News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by arcticbull on Friday April 23, 2021 @05:56AM (#26912928)
People put them on exchanges because crypto is actively user hostile. You forget a word, you lose a scrap of paper, someone knocks over your bird bath - and boom you're broke. This is one of the many, many fundamental problems with crypto.

It's basically just a digital obstacle course to see who can keep hold of their coins lol. You make fun of people who forget their passwords, you make fun of people who get rekked when an exchange exit scams. You send the wrong Elon bitcoin (both the fake and real ones now accept bitcoin) it's SFYL. Ransomeware? Whoopsie poopsie. SFYL.

It's always the customer's fault, never the technology.

I do wish this Turkish gentleman best of luck building that orphanage in India with Gerald Cotton though. With the billions between them I'm sure the children will be well looked after.

Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by Mordisquitos on Friday April 23, 2021 @06:23AM (#26913112)
Exactly. Apart from the intrinsic wastefulness of proof-of-work cryptocurrencies, the utopian evangelising on how The Algorithm is perfectly trustworthy and irreversible as an ultimate arbiter of truth is very far from what is desirable in the real world. It is not a feature, it is a bug.
Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7 on Friday April 23, 2021 @09:43AM (#26914681)
> It is not a feature, it is a bug.

What gives you the right to proclaim what a user wants their software to do?

If it is a feature to some people they are perfectly fine to consider it as such.

Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by Mordisquitos on Friday April 23, 2021 @03:29PM (#26918272)
I am a user of currencies, and that gives me the right to proclaim that impossible reversibility of transfers is a bug for functioning as a currency.
Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by kuroguro on Friday April 23, 2021 @08:40AM (#26914103)
> because crypto is actively user hostile

The "marketing" of "everyone should keep their own wallet" is off, as it was initially only for the computer savvy. But that is also the main selling point. If you want to have it, you get full control.

The average user is better off keeping their coins in an online wallet/exchange. We wouldn't expect them to interact directly with bank/forex/stock back-end networks and not fuck something up. The main difference here is that they can if they want to.

> It's always the customer's fault, never the technology.

No, the field is still green and over-hyped, lots of gullible "investors" coming in, scammers follow. The regulations have not fully caught up.

Even with some regulations, I assure you, if you choose a shady bank or a broker for stocks you can lose your money just as easily. If you don't keep the coins yourself it becomes a question of who to trust. I really don't see what that has to do with "the technology".

Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by PragmaticPulp on Friday April 23, 2021 @09:09AM (#26914376)
> Even with some regulations, I assure you, if you choose a shady bank or a broker for stocks you can lose your money just as easily.

Can anyone even cite a single banking exit scam in the United States in recent history? The closest I can think of is Ponzi schemes like Madoff, but those were operated as businesses, not banks.

Meanwhile, we hear about multiple crypto exit scams per year. More if you include all of the suspicious coin disappearances that were blamed on hacks.

It would be nearly impossible for an actual bank owner in the United States to abscond to a foreign country with customer funds and avoid consequences, and even more unlikely that those customers wouldn't be made whole.

But with cryptocurrency banks, being able to abscond with funds and avoid traceability/consequences is almost a core feature.

I don't understand how anyone can think traditional, regulated, insured banks are in any way equivalent to unregulated, international crypto exchanges. The two couldn't be any more different when it comes to safety.

Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by kuroguro on Friday April 23, 2021 @09:37AM (#26914623)
> Can anyone even cite a single banking exit scam in the United States

I'm from east EU so I can't comment on US, but we've had at least two major banks go under (that I can remember) due to some shady manipulations. A lot of people lost a lot of money.

> in recent history

Part of my point is that the regulations aren't here yet. We've had hundreds of years of experience with dealing with banks. They're so highly regulated precisely because there's been plenty of fraud.

> regulated, insured banks are in any way equivalent to unregulated, international crypto exchanges

Exactly! They aren't even near equivalent without the regulation. But I don't see why they couldn't come close with proper regulation.

Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by StavrosK on Friday April 23, 2021 @07:19AM (#26913506)
Whereas cash is much better! You can't lose it, it can't catch on fire, it can't be blown away by the wind, it can't be stolen, you can't give it to the wrong person! So good. That's why everyone keeps all their money in cash at all times.

What's that? They put their money in a bank? What if the bank owner takes all the money and flees to Venezuela? "You should only use trustworthy banks", you say? Interesting.

Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by ceejayoz on Friday April 23, 2021 @07:31AM (#26913585)
Someone across the world can't irreversibly take my cash with a couple keystrokes.

My cash in the bank is protected by the US government. If they're not good for it, I've got bigger problems of the "zombie apocalypse" scale.

Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by StavrosK on Friday April 23, 2021 @07:36AM (#26913624)
Everyone keeps shifting the goalposts. Are we comparing cash to cryptocurrency? Are we comparing banks to exchanges? You can't say "Cash is better than cryptocurrency because banks". If you want someone to safeguard your cryptocurrency, find a trustworthy custodian for it. The fact that banks won't hold cryptocurrency for you isn't the cryptocurrency's fault.
Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by TeMPOraL on Friday April 23, 2021 @08:01AM (#26913812)
The goalposts were mobile by design, that's how cryptocurrency promoters like them :). After all, it's not the skeptics that spread the idea that crypto should/will replace the whole fiat economy.

One important problem of cryptocurrencies is blockchain's immutable nature. This is, of course, by design, but it's not something you actually want for real money. When I fuck up when banking, I can get the bank to reverse it. If the bank fucks up, they can easily undo it, or I can compel them to undo it by proxy of the court (or threat of it). In the fiat world, unmaking a transaction is a relatively cheap operation. On the blockchain, not so much. While we can start piling up social and technological abstractions on top of crypto to allow for decent UX, this also erases the whole selling point of crypto (decentralization, anarchy) - at which point one has to ask, why burn all that energy just to reimplement fiat, poorly?

Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by andxor on Friday April 23, 2021 @08:35AM (#26914055)
You can implement all of this, including reversable transactions under specific conditions, via smart contracts, without sacrificing decentralization.
Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by TeMPOraL on Friday April 23, 2021 @05:41PM (#26919548)
Smart contracts should really be called "dumb contracts", as they're strictly dumber than traditional, old-school contracts.

Here's something worth pondering: what happens if you trigger a bug in a smart contract? What options do you have to fix or undo it?

Smart contracts are all bug-ridden by definition - formally codifying intent is a General-AI-complete problem, and since we are nowhere near close to making a human-level AI, it follows that a smart contract is just a crude approximation of the most obvious aspects of what you actually meant it to represent (no different than any other program here). Traditional contracts are smart enough to not even try - they don't codify intent, they just help achieve mutual understanding and pin down shared context for further reference. Interpretation, execution and debugging are all left to the general framework of common sense, tradition, regulations and accumulated case law.

Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by ludamad on Friday April 23, 2021 @09:07AM (#26914353)
When I can use a major chain and execute a smart contract for <$1 (on say a $100 contract) I'll be reasonably stoked. How are people playing with these when the fees are so high?
Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by andxor on Friday April 23, 2021 @09:41AM (#26914659)
A lot of liquidity is moving to L2 Ethereum already and you can definitely execute smart contracts there for way less than $1 (e.g. on Polygon).

As for why people are willing to pay high gas fees on L1 - have you considered the possibility that the opportunities and value that they're getting out of it are worth the cost?

Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by ludamad on Friday April 23, 2021 @10:09AM (#26914944)
I am not debating that the value can be worth the cost; I really meant "playing". Thanks, I'll look into Polygon
Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by hanniabu on Friday April 23, 2021 @08:31AM (#26914016)
> When I fuck up when banking, I can get the bank to reverse it.

Wire transfers

Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by StavrosK on Friday April 23, 2021 @08:38AM (#26914086)
> When I fuck up when banking, I can get the bank to reverse it.

No, you're comparing dissimilar things. Cryptocurrency is cash (with the benefit of not having to be close to someone for a transfer), and you can't "roll back" the giving of cash to someone (except compel them to give it back with the help of a court).

If you want to compare a bank to something, you need to compare it to another custodial/off-chain solution.

Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by Mordisquitos on Friday April 23, 2021 @09:07AM (#26914357)
> Cryptocurrency is cash (with the benefit of not having to be close to someone for a transfer)

If not having to be close to the payee is the only benefit of cryptocurrency over cash, that problem has been solved for literally centuries by the concept of giro transfers.

Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by TeMPOraL on Friday April 23, 2021 @05:29PM (#26919429)
> that problem has been solved for literally centuries by the concept of giro transfers

Tangential:

From Wikipedia, "A giro transfer (...) is a payment transfer from one bank account to another bank account and initiated by the payer, not the payee. The debit card has a similar model."

