News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by 908B64B197 on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:38PM (#26944569)
> Roku alleges Google has asked it to favor YouTube music results from voice commands made on the Roku remote while the YouTube app is open, even if the user's music preference is set to default to another music app, like Pandora.

That's the behavior I would expect from a full screen app. ie, if I issue a command in a full screen app for the command to be interpreted in the context of that app.

Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by pbhjpbhj on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:04PM (#26944976)
I find FireTV stick (from Amazon) to be applying in this respect, it doesn't appear to know command that direct them input to a specific app. When I have Google open and ask it to search for $search-string it will do it in the Amazon store context, ie offer to sell me a program rather than find the string on Google.

Annoying. It relates to the lack of discoverability in voice interfaces, there may be an incantation to get the behaviouyr I want but there's no way within the interface that such methods is revealed.

Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @09:54AM (#26969377)
s/applying/annoying
Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by stefan_ on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:51PM (#26944764)
Maybe, maybe not? If I'm in Google Maps, should Siri offer me Google^TM-themed recommendations?
Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by ceejayoz on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:52PM (#26944775)
If I'm actively using Google Maps, I'd love for Siri to respond to "get directions to McDonalds" within the Google Maps context instead of opening Apple's.
Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by wiseleo on Monday April 26, 2021 @05:54PM (#26948723)
"Hey Siri, navigate to ___ using google maps" is how I do it. :)
Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by p49k on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:57PM (#26944861)
Sure, but that’s not what Google is asking of Roku.
Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by 908B64B197 on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:59PM (#26944890)
It is.

If their app is open and full screen, search within the app first.

Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by p49k on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:19PM (#26945171)
No it isn’t. If you have Google maps open and suddenly decide you want to go to McDonald’s, then sure, that voice command should go to Google Maps. But if you make a voice command to send an email to someone, it shouldn’t open Gmail instead of your default mail app just because Google maps is open.

Similarly, if you’re watching a video on YouTube and want to search for a cat video, sure, the voice command should search in YouTube. But if you want to listen to music and have Spotify set as your default music app, it shouldn’t send the request to YouTube Music just because YouTube is open.

Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by minsc__and__boo on Monday April 26, 2021 @04:36PM (#26947754)
Google isn't asking Roku to open a separate app, they're asking the search to be performed in the open app first.

What the person above you originally said.

Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by DashAnimal on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:39PM (#26945430)
But YouTube is a music streaming platform. The most popular, in fact (no, not YouTube music). I constantly listen to music across both Spotify and YouTube. YouTube serves video and doesn't present music in the way we usually think of it, albums sorted by artist, chronologically presented... But that isn't really how the younger gen listens to music. It is a music app and a common way a lot of people consume their music.
Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by 8note on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:46PM (#26945518)
The distinction is that YouTube and YouTube music are different apps
Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by izacus on Monday April 26, 2021 @02:17PM (#26945966)
They're not on TVs. YTM is a section inside YT app on the TV.
Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by heavyset_go on Monday April 26, 2021 @04:03PM (#26947342)
I'm using a Chromecast with Google TV, and YouTube and YouTube Music are separate apps.
Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by tick_tock_tick on Monday April 26, 2021 @04:53PM (#26947985)
On Roku there is only 1 app.
Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by JohnJamesRambo on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:00PM (#26944907)
Siri can’t even give me driving directions unless I have Apple Maps installed...
Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by xuki on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:11PM (#26945065)
You can say "Hey Siri drive to xyz using Google Maps".
Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by JohnJamesRambo on Monday April 26, 2021 @06:33PM (#26949147)
Is that new? I swear I googled this so many times and the consensus was "You have to use Apple Maps with Siri."

Thank you so much!

Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by girvo on Monday April 26, 2021 @08:47PM (#26950322)
Seems new-ish, my girlfriend found the same thing. Also worked out how to get Google Maps to work with CarPlay too!
Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by djanogo on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:54PM (#26944795)
That's not at all how voice assists are meant to work. Voice icon in cars/remotes are all meant to provide answers or take commands irrespective of what's happening on that device or other devices they control.
Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by 908B64B197 on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:58PM (#26944879)
In a car sure. On a living room TV?
Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by djanogo on Monday April 26, 2021 @09:21PM (#26950619)
iPhone siri (iphoone gesture), Fire stick microphone icons perform broad range of tasks irrespective of last task.
Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by vineyardmike on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:02PM (#26944939)
I don’t think you can make such a blanket statement.

