News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by thebigspacefuck on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:07PM (#26933789)
I found out my company is willing to pay people with the same experience I have more money. Just not me.
Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by input_sh on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:14PM (#26933841)
In my experience, the easiest way to get a substantial raise is to switch companies.

Your existing one will bump your salary by like 5-10%. A new one won't have that baseline, making it easy to go above that. My salary increased by like 45% in the last year. I've seen posts of people claiming they've doubled their salary with this one simple trick.

Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by DistressedDrone on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:25PM (#26933954)
This is largely because managers don't understand just how in demand people are in tech. They think you are replaceable, until you quit, then they realize the market is insane and they have to increase their offer significantly.

At least here in Montreal software engineers are almost as high in demand as doctors.

Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by JMTQp8lwXL on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:37PM (#26934048)
It's not managers. The board sets a budget, the budget gets subdivided, and by the time low-level managers have an opportunity to chime in, an Overton window has been established and I have the power to give a 0-9% raise.

Upper management doesn't have the visibility or the introspection to know one single individual contributor is truly worth 30% more to their business.

I coach my reports to sell themselves. Tell the directors how they individually are adding value to the company. They are completely allowed to speak with higher ups, and usually they're more than willing to take 15 minutes and listen to ICs on virtually any topic they wish to speak about. Then, the directors will remember you when it comes time to making pay decisions. Most engineers are modest, but nobody gets penalized for communicating and highlighting the great work they do.

Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by danaris on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:52PM (#26934809)
I mean, this may be true where you are, and it may be true in some other similar companies, but it's definitely not universally true.

Some companies are smaller than yours, or have better visibility, or give managers more budgetary latitude. Speaking as if this is The One Way It Always Works is unhelpful.

Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by serial_dev on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:40PM (#26934083)
We (tech people) are replaceable, just that replacing us takes a lot of time, effort and money.

I know it feels like nitpicking, but I never felt that any of the developers were actually hard to replace: it takes some money, time spent on recruiting, interviewing, then training, but in the end, the new people catch up in a matter of months and the resources needed to invest in a replacement can be relatively easily estimated.

I usually don't see that with very good business and product people. When they left the company, the team became demotivated, the lack of company and product vision caused frustration, the company couldn't find a replacement at all, caused turnover. In my experience, good business people leaving is the early sign of the company going south.

The causation can go in both directions, though: 1. product and business people are the first to see if a product/business model isn't working out, so they leave. 2 they leave, then they can't be replaced, replacement is only half as good, people quit because of lack of vision, things go even worse, more people quit, company has to shut down.

Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by ipaddr on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:30PM (#26934563)
Senior leadership is the hardest to replace. Marketing managers or sales agents or the director of HR or a jr accountant or product managers are easy to replace and change happens often. Changing the CEO can be a big transition but replacing the product owner on the main app shouldn't be too difficult and happens often enough.

In your example if the product manager sees the plan is not working out so they leave. Is it their business model? If so they are running away from a mess they created. If the model comes from above than senior leadership is lacking.

Not being able to replace would point to a problem with either HR or senior leadership .

Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by danaris on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:54PM (#26934833)
> Senior leadership is the hardest to replace.

[Citation needed]

I'm sure there are senior leaders who are amazing, and would be extremely difficult to replace. My experience of "senior leadership", however, has been, almost universally, that they're in that position because they were born into money, their organizational skills are crap, and they think "vision" means "sticking with the status quo (with maybe one oddball quirk) and "leadership" means "yelling at people until they do what you want."

That kind of "senior leadership" isn't hard to replace at all.

Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by magnusmundus on Sunday April 25, 2021 @02:15PM (#26935068)
I see where you're coming from, but consider the cost of the replacement process itself: it can be chaotic jumping from one set of crap organizational skills to another. Point being, it's not so much that the person is very valuable themselves, but more that higher position = bigger disruption.

In fact there might be a slightly counterintuitive relation here: assuming good intent on all sides, transition from a leader with good organizational skills would be less disruptive.

Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by danaris on Sunday April 25, 2021 @07:04PM (#26937562)
You're not wrong, and I think that your last point is actually very true—and that this is part of what lets the leaders with crap organizational skills get away with it. It's not immediately obvious that their terrible leadership is ruining the organization.

What's needed, IMO, is a cultural shift away from the idea that we need a singular, extremely powerful CEO/president/chairman, and toward more group-oriented decision-making processes and devolution of both responsibility and power.

We abandoned absolute monarchies for a lot of very good reasons, and one of them is that having one guy who can just walk into any room in the kingdom/company and exercise the power of (in this case, financial, but that often becomes very literal) life and death over anyone else in there is a bad thing.

Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by shard on Monday April 26, 2021 @03:18PM (#26946773)
A lot of the ability for senior leadership to get things done is due to the network they've built inside the company, and their understanding of the power dynamics within that company. This is less and less true the lower you go in the ranks. Therefore it might cost some extra money to replace that IC, but nothing like the hit to productivity that switching senior management could cause. One way to guard against that would be to adopt a model where senior management are routinely switched so that the working level becomes robust against changes in management.
Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by brazzy on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:08PM (#26934358)
Lol, no. They understand exactly how in demand developers are. But they also understand that most people are reluctant to switch jobs because of the effort, the uncertainty, and the bad feeling of letting your teammates down.

You can save a lot of budget by not giving competitive raises.

Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by akmarinov on Sunday April 25, 2021 @05:05PM (#26936679)
This, especially with women, they don’t quit as often and are much more likely to stay, even if the environment is bad.
Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by blaser-waffle on Monday April 26, 2021 @08:57AM (#26942026)
The demand in Montreal is... different. I'm in tech in Canada and I consider it from time to time -- Montreal, I mean -- and it's often a no-go. My wife is French-Canadian, ethnically speaking, and kinda interested, and I'd like the city all of the times we've visited.

Taxes are high in Canada but are the highest in the QC. By a lot. You get good stuff, like free or subsidized daycare, but you lose a lot of $$$ out of that paycheck.

COL in Montreal is low, but it's a cold place. Like, why go to Canada when I could go to Austin or the NC Research Triangle? Low COL means lower salaries. "Easier to be a human but harder to be a consumer" is what I've heard about COL and taxes in QC.

The CAD is weaker than the USD by around 20-30%, which makes it less cool for US-based devs. You can work around that by upping that CAD number, but remember the taxes are much higher and you'll be paying comparatively more, %-wise, at 210k CAD than you would at 150k USD.

Most jobs expect some degree of French, ranging from "learning but can get by" to "full-fluency in English and French". The city as a whole is kind of like that.

So yeah, of course there are jobs. They pay mediocre rates, need a second language, and mean you'll get taxed a lot. And if you're not in Canada, moving north presents logistical issues on top of months of snow.

Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by DistressedDrone on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:48PM (#26951372)
I can't disagree with much of what you're saying, and still as a Canadian there is no realistic amount of money that could incentivize me to move to the US.

For Montreal, the French thing is largely true, meaning you would generally have to at least pretend to be learning French. I find that the requirement gets ignored regularly however when yours is the only decent CV in the pile.

Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by qeternity on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:34PM (#26934031)
I’m not sure that’s true. Anyone who has had any attrition knows the cost of turnover.
Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by MattGaiser on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:52PM (#26934200)
Has it actually been established to matter all that much?

As attrition rates are surging throughout society. People are quitting faster. More and more people are on temp contracts. I find it kinda nuts that the sign that it is time to leave a company for a raise is hitting a productive stride. It is common knowledge that the best way to get a raise is to switch employers.

Yet absolutely nothing is being done with this information by employers. It isn't secret. So they seemingly have determined that preventing attrition isn't worth it.

Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by ipaddr on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:39PM (#26934650)
No one wants to pay more for what you already have even though it is offering more. We see this with cable bills. Everyone expects more channel but static prices. Companies expect more out of a developer who has been with them 5 years over someone who has been there a year. But they want to continue to pay them the same as they did 5 years ago so they never give them raises.
Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by tacostakohashi on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:26PM (#26934523)
If company Y is willing to pay 50% more to hire someone from company X, it's often because they want to bring in someone with external experience. A person already working at company X has that to offer to company Y, but not to their current company.

If company X isn't looking for external experience (because they figure they already have that experience in their senior management, other team members, etc), then they'll be happy to let the person leave for company Y and hire some new entry level / fresh grad / minimally qualified person for the position and start over.

Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by javajosh on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:27PM (#26934541)
The best way to get a raise is to switch, but the side-effect cost goes up as you get older, especially when you're in "family, house" territory. Remote work helps enormously with this, but there are other issues as well. To wit, a new job always comes with new social group and almost always with new tech, and both have a learning curve that can be quite stressful - and, hopefully, transient. There's also risk, like when you try to move a tree: sometimes the roots just don't take to the new soil, no matter how prepared you are or how good your analysis was. You ran the experiment, and you missed something and/or got unlucky, and theme's the breaks -- which is fine when you're single, and absolutely not fine when you have dependents. Hence: the traditionally risk-averse family man. It's not cowardice, it's love mixed with reason.
Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by sagarm on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:15AM (#26939430)
If you're in a job dense area like the Bay Area, you can often find a new job that is the same or easier to commute to.

There is risk to switching companies, but a signing bonus helps compensate for that risk.

Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by catlifeonmars on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:34PM (#26934032)
This was the case for me as well, up until my current employer. At my current employer, I have been consistently getting 30-40% raises each year (mostly in the form of RSUs). I am not sure if this is because the market has changed, or if this is specific to my current employer (probably a bit of both).
Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by catlifeonmars on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:27PM (#26933972)
I wonder if transparent salaries across the board could help shift that? Companies may be then forced to offer competitive raises to retain their current workforce.

Or perhaps they’ll just find a way around it by using other forms of compensation that skirt transparency laws in spirit.

Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by sokoloff on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:03PM (#26934314)
I think companies trail the market in a quickly rising market (like this one for SWEs) out of laziness and inertia (on both the company and employee side; employees don’t want to bother looking for a job if everything is otherwise good and the comp is “close enough”).
Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by soared on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:10PM (#26933808)
I found the opposite. I was hired mid-pandemic, but now my team is hiring someone with <20% of my experience for the same title and compensation. My manager has not addressed directly the point when I've brought it up.
Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by PragmaticPulp on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:40PM (#26934082)
Experience isn’t the only variable in determining compensation.

Some companies will simply pay people whatever it takes to convince them to join the company, which results in compensation that’s all over the place.

Some companies have surprisingly uniform compensation, some to the extreme that all developers are paid the same compensation in lock-step. This is usually an attempt to make things fair, but it creates a lot of animosity when people feel they deserve more than their coworkers.

And some times, it really does make sense to hire less experienced people into high-paying roles of their career trajectory looks promising. Hiring isn’t just about selecting for the height of experience on a bar chart. It’s also about looking at the slope. Less experienced employees who are growing very fast are best hired at high salaries, otherwise they’re just going to leave in a year when they grow even more. Conversely, if they fail to grow into the role they might need to be let go to make room for someone more appropriate for the position.

One of the tricky things about teams sharing compensation is that there is almost never a specific ordering of salaries that everyone on the team would agree is appropriate. It’s one of those situations where 80% of people on a team might see themselves as being in the top 20%.

As always, it helps to collect competing offers elsewhere. It helps even more to be prepared to take those offers if they pay more and higher salary is your highest priority.

Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by extra88 on Sunday April 25, 2021 @02:33PM (#26935260)
> Conversely, if they fail to grow into the role they might need to be let go to make room for someone more appropriate for the position.

How many places fire people because they thought they might be a star performer but turn out to be only average? I thought Netflix was newsworthy for being "ruthless" in that way, that it was rare and that few companies have followed their example.

Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by PragmaticPulp on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @08:48AM (#26955141)
It comes down to your budget.

