a lie.

Women blamed the patriarchy for "eliminating" their right to work. Now they have to. Do you think it's a coincidence that, since the 70's, feminism has increased dramatically, while wages have remained flat? Wages should be twice as high right now and women should still have the choice to stay home with the kids -- or men. It's been like that since human history, all the way back to hunter gatherers, and now suddenly, in a geological blink of an eye, kids are home alone for hours a day. Cared for the rest of it, mostly by people who are paid to, with no familial relationship or incentive to care for them and help them succeed.

Why do we think this is good?

It's not good. It's a real tragedy.

Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by w0de0 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:09PM (#27054282)
I think there's a distinction to be made here between sex, the biological facet, and gender, the cultural construct that maps to sex - or more accurately, maps our assumptions, myths, and platitudes about sex to an expected set of behaviors.
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by slowmovintarget on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @06:33PM (#27056667)
"Gender perception" or "gender presentation" perhaps. But for the longest time "gender" meant one's biological sex.

We should, instead, talk about personality as affected by gender, and behavior as influenced by personality and culture, including assumed or adopted gender norms.

What the article says is that personality is affected by gender. Behavior is influenced by more than just personality. These are distinctions in cause and effect, which tend to be blurred together when using political language. Personality (ex ante) and behavior (ex post) distinctions keep getting wrapped around the axle of these attempted redefinitions.

Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by Spinnaker_ on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @07:36PM (#27057306)
There is a distinction, but you can't simply separate sex into biology and gender into cultural construction. There is still much debate as to how much of this set of behaviours is biological. Many animals exhibit sex roles.
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by TulliusCicero on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:13PM (#27054331)
That's fair, I should've said sex differences instead of gender differences.
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by logicslave on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:04PM (#27054219)
Large scale brainwashing, but also, holding the opinion of biologically driven personality eats away at the concept of free will
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by TulliusCicero on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:11PM (#27054310)
Calling it brainwashing is maybe overselling the point, but as an exmo it does feel similar to me to arguments around religious dogma, where people are already 100% certain on the only outcome/position that's acceptable to them, then go find the arguments and evidence that backs that.

It's clear to me that many social progressives find the idea that there may be average biological differences in personality between genders to be unacceptable.

> holding the opinion of biologically driven personality eats away at the concept of free will

Eh, I don't think you'll find many people who dispute that there's individual variation in personalities due to biology/genetics. Hell, "born this way" (for being gay) was practically a rallying cry on the left.

Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by silicon2401 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:17PM (#27054376)
The superset is "ideology" imo. Whether the topic is supernatural or physical, people who base their lives on ideology tend to behave similarly, as you've pointed out.
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by TaylorAlexander on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:29PM (#27054519)
I think the problem is that people like James Damore will say that women aren’t suited for work in tech, and I don’t think that’s correct. And worse, the very idea almost provides support for the abuse women regularly feel working in tech from their male coworkers.

So sure, hormone differences seem to lead to different brain chemistry. But then people draw wild and incorrect conclusions like gate keeping women out of tech. And the fact that their conclusion is wrong is more important than the fact that some differences do exist.

Edit: I worked at Google when the memo came out. Personally I didn’t think the memo was that bad... until I spoke to my female friends that worked at Google. They told me a lot about how women are treated in tech. And they showed me how things said in the memo that I thought were harmless actually perpetuated beliefs that they believed did cause them harm.

So the people saying I am misrepresenting the situation... are you a man? Maybe you can’t recognize the harmful statements the way women do and so you do not remember them being harmful? I certainly got a lesson in my own bias after that memo came out. My close friends sat me down and we had some difficult conversations about it. If you’ve never done that, consider what you might be missing.

Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by HideousKojima on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:39PM (#27054656)
>I think the problem is that people like James Damore will say that women aren’t suited for work in tech

That's something he never said, and even explicitly said the opposite multiple times. The fact that people like you continue to repeat lies about what he said without ever reading what he said (or worse, willfully lying in spite of actually reading it) is why we can't have honest conversations about this.

Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by ackfoobar on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @04:04PM (#27054962)
"Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity."

Most people don't have a strong enough grasp of statistics.

