News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Three arguments against the singularity by lucasjung on Wednesday June 22, 2011 @09:41AM (#2683029)
I agree with you, but I think I can respond in summary instead of point-by-point:

"First: super-intelligent AI is unlikely because, if you pursue Vernor's program, you get there incrementally by way of human-equivalent AI, and human-equivalent AI is unlikely."

The arguments that follow don't say anything about why it's impossible or even prohibitively difficult to do, they only provide reasons why people wouldn't want to try. There are, however, motivations beyond those he takes into consideration.

Uploading: Again, he doesn't make any arguments as to why uploading is not achievable, he just talks about the very hard ethical questions that arise when dealing with uploaded intelligences. That didn't stop us from inventing nuclear weapons and a host of other ethicaly challenging technologies, so why would it stop us from inventing uploading?

One particular statement he makes in this section I do want to address specifically: "Uploading implicitly refutes the doctrine of the existence of an immortal soul, and therefore presents a raw rebuttal to those religious doctrines that believe in a life after death."

This is so obviously untrue that I don't know how any intelligent person could use it in a serious argument. Religions that believe in immortal souls will simply maintain that the uploaded copy is just that: a copy, a soulless simulation of a real person. How can you possibly prove this one way or another? "Soul" is a purely religious concept, beyond any temporal means of observation or measurement, and therefore not subject to empirical study. I still think you would see plenty of religious people oppose uploading, but for different reasons.

He finishes by discussing the possibility that our entire universe is already a simulation being run in the "real" world, and admits that nobody can prove this one way or another, at least not anytime soon.

Re:Three arguments against the singularity by astine on Wednesday June 22, 2011 @11:29AM (#2683527)
"Religions that believe in immortal souls will simply maintain that the uploaded copy is just that: a copy, a soulless simulation of a real person."

This might be true of some religious institutions but not of all. The concept of the 'Soul' is actually derived from Aristotelianism (there is no mention of it as such in the Bible) and many sects, (particularly Catholics) believe that in order for something to be intelligent it needs to have a soul, that is, an immaterial aspect. If an uploaded person, or an AI, or space alien or whatever is demonstrated to be intelligent, it would by definition have a 'soul.'

You would still get lots of folks who refused to accept the person-hood of uploaded persons and those folks might actually dominate, but the actual theological consequences would be different (and far more complex) than you imagine.

Re:Three arguments against the singularity by michael_dorfman on Wednesday June 22, 2011 @02:08PM (#2684351)
The concept of the 'Soul' is actually derived from Aristotelianism (there is no mention of it as such in the Bible)

Wrong, and wrong. The notion of the "soul" in Greek philosophy predates Aristotle; it's found in Plato's Phaedo, for example-- and there are several words in the Hebrew bible that are usually translated as "soul" (nefesh and ruach, which correspond roughly to psyche and pneuma, respectively.)

Re:Three arguments against the singularity by astine on Wednesday June 22, 2011 @06:48PM (#2685731)
"and there are several words in the Hebrew bible that are usually translated as "soul""

I stand corrected on this.

"The notion of the "soul" in Greek philosophy predates Aristotle."

True, but my point is that certain sects of Christianity borrow heavily from Greek philosophy when trying to intellectualize what a 'soul' actually is. Some tend to follow the Aristotelian conception rather than the Platonic (they are distinct.) I'm not trying to say that Aristotle invented the concept of the soul if that's what you're thinking.

Re:Three arguments against the singularity by lucasjung on Wednesday June 22, 2011 @11:55AM (#2683687)
Very interesting. I see a few possible lines of argument that sects who believe this (must have soul to be intelligent) could take. The more crude argument would be a variation of "no true scotsman:" It's not really intelligent, it's just doing a very good job of reproducing the behavior of an intellingent being." There are a lot of issues with that argument, so a better approach might be, "When it becomes intelligent, God endows it with a distinct, unique, and individual soul." Another possible approach would be, "The original and the copy share the same immortal soul," but that would be incompatible with some concepts of the afterlife. There's also a version heavy on FUD: "When it becomes intelligent, it is possessed by an evil soul."
Re:Three arguments against the singularity by glhaynes on Wednesday June 22, 2011 @11:28AM (#2683525)
Yes, religions will almost always maintain a position that retains their previous "correctness", but if you could make a "soulless simulation" that is indistinguishable from the "real thing", it'd make a lot of people scratch their heads and say "wait, so what role does the soul play here?" ... it would seem to make the soul redundant. (Of course, that feeling of the soul's lack of necessity has already happened for most that have any knowledge of modern neuroscience.)
Re:Three arguments against the singularity by Symmetry on Wednesday June 22, 2011 @09:49AM (#2683062)
There's also the position in Peter F. Hamilton's Night's Dawn series that all sentient minds have souls, regardless of how they were created or whether there's a similar mind somewhere out there. And presumably Christian's can always say "God can figure it out" with regards to what exactly where the boundaries should be.
Re:Three arguments against the singularity by ignifero on Wednesday June 22, 2011 @10:01AM (#2683122)
Religion is a fine art of emotional manipulation, but it has a weak spot: it requires an intact emotional (limbic) system. What if our artificial counterparts forgo that?
Re:Three arguments against the singularity by lucasjung on Wednesday June 22, 2011 @12:14PM (#2683795)
Many philosophers and theologians have made completely rational (emotion-free) arguments in favor of religion (sometimes a particular religion, sometimes religion in general).

That being said, I'll accept your fallacious assumption for a moment and turn your question around: what if an emotional system is necessary for self-aware, volitional intelligence? Our emotions are inseperably intertwined with the other aspects of our minds, and it might very well be that they are a fundamental aspect of consciousness.