If you have virtually unlimited budget then keeping an over-leveled person in an overpaid position can slide if they’re still adding some value. However, it’s still better to demote them (difficult) or remove them to prevent animosity from brewing in their peers.

If you only have the budget to hire a few people, then having an overpaid and underperforming person taking up a valuable slot in your limited budget is a pressing issue. You need to get them off the team to free that budget up for someone who can earn it appropriately.

Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by blaser-waffle on Monday April 26, 2021 @09:01AM (#26942061)
I mean Stack Ranking is still a thing in a lot of places.

Couple rotations through the ranking process and if you're not jumping you're on the way out. Smart devs will read the room and find a new gig before then.

Netflix also offers amazing, most-cash, compensation, and demands results up front. Throw 300k cash at me and I'll play those games for a while, too.

Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by visarga on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:12PM (#26933823)
Depends also on how desperate was the company to fill the position when you were hired vs now.
Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by paulryanrogers on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:10PM (#26934381)
Good point. Still, once it's known it speaks to how desperate they are too keep the talent they have. Turn over usually has significant costs.
Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by mtzaldo on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:21PM (#26933911)
I got layoff about a month ago. While looking for jobs, the average pay increased about 20‰. I think it is either a reflection of the inflation, or that the companies are recognizing the need of more qualified employees amid the "great recovery". Update: I was a Lead Software Eng.
Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by scsilver on Monday April 26, 2021 @02:22PM (#26946040)
I saw something similar. I wonder if its continuing.

You need software engineers to make software, we are the necessary commodity of the future economy, nee grads arent getting in person experience, bootcamps arent doing as great at teaching during the pandemic, the visa program was also reduced. Are we sreing a supply side squeeze and a demand side rush on devs?

Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by midasuni on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:26PM (#26933961)
2% over what period? Did you see enough jobs to draw such a conclusion (2%, or 20‰, is pretty insignificant)
Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by dominotw on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:26PM (#26933959)
same. i switched jobs last june but now have offers 20-30% more.
Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by emodendroket on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:08PM (#26934356)
Why would you expect your manager to “address” the point that you think one of your peers is overpaid?
Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by pseudalopex on Sunday April 25, 2021 @06:16PM (#26937243)
The strongest plausible interpretation of what they said is they think they're under paid.
Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by emodendroket on Sunday April 25, 2021 @06:33PM (#26937359)
Well, rule number one of trying to ask for more money is don't make it about how you think you deserve more than so-and-so.
Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by SamBam on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:41PM (#26934094)
Not exactly the opposite... Paying someone else with the same experience more money is very similar to paying someone with less experience the same money. In either case, they are paying other people more for equivalent experience.
Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by sokoloff on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:05PM (#26934325)
Experience is multi-faceted and I think often over-valued (I say this as someone who would benefit a lot if experience was highly valued).

Plenty of engineers effectively have 1 year of experience 12 times.

Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by paulryanrogers on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:13PM (#26934409)
> Plenty of engineers effectively have 1 year of experience 12 times.

Do you mean they've been doing the same things year after year? I.e. without growing their skills in breadth or depth?

Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by sokoloff on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:48PM (#26934759)
Yes. They’re capable of handling about as complex task now as they were 11 years ago. If that’s the case, their relative value has not increased beyond that of their 1-year experienced peer.
Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by mbernstein on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:03PM (#26934311)
If it’s the same role and they can do the role why would they get paid less?

Experience alone doesn’t mean much.

Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by tuwtuwtuwtuw on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:16PM (#26933860)
Same here. When I found out, I asked my manager for a raise but didn't get it so I resigned. When I did, he offered to raise my salary with 30%. Left anyway and was hired again at same company a few years later for 50% above my original salary. Still felt like I was originally tricked into a low salary.
Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by vbtemp on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:38PM (#26934644)
Probably because they were hired after you. Normally newer hires have much higher salaries than old timers for equivalent role/experience, it's like that everywhere
Re:Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range by emodendroket on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:07PM (#26934345)
Sounds like information that you could act on by finding a new job.