As for your latter point: if you disprove the possibility of deities with a particular quality or set of qualities, I can then describe a deity which lacks those qualities and is therefore outside the set of deities you have proven impossible. For example, if you can somehow prove that there has never been divine intervention of any form (which I highly doubt is possible to prove), then I could respond by positing a deity that does not intervene in the temporal universe at all, but instead rules only in the afterlife. Since the afterlife is beyond temporal measurement, it is by definition beyond empirical observation, and there is therefore no way you can disprove the existence of an afterlife. By extension, there is no way you can disprove the existence of a deity which rules the afterlife.
Re:Three arguments against the singularity
by lucasjung on Thursday June 23, 2011 @12:12PM
(#2688417)
It was not an appeal to authority, nor was it intended to support any of those arguments. It was intended to underscore the point that a particular philosophical argument is not automatically invalid simply because some people, no matter how intelligent and rational, do not find it convincing. In effect, it was a rejection of gp's appeal to his own authority as a student of philosophy.
Re:Three arguments against the singularity
by ignifero on Thursday June 23, 2011 @04:24PM
(#2689711)
Thanks for your time. See, i am an eliminativist myself, so i would doubt things like afterlife and spirit are accessible to us humans. I might accept forms of non-intervening deities if it were confined to setting the initial conditions of the big bang. Point is, arguing against it or for it is like arguing the weather.
Well, if you accept that it's impossible to prove that we aren't in a simulation - then it's possible we are in a simulation, and that would make the being responsible for simulating us a deity of sorts.
p.s. "...but it's impossible to prove that no form of deity is possible" - could you point to a proof of that?