No matter how careful one is with the wording, some can only hear what they are capable of understanding, because they lack the frame of understanding.

Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by themediasucks on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @04:59PM (#27055744)
It wasn't Damore's wording that has created the view of his memo that is counterfactual, it was the reporting done by "reputable" journals, who blatantly lied in articles about what the memo said.

It was journals like Wired, TechCrunch, the NYT's technology board, Ars Technica, the whole tech media came out of the woodwork to create a false narrative about what Damore wrote and succeeded in getting him terminated. They may have even ruined his life, just some random autistic engineer who accidentally violated their taboo.

And Damore isn't the first person mainstream journalists have done this to, they did it with Jordan Peterson, as another example, and they'll make up all kinds of lies if it fits their ideological goals to do so.

The sooner people realize that they need to consume "mainstream" journalism with the same skepticism they bring to "alt" journalism or "tabloids," the better off we'll be.

In the meantime, the journalists I trust most are the ones that have seen through this game: Glenn Greenwald, Matt Taibbi, Andrew Sullivan, Bari Weiss, to name a few.

Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by TaylorAlexander on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @04:34PM (#27055392)
I read it and I participated in a lot of conversations with women at Google at the time. That’s my honest recollection of what was written and how people received it.

The Damore memo sounds very different to women than to men. I didn’t see that much of a problem with it until I spoke to my female friends. And they pointed out how work like that reinforces serious problems they already have at the workplace.

Honestly I think the downvoters remember it differently because men remember it differently from women, and I am remembering all the conversations I had with women while working at Google when the memo came out.

Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by HideousKojima on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @04:57PM (#27055721)
The memo is out there for you to directly quote, easily. Feel free to quote any part where Damore said (or even made a thinly veiled suggestion that) women aren't suited to working in tech. No need to rely on memory
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by TaylorAlexander on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @05:41PM (#27056174)
Ah, sorry. I guess I did not correctly recall the content of the memo. It seems instead he was suggesting that biological differences between men and women are sufficiently real that company policy should be structured in some ways around this phenomenon. I can tell you that the women of Google that I spoke to do not seem to support that or believe it is a good idea.
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by 13years on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:38PM (#27054637)
I don't believe that is what Damore said or intended. The discussion revolves around preference not capability. They are not the same thing.
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by TulliusCicero on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:38PM (#27054635)
I would never say one gender simply "isn't suited" for a particular career type, but I do think it's likely that, if there are average sex differences in personality, there are almost certainly average sex differences in occupational preferences.

But, that doesn't preclude there also being sexism present that needs to be dealt with.

Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by bourgwaletariat on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:57PM (#27054888)
Of course you don't think that's correct. Neither does he. No one is gatekeeping women out of tech. You want to believe that, so you find reasons to explain it that put the responsibility for it on everyone except those choosing not to do it.

The problem is that people like you will say people say things they didn't say and won't acknowledge the things they actually did say.

No one is gatekeeping women out of working in coal mines or driving trucks or heavy equipment or welding or garbage collection or any of those jobs either.

Why tech?

Why? Because it's not.

There is an overabundance of oppression in the world and it has nothing to do with gender, race, class, etc. There are oppressive people and they ruin life for many of all genders, races, classes, etc. Oppressive people are going to find any reason at all to insult, degrade, and disrespect others to oppress them.

Blaming other people for your own situation that you largely control, I would argue that the individual has more control over their life than anyone yet, responsibility of the self is completely absent from the discussion.

That, itself, is a form of oppression. It is oppression that we need to focus on. Not gender, race, class, wealth, geography, nationality, etc, etc, etc.

Oppressive people need to be rooted out and removed from society until they are rehabilitated.

Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by gotoeleven on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:09PM (#27054281)
The creation of mass delusions that benefit powerful groups is basically the norm in human society it seems like. It used to be religion and now it's fact-free feel good wishful thinking. My lived experience. My truth. It's no different than dancing to please the sun god.
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by wizzwizz4 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:33PM (#27054577)
> My lived experience.

Somebody's “lived experience” is their personal anecdotes. It's often in contrast with “quantify or discard”-type bad-at-science academics who make blanket assertions about things they don't know very much about.