Re:Three arguments against the singularity by Locke1689 on Wednesday June 22, 2011 @02:11PM (#2684365)
Many philosophers and theologians have made completely rational (emotion-free) arguments in favor of religion (sometimes a particular religion, sometimes religion in general).

Many philosophers and theologians have attempted to make completely rational arguments in favor of the existence of God. My liberal arts theme in undergrad was philosophy so I've read a fair amount, but I have yet to see a compelling argument yet. Could you please make some suggestions?

Re:Three arguments against the singularity by lucasjung on Wednesday June 22, 2011 @02:42PM (#2684481)
Just because you didn't find them compelling doesn't mean they are somehow flawed. There are whole schools of philosophy that are mutually exclusive and yet are subscribed to each by many very intelligent people who are unable to decisively prove each other wrong. Having studied so much philosophy, you of all people should understand that there is a huge difference between a rational, consistent argument and a proof.

EDIT: Proving or disproving the existence of God is, in general, a fool's game. One could probably prove that certain types of deities are impossible, but it's impossible to prove that no form of deity is possible. On the other hand, proving the existence of God would almost certainly require a well-documented divine intervention, and even then many people would (rightfully) remain skeptical.

Also, my previous post didn't say anything about proving the existence of God: I said that they made "arguments in favor of religion," which is not the same thing. First, not all religions involve deities. Even if you restrict the discussion to religions involving deities, it is possible to argue that it is desireable or advantageous to believe in God without first proving that God exists. Furthermore, even some atheists argue that religion in general or some religions in particular have had a net positive impact on humanity.

Re:Three arguments against the singularity by ignifero on Wednesday June 22, 2011 @03:58PM (#2684899)
Good points here, although i must note that your appeal to authority ("many intelligent people") does not lend credence to any of these arguments. For many people, they are no more true than any random syntactically correct sentence. And in any case, i feel this thread is diverting to a ... religious argument.

p.s. "...but it's impossible to prove that no form of deity is possible" - could you point to a proof of that?

Re:Three arguments against the singularity by lucasjung on Thursday June 23, 2011 @12:12PM (#2688417)
It was not an appeal to authority, nor was it intended to support any of those arguments. It was intended to underscore the point that a particular philosophical argument is not automatically invalid simply because some people, no matter how intelligent and rational, do not find it convincing. In effect, it was a rejection of gp's appeal to his own authority as a student of philosophy.

As for your latter point: if you disprove the possibility of deities with a particular quality or set of qualities, I can then describe a deity which lacks those qualities and is therefore outside the set of deities you have proven impossible. For example, if you can somehow prove that there has never been divine intervention of any form (which I highly doubt is possible to prove), then I could respond by positing a deity that does not intervene in the temporal universe at all, but instead rules only in the afterlife. Since the afterlife is beyond temporal measurement, it is by definition beyond empirical observation, and there is therefore no way you can disprove the existence of an afterlife. By extension, there is no way you can disprove the existence of a deity which rules the afterlife.

Re:Three arguments against the singularity by ignifero on Thursday June 23, 2011 @04:24PM (#2689711)
Thanks for your time. See, i am an eliminativist myself, so i would doubt things like afterlife and spirit are accessible to us humans. I might accept forms of non-intervening deities if it were confined to setting the initial conditions of the big bang. Point is, arguing against it or for it is like arguing the weather.
Re:Three arguments against the singularity by klipt on Thursday June 23, 2011 @05:37AM (#2687281)
Well, if you accept that it's impossible to prove that we aren't in a simulation - then it's possible we are in a simulation, and that would make the being responsible for simulating us a deity of sorts.
Re:Three arguments against the singularity by ignifero on Wednesday June 22, 2011 @03:47PM (#2684824)
a) The arguments i 've heard about religious faith attempt to explain metaphysics by resorting to metaphysics, which, to me, is weak circular logic; but, fair, i don't have the means to disprove them either. My critical attitude was towards religion, the social construct which has historically been used to manipulate human groups through religious faith. Then again maybe religion has been evolutionary advantageous, although it hasn't been around long enough to be selected out of the population.

b) You are right. AFAIK, religious experiences involves the parietal and temporal lobes, so its not just the emotional system. Agree that it's an important (irreplaceable?) part of our self-awareness. However the fact that non-religious people can act ethically in a harmonious society indicates that it might be reduntant. Still, religious beliefs arise in a brain, so there will probably be a way to turn them off (probably not without sideeffects).

Re:Three arguments against the singularity by Apocryphon on Wednesday June 22, 2011 @04:11PM (#2684986)
Non-religious people can also believe in superstitious, irrational beliefs. Isn't irrationality inevitable?
Re:Three arguments against the singularity by ignifero on Wednesday June 22, 2011 @04:25PM (#2685078)
They can, but they don't have to, so it's not inevitable.
Re:Three arguments against the singularity by Apocryphon on Wednesday June 22, 2011 @04:34PM (#2685120)
Don't they have to? Isn't everyone irrational to some extent? I mean it may be as little or minor as believing one economic/political theory over another in the absence of clear evidence. Or betting on string theory over another explanation.
Re:Three arguments against the singularity by khafra on Thursday June 23, 2011 @08:43AM (#2687623)
Cognomancers, at this point, will attempt to restate what they mean by "irrational" without using it or any close synonyms. They might also try to figure out if religiosity is correlated with greater levels of whatever they mean by "irrationality," or not.
Re:Three arguments against the singularity by ignifero on Wednesday June 22, 2011 @04:56PM (#2685229)
Making a random decision in the absence of empirical evidence is rational thinking. It's irrational to make it in the presence of overwhelming evidence or counter evidence.