Re:Three arguments against the singularity
by Apocryphon on Wednesday June 22, 2011 @04:11PM
(#2684986)
Non-religious people can also believe in superstitious, irrational beliefs. Isn't irrationality inevitable?
Re:Three arguments against the singularity
by ignifero on Wednesday June 22, 2011 @04:25PM
(#2685078)
They can, but they don't have to, so it's not inevitable.
Re:Three arguments against the singularity
by Apocryphon on Wednesday June 22, 2011 @04:34PM
(#2685120)
Don't they have to? Isn't everyone irrational to some extent? I mean it may be as little or minor as believing one economic/political theory over another in the absence of clear evidence. Or betting on string theory over another explanation.
Cognomancers, at this point, will attempt to restate what they mean by "irrational" without using it or any close synonyms. They might also try to figure out if religiosity is correlated with greater levels of whatever they mean by "irrationality," or not.
b) You are right. AFAIK, religious experiences involves the parietal and temporal lobes, so its not just the emotional system. Agree that it's an important (irreplaceable?) part of our self-awareness. However the fact that non-religious people can act ethically in a harmonious society indicates that it might be reduntant. Still, religious beliefs arise in a brain, so there will probably be a way to turn them off (probably not without sideeffects).