Maybe it's my European bias speaking, but how does that even deserve a weird name? Isn't this how normal paying works? Who else should initiate the transfer? The payee? Why?

Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by StavrosK on Friday April 23, 2021 @09:11AM (#26914393)
Can I make a giro transfer without a third party intervening? Then it would be comparable, yes.
Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by Mordisquitos on Friday April 23, 2021 @09:23AM (#26914480)
That is if you don't consider the public blockchain and its nodes as a "third party". Can you make a cryptocurrency exchange without a third party ever knowing that it took place or leaving any trace of it? You can with cash.
Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by StavrosK on Friday April 23, 2021 @09:26AM (#26914510)
Depending on which cryptocurrency you use, you can (e.g. Monero).
Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by Majromax on Friday April 23, 2021 @09:44AM (#26914687)
> What's that? They put their money in a bank? What if the bank owner takes all the money and flees to Venezuela? "You should only use trustworthy banks", you say? Interesting.

Bank failures are indeed a problem of the banking system. That's also why developed countries impose strict regulations and depository insurance on their banks, so average people do not need to perform costly due diligence on their daily-use bank.

Cryptocurrency exchanges currently dis-favour government regulation, so I doubt they will be seeking a mandatory deposit insurance regime anytime soon. Nothing prevents an exchange from taking out voluntary insurance from a private insurer, but I imagine that the underwriting fees would be costly.

Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by StavrosK on Friday April 23, 2021 @09:50AM (#26914738)
> I doubt they will be seeking a mandatory deposit insurance regime anytime soon

Certainly, but they have a big vested interest in telling their customers "your money is safe with us, we even have the insurance to prove it!".

Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by Majromax on Friday April 23, 2021 @09:54AM (#26914788)
They may, but it again goes back to costs. Do any crypto exchanges in fact carry such insurance in a verifiable manner? (It's cheaper to _say_ they have a Lloyd's of London policy than it is to actually have one, after all).

I also didn't get into it in the parent comment, but deposit insurance also may not be suitable for those who are deliberately taking advantage of the pseudonymous nature of cryptocurrency. In the event of an exchange failure, the insurer or trustee would obviously need to know the personal details of the account-holder in order to remit payment. Keeping such contact information up-to-date and verified would replicate many of the same know-your-client rules that exchanges hate to follow.

Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by StavrosK on Friday April 23, 2021 @09:58AM (#26914835)
> would replicate many of the same know-your-client rules that exchanges hate to follow.

They may hate to, but do you know any that don't? All the ones I've used asked for ID.

Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by imtringued on Friday April 23, 2021 @08:16AM (#26913918)
The problem with banks isn't that they outright scam you, it's that they are mismanaged and are too eager to lend out money to borrowers who cannot pay their debts back.
Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by nradov on Friday April 23, 2021 @08:43AM (#26914148)
That isn't a problem for individual depositors. Even if my bank is mismanaged, my personal accounts are safely insured.
Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by bena on Friday April 23, 2021 @09:31AM (#26914553)
SFYL? What does that mean?
Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by frombody on Friday April 23, 2021 @10:29AM (#26915124)
sorry for your loss
Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by casi18 on Friday April 23, 2021 @07:56AM (#26913770)
social recovery wallets seem pretty inevitable at this point, it is a much needed ux improvement.

glad to see account abstraction being pushed in optimism and other rollups so we can start building these new mechanisms that arent so hostile.

Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by foepys on Friday April 23, 2021 @08:35AM (#26914051)
Who would pay into these wallets?
Re:Police search cryptocurrency trading firm after Turks say... by CynicusRex on Friday April 23, 2021 @07:35AM (#26913617)
Bitcoin fantasy: “Be your own bank.”

Bitcoin reality: “Buy me because number go up; make the rich richer. Also, use a bank.”

Ledger Hack - What Happened with Pascal Gauthier: «Peter McCormack: Yeah. Well, the point is, would you keep $20,000, $30,000, $50,000, $100,000 in your house? No, that would be crazy; you'd keep it in the bank. And, you have to consider your security is your own personal bank. I mean, I recommend, ever since I've been with Casa, I would recommend everybody who has a serious amount of Bitcoin to consider setting themselves up with that, because it does protect you in so many ways.

Pascal Gauthier: Just on this, you're right, because you asked me the question offline, but multisig is definitely -- this is why I'm saying today, like in the present.» —https://www.whatbitcoindid.com/wbd290-pascal-gauthier