News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by klyrs on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:13PM (#27054339)
Good science validates, disproves, or quantifies common sense. The nature vs nurture question is especially complicated, because a proper study effectively requires horrible experiments on isolating children from "culture" starting from infancy -- and that's under the optimistic assumption that culture isn't absorbed in the womb
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by TulliusCicero on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:32PM (#27054563)
The idea that the article uses is that if you find commonalities across widely dispersed and different cultures, that strongly points to a common biological cause.
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by Workaccount2 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:50PM (#27054807)
Twin studies have done a lot of work in this area. Two genetically identical children, separated at birth and raised in 2 separate families.

At least from these studies, genetics play a far larger role than expected.

Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by excepttheweasel on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @04:46PM (#27055567)
How do twin studies separate those children from the culture they're raised in?
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by francisofascii on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:19PM (#27054401)
If you were to study children from a diverse range of cultures, and found similar results regardless of culture, could you come to a conclusion? Might be easier than the removal of culture.
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by klyrs on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:42PM (#27054685)
Did those "diverse range of cultures" arise separately, or did humans originate in one location and spread their culture from there? Contrast to a drug trial -- imagine you only test penicillins, and nobody gets a placebo or a non-treatment, could you come to a conclusion? Are the potential outcomes / conclusions of the experiment the same as an experiment where there are placebo and non-treatment controls?
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by seneca on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @05:10PM (#27055886)
> Did those "diverse range of cultures" arise separately, or did humans originate in one location and spread their culture from there?

If you define cultural influence as broadly as pre-historic shared origins, I fear you've stepped into the territory of unfalsifiable claims. Interesting conversationally, but useless scientifically.

Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by klyrs on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @05:41PM (#27056171)
If you'd like to claim that one culture is totally independent from another culture, there's a pretty big burden of proof there and I reject it out of hand. Humans don't spontaneously materialize, abandoned infants rarely survive to adulthood, and nearly all cultures interact with their neighbors in some form or another (so even if they started independent, they won't remain so for long)

Moral monstrosity aside, it should be possible to answer nature-vs-nurture questions by raising humans from infancy in a robo-nursery where they only interact with other such "culturally pristine" humans. Seed a dozen such communities and watch their culture evolve over several generations, and you'd have a pretty good basis to draw conclusions on nature vs nurture.

Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by nairboon on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @06:10PM (#27056457)
How will you teach them a language in the robo-nursery without adding any culture?
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by klyrs on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @06:20PM (#27056552)
I wasn't imagining any such education, just provision of physical needs. More like commercial chicken farming, less like an actual nursery you'd send a child to. I did say this was monstrous, after all. One may hope that altruism, compassion, and child-rearing are human nature, and the robo-nursery could be phased out.
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by systemvoltage on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:33PM (#27054576)
> Good science validates, disproves, or quantifies common sense.

The problem is even more insidious - good science is prevented from being conducted for political reasons largely by extreme progressives. It is unsettling to me that we have so much politics mixed in with scientific understanding of humans.

The chilling effect of this is that no professor or researcher would these days attempt to conduct good science around gender differences - they fear their life, liberty and right to pursuit a prosperous career.

Just look at the number of gray comments in this thread - it shows how intolerant, childish and absolutely infuriating it is to discuss something that should not be contentious or confrontational. We're not acting like adults.

Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by klyrs on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:47PM (#27054756)
I'd encourage you to read your own comment here. You're pointing a finger at "extreme progressives" and calling folks intolerant, childish and confrontational. Does this framing facilitate a reasoned conversation, or further polarize it?
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by throwaway3699 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @04:03PM (#27054948)
How can we un-polarize science of we cannot discuss it?
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by klyrs on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @04:15PM (#27055102)
Here it is, being discussed. Therefore, we can discuss it. Can we do so without name-calling? That seems to be a good place to start.
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by google234123 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @04:24PM (#27055233)
Imagine trying to discuss the US's stem cells laws/prohibitions in the early 2000s without being able to "point fingers at" Bush, the far right, or religion.
Re:Taking sex differences in personality seriously (2019) by klyrs on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @04:39PM (#27055462)
Been there, done that, didn't buy the t-shirt. Calling one's opponent an "extremist" was insultingly reductive then, just as it is now.