I think this behavior is what I would expect (search within open app first) and when it’s not present, it’s frustrating.

Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by mupuff1234 on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:08PM (#26945024)
Quite the opposite, context is a critical aspect voice assistants currently lack.
Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by egberts1 on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:23PM (#26945213)
yeah, what’s worse about the YouTube crippling of its full-screen is that it actually DISABLED any captioning.

Talk about corporate-imposed audism.

Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by gsich on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:49PM (#26944735)
Make it configurable and everyone is happy.
Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by resizeitplz on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:52PM (#26944773)
It is configurable. Google is asking Roku to override the user's chosen configuration.
Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by pythonaut_16 on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:16PM (#26945138)
He's clearly suggesting making context aware search an option.

"When searching within an app, favor results from that app" vs "When searching within an app always favor my default"

Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by Nadya on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:24PM (#26945231)
>"When searching within an app, favor results from that app"

vs

>"When searching within an app, favor results from a related app"

There is a big difference between these two things. "Youtube" is not the same as "Youtube Music" in the same way that "Xbox" is not the same as "Xbox Live".

As p49k explained it - if you were trying to send an email from YouTube would you expect Gmail to come up or your preferred email app? What if Gmail was renamed to "Youtube Mail"? Would that change your expected behavior?

Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by pythonaut_16 on Monday April 26, 2021 @02:03PM (#26945788)
Sending an email is a different interaction than doing voice search.

Sending an email is an explicit intent - open whatever app I use to send emails.

Searching is an open query - find the most relevant results. What results are most relevant is subjective, hence why you would give the user a choice for what results to favor.

The separation between Youtube and Youtube Music is a technical minutia, they're both Youtube just different apps. If you want a technical solution, Roku should probably implement a search API such that doing a voice search would let the Roku query whatever app is currently running for results. Then any app can provide more relevant, context aware results.

Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by Nadya on Monday April 26, 2021 @02:18PM (#26945984)
>Sending an email is a different interaction than doing voice search.

Going from watching videos to playing music is a different interaction than doing voice search.

>Sending an email is an explicit intent - open whatever app I use to send emails.

Using a global voice commands (not search) has explicit behavior - use whatever app I have set to default for the functionality I am requesting. "Play Stairway to Heaven" should use my default music app. Note that "voice commands" is different from "voice search" in this context and is the alleged problem.

>Searching is an open query - find the most relevant results.

If I use Spotify as my default music app it is because I trust their music search more than YouTube Music. Otherwise YouTube Music would be my default music app.

There is also a massive contextual difference between a global Voice Search (using the Voice search icon on the Roku remote: it searches Roku) and using the Speech to Text option that may appear when already searching within a search field (which uses the search field of the app itself, in this case: Youtube)

>The separation between Youtube and Youtube Music is a technical minutia, they're both Youtube just different apps.

Google deciding there is a difference between the two means that there is a difference between the two for both a marketing perspective and whatever minor technical differences there are. If there were no differences there would not be a YouTube Music app and to pretend otherwise is disingenuous.

Re:Roku says it may lose YouTube TV app after Google made an... by pythonaut_16 on Monday April 26, 2021 @03:26PM (#26946860)
You're basically making the argument for why this should be a user preference.

Do I want the current app I'm using to influence the result of a voice command or not.

Unfortunately the line between voice commands and voice search is often fuzzy. Lines like this: > Roku alleges Google has asked it to favor YouTube music results from voice commands made on the Roku remote while the YouTube app is open make it unclear if it's talking about a search or a command.

Ideally Roku would implement a more fine grained API where a user can set permissions/preferences on an app by app basis, similar to Android and iOS permissions APIs and especially how notifications are handled.

Either way if Roku's allegations definitely don't paint Google in a good light here. It just seems like there could be more